Blog

Do I need a balance transfer card or a 0% purchase card?

Intro-rate cards do two different jobs: paying down old debt or financing a planned purchase. Criteria, arithmetic and a decision list for choosing.

"0% APR" appears on two quite different products, and the advertising often blurs them. One is built to take over debt you already have, moving it from a card that charges interest to one that charges none for a set period. The other is built to carry new purchases at no interest for a set period. Some cards do both, some do only one, and a card that does one job well can do the other badly. If you pick by the headline rate, you may end up with a card that is wrong for your situation.

This post separates the two jobs, shows the arithmetic for each, explains how they interact when they are on one card, and ends with a list of criteria. Every figure below is an invented illustration with round numbers. The terms of a real offer, including the length of the intro period, the fee and the rate afterward, are in its Schumer box and agreement.

The two jobs

Job one: pay down debt you already carry. A balance transfer moves a balance from one card to another. If the new card offers an Introductory APR on transfers, the moved balance accrues no interest, or very little, for the length of the intro period. The point is to turn every payment into principal instead of paying part of it as interest. You usually pay a balance transfer fee, which is commonly published in guides as about 3 to 5 percent of the amount moved, and some cards waive it in promotions.

Job two: finance a purchase you are about to make. A card with an introductory APR on purchases charges no interest on new purchases for a set period. The point is to spread a planned cost over several months without paying for the privilege. It has no transfer fee, because nothing is being transferred, though it often has an annual fee or a higher purchase APR after the intro period ends.

The two share a number, 0%, and a clock, the intro period, but they differ in what they take as input. The first takes an existing balance, and the second takes a purchase you have not made yet. Most people have one of these problems and not the other. If you have both, the advice changes, as a later section explains.

The payoff arithmetic: when a transfer is worth it

Say Elena has $6,000 on a card at an illustrative 24% APR, and she can pay $343.33 a month.

If she stays put. Interest in the first month is $6,000 × 0.24 ÷ 12 = $120.00, so only about $223 of her payment reduces the balance. Paying $343.33 a month at 24%, she is debt-free in 22 months and pays about $1,457 in interest.

If she transfers to a card with a 3% fee and an 18-month 0% intro rate. The fee is $6,000 × 0.03 = $180, so the new balance is $6,180. Divided over 18 months, that is $6,180 ÷ 18 = $343.33 a month. She is debt-free in 18 months for a total cost of $180.

The difference is about $1,457 − $180 = $1,277 in her favor, with four fewer months of payments. At a 5 percent fee, the fee is $300, the balance is $6,300 and the monthly figure to clear it in 18 months is $350. The saving falls to about $1,157, still large.

Three conditions made the transfer work in that example. She could actually pay $343.33 a month. She did not run up new balances on the old card. She had a clear date by which the balance would be zero. If any of the three fails, the picture changes, and Three households weigh a balance transfer card. Who should skip it? shows what that looks like. The balance transfer calculator and the 0% intro APR payoff planner let you try your own numbers.

The purchase arithmetic: when 0% on purchases is worth it

Say Tomas needs to replace a $3,000 appliance and can afford $250 a month.

On a card with a 12-month 0% purchase rate. $3,000 ÷ 12 = $250 a month, so he pays it off by the end of the intro period at no interest.

On a regular card at an illustrative 24% APR. The first month's interest is $3,000 × 0.24 ÷ 12 = $60. Paying $250 a month, he clears the balance in 14 months and pays about $465 in interest.

The saving is about $465. It is smaller in dollars than Elena's, because the amount is smaller and the time is shorter, but it is real. It disappears if Tomas does not pay in full by the end of the intro period. Say he pays only $200 a month. After 12 months he has paid $2,400 and owes $600, which then begins to accrue interest at the card's regular rate. One month of that is $600 × 0.24 ÷ 12 = $12.00. A modest bite, but not zero.

There is one more caution. If a promotional offer is a store's deferred interest financing and not a true 0% rate, the rules are different, and leftover balance at the end can trigger interest back to the purchase date. Deferred interest vs a true 0% APR: how to tell the offers apart explains that distinction. Check which one you have before you sign.

Can one card do both jobs?

Often yes, which is where it gets tricky. A card may offer 0% on transfers for 18 months and 0% on purchases for 12, or two different lengths, or 0% on one and a regular rate on the other. Read the Schumer box for the rate and the length for each, separately.

When one account holds balances at different rates, how payments are applied matters. Under federal rules, any amount you pay above the minimum must be applied first to the balance with the highest APR. The minimum itself can be allocated by the issuer, often to the lowest-rate balance. The effect, if you transfer $6,000 at 0% and then add $500 of purchases at the card's regular 24% rate, is that your payments above the minimum go to the purchases first. That is actually a good outcome for you, because it clears the costly balance first, but it can leave the 0% balance ticking along and the clock running.

Another problem is the grace period. On many cards, carrying a promotional balance does not lose the grace period on new purchases, but on some it does, and new purchases may accrue interest from the day you make them. This is in the cardholder agreement, and it is worth reading before you use a transfer card for anything else. The simplest rule for a transfer card is not to use it for purchases at all during the intro period.

Criteria: which job is yours?

Ask these questions about your own situation, in this order.

  1. Do I have a balance now that carries interest? If yes, the transfer job applies. If no, you do not need a transfer.
  2. Do I have a purchase planned within the next few months that I cannot pay for in cash? If yes, the purchase job applies.
  3. Could I pay the full amount within the intro period? Divide the amount, including any fee, by the number of months. If you cannot afford that monthly figure, neither job will finish on time.
  4. Will the offer be available to me? Approval and the limit depend on your credit and the issuer. A transfer cannot exceed the new card's limit, and an issuer will not usually accept a transfer from its own card. Why was my balance transfer denied, or approved for less than I asked? covers common reasons for a smaller limit.
  5. What is the rate after the promotion? A card with a long intro period and a high rate afterward is a bad fit if you may not finish.
  6. What is the fee? For a transfer, the fee is a cost on day one. For a purchase card, check for an annual fee.
  7. Will I leave the old card alone? If the answer is no, a transfer might lead to two balances instead of one.

Comparing three offers on paper

Suppose Elena finds three offers for her $6,000 balance. All are invented. She can pay $343.33 a month, and she wants the cheapest way to finish.

Offer 1 Offer 2 Offer 3
Transfer fee 3% 5% 0%
Intro period 18 months 21 months 12 months
Balance after fee $6,180 $6,300 $6,000
Monthly payment to finish inside the period $343.33 $300.00 $500.00
Fits her $343.33 budget? Yes, exactly Yes, with room No

The monthly figures are the balance divided by the months: $6,180 ÷ 18 = $343.33, $6,300 ÷ 21 = $300.00 and $6,000 ÷ 12 = $500.00. Offer 3 has no fee but is out of reach on her budget, so it would leave a balance when the period ends. If it left $6,000 − (12 × $343.33) = $1,880.04 unpaid, then at an illustrative 24% APR the first month of interest on that is about $37.60, and it would take several more months to clear. Offer 2 costs $120 more in fees than Offer 1 but leaves her $43.33 a month of breathing room and three extra months of protection. Whether that is worth $120 depends on how steady her income is. If a surprise expense is likely, the cushion may be the better buy. If her budget is stable, Offer 1 is cheaper.

Notice what the table does not contain: anything about rewards, because a transfer card is judged on cost and fit. Notice also what it does not guarantee: that she will be approved for a $6,300 transfer limit, or that the offer is still on the market when she applies.

A calendar that keeps the clock honest

Whichever job you choose, the intro period is a deadline, and deadlines are easier to meet when you write them down on day one. Put these items in your calendar the day the account is approved.

  • Day 1: the date the offer started, and the date it ends. Some offers count from account opening, not from the date of the transfer, so a transfer made in month two has a shorter window than it seems.
  • Within the transfer window: the last date a transfer is eligible for the promotional rate, if the agreement sets one.
  • Every statement: the balance, the amount you must pay to finish on time, and the minimum. They are three different numbers, and the minimum is usually far lower than the one that finishes the job.
  • Two months before the end: the date to check your remaining balance and decide whether to pay a lump sum, move to another offer or ask a counselor.
  • Last statement of the period: the date to make sure the balance is zero or the plan for the rest is settled.

Set autopay to a fixed amount equal to the monthly figure, not to the minimum, because the minimum will not finish the balance in time. Say Elena's minimum is $62 and her finishing payment is $343.33. If she leaves autopay on the minimum, at the end of 18 months she will have paid $62 × 18 = $1,116, and $6,180 − $1,116 = $5,064 will remain and start to accrue interest. That is the typical way a transfer fails: not through an unexpected fee, but because the default payment is set for the wrong goal.

What to do when you realize you will not finish

Sooner or later some readers find themselves four months from the end with more owing than they can pay. Do not wait for the last statement. Start with the numbers.

  1. Work out the exact balance and the date the rate changes.
  2. Compute the payment that would clear it on time, and the gap between that and what you can pay. If the gap is small, a one-time payment from savings or a tax refund may close it.
  3. If the gap is large, ask whether a second transfer is available. A new card might accept the remaining balance, though that means a second fee and a new application with a hard inquiry, and approval depends on your credit and income.
  4. Look at the rate you would pay on what remains. A small remainder at a regular APR is a modest cost. A large remainder is the problem to solve.
  5. If you are struggling to meet the payments at all, call the number on the back of the card and ask about hardship programs, and consider a nonprofit credit counselor, who can look at the whole budget. My balance transfer offer ends soon and I still owe. What now? covers this situation in more detail.

Fine print that applies to both

A few federal rules apply to promotional rates on consumer cards, and they are worth knowing, though the offer's own terms control the details.

  • A promotional rate must last at least six months, and the rate that applies afterward must be disclosed up front.
  • The issuer cannot raise the rate on your existing balance during the promotion except in specific cases, such as when your minimum payment is more than 60 days late.
  • Fees charged in the first year of an account are limited to 25 percent of the credit limit, with certain penalty fees excluded.
  • A rate increase generally needs 45 days' written notice, and some changes can be rejected.

Practical points that the rules do not cover: transfers often must be requested within a window after account opening, a promotional rate may be lost if you pay late, and the offer may apply only to a balance transferred from another issuer. All of that is in the agreement. a balance transfer from start to finish, fee and deadline included walks through a transfer from request to last payment.

When neither card is the answer

An intro-rate card is a tool for people who can finish within the period. It is not an answer if the balance is too large for the budget, or if the underlying cause is that spending exceeds income. In those cases, a transfer may postpone the problem and add a fee. Options worth discussing with a nonprofit credit counselor include a debt management plan, a consolidation loan with a fixed rate, or a budget rebuilt around the real numbers. A consolidation loan's costs are laid out in consolidation loan, balance transfer or paying cards in place?. If you are already behind on payments, call the number on the back of your card and ask about hardship options before taking on a new account.

A decision list you can reuse

Write your answers to these and the choice usually follows.

  • Existing balance, can pay it within the intro period: a balance transfer card.
  • Existing balance, cannot pay it within the period, but the 0% rate would still help: a transfer may still reduce interest, but plan for what happens after, and consider a fixed-rate alternative.
  • Planned purchase, can pay it within the period: a 0% purchase card.
  • Existing balance and a planned purchase: handle the balance first, and delay the purchase, or choose a card that offers both with clear terms and keep the two apart.
  • No balance, no planned purchase: you do not need an intro-rate card, and a card chosen for its ongoing terms may serve you better.

Key takeaways

  • A 0% transfer card takes an existing balance, and a 0% purchase card takes new spending. They solve different problems.
  • Divide the full amount, plus any transfer fee, by the intro months to find the payment you must make. If you cannot afford it, the offer will not finish on time.
  • In an illustration, moving $6,000 at a 3% fee saved about $1,277 against staying at 24%, but only because the balance was cleared in the window.
  • Payments above the minimum go to the highest-rate balance, which helps when a card holds both promotional and regular balances.
  • Do not use a transfer card for new purchases during the promotion unless you have read how the grace period works on it.
  • If the balance is larger than your budget can clear, talk to a nonprofit credit counselor before choosing a card.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic