Compare cards

Hilton Honors American Express Aspire Card vs Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant American Express Card

Two premium Amex hotel cards, $550 and $650: decides by the chain you use and how many of each card's credits you would spend on anyway.

Who should choose which

Both profiles rely on The Points Guy and Doctor of Credit, because the issuers' own pages could not be read. Figures are as of November 2026.

Choose the Hilton Honors American Express Aspire Card if you stay at Hilton resorts often. It costs $550, earns 14X at participating Hilton hotels and resorts, 7X on flights, select car rentals and U.S. restaurants, and gives complimentary Diamond status, a Free Night Reward each membership year, up to $400 a year in Hilton resort credits, up to $200 a year in flight credits and up to $219 toward CLEAR Plus.

Choose the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant American Express Card if you stay at Marriott hotels and also eat out. It costs $650, earns 6X at participating Marriott Bonvoy hotels and 3X at restaurants worldwide and on flights booked directly with airlines, and gives Platinum Elite status, 25 Elite Night Credits a year, a Free Night Award valid up to 85,000 points, up to $300 a year in dining credits ($25 a month), a Global Entry or TSA PreCheck credit and Priority Pass lounge membership after enrollment.

The number that decides it: the credits you would use anyway

The fee gap is only $100, so the decision is how much of each card's credits you would really spend. A credit is worth nothing if you would not otherwise have bought it. Assume, for both cards, a free night worth $300 (an illustrative figure, not a hotel price).

  • Aspire, everything used: $400 resort + $200 flight + $219 CLEAR Plus + $300 free night = $1,119, minus $550, a net of $569.
  • Brilliant: $300 dining + $30 a year for Global Entry ($120 spread over four years) + $300 free night = $630, minus $650, a net of -$20. With the $100 Ritz-Carlton or St. Regis property credit used, it becomes $80.
  • Aspire, only the free night and flight credit used: $500 minus $550, a net of -$50.

So the Aspire is ahead only if you would use its resort credit, which applies at eligible Hilton resorts and, per Doctor of Credit in September 2024, only to properties on the Aspire list. The Brilliant's dining credit is more broadly usable, but it is a monthly allowance that does not roll over, and its free night is capped at 85,000 points, which may not cover a peak-night stay at a high-end hotel. Hilton and Bonvoy points are worth different amounts depending on hotel and date, so none is valued here.

Welcome offers, as listed in November 2026: 200,000 Hilton points after $6,000 in 6 months on the Aspire (offer ends January 13, 2027); on the Brilliant, 100,000 points after $6,000 in 6 months per The Points Guy, while Doctor of Credit reported a higher 150,000 points plus a $250 statement credit on August 26, 2026. Offers change and vary.

What is the same

Both are American Express cards tied to one hotel group, with a free night each year, complimentary elite status, and the same listed APR range of 19.74% to 28.74% variable. The Brilliant lists no foreign transaction fee; the Aspire's profile does not state one. Both profiles say credits require enrollment or have rules, so check the issuer's terms.

What neither does

Neither profile describes points transfers to other hotel chains, and both put most of their value in a single chain. The Aspire's profile reports Priority Pass was removed; the Brilliant still lists it.

When to choose neither

For a lower fee in the same chains, compare Hilton Honors American Express Surpass Card or Marriott Bonvoy Bevy American Express Card. For flexible points with broad travel credits and lounge access, compare The Platinum Card from American Express. The annual fee break-even calculator tests your own numbers.

Side by side

Hilton Honors American Express Aspire Card Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant American Express Card
Type Hotel co-brand Hotel co-brand
Annual fee $550 $650
Purchase APR 19.74%-28.74% variable (as listed by The Points Guy, as of November 2026) 19.74%-28.74% variable (as listed by The Points Guy, as of November 2026)
Cash advance APR 28.99% variable (as listed by The Points Guy, as of November 2026) 28.99% variable (as listed by The Points Guy, as of November 2026)
Foreign transaction fee — No foreign transaction fee (per The Points Guy and Doctor of Credit, as of November 2026)
Penalty APR 29.99% variable (as listed by The Points Guy, as of November 2026) 29.99% variable (as listed by The Points Guy, as of November 2026)
How it earns 14X Hilton Honors Bonus Points at participating Hilton hotels and resorts; 7X on flights booked directly with airlines or through American Express Travel, car rentals booked directly with select companies, and U.S. restaurants; 3X on all other eligible purchases (as listed by The Points Guy, November 2026) 6X Marriott Bonvoy points at participating Marriott Bonvoy hotels; 3X at restaurants worldwide and on flights booked directly with airlines; 2X on all other eligible purchases (as of November 2026)
Welcome offer 200,000 Hilton Honors Bonus Points after $6,000 in purchases in the first 6 months; offer ends 1/13/2027 (as listed in November 2026; offers change) 100,000 Marriott Bonvoy points after $6,000 in purchases in the first 6 months as listed by The Points Guy in November 2026; Doctor of Credit reported a higher 150,000 points plus $250 statement credit after $6,000 on August 26, 2026 (offers change and vary)
Rewards program Hilton Honors Marriott Bonvoy
Issuer American Express American Express
Network American Express American Express
Type Hotel co-brand Hotel co-brand
Status Open to new applicants Open to new applicants
Credit needed Good to excellent Good to excellent
Best suited to Frequent Hilton guests who will use the resort credit, flight credit and free nights enough to cover the $550 fee. Frequent Marriott guests who will use the dining credit, free night and lounge access enough to justify the $650 fee.
Key benefits
  • Complimentary Hilton Honors Diamond status
  • Free Night Reward each membership year
  • Up to $400 a year in Hilton resort credits
  • Up to $200 a year in flight credits
  • Up to $219 a year toward CLEAR Plus
  • National Emerald Club Executive status
  • Free Night Award each year valid up to 85000 points
  • Complimentary Marriott Bonvoy Platinum Elite status
  • 25 Elite Night Credits each calendar year
  • Up to $300 a year in dining credits
  • Priority Pass lounge membership
  • Global Entry or TSA PreCheck credit
  • No foreign transaction fee
Drawbacks
  • High annual fee
  • Resort credit applies only at eligible resorts
  • Credits need enrollment and use
  • Points are tied to Hilton
  • High annual fee
  • Credits require use and enrollment
  • Earning is tied to Marriott
  • Welcome offers vary

Facts come from each profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. APRs are variable and offers change: confirm on the issuer's own page before you apply.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

In the index now