Compare cards

Capital One QuicksilverOne Rewards vs Discover it Secured Credit Card

Decides between an unsecured $39 card paying a flat 1.5% and a no-fee secured card that needs a deposit but pays 5% rotating categories and a first-year match.

The short verdict

These cards solve the same problem in opposite ways. The Capital One QuicksilverOne Rewards asks for no deposit but charges a $39 annual fee. The Discover it Secured Credit Card has no annual fee but asks for a refundable deposit of $49, $99 or $200 and a starting line of at least $200. Choose the QuicksilverOne if you cannot tie up a deposit, have fair credit, and will spend steadily enough to cover the fee. Choose the Discover card if you can fund the deposit and want to avoid a yearly fee.

The number that decides it

The $39 annual fee against 1.5% cash back. The QuicksilverOne pays 1.5% on every purchase (as of November 2026), so it breaks even at $39 / 0.015 = $2,600 of spending a year.

Hypothetical example. Say you spend $6,000 a year.

  • QuicksilverOne: $6,000 x 0.015 = $90, minus the $39 fee, is $51.
  • Discover it Secured, with every purchase at the 1% base rate: $6,000 x 0.01 = $60, matched in the first year with another $60 for $120. There is no fee. Any spending in the 5% quarterly categories would add to this, though Discover's quarterly maximum was not stated on its pages.

In year two the Discover match is gone, so $60 at the base rate would trail the QuicksilverOne's $51 net only if the categories do not pay off. The deposit is separate: it is refundable, but it is cash you cannot spend while it is held.

What is the same

  • Both target people with limited or fair credit.
  • Both pay cash back on purchases without a list of fees for the rewards themselves.
  • Both are from the same corporate family: Discover's page carries Capital One's footer as of November 2026, but the cards keep separate terms.

What differs

  • Security. QuicksilverOne is unsecured and asks for no deposit; Discover requires one.
  • Rate to carry a balance. QuicksilverOne lists 29.24% variable as of November 2026. Discover's secured-card APR was not readable, so it is not given.
  • Bureau reporting. Discover says it reports to all three bureaus. The QuicksilverOne page does not say which bureaus receive account activity, so ask Capital One if that matters.
  • Line growth. Capital One says it considers cardholders for a higher line in as little as 6 months, with no criteria. Discover describes an upgrade path to an unsecured card with a returned deposit and no timetable.
  • Activation. Discover's 5% rate requires quarterly activation; the QuicksilverOne has no categories.

What neither does

Neither publishes a guarantee of a line increase or upgrade, and neither is a good place to carry a balance. The QuicksilverOne page also omits a foreign transaction fee, and Discover's was not stated either.

When to choose neither

If you want no annual fee and no rewards, compare Capital One Platinum Secured (secured) or Capital One Platinum Credit Card (unsecured). To test the fee against your own spending, use the annual fee break-even calculator.

Side by side

Capital One QuicksilverOne Rewards Discover it Secured Credit Card
Type Secured and credit-builder Secured and credit-builder
Annual fee $39 $0
Purchase APR 29.24% variable purchase APR (as of November 2026) —
How it earns Unlimited 1.5% cash back on every purchase; rewards do not expire for the life of the account (as of November 2026) 5% cash back on everyday purchases in rotating categories each quarter, up to a quarterly maximum when you activate; 1% on all other purchases; Cashback Match doubles the first year's cash back (as of November 2026)
Welcome offer No welcome offer is described on Capital One's page (as of November 2026) Cashback Match: Discover matches all the cash back you earn in the first 365 days after approval, with no limit, applied at the end of the first year; for new cardholders (as of November 2026; offers change)
Rewards program Capital One cash back —
Issuer Capital One Discover
Network — Discover
Type Credit builder Secured
Status Open to new applicants Open to new applicants
Credit needed Fair Limited or fair credit; Discover says no credit score is required to apply
Best suited to People with fair credit who want an unsecured card with a flat 1.5% return and who will pay the balance in full each month. People building credit who can fund a small deposit and want cash back while they do.
Key benefits
  • Unlimited 1.5% cash back
  • Rewards do not expire while the account is open
  • Automatic credit line reviews in as little as 6 months
  • Free CreditWise score access
  • Zero fraud liability
  • Contactless Tap to Pay
  • Refundable deposit of $49 or $99 or $200 based on creditworthiness
  • Credit line starting at $200
  • 5% rotating categories and 1% elsewhere
  • Unlimited dollar-for-dollar Cashback Match after the first year
  • Reports to the three major credit bureaus
  • Free FICO Score 8 through CreditWise
  • Path to an unsecured Discover it Cash Back card
Drawbacks
  • $39 annual fee
  • 29.24% variable purchase APR
  • No welcome offer listed
  • Foreign transaction fee not stated on the page
  • Quarterly 5% categories need activation each quarter
  • 5% rate is capped at a quarterly maximum not stated on the page
  • Network acceptance abroad is lower than Visa and Mastercard according to reports
  • APR and fee schedule were not readable on the public page

Facts come from each profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. APRs are variable and offers change: confirm on the issuer's own page before you apply.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

In the index now