Blog

Debt settlement ad claims tested, from pennies on the dollar to debt free

Seven common debt settlement ad claims checked one at a time against the mechanics, the FTC fee rule and a worked example, with the question to ask for each.

Debt settlement ads follow a script. They show a worried person, a large balance, a friendly voice and a phrase such as "settle for pennies on the dollar" or "become debt free in as little as 24 months." Some of the words in those ads are true in a narrow sense and misleading in the way they are used, and some are simply claims nobody can promise. This article takes seven of the most common ones and tests each against how debt settlement works, what the FTC rule on debt relief says and a single set of labeled numbers.

The aim is not to say that settlement never works. For some people it ends a debt they could not otherwise repay, at a cost. The aim is that you can hear an ad, translate it into a specific, checkable claim and know what to ask.

The example behind the tests

Every dollar figure in this article is a labeled illustration, not a market rate or a company's price. Say a household enrolls $20,000 of credit card debt in a settlement program. The cards carry an illustrative 24% APR, which is 2% a month, and the household stops paying while it saves. After about six months, before the issuers charge off, interest alone has grown the balance to $20,000 × 1.02^6, about $22,523, and we round that to $22,500 for the example. The program charges a fee of 20% of the enrolled debt, which is $4,000. The household deposits $400 a month. The example leaves out late fees, which would push every figure higher.

Each claim below is held up against these numbers.

Claim 1: "Settle your debt for pennies on the dollar"

What is true. Creditors sometimes accept less than the full balance, and a settlement is by definition a payment smaller than the debt.

What the example shows. "Pennies" suggests a few cents per dollar. Suppose the creditors accept half of the $22,500 balance: $11,250. Add the $4,000 fee and the household has paid $15,250 to clear $20,000 of enrolled debt, about 76 cents on each enrolled dollar ($15,250 ÷ $20,000 = 0.7625). If the creditors accept only 40%, the settlements are $9,000, the total is $13,000 and the cost is 65 cents on the dollar. Even that favorable result is far from pennies.

The number in ads usually leaves out three things. The balance when settled is higher than the balance when enrolled. The fee is on top. And "up to" a given percentage off describes the best case.

What to ask. "Show me, in writing, the total I would pay in settlements and fees, measured against the balance I have today." Then compare that number with what staying current on a payment plan would cost, which the credit card payoff calculator can estimate.

Claim 2: "Be debt free in 24 to 48 months"

What is true. Programs often run for a few years, and a household that saves the full amount can finish.

What the example shows. The time depends on how much you deposit and how the creditors respond. The whole program costs $15,250 in the 50% case. At $400 a month, that is $15,250 ÷ $400, or 38.1 months. In the 40% case, $13,000 ÷ $400 is 32.5 months. To finish in 24 months, the household would need to deposit $15,250 ÷ 24 = $635.42 a month in the 50% case. If the creditors insisted on 60%, the settlements would be $13,500, the total $17,500, and the program would take 43.75 months at $400.

The timeline in an ad is a best case assuming a deposit you may not be able to make and creditors who agree on schedule. A creditor that refuses, or that sues, can add months or end the program.

What to ask. "What deposit does the 24-month version require, and what happens to my accounts if I can only afford half of it?"

Claim 3: "No upfront fees"

What is true. For debt relief sold by phone, a federal rule, the FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule, bans charging a fee before the company has settled or reduced a debt. The ban took effect in 2010, and hiring attorneys does not exempt a company from it. A company that follows the rule collects its fee only after results.

What the ad leaves out. "No upfront fees" describes timing, not cost. The fee is still charged, typically as a percentage, and in the example it is $4,000, which is 20% of the debt you enrolled even though it is paid out of the fund account bit by bit. It is also charged on the enrolled balance, not on the amount saved. Without the fee the household would pay $11,250 in settlements; the fee adds $4,000, which is about 36% on top of the settlements ($4,000 ÷ $11,250 = 0.356).

Be careful with that figure: it is one piece of the cost and ignores the interest, damage and time. It is not a claim that settlement is a bad deal, only a reminder that "no upfront fees" is not the same as "cheap."

What to ask. "What is the fee, as a percentage and in dollars, on what balance, and when exactly is each part taken?"

Claim 4: "We'll stop the collection calls and protect you from lawsuits"

What is true. A company can handle conversations with creditors and collectors, and a household with a company representing it may feel fewer calls.

What to check. No company can promise to stop all calls or all lawsuits. A creditor or collector that has not been paid can continue to contact you and can sue, and a program that relies on missed payments gives it reason to. The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act gives you rights against third-party collectors, including the right to tell a collector in writing to stop contacting you, as covered in how to send a collector a stop-contact letter and what it does not do. You can use that right without paying a company. It does not stop the debt or a suit, and it does not apply in the same way to the original creditor.

Some ads add "our attorneys will protect you." Attorney involvement is not a shield: it does not take a company outside the fee ban, and it does not prevent a lawsuit. If you are sued, the court deadline for responding is yours, and missing it can lead to a default judgment.

What to ask. "If one of my creditors sues me, what exactly do you do, and who pays for it?"

Claim 5: "Little to no damage to your credit"

What is true. A settled account is better than an account that stays unpaid and keeps growing, and over time the effect of older negative items fades.

What the example shows. The program in the example works because accounts stop being paid. Each unpaid month adds a late payment, and after about six months the accounts are typically charged off. payment history is the biggest single factor in the FICO method, about 35 percent according to FICO's published weights. Negative items such as late payments and charge-offs can be reported for seven years, counted from the first missed payment plus 180 days, and settling the debt does not remove them early.

An ad may say the damage is the same as it would be without the program, because you were in trouble anyway. That can be true for someone already behind. It is not true for someone who could have kept paying, because the program creates the delinquency.

What to ask. "What will my reports show, month by month, if I follow this program, and how does that compare with a debt management plan?"

Claim 6: "A new government program" or "special deals with your creditors"

What to check. Claims of a government forgiveness program, a "new law" or an exclusive agreement with your bank are the ones most associated with scams. Government agencies do not cold-call to offer card debt forgiveness, and no company can credibly claim an arrangement that lets everyone settle on the same favorable terms. Issuers decide individually and set their own policy.

If the ad names a program, look it up on the government agency's own site, by typing the address yourself. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the Federal Trade Commission publish consumer guidance on debt relief, and your state attorney general can tell you whether a business is licensed or has complaints. The warning signs are collected in how to spot a debt relief scam before you sign or pay anything.

What to ask. "What is the exact name of the program, which agency runs it and where can I read its rules?"

Claim 7: "A 95 percent success rate" or "thousands of satisfied clients"

What to check. A success rate is meaningful only with its definition. It could mean the share of enrolled debts that were settled, the share of customers who finished the program, the share of customers who said they were satisfied at some moment or something else. The figures that matter are how many people who enrolled finished, how many dropped out, how much those who finished saved after fees, and how long it took. No public national figure for those was found in the research for this site, so any specific number in an ad should come with its source.

Ad testimonials have the same problem. A customer who finished and saved money is a real outcome, but the ad does not show the ones who left after months of unpaid accounts.

What to ask. "How do you define your success rate, over what period and for how many customers? Can I see it in writing?"

What a plain version of the ad would say

It helps to imagine the same offer described with the missing parts put back. A plain version for the example household might read like this, and a provider that is comfortable with its program should be willing to write something close to it.

"If you enroll $20,000 of card debt, we will ask you to stop paying your creditors and deposit $400 a month into an account in your name. While you save, your balances will keep growing with interest and late fees, probably to more than $22,000. Your credit reports will show late payments and probably charge-offs, and they can stay for seven years. Creditors may call, and some may sue; we cannot stop either. We will try to settle each account for a lump sum when the fund allows. We cannot promise any creditor will agree or what percentage it will accept. If we settle, our fee is 20 percent of the enrolled debt, $4,000, charged only after each settlement and your payment. Forgiven amounts may be taxable. Expect the program to take roughly three years at this deposit, and longer if creditors want more or refuse."

Compare that with the headline. The plain version is longer and less exciting, and it is the version you can plan around. When a provider will not say these things, or says them only after you have signed, treat the omission as the information it is.

Two other habits help. Read the contract before the sales call ends, and ask for it by email so you can read it alone. And compare any quote with a second source, such as a nonprofit counselor who does not take a fee from the outcome, since a quote you cannot compare is just a number.

How to test an ad yourself

Use this checklist on any debt relief claim.

  1. Find the number. Is there a figure (a percentage, a timeline, a fee)? If not, ask for it.
  2. Find the base. A percentage of what: enrolled debt, current balance or the amount saved?
  3. Find the time. How long does the result take, and what must you deposit to reach it?
  4. Find the cost. Fee plus interest during the wait plus a possible tax bill, as explained in I settled a card debt for less. What about taxes and my credit report?.
  5. Find the alternative. Compare with a nonprofit plan, a hardship arrangement, a debt management plan or a bankruptcy consultation; Is bankruptcy right for me? Questions to answer before filing lists the questions to bring to an attorney.
  6. Find it in writing. If the ad says it, the contract should say it.

If an issuer or collector is involved in your account, call the number on the back of your card for the current balance and hardship options before you sign anything. And if an ad, a call or a contract misled you, you can file a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and report it to the FTC and your state attorney general.

Key takeaways

  • "Pennies on the dollar" does not survive the arithmetic: in the labeled example a 40% settlement plus a fee still cost 65 cents per enrolled dollar, and a 50% settlement cost about 76 cents.
  • "Debt free in 24 months" depends on a monthly deposit and creditors' cooperation; the example needed $635 a month for 24 months, not $400.
  • "No upfront fees" is a timing claim backed by the FTC rule on phone sales, not a statement that the fee is small.
  • No company can promise to stop calls, stop lawsuits or protect your credit; unpaid accounts create late entries that can stay for seven years.
  • Turn each claim into a number, a base, a time and a written term, and compare it with a payment plan or a bankruptcy consultation before you stop paying anyone.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic