Blog

What credit repair companies promise and what you can do free

Common credit repair promises and tactics, which parts you can do yourself at no cost, and the warning signs of paid help that costs more than it delivers.

The ads promise to delete negative items, raise a score by a stated number of points and "fix" a file in ninety days. The pitch is attractive because a bad credit file is stressful and the process of fixing one looks confusing. But the legitimate part of what a credit repair company does is a short list of things that a consumer has the legal right to do alone, for free. The rest is either a promise that nobody can keep or a practice that can cause real harm.

This article walks through the common promises and tactics, one at a time, with what is true about each and what you can do without paying. It is organized as a list of mistakes, since most of the damage here comes from a handful of avoidable choices. It is general information, and a nonprofit credit counselor, a licensed attorney or the CFPB is the right place to turn for your own file.

What a credit repair company actually does

In plain terms, these companies sell a service of reviewing your reports, disputing items they say are inaccurate or unverifiable, writing letters to bureaus and creditors, and sometimes offering advice on utilization and new accounts. Fees are typically charged monthly, sometimes with a setup fee. Results vary, and no company can guarantee a score.

Federal law regulates them. The Credit Repair Organizations Act, a federal statute, generally bars these companies from charging before they have performed the promised services, requires a written contract, and gives the consumer a right to cancel within a short period. State law adds its own licensing and bonding rules in many places. Those protections are a baseline, not a guarantee of quality. If a company asks for payment up front, that alone is a reason to walk away.

Mistake 1: Paying someone to dispute errors you could dispute yourself

The promise. "We will challenge every negative item on your report."

The reality. The Fair Credit Reporting Act gives every consumer the right to dispute an item they believe is inaccurate or incomplete. A bureau that receives a dispute must reinvestigate it within 30 days, extendable by up to 15 days if the consumer sends additional information during that time. It costs nothing but a letter or an online form, and how to dispute a credit report error, with the deadlines that apply shows the steps. If an item is wrong, the bureau must correct or delete it. If an item is accurate and verified, no amount of paid disputing will make it go away, and a flood of identical disputes can be treated as frivolous and ignored.

What you can do free. Get your credit report from each bureau at AnnualCreditReport.com, read it against your own records, and dispute what is wrong yourself. Start with how to pull your free credit reports and read each section.

Mistake 2: Believing accurate negative items can be removed

The promise. "We can remove late payments, collections and charge-offs from your report."

The reality. Accurate negative items generally stay for the period the law sets: usually seven years for late payments, collections and charge-offs, and up to ten for bankruptcies. A company that gets an item deleted has usually found an error or a record the furnisher could not verify in time. That can happen, but it is not a service anyone can promise on demand, and a deletion of accurate information that the furnisher later restores can leave you where you started.

What you can do free.

  • Pay accounts on time from now on. payment history is the biggest single factor in the general FICO model, about 35 percent, and recent months weigh most.
  • Ask a creditor for a goodwill adjustment on a one-time late payment. It is a request that a creditor can refuse, and it costs a letter.
  • Wait. The weight of an old item shrinks as it ages.

Mistake 3: Paying for a "new credit identity" or a CPN

The promise. A "credit privacy number" or "credit profile number" that you can use in place of your Social Security number to start a clean file.

The reality. Using a number other than your own Social Security number on a credit application can amount to fraud, and the numbers sold this way are commonly reported to be stolen or to belong to children. A buyer can end up in legal trouble and with a damaged file. There is no legitimate product of this kind.

What you can do free. If you truly have no credit history, start one the ordinary way with a reporting account, as in how to build credit from scratch, month by month for a year.

Mistake 4: Letting a company tell you not to contact the bureaus or creditors yourself

The promise. "Do not talk to your creditors. Let us handle it."

The reality. A company that stands between you and your creditor can make things worse, for instance by encouraging you to stop paying on an account that was still current, or by missing a deadline in a debt validation window. Contact with a collector has deadlines of its own: a collector must provide validation information, including a 30-day window to dispute the debt, and a written dispute in that window stops collection until the debt is verified. A debt validation notice is yours to answer.

What you can do free. Respond to collection letters in writing within the window, ask for validation, and call the number on the back of your card when it is a card account.

Mistake 5: Paying a monthly fee for things the law already gives you

The promise. Monitoring, "score tracking," a customer dashboard.

The reality. You are entitled to free reports from each of the three bureaus through AnnualCreditReport.com, where the bureaus extended free weekly access in 2023 and made it permanent, according to the site and press coverage. A credit freeze is free to place and remove under federal law, and so are fraud alerts. Many card issuers and banks show a free score in their apps. credit freeze explains what a freeze does and how to place one.

Here is a labeled example of the cost. Say a company charges a $199 setup fee and $99 a month for six months. The total is $199 + (6 × $99) = $199 + $594 = $793. Compare that with what you would spend doing the core tasks yourself: a few stamps and certified-mail fees, or nothing at all online.

Mistake 6: Expecting a fixed score gain or a deadline

The promise. "Raise your score 100 points in 60 days."

The reality. The effect of any change depends on what else is in the file, and no one can responsibly give a figure without seeing it. A rapid rise is usually the result of a correction of a large error or a big drop in utilization, neither of which needs a paid service. The standard factors, from the general FICO model, are payment history about 35 percent, amounts owed about 30 percent, length of history about 15 percent, new credit about 10 percent and credit mix about 10 percent.

What you can do free. Lower the balances reported on your cards (a balance of $900 on a $3,000 limit is 30 percent, and $300 is 10 percent), keep every account current, and avoid new applications. The sequence is laid out in a twelve-month plan to rebuild your score after late payments.

Mistake 7: Ignoring the warning signs of a bad actor

These signs are reasons to stop and not to sign:

  • A request for payment before any work is done.
  • A guarantee of a specific score, or of removing accurate information.
  • Advice to dispute everything on the report, whether or not it is wrong.
  • Advice to create a new identity, use a CPN, or apply for an employer identification number to use as a personal credit number.
  • A contract that is vague, that is not in writing, or that is signed under time pressure.
  • A refusal to explain what the company does that you could not do yourself.
  • Pressure to avoid contacting the bureaus or creditors.
  • A claim to be a government program or to be affiliated with the bureaus.

How to read a credit repair contract before signing anything

If you are still weighing paid help, treat the contract as the product, because it states what you are actually buying. Read it at home, not at the sales call, and look for the following.

Check What a reasonable answer looks like What is a warning sign
When is payment due? After the services are performed Any fee before work is done
What exactly will be done? A specific list, such as reviewing three reports and disputing named items "Repair your credit" with no detail
How long does it run, and how do I cancel? A stated term and a written cancellation right Automatic renewals with no clear exit
What are all the fees? A total you can add up Setup, monthly and "success" fees that stack
Who sends disputes? Disputes under your name with your knowledge Disputes sent in bulk you never see
What is guaranteed? Nothing about a score A promised score or deletion

Ask for the answers in writing. If the salesperson will not put a statement in the contract, the statement is not part of the deal. Keep a copy of every document and every payment record. If you decide not to go ahead, you have lost nothing.

A do-it-yourself schedule over six months

Many people are held back less by difficulty than by not knowing where to begin. Here is a schedule that shows the work is modest. It assumes a file with a few real problems and no emergency.

Week or month Task Cost
Week 1 Request all three reports; save each as a file Free
Week 2 Compare the reports with your own records; list errors, items you do not recognize and negative items that are accurate Free
Week 3 Send written disputes for the errors, with copies of evidence; note the date each bureau receives it Postage or free online
Week 7 or so Bureaus must have finished reinvestigating within 30 days of receipt, or up to 45 if you sent more information; read the results Free
Month 2 Set up autopay on every account; line up due dates with payday Free
Months 2 to 4 Pay down the card with the highest reported utilization first Your payments
Month 3 Write one goodwill letter for an isolated late payment, if the history is otherwise clean Postage
Month 6 Pull the three reports again; check that disputes were applied and balances reflect your payments Free

Every line is something a credit repair company would charge a monthly fee to do or to take credit for. Nothing in the schedule needs a license or special access.

What about help that is legitimately paid?

Paying for help is not always a mistake. The test is whether the person is doing something you cannot or should not do alone, and whether the fee is disclosed and earned.

  • An attorney is the right person for a lawsuit, a wrongful collection practice, a bankruptcy decision or a dispute that a bureau mishandled. Many consumer attorneys handle violations of the federal credit laws, and some take cases on terms that do not require money up front. Ask how fees work before you agree.
  • A nonprofit credit counselor reviews a budget, explains options and may set up a debt management plan. Fees are generally modest and disclosed, and may be waived in hardship. A plan is a different path from repair, and enrolled cards are typically closed.
  • A tax professional helps with canceled debt and the tax forms that follow a settlement.

In each case the professional's role is specific and the fee is for work you can see.

What a dispute can and cannot do

One more point causes confusion, because it is the heart of many repair pitches. A dispute asks a bureau to check whether an item is accurate. The bureau asks the company that reported it, the furnisher, to verify. If the furnisher confirms the item, it stays. If the furnisher cannot or does not verify it, or the item turns out to be wrong, it must be corrected or deleted. A dispute is not a tool for erasing accurate history, and repeated disputes about the same verified item add nothing. Disputes work best when they are specific: name the item, say what is wrong and attach the evidence.

What you can do free, in order

Everything below costs nothing but time.

  1. Get all three reports at AnnualCreditReport.com and read them line by line.
  2. Dispute real errors in writing, with copies of your evidence, and keep a dated record.
  3. Pay every current account on time and set up autopay.
  4. Lower reported balances. The sooner the reported utilization falls, the sooner the score reflects it.
  5. Respond to collectors in writing within the validation window, and ask for verification.
  6. Ask for goodwill adjustments on isolated lates, when the history is otherwise clean.
  7. Use a nonprofit. A nonprofit credit counseling agency, many of them members of the NFCC, can review a budget and set up a debt management plan. Fees, where there are any, are disclosed and regulated by states, and how to vet a nonprofit credit counseling agency before you share anything shows how to check one.
  8. Add positive history with one reporting account, if you need it.

If you already paid

If you paid a company and nothing happened, or you are having second thoughts, act promptly.

  • Check your contract. You may have a right to cancel within a few days of signing, and the cancellation period can be short.
  • If you paid by credit card, call the number on the back of your card and ask about disputing the charge. The Fair Credit Billing Act's written-notice deadline is 60 days after the statement showing the charge was sent, so do not wait.
  • File complaints with the CFPB and the Federal Trade Commission, and tell your state attorney general. How to file a CFPB complaint about a credit card, step by step describes the CFPB process, which can also be used for credit reporting problems.
  • Do not send more money to recover what you paid.

Key takeaways

  • The legitimate parts of credit repair, disputing real errors, paying on time, lowering balances and negotiating, are things you can do yourself for free.
  • No company can guarantee a score, and accurate negative items stay for the period the law sets, usually seven years.
  • A company that asks for payment before doing work, promises to delete accurate items or sells a "new credit identity" is a warning sign, and a CPN can amount to fraud.
  • You already have free reports, free freezes and free fraud alerts, so a monthly fee for them is hard to justify.
  • If you paid and regret it, check your contract, call the number on the back of your card quickly if you paid by card, and file complaints with the CFPB, the FTC and your state attorney general.

Terms used in this article

Latest on this topic