Blog

A year of cash back versus a year of interest on a carried balance

Three labeled households spend the same amount on a cash-back card but carry different balances. The arithmetic shows when interest cancels the rewards.

A card that returns 2 percent of everything you spend sounds like free money, and for a household that pays its statement in full every month it is close to that. For a household that carries a balance from month to month, the same card can quietly cost more in interest than it returns in rewards. The two numbers live on different statements, one in the rewards app and one in the interest line, and people rarely put them side by side. This post puts them side by side.

Three invented households spend the same amount on the same invented card, and differ only in the balance they carry. The point is the shape of the answer, which holds for any card: there is a balance size at which the interest eats the whole reward, and it is lower than most people expect. Every rate and amount below is an illustration and not a market figure.

The shared setup

All three households use one card.

  • It pays 2 percent cash back on every purchase.
  • Its APR is an illustrative 24 percent, a round number a little above the Federal Reserve's reported average of 22.36 percent for card accounts that were assessed interest in the third quarter of 2026. That Fed figure is real, for commercial banks, and the card here is not any real card.
  • Each household charges $2,000 a month, or $24,000 a year.
  • No annual fee.

The rewards are the same for all three: 2 percent of $24,000 is $480 a year, or $40 a month. What differs is interest.

To compute interest I need the monthly rate. A 24 percent APR divided by 12 gives 2 percent a month. (Issuers typically compute interest daily, at a daily periodic rate equal to the APR divided by 365 or 360, and add it up over the cycle, so the monthly figure is a close approximation.) That is the simple and common approach: interest each month is about the average balance times the monthly rate, where the average balance is what the card's balance method calls the average daily balance. The precise method is in the card's agreement and is explained in work out one month of card interest by hand with average daily balance.

Household A: pays in full every month

Anna charges $2,000 a month and pays the full statement balance by the due date, every month. Because she pays in full, she keeps the grace period, the stretch between a purchase and the due date in which a new purchase does not accrue interest. A grace period, where a card offers one, applies when the prior balance was paid in full by the due date.

  • Interest: $0.
  • Rewards: $480.
  • Net: +$480 a year.

This is the case the rewards pitch describes. For Anna, the card is a modest 2 percent discount on spending she was going to do anyway.

Household B: carries a small balance

Ben has the same $2,000 a month in purchases but uses his card as revolving credit: he carries a balance of $1,000 from month to month that he does not pay off. He pays more than the minimum, enough to keep the balance from growing, but he never clears it.

Interest on a carried balance is easy to underestimate for a reason that matters here. Once you carry a balance, you generally lose the grace period on new purchases, so each new purchase begins to accrue interest from the day it posts. That means interest is charged not only on the $1,000 that is carried but also on the new purchases while they sit unpaid.

Two estimates bracket it.

  • Lower estimate, interest on the carried balance only. $1,000 × 24% = $240 a year ($20 a month).
  • Higher estimate, also counting new purchases. If Ben charges $2,000 evenly across the month and the new purchases sit unpaid until the end of the cycle, they average about $1,000 outstanding over the month. His average balance is then about $1,000 (carried) plus $1,000 (new purchases) = $2,000. Interest is $2,000 × 2% = $40 a month, or $480 a year.

The truth depends on the card's balance method, how the payments are timed within the cycle and when the new purchases land. It will fall somewhere in or near this range.

  • Rewards: $480.
  • Interest: about $240 to $480.
  • Net: about +$240 down to $0.

At the upper end, Ben's interest equals his entire rewards. A $1,000 balance sounds small. It is the amount that moves a household from +$480 to roughly nothing.

Household C: carries a larger balance

Chloe also charges $2,000 a month but carries $5,000 from month to month.

  • Lower estimate: $5,000 × 24% = $1,200 a year.
  • Higher estimate: an average balance of about $5,000 + $1,000 = $6,000, so $6,000 × 24% = $1,440 a year.
  • Rewards: $480.
  • Net: about −$720 to −$960.

Chloe pays $720 to $960 a year more than she receives, in effect paying 3 to 4 percent of her spending to hold the card. The rewards do not offset the interest. They offset a third to two-fifths of it at best. Her real problem is the balance, and the rewards structure does not change that.

The break-even balance

There is a simple way to find where interest cancels rewards. Rewards per year equal the reward rate times annual spending. Interest per year, on the lower estimate, equals the APR times the carried balance. Set them equal and solve for the balance:

break-even carried balance = (reward rate × annual spending) ÷ APR

With the shared setup, that is (0.02 × $24,000) ÷ 0.24 = $480 ÷ 0.24 = $2,000. A carried balance of $2,000 produces $480 of interest, the same as the rewards, on the lower estimate. On the higher estimate, which counts new purchases, the break-even balance is only $1,000, because the new purchases are counted in the average.

At the Fed's 22.36 percent average for accounts assessed interest, the break-even is $480 ÷ 0.2236 = about $2,147, a bit higher because the interest rate is a bit lower.

Here is how the break-even moves with spending, at 24 percent and the lower estimate.

Yearly card spending Cash back at 2% Break-even carried balance
$12,000 $240 $1,000
$24,000 $480 $2,000
$36,000 $720 $3,000

The break-even scales with spending, but slowly, and it is modest next to the balances many households carry. For perspective, the Federal Reserve's 2025 household survey found that 45 percent of cardholders carried a balance at least once in the prior twelve months, and the survey's average card balance among respondents with cards was $7,279 in 2025. That average includes people who pay in full, so it is not a typical carried balance, but it shows that a balance of a few thousand dollars is ordinary.

The month-by-month view

The reason this is easy to miss is that interest comes in small monthly bites and rewards in small monthly credits. Look at one month for Household B, on the lower estimate.

  • Rewards: 2% of $2,000 = $40.
  • Interest: 2% of $1,000 = $20.
  • Net for the month: +$20.

On the higher estimate it is $40 − $40 = $0. In either case it looks fine in a given month, and the loss shows up only when you total a year. And if the balance grows, which happens when a household pays only a little more than interest and charges as much as before, the interest line grows and the reward line does not.

A useful way to see the problem: at 24 percent, the monthly interest rate is 2 percent. A card that pays 2 percent cash back on spending and charges 2 percent a month on a balance pays you $2 for every $100 you spend and charges you $2 for every $100 you carry for a month. If you carry a balance equal to one month of your spending, the two are equal. Does carrying a balance build credit? What the interest costs instead makes a related point about carrying a balance for a reason people often believe, and six ways people lose their grace period without realizing it lists how the grace period goes.

What Chloe could do about it

Rewards are not the solution for Chloe, but she has options. Here are the arithmetic and the logic of paying the balance down, without recommending any product.

Say Chloe stops adding new charges to the card and pays $250 a month toward the $5,000 balance at the same 24 percent APR (2 percent a month). Each month, interest is added and then her payment is subtracted. Running that forward, the balance is cleared in 26 payments, with the last one smaller than $250, and she pays about $1,449 in interest over that time (the total of her payments is about $6,449). If she pays $300 a month instead, the balance clears in 21 payments and the interest is about $1,143. The extra $50 a month cuts about $306 of interest and five months of payments. The credit card payoff calculator does this arithmetic for any balance, rate and payment.

If she keeps charging $2,000 a month on the card while paying $250, the balance does not fall, because new charges exceed her payment. The break between "the card's balance is shrinking" and "the card's balance is stable or growing" is the single most important fact about a carried balance. Moving everyday spending to a debit card or cash while paying the balance down is one way households stop the growth, and how to build a credit card payoff plan you can actually stick to sets out a complete plan. A nonprofit credit counselor can help if payments are hard, and a hardship call to the issuer, using the number on the back of the card, is a reasonable step when you are close to missing one.

Do not skip minimum payments to fund the larger payoff. A late payment adds a fee and can raise the rate, and the plan loses more than it gains.

A fourth case: the balance that comes and goes

Not every household carries a balance all year. Say Dana usually pays in full, then carries $3,000 for four months around the holidays and clears it in the new year. Using the lower estimate, interest is the balance times the monthly rate times the months carried: $3,000 × 2% × 4 = $240. Her rewards are still $480, so the net is +$240.

Two things are worth noticing. First, a temporary balance costs in proportion to how long it stays. Carrying $3,000 for one month costs $60, and for twelve months, $720. Second, the loss of the grace period applies in the months she carries, so her new purchases in those months also accrue interest, and her true cost is above $240. The takeaway is that a seasonal balance is far cheaper than a permanent one but not free, and that the break-even idea works on any period: compare the interest on the balance for the months it is carried with the rewards earned over the same months.

What a higher reward rate does and does not change

A bigger reward lifts the break-even, but only in proportion. Suppose the same household moved to a card that paid 3 percent on all spending (an invented rate, since few cards pay that much on everything). Rewards would be 3% of $24,000 = $720, and at 24 percent the break-even balance becomes $720 ÷ 0.24 = $3,000, up from $2,000. A 50 percent bigger reward bought a 50 percent bigger break-even, and it is still a balance of $3,000 against a typical American card balance in the thousands.

A bonus category works the same way, with the rewards in the category only. And a welcome bonus, which is a one-time reward, covers the interest on a carried balance for a short time and then stops. The reward rate is one number that you cannot make large enough to beat a 24 percent APR for a household that stays in debt. Choosing a lower-APR card or a promotional balance-transfer offer, which come with their own fees and terms, addresses the interest directly. Those are separate decisions with their own arithmetic, and they belong to the posts on balance transfers, not to a rewards comparison.

What the three households teach

  1. The same card is three different products. For Anna it is a discount. For Ben it is roughly a wash. For Chloe it is a loan with a small rebate.
  2. The break-even is lower than it feels. A balance of about one month of spending can cancel the rewards, and a second month's worth turns them negative.
  3. Losing the grace period raises the cost on every purchase, not just on the carried balance, which is why Ben's cost may be near the high end of the range.
  4. Rewards rates are small next to APRs. A 2 percent reward is a once-a-year return on spending, and a 24 percent APR is a once-a-year cost on a balance. A dollar carried costs about twelve times what a dollar spent earns.

Check the last one. Annual reward on a dollar spent once is 2 cents. Annual interest on a dollar carried all year is 24 cents. The ratio is 12, and so a household carrying $1 for the whole year offsets the rewards on $12 of spending.

A quick test for your own card

  1. Find your yearly rewards. Use your rewards summary or multiply spending by your rate.
  2. Find your yearly interest. Add the interest charged line on twelve statements, or multiply your average carried balance by your APR as a first estimate. The credit card interest calculator helps.
  3. Subtract. Rewards minus interest is the net.
  4. If the net is negative or small, the decision to make is about the balance, not the card.
  5. If you pay in full, none of this applies, and the rewards are what they appear to be.

Key takeaways

  • With a 2% cash-back card, $24,000 of yearly spending earns $480. At an illustrative 24% APR, a carried balance of about $2,000 costs $480 in interest on the lower estimate, which cancels it.
  • Carrying a balance usually costs you the grace period, so interest also accrues on new purchases. That can halve the break-even balance, which was $1,000 in the higher estimate.
  • In the example, Anna (pays in full) nets +$480, Ben ($1,000 carried) about +$240 down to $0, and Chloe ($5,000 carried) about −$720 to −$960.
  • Break-even carried balance equals the reward rate times annual spending, divided by the APR. Chasing a higher reward rate does not change the order of magnitude.
  • If you carry a balance, the first move is to pay it down and stop adding to it, and to call the issuer's number on the back of the card if a payment looks out of reach.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic