Blog

Credit freeze, fraud alert or credit lock: how they differ and when

Three identity-theft protections compared on cost, what they block, how long they last and how each is placed or lifted, with a decision list.

A credit freeze blocks most new lenders from seeing your file, so a thief usually cannot open a new account in your name. A fraud alert leaves the file open but asks lenders to verify who is applying. A "lock" is a product a credit bureau sells or bundles, and it behaves like a freeze but runs on the bureau's own terms, not the federal statute. Which one fits depends on what has happened and what you plan to do next, and you can use more than one at once.

This post sets the three side by side, shows how each is placed and removed, and ends with a decision list. Nothing here is legal advice. For a specific case, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the FTC's identity theft site are the places to check current procedures.

What each protection actually is

All three work on the same target: the files kept by the three nationwide credit bureau companies, Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. A lender deciding on a new card or loan usually asks one or more of them for your credit report. The protections change what the bureau does when that request arrives.

A freeze (also called a security freeze). The bureau refuses to release your report to most parties who ask for it. Your file is still there and still collects information from your existing accounts. Your score is not affected. You can still see your own report, and companies you already do business with can generally still check it, as can collectors working for them and some government agencies. A freeze is created by federal law under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, which is why the rules on cost and speed are the same at every bureau.

A fraud alert. The bureau puts a flag on your file. A business that is about to extend credit is supposed to take extra steps to confirm the applicant is really you, such as calling a phone number you supplied. The report is still released. An alert is a request for care, not a lock, and it does not stop an application from being processed.

A credit lock. This is a bureau's commercial product, often delivered through an app, that blocks access to your file in a way that resembles a freeze. Because it is a contract product and not the statutory freeze, its price, its speed, its limits and the way you switch it on and off are whatever the bureau's terms say. Some are free, some are bundled with a paid subscription, and the terms can change. Read them before you assume equivalence.

The comparison table

Feature Security freeze Fraud alert Credit lock
Source of the rules Federal law Federal law Bureau's own terms
Cost Free to place and remove Free Varies by bureau and plan
Effect on new credit Most lenders cannot see your report Lenders asked to verify identity Similar to a freeze, per the terms
Effect on your score None None None expected; confirm in the terms
Duration Until you remove it Initial: at least one year. Extended: seven years. Military: at least 12 months Until you switch it off or the plan ends
Placed by Each bureau separately One bureau, which is supposed to pass it on Each bureau's own app or site
Removing or pausing Free; lifted within one hour of a phone or online request Expires on its own, or you ask for removal One tap in the app, usually
Proof required Identity verification Identity theft report required for the extended alert only Account login
Stops misuse of an existing card No No No

A few cells deserve a sentence each. The freeze speed numbers come from the statute: a bureau has to place a freeze within one business day of a phone or online request, or within three business days of a request by mail, and it has to lift one within one hour of a phone or online request. Those timing rules are why a freeze is practical even if you apply for credit often.

The fraud-alert row distinguishes three kinds, covered below. The lock row stays vague on purpose, because the point of a lock is that its rules belong to the seller.

How a freeze works in practice

You request a freeze at each bureau separately. Placing one at Equifax does not freeze your Experian file. You can do it online, by phone or by mail, and the online route is the quickest. The bureau will verify who you are, then either issue a PIN or ask you to create a login. Keep that PIN or password somewhere safe and offline, because it is what lifts the freeze later.

Once the freeze is on, three things change:

  1. A new credit application that depends on a report from that bureau usually fails to retrieve one. The lender may deny the application, ask you to lift the freeze, or put it on hold.
  2. Your existing accounts carry on as normal. The issuer keeps reporting your payments to the bureau. A freeze does not close, restrict or change any account you already have.
  3. Pre-screened offers in the mail or by email generally stop coming for as long as the freeze lasts, since those lists are built from bureau data.

To use credit, you lift the freeze. Bureaus commonly allow a temporary lift for a date range, and some let you lift it for one named lender, though the options differ by bureau. A phone or online request has to be honored within one hour. Say you plan to apply for a card on a Saturday afternoon. You find out which bureau the issuer usually pulls, lift that one Saturday morning, apply, and refreeze afterwards. If you are not sure which bureau a lender uses, ask the lender before you apply. Lifting all three is the fallback, and it is free.

A worked example, labeled as an illustration. Dana places a freeze at all three bureaus on a Monday and gets a PIN from each. Two months later Dana wants to refinance a car loan. The lender says it pulls TransUnion. Dana lifts only TransUnion, uses the one-hour window as a buffer by lifting that morning, applies in the afternoon, and refreezes that evening. Equifax and Experian stay frozen the whole time. The lender sees a report, and the other two files stay locked against anyone else.

How the three kinds of fraud alert differ

The statute describes three flavors, and the difference between them is mostly duration and proof.

  • Initial fraud alert. You say, without proof, that you are or may be a victim of identity theft or fraud. It lasts at least one year. If you place it on 16 November 2026, it runs at least until 16 November 2027.
  • Extended fraud alert. You supply an identity theft report, which is a report to the FTC or a police report as the bureau requires. It lasts seven years. Placed on 16 November 2026, it runs until 16 November 2033. Extended alerts also remove you from prescreened offer lists for a period set by the statute.
  • Active-duty military alert. A servicemember away from their usual station can place one, and it lasts at least 12 months. It helps because someone deployed may not see mail or notices promptly.

One request to one bureau is supposed to reach the other two, because the law has the bureau you contact notify the others of an alert. Many people still place it on all three sites so there is no doubt. A fraud alert does not require a lender to refuse anything; it requires the lender to take reasonable steps to verify. That makes it a lighter tool than a freeze. It also makes it easy to live with: it does not block your own applications, though a lender may phone you to confirm.

What a lock adds and what it takes away

A lock is the easiest to use, since you toggle it on your phone. That convenience is the main selling point. The trade-offs are worth reading about before you rely on one:

  • The legal protections of a statutory freeze, such as the one-hour lift and the free-of-charge guarantee, belong to the freeze and not necessarily to the lock.
  • A lock may be tied to a paid membership. If the membership ends, the protection may end with it.
  • Marketing language can blur the line, so check whether a product calls itself a "freeze," a "lock" or both. A bureau can offer both.
  • A lock at one bureau only covers that bureau. You would need the equivalent at the other two.

None of this makes a lock a bad choice. It means the freeze is the baseline you can count on by law, and the lock is a convenience layer whose details you should read.

What none of them do

All three protections target new-account fraud. Neither a freeze nor an alert nor a lock stops these problems:

Because of this, a freeze is a strong piece of a plan and a poor substitute for the rest of it. Watching your accounts, reading statements and pulling your reports on a schedule still matter, and free credit monitoring or a paid plan: what each really gives you explains what monitoring adds beyond a freeze.

A decision list for common situations

Match the situation to the starting point. Several can be combined.

  1. You received a data breach notice and nothing bad has happened. A freeze is free, fast and lasts until you lift it. Many readers choose it because it needs no proof and takes minutes per bureau. A fraud alert is a lighter alternative if you expect to apply for credit often and want fewer steps. See data breach myths that send people in the wrong direction.
  2. You think someone opened an account in your name. Place a freeze, place an initial fraud alert, then follow the recovery steps. If you file an identity theft report, you can upgrade to an extended alert. Build an identity theft recovery plan with the FTC, bureaus and issuers covers the sequence.
  3. You are about to apply for a mortgage, auto loan or card in the next few weeks. An alert is simpler during that window, since nothing needs lifting. A freeze also works if you are willing to lift the right bureau for the lender. how to apply for a card when your credit report is frozen walks through it.
  4. You are deployed or about to be. The active-duty alert fits, and a freeze is also available if you do not expect to apply for credit.
  5. You manage a child's or an older relative's file. Freezes can generally be placed for a minor or a person under a representative's care with documentation. The bureaus explain the paperwork. See Someone used my child's Social Security number for credit. Questions answered.
  6. You like app control and accept bureau terms. A lock is a legitimate convenience. Confirm what it costs, what ends it and whether the three bureaus each need one.

Mistakes that weaken the protection

  • Freezing one bureau and calling it done. Lenders may pull any of the three. A gap at one bureau is a gap.
  • Losing the PIN. Bureaus have a recovery path, but it requires identity verification and takes time. Store the PIN where you can find it in a year.
  • Forgetting to refreeze. If you lift for a loan application and never re-lock, the protection is gone without any notice to you.
  • Assuming the alert expired quietly. An initial alert lasts at least a year, and then it lapses. Put the renewal date on a calendar if you still want it.
  • Skipping the specialty files. If your problem involves renting or banking, check whether those services have their own freezes.
  • Using a third party that charges for a free right. A freeze is free at the bureaus. Be wary of any service that asks you to pay to place one.

Key takeaways

  • A freeze blocks access to your report, a fraud alert asks lenders to verify identity, and a lock is a bureau's commercial product with its own terms.
  • Federal law makes freezes free, requires placement within one business day of a phone or online request, and requires a lift within one hour of one.
  • Initial alerts last at least one year, extended alerts seven years with an identity theft report, and military alerts at least 12 months.
  • Each protection targets new accounts. None stops a thief who has your existing card number, so call the number on the back of the card and use the CFPB complaint process if an issuer or bureau does not respond.
  • Pick the tool to match the situation: freeze for the strongest block, alert for lighter friction, lock for convenience if the terms suit you.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic