Blog
What a cash advance costs from day one, with fee and no grace period
A worked example of a cash advance's up-front fee plus interest that starts the same day, why it costs more per dollar than a purchase, and what to check first.
A cash advance costs two things at once. You pay a fee at the moment you take the money, and you pay interest from that same day, with no interest-free window to protect you. On a $500 advance held for a month, with the illustrative terms used below, that comes to about $37, which is roughly 7 percent of the amount in a single month. The same $500, spent on a purchase and paid off by the due date, would cost nothing. This post shows where each part of the charge comes from, runs the numbers for 10, 30 and 60 days, and explains why a cash advance is among the costliest ways to use a card.
All dollar and percentage figures below are labeled hypotheticals chosen for easy arithmetic. They are not any card's terms. The fee and rate on your card are in the Schumer box on its application and in the cardholder agreement, and the cash advance cost calculator runs the same calculation with your numbers.
Three charges, not one
A cash advance is any transaction in which you use the card to get cash or something treated like cash. The most familiar case is a withdrawal at an ATM or bank counter using your credit card and a PIN. The charges come in three layers.
- The up-front fee. Issuers add a cash advance fee to the amount, usually the greater of a percentage or a minimum dollar amount. Published guides describe the percentage as typically about 3 to 5 percent, with a minimum often around $5 to $10. It is billed right away and added to your balance.
- Interest from the first day. There is no grace period on a cash advance. A grace period lets you avoid interest on new purchases if you pay the statement balance in full by the due date. It does not apply to cash advances, so interest starts accruing on the transaction date, and paying your bill in full later does not erase the interest already accrued. The rate is the Cash advance APR, which is usually higher than the Purchase APR on the same card, and your agreement lists it separately.
- Possible extras. An ATM operator may charge its own fee, which the machine should show on the screen before you confirm. Some issuers do not give rewards on cash advances, and the advance may count against a separate, smaller cash limit that sits inside your credit limit.
The result is that you pay to borrow, and you pay immediately. The rest of the post puts numbers on it.
A worked example: $500 for 30 days
Say Sam takes a $500 cash advance. For the example, the fee is 5% of the amount and the cash advance APR is 29%. Sam repays the whole $500 plus the fee 30 days later. The daily periodic rate is APR ÷ 365 (some issuers use 360; the agreement says which), and interest accrues each day on the balance, which in a simple case is the advance plus the fee.
To keep the arithmetic easy to check, this example charges interest on the $500 advance only. Interest on the fee itself adds a small amount that is left out, so real totals will run slightly higher.
- Fee: $500 × 0.05 = $25.00
- Daily rate: 0.29 ÷ 365 = 0.0794521% per day
- Interest per day on $500: $500 × 0.29 ÷ 365 = $0.3973
- Interest for 30 days: $0.3973 × 30 = $11.92
- Total cost of borrowing for 30 days: $25.00 + $11.92 = $36.92
That is $36.92 on $500, or 7.4 percent for a single month. Expressed as an annual rate, it is far above the 29% APR on the statement, because a flat fee spread over a short period is expensive. Dividing $36.92 by $500 and scaling 30 days up to a year (× 365 ÷ 30) gives roughly 90 percent a year. That is an effective cost, not a rate you will see disclosed, and it shows why the fee matters more than the APR for short-term cash.
What it costs at 10, 30 and 60 days
The interest depends on how long the money is out. The fee does not. This table uses the same $500, 5% fee and 29% APR.
| Days outstanding | Interest on $500 | Fee | Total cost | As a share of $500 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | $3.97 | $25.00 | $28.97 | 5.8% |
| 30 | $11.92 | $25.00 | $36.92 | 7.4% |
| 60 | $23.84 | $25.00 | $48.84 | 9.8% |
Two things stand out. First, even if Sam repays within 10 days, 86 percent of the cost is the fee ($25.00 of $28.97). The fee is a fixed price of entry. Second, the cost keeps climbing at about $0.40 a day for as long as the balance remains, and does not stop at the due date.
How it compares with a purchase
Put the same $500 through two other routes with the same illustrative terms: a purchase at a 24% purchase APR.
| Route | Cost for 30 days |
|---|---|
| Buy $500 of goods and pay the statement balance in full by the due date | $0, because of the grace period |
| Buy $500 of goods and carry the balance for 30 days at 24% | $500 × 0.24 ÷ 365 × 30 = $9.86 |
| Take a $500 cash advance and repay in 30 days | $36.92 |
A purchase paid on time is free of interest. A purchase carried for a month costs under $10. The cash advance costs nearly four times as much as the carried purchase, and it is the only one of the three that is charged even if you repay the full amount quickly. A cash advance is the only way of using the card that has no version which costs nothing.
A balance transfer is a useful contrast. Its fee is also paid up front, but a promotional rate can offset it, as how to calculate whether a balance transfer fee is worth paying shows. A cash advance has no promotional rate to do that.
Small advances cost the most per dollar
The minimum fee is what makes small advances expensive. Say the fee is the greater of 5% or $10.
| Advance | 5% of the amount | Fee charged | Fee as a share |
|---|---|---|---|
| $100 | $5 | $10 | 10% |
| $200 | $10 | $10 | 5% |
| $500 | $25 | $25 | 5% |
| $2,000 | $100 | $100 | 5% |
A $100 advance repaid after 30 days costs $10 in fees plus $100 × 0.29 ÷ 365 × 30 = $2.38 in interest, which is $12.38, or 12.4 percent of the amount. For a person tempted to take a little cash to bridge a few days, it is the smallest amounts that carry the highest cost for each dollar.
Why waiting for the bill makes it cost more
The 30-day figure assumes Sam repays on day 30. Many people take the cash and wait for the statement, and the statement cycle adds days. Here is a labeled timeline on the same terms.
| Day | What happens | Running cost |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Sam takes $500. The $25 fee posts the same day. | Fee $25.00 |
| 20 | The statement closes. It shows the $500, the $25 fee and about 20 days of interest: $0.3973 × 20 = $7.95. | $32.95 |
| 45 | The payment is due, 25 days after the close. Sam pays in full. Interest has run 45 days: $0.3973 × 45 = $17.88. | $42.88 |
By waiting for the due date, Sam pays about $42.88 in fees and interest, not $36.92, a difference of roughly $6. Two further details follow from the timeline. First, the statement balance of about $532.95 is not quite the whole story, since interest keeps accruing between the statement date and the day your payment posts, and a small trailing interest charge can appear on the next statement even though you paid "in full." Second, the interest on the fee itself, which the example left out, adds a little more. The lesson is practical: if you take a cash advance, pay it off as soon as you can, not at the due date. A payment made online the next day stops the clock about six weeks earlier.
Questions to ask before you take one
Run through these in order. If any answer is "no" or "I do not know," stop and find out.
- Do I know the fee, the rate and the cash limit on this card? If not, the agreement or the Schumer box has them.
- Is cash the only way to pay this? Many bills accept a card directly, and a purchase has a grace period, which a cash advance does not.
- When exactly will I repay it, and from what money? A date and a source. "Next paycheck" is a date; "when I can" is not.
- What does it cost for that length of time? Fee plus daily interest times days, using the method above.
- What is the cheaper alternative I have not tried? A call to the issuer about a hardship option, a payment plan for the bill, a smaller expense moved or help from a nonprofit counselor.
If you cannot pass all five, the advance is likely to cost more than it solves.
Where your payments go if you carry both balances
Most cards carry more than one balance at once, and a cash advance often has the highest rate. Under Regulation Z, any payment above the minimum must be applied first to the balance with the highest APR. If the cash advance APR is the highest, extra payments go to it first, which is helpful for you. The minimum payment itself is applied as the agreement says, so a person who pays only the minimum may find that the cash advance, with its high rate, keeps accruing while the minimum goes toward a lower-rate balance. The Where your payment goes when a card has balances at different APRs post walks through this with numbers. The practical lesson is that paying more than the minimum matters more when a cash advance is on the card.
A cash advance can also change how the rest of the card behaves. Because it makes the account carry a balance, new purchases typically stop being covered by the grace period until the card is paid in full again. The agreement states how the grace period is restored. The result is that one advance can raise the cost of everyday spending for a cycle or more, a cost that the table above does not show.
What triggers a cash advance without an ATM
You do not have to put a card in a cash machine to take a cash advance. Depending on the issuer's coding, any of these may be treated as one: money orders, wire transfers, prepaid card loads, foreign currency, gambling chips and some peer-to-peer transfers or cash-like purchases. The transactions that count as cash advances without looking like one checklist covers these in detail. Checks mailed to you by the issuer, often called convenience checks, can also be cash advances, a topic covered in how convenience checks in the mail work and what they cost. If you are not sure, ask the issuer before paying, because the charge is the same whether you meant to borrow cash or not.
Not a way to pay other bills
A cash advance can look like a quick fix for a bill that is due or a card payment that is short. It rarely is. Using a cash advance to pay another card or a bill moves debt from a cheaper place to a pricier one, and adds a fee for the move. If you are short this month, there are better first steps: call the issuer of the card or bill that is due and ask about a hardship program or a new due date, talk to a nonprofit credit counselor about options for the whole picture, and check local assistance programs for essentials. These cost nothing up front, and some of them can lower the amount you owe or the rate you pay.
A small example shows the trap. Say a person takes a $300 cash advance on one card to cover a $300 payment due on another. On the illustrative terms above, the fee is $300 × 0.05 = $15, and a month of interest at 29% is $300 × 0.29 ÷ 365 × 30 = $7.15, so about $22 is spent to move $300 from one card to another. The first card now holds $315 of debt at a higher rate, the second card is no better off in the long run, and the underlying shortfall is still there next month. If money is short, say so to the lender before the due date. Issuers can offer options that a cash advance cannot, and the call is also what the I can not make my card payments this month. What are my options? post recommends.
What to check in your agreement
Before you ever need it, look at four items for each card:
- The cash advance fee, both the percentage and the minimum.
- The cash advance APR, and whether it is variable.
- The cash advance limit, which can be lower than your credit limit.
- How the card treats cash advances for rewards and the billing cycle grace period.
Write the numbers down. When you know your fee and rate, you can price any advance in a minute: fee plus daily interest times days.
Key takeaways
- A cash advance has an up-front fee, usually the greater of a percentage or a minimum, and interest that starts the same day, with no grace period.
- On the illustrative $500 advance at a 5% fee and 29% APR, the cost is $28.97 at 10 days, $36.92 at 30 days and $48.84 at 60 days, and most of it is the fee at short durations.
- Small advances cost the most per dollar when a minimum fee applies: $100 with a $10 minimum fee costs $12.38 for a month, or 12.4 percent.
- Extra payments above the minimum go first to the highest-rate balance, but the minimum payment is applied as your agreement says, so pay more than the minimum when a cash advance is on the card.
- A cash advance is not a fix for another bill or card payment: ask about a hardship program, a nonprofit credit counselor or local assistance first.