Blog

Mistakes people make when closing a card: points, timing and age

Eight errors when closing a card, from forfeited points to bad timing around fees and credits and a shrinking total limit, with how to avoid each one.

Say Kai decides to simplify. A card with an annual fee has been sitting in a drawer, so Kai calls the number on the back, asks to close it and is done in four minutes. Over the next month a streaming subscription fails, a balance of points that would have covered a flight is gone, a credit that Kai meant to use never posts, and the credit score dips more than expected. None of those outcomes was inevitable and each had a cause that was visible before the call. The mistakes below come up again and again, and each is followed by how to avoid it. The figures are invented to illustrate the arithmetic and the rates are not market numbers.

The account closure itself is not the problem. Closing a card can be the right call, and sometimes the only one. The trouble is closing it in the wrong order, at the wrong time or for the wrong reason.

Mistake 1: letting points and cash back disappear

The most expensive error is also the easiest to avoid. Rewards earned on a card belong to a program, and the program's rules decide what happens when the account closes. In some programs the points stay available as long as another card in the program is open. In others they are forfeited or must be redeemed within a short window after closing.

A labeled example. Say the account holds 62,000 points and the program redeems for cash at 1 cent per point, which is the typical cash value, though travel redemptions can be worth more or less. The value is 62,000 × $0.01 = $620. Closing without checking could throw that away. Points values are estimates, not guarantees, and the issuer's rules and any redemption terms are the final word.

How to avoid it:

  • Look up your balance before you call. Check the program terms or the card's profile on this site for what happens at closing.
  • Redeem for cash, a statement credit, gift cards or travel before closing, if the terms allow it.
  • Ask whether the points can move to another card in the same program.
  • If the card is a co-brand airline or hotel card, the miles may live in the airline's or hotel's own program, where they are safe from the closing. Check that, do not assume it.

Mistake 2: closing at the wrong moment around the fee and the credits

Timing is the second-largest source of avoidable loss. Two versions come up.

Version one: closing just after the annual fee posts. The annual fee appears on a statement, the cardholder sees it and decides to close, and the fee has already been charged. Say the fee is $250 and it posted ten days ago. Some issuers refund all or part of a recently posted fee when you close, some do not, and there is no general legal requirement to refund it. If the issuer does not, the cost of the single month of use is $250. Calling in the weeks before the anniversary would have avoided it. How the days around the fee run is in when the annual fee posts, and what happens if you cancel around it.

Version two: closing before using a credit you have already paid for. Many cards with fees offer credits that reset on a calendar or an anniversary. Say a card gives a $100 dining credit each calendar year, and the cardholder closes in December without using it. The $100 of value that the fee was partly buying is lost. If the same cardholder had spent $100 at a restaurant they would have visited anyway, the credit would have covered the meal. The warning has a limit: do not buy something you do not need to capture a credit. What belongs to the plan is checking which credits remain and using them first on purchases you would make anyway.

A statement credit that has been promised but has not posted is a related trap. If a welcome offer includes a credit that posts after a minimum spend or a billing cycle, closing the account before it posts can cancel it. When a promised credit never arrives, see A promised statement credit never posted. How do I chase it?.

How to avoid it:

  • Find the date the fee posts and the dates credits reset.
  • List the credits you have not used and decide which you will use before the close date.
  • Ask about a refund of a recently posted fee, and ask for the answer in writing.
  • If the fee is the problem and the card is otherwise fine, ask about a product change to a no-fee card before you close.

Mistake 3: forgetting what is attached to the card number

A card number is attached to more places than most people remember. Subscriptions, insurance premiums, utility autopay, parking apps, ride-sharing, travel bookings and saved wallet entries all use it. When the account closes, charges are declined, and a merchant that cannot collect may add a fee or cancel service.

How to avoid it:

  • Scan three months of statements and make a list of every recurring merchant.
  • Update each one to another payment method before the close date.
  • Look at pending reservations, such as a hotel booking or rental car that expects the same card at check-in.
  • Look at your bank-side autopay for the card. If you pay by autopay from your bank, make sure the final payoff happens, then turn off the payment arrangement.
  • If the issuer is the one closing the account, the same problems arrive without warning. autopay, subscriptions and rewards when your issuer closes your card covers that case.

Mistake 4: shrinking the total limit without doing the arithmetic

A card's limit counts in your total available credit even when you never use it. Closing it removes the limit and leaves the balances. credit utilization is the share of your total revolving limits you are using, and amounts owed make up about 30 percent of a FICO Score in the general model, according to FICO's published description.

A labeled example. Say you have limits adding up to $20,000 and balances adding up to $4,200.

  • Before: $4,200 ÷ $20,000 = 21 percent.
  • Close a card with a $6,000 limit and no balance: $4,200 ÷ $14,000 = 30 percent.
  • Close a card with a $2,000 limit and no balance instead: $4,200 ÷ $18,000 = 23.3 percent.

The same act of closing a card moves the total from 21 to 30 percent or from 21 to 23.3 percent, depending on which card. Experian says utilization above roughly 30 percent starts to weigh more heavily on scores, and FICO does not name a magic number. The close-a-card utilization impact calculator runs this arithmetic for the cards you have.

How to avoid it:

  • Compute the ratio with and without the card before you decide.
  • If the closing would push you past a level you are uncomfortable with, pay balances down first, or choose a different card to close.
  • Consider a product change on the card you wanted to close, which usually keeps the limit.

Mistake 5: believing closing a card rewrites your history, in either direction

People get age wrong in two opposite ways.

The first belief is that closing erases the past. It does not. A late payment is reported for up to seven years under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, whether the account is open or closed, and for collections and charge-offs the seven-year clock starts 180 days after the delinquency began. Closing a card with a late payment does not remove the late payment.

The second belief is that closing destroys the account's age at once. A closed account in good standing generally continues to appear on a credit report, and how long it stays and how a scoring model treats it are questions for the bureaus and for the model. Look at your own report. length of credit history is about 15 percent of the general FICO model, so it is a real factor, but it is not the whole score. A closed account stops growing older in the way an open one does, and eventually may drop from the report.

What can go wrong is a combination: closing the oldest card and opening a new one in the same year, which lowers the average age and adds a hard inquiry.

How to avoid it:

  • Look at the open date of each card on your credit report. Free reports are at AnnualCreditReport.com.
  • If a card is your oldest account and it has no fee, think twice. If it has a fee, ask about a conversion first.
  • Do not close an account in the hope that a past mistake will disappear. Dispute errors with the bureau instead.

Mistake 6: closing right before a loan application

Lenders for mortgages and auto loans look at recent changes. A new inquiry, a recent closing and a rising balance each make a different statement. A closed card can change utilization and account counts in the weeks before an underwriter pulls a report.

A simple rule is to avoid changes you can postpone. If the loan is coming in the next several months, leave the cards as they are and make the changes afterward. The reasoning lenders use is in card habits in the months before a mortgage application, in order. A loan officer can tell you how the lender will treat a specific change.

How to avoid it:

  • Write down the date of the application and count backward before making any changes.
  • Do not apply for new credit or change the number of accounts without asking the lender if it matters.
  • If you must close a card for reasons such as a fee about to post, compute the effect on utilization first and pay balances down to offset it.

Mistake 7: closing the card when the real problem is something else

Closing is sometimes the answer to a different problem, and the other fix is better.

  • Fraud. If a card was used without your permission, call the number on the back of the card and report it. The issuer can block the number and issue a new one on the same account. You can also dispute the charges and, if the response is not adequate, use the CFPB complaint process. Federal law caps a cardholder's liability for unauthorized use at $50, and a card that is reported before it is used carries no liability. Closing the account does not undo the fraud.
  • Overspending. If the problem is that you spend too much on a card, closing it feels decisive, but the balance remains and the other cards are still there. Remove the card from your wallet and from saved merchant profiles, lower the limit, or set a spending alert, and look at the underlying budget.
  • Debt. If you are working on a balance, closing all your cards can reduce your limits and raise utilization at the very moment you most need it to look healthy. A nonprofit credit counseling agency may enroll cards in a debt management plan, in which enrolled cards are typically closed; that is a deliberate step with a plan behind it, and it is a decision to make with the agency.
  • Annoyance. If the issue is a fee or too many cards, ask about a product change or a retention offer before closing.

Mistake 8: closing without a paper trail

The last mistake is procedural. The representative says the account is closed. A month later you find that it is still open, or that a fee posted, or that the credit report shows the account as closed by the issuer, not by you.

How to avoid it:

  1. Ask the representative for the effective date and a confirmation number. Write down the name and the date of the call.
  2. Ask for confirmation by mail or secure message.
  3. Check the next statement. It should show a zero balance or a payoff, and no new fee.
  4. Check your credit report after a cycle or two. A bureau must reinvestigate a disputed item within 30 days of receiving the dispute, with a possible 15-day extension.
  5. Keep the records for as long as the account could appear on your report.

A short list before you call

  1. Have I redeemed or moved the points and used the credits?
  2. When does the fee post, and is a refund possible?
  3. Have I moved every recurring charge and checked reservations?
  4. What does the total limit and utilization look like without this card?
  5. Is this my oldest account, and is a conversion available?
  6. Is a loan application close?
  7. Is the real problem something a closing will not solve?
  8. How will I get a confirmation and check the result?

Key takeaways

  • Rewards are often the biggest loss. Find out what happens to points when the account closes and redeem or transfer them first; 62,000 points at 1 cent each was $620 in the example.
  • Timing matters in both directions: close before the annual fee posts if you can, and use credits you have already paid for before the close date.
  • A card with no balance can do the most harm to utilization when closed, because its limit leaves the total: 21 percent became 30 percent or 23.3 percent in the example, depending on the card.
  • Closing does not erase late payments, and a closed account in good standing generally does not vanish from a credit report right away. Check your own report.
  • If the real problem is fraud, a fee or overspending, a different fix may work better than closing, and any closing should end with written confirmation and a later look at your credit report.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic