Blog

Three fliers react when an airline program pays on dollars spent

Three invented fliers show how a switch from distance-based to spend-based earning helps some travelers and hurts others, without naming any real program.

For decades the standard deal in airline loyalty was simple: fly a mile, earn a mile. Over time, several programs moved toward paying on the money you spend with the airline instead of the distance you travel. The announcement usually arrives as good news in the first paragraph and as a long list of conditions in the rest. Whether the change is good for you depends on how you fly, and in particular on what you pay per mile.

This post follows three invented fliers through one invented program change. It does not describe any real airline's formula; those are published, with dates, by the programs themselves, and the profiles on this site link to them. The numbers are chosen to be easy to follow so you can substitute your own. Everything about the invented program is an assumption, and the point is the method: take twelve months of tickets, apply the old and the new rule, and see which side of the change you are on.

The invented change

Say a program has paid 1 mile for every mile flown and is switching to 5 miles for every dollar of the base fare. "Base fare" here means the ticket price excluding government taxes and fees, and, in this example, excluding any extras such as seat selection. The program also says it will keep the same award prices, so a given trip costs the same number of miles before and after.

Two terms matter in what follows. miles are the spendable currency. And a redemption is a trip or product bought with them. A change in how miles are earned does not change what a trip costs in miles, unless the program changes that as well. If it does, the two changes compound, and award charts versus dynamic pricing for flights, and why it matters explains how award pricing works.

To compare the rules, divide: under the old rule you earn miles per mile flown, under the new you earn miles per dollar paid. The break-even is the fare per mile flown at which the two rules pay the same. If the new rule gives 5 miles per dollar and the old gives 1 mile per mile, then 5 × price per mile = 1, so the price per mile is $0.20. A flier paying 20 cents per mile of distance earns the same under both rules. A flier paying more earns more under the new rule, and a flier paying less earns less.

That one number, 20 cents per mile in this example, is the most useful thing to calculate. Divide the base fare you paid by the miles you flew, and compare it with the program's break-even.

Flier one: Marisol, the bargain leisure traveler

Marisol flies three round trips a year to see family, all cross-country, about 2,500 miles each way. She watches fares and books the cheapest she can find, which has averaged $150 each way in the base fare.

  • Old rule. 3 round trips × 2 legs × 2,500 miles = 15,000 miles.
  • New rule. 3 × 2 = 6 legs × $150 = $900 in base fares, and $900 × 5 = 4,500 miles.
  • Change. 4,500 − 15,000 = −10,500 miles, a 70 percent drop.

Her fare per mile is $150 ÷ 2,500 = $0.06, well below the break-even of $0.20, which is why she loses so much. In practical terms, if an award costs 25,000 miles, she once earned enough for one every 25,000 ÷ 15,000 = 1.67 years and now earns one every 25,000 ÷ 4,500 = 5.56 years. Under the new rule, flying alone will rarely fund a trip for her.

What she might do. Marisol has several choices, and none is obviously right.

  1. She can keep flying the cheapest fares and treat any miles as a small bonus, which costs her nothing in ticket price.
  2. She can look at whether a credit card in the program earns enough on everyday spending to replace what she lost; this is the subject of flier three below.
  3. She can shop other airlines' programs, since a program that pays on distance, if there is one on her routes, may fit her pattern better.
  4. She can book a slightly more expensive fare if it comes with a meaningful benefit, but not simply to earn miles. Paying $60 extra to earn 300 additional miles is paying 20 cents per mile of earnings, which is only sensible if a mile is worth more than that to her.

Notice the last point. Under a spend-based rule, extra dollars buy miles at a fixed price: $1 of fare earns 5 miles, so earning 100 miles costs $20 of fare. Whether that is attractive depends on what miles are worth to you. If a mile is worth 1.3 cents, 100 miles are worth $1.30, and $20 of extra fare to earn them is a loss of $18.70. The earning rate does not turn a fare increase into a bargain.

Flier two: Teddy, the short-haul business traveler

Teddy flies 40 round trips a year for work between two cities 400 miles apart. The company buys flexible fares that cost $380 each way in base fare.

  • Old rule. 40 × 2 × 400 = 32,000 miles. (Some programs have a minimum credit per flight, which would raise this a little. This example assumes none.)
  • New rule. 40 × 2 = 80 legs × $380 = $30,400 in base fares, and $30,400 × 5 = 152,000 miles.
  • Change. 152,000 − 32,000 = +120,000 miles, almost five times as many.

His fare per mile is $380 ÷ 400 = $0.95, far above the $0.20 break-even. Under an award price of 25,000 miles, he went from one award every 25,000 ÷ 32,000 = 0.78 years to six a year, 152,000 ÷ 25,000 = 6.08.

What he might notice. Teddy has gained the most, and several things are worth checking before he enjoys it.

  • Whose miles are they? The miles go to the account on the ticket, which is Teddy's. Employers sometimes have policies on personal use of business-earned miles, and tax and expense rules vary. Those questions are for an employer or a tax professional.
  • Do the miles expire or lose value? A bigger balance matters only if it can be spent. Do points and miles expire? How inactivity rules work covers the rules on expiry, and anatomy of a points devaluation, from first rumors to the new chart shows how a pile of miles can lose purchasing power when award prices rise.
  • Is the ticket price the one that counts? If the company's fares are booked through a corporate channel, the program may treat some of them differently. Teddy would check which tickets qualify.
  • What does the change do to his elite status? Programs that move earning to dollars often move status qualification to dollars as well, and a person who spends $30,400 a year with the airline is likely to be affected there too. See how airline elite status is earned, from flying to spending to cards.

Flier three: Joyce, the card-first member

Joyce flies two round trips a year, each 1,800 miles each way at $260 base fare each way, so she is no road warrior. She does, however, hold the airline's co-brand airline credit card and puts $30,000 a year of ordinary spending on it, earning an invented 1.5 miles per dollar.

  • Flying, old rule. 2 × 2 × 1,800 = 7,200 miles.
  • Flying, new rule. 2 × 2 = 4 legs × $260 = $1,040, and $1,040 × 5 = 5,200 miles.
  • Card. $30,000 × 1.5 = 45,000 miles, unchanged by the rule in this example.
  • Total, old. 45,000 + 7,200 = 52,200.
  • Total, new. 45,000 + 5,200 = 50,200.
  • Change. −2,000 miles, about 3.8 percent.

For Joyce the program change barely registers, because her balance comes from the card, not from the cabin. Her flying changed by 2,000 miles out of 7,200, a 28 percent drop in the flying component, but the flying is under a sixth of her total.

What she should watch. The card, not the ticket, is where a program change would hurt or help her, so she would check three things.

  1. Did the card's earn rate change in the same announcement? Programs sometimes adjust cards and the base program at once. Read the cardholder notice, not only the airline's.
  2. Does her card spending count toward status under the new rules? Some programs let it, and the details are different each year.
  3. Is the airline paid more or less by the bank for each mile? She cannot see this, but it is the reason co-brand cards exist: how airlines profit from co-brand credit cards, and what that means for you explains it, and Is an airline credit card worth it? Three flyers, three answers shows how different fliers come out on the card.

What the three have in common

Put the three side by side:

Flier Fare per mile flown Old rule New rule Change
Marisol $0.06 15,000 4,500 −10,500
Teddy $0.95 32,000 152,000 +120,000
Joyce (flying only) $0.14 7,200 5,200 −2,000

Joyce's fare per mile is $260 ÷ 1,800 = $0.144, which rounds to $0.14. Every row fits the same rule: below 20 cents per mile you lose, above you gain, and the size of the change grows with the distance from 20 cents.

Several consequences follow.

A program changing its earn rule is choosing who to reward. A spend-based rule pays most to those who pay the airline the most, which tends to mean business travelers and people on premium fares. This is why such changes are announced alongside new perks for high spenders.

Totals matter more than rates. The headline "five miles per dollar" is generous in appearance and means little unless you know your fare per mile and how many miles you fly.

The swing is not a loss or gain in value, only in miles. What a mile buys depends on award prices, and if those move, the picture changes again. cents per point: why the same 10,000 points can be worth very different amounts shows how to value a mile, and dynamic award pricing describes the design in which prices follow cash fares. If award prices rise in step with the earn change, the apparent gains and losses partly cancel. A devaluation is exactly that: the same miles buying less.

The same change, seen as a rebate on the fare

A spend-based rule is easier to judge once you turn it into a percentage of what you pay. Say you value a mile at 1.3 cents, an illustrative figure and not a market rate. Five miles per dollar then returns 5 × $0.013 = $0.065 on every dollar of base fare, which is 6.5 percent. If you value a mile at 1.8 cents, the same rule returns 5 × $0.018 = $0.09, or 9 percent. If you value a mile at 1 cent, it returns 5 percent.

That framing shows two things. First, the earning rate is not generous or stingy on its own; it is the rate times what a mile is worth to you. cents per point: why the same 10,000 points can be worth very different amounts shows how the value of a mile changes with what you redeem it for. Second, it tells you what an award costs in flying. If a trip costs 25,000 miles, then at 5 miles per dollar you have to pay $5,000 of base fares to earn it, and if a trip of that kind would cost $450 in cash, you are earning a $450 trip for every $5,000 of flying, which is 9 percent. Marisol's $900 a year of fares earns her 4,500 miles, a fifth of one award.

A traveler sitting at the break-even shows the rule's neutrality. Say Dev flies 10 round trips of 1,000 miles each way on $200 fares each way. The fare per mile is $200 ÷ 1,000 = $0.20, exactly the break-even.

  • Old rule: 10 × 2 × 1,000 = 20,000 miles.
  • New rule: 20 legs × $200 = $4,000, and $4,000 × 5 = 20,000 miles.

Nothing changes in miles earned. But Dev now has a lever he did not have before: paying 10 percent more per ticket, $220 instead of $200, raises earning by 10 percent to 22,000 miles, while flying farther for the same price no longer helps. Under the old rule the lever was distance, so a long, cheap itinerary was the efficient way to earn. Under the new rule the lever is the fare, so the efficient way to earn is to pay more per mile, which is not the same as earning more per dollar. That is why a spend-based rule makes the cheapest fare and the best earning fare opposite choices.

A worksheet to run on your own year

  1. Gather your tickets for the last twelve months: the base fare (excluding taxes), the origin and destination, and the cabin.
  2. Add up the distance of each leg. If you do not know it, the airline's earning calculator or your account history lists it.
  3. Compute your fare per mile: total base fare ÷ total miles flown.
  4. Compare with the break-even from the program's new rule, which is 1 ÷ (miles per dollar) for a program that pays 1 mile per mile before. If the new rule is 5 miles per dollar, the break-even is $0.20.
  5. Compute your earnings under both rules and the difference.
  6. Check the other levers: the card, status qualification, partner earning, and any change in award prices.
  7. Decide what to concentrate. If you are on the losing side, ask whether the program still serves you or whether your flying should go where the fare per mile is rewarded.

If you do not have the tickets, your account's activity statement and your email receipts are usually enough to reconstruct the year.

What to keep in mind when you hear an announcement

  • Read the effective date. Changes usually start on a stated date and apply to flights flown or tickets bought after it. Flights already booked may follow the old rule, or may not.
  • Read what counts. Base fare, taxes, fees, fare class, partner flights and tickets bought through third parties are common exclusions.
  • Do not rush to spend miles. A panic redemption at a poor rate is a loss of its own. Miles lose value from devaluation, but a bad redemption loses value immediately. Compare before you act.
  • Do not buy tickets just to earn. A ticket bought for earning, at five miles per dollar, costs far more than the miles are worth in most cases.
  • Beware of messages about "your account." Program changes bring scam emails and texts about updating accounts. Use the airline's own site or app, and call the number on the back of your card if a message mentions your card.

Key takeaways

  • A spend-based earn rule pays by the dollar, so what matters is your fare per mile flown. In the invented example, the break-even was 20 cents per mile of distance.
  • Below the break-even you earn less: Marisol, paying 6 cents per mile, fell from 15,000 to 4,500 miles. Above it you earn more: Teddy, paying 95 cents per mile, rose from 32,000 to 152,000.
  • A card can dwarf the flying: Joyce's total moved by only 3.8 percent because 45,000 of her 52,200 miles came from card spending.
  • The earning change is half the story, because award prices, expiry, status rules and the card's terms decide what the miles are worth.
  • Run the worksheet on your own twelve months of tickets before deciding anything, and never buy a ticket only to earn miles.

Terms used in this article

Latest on this topic