Blog

Does a consolidation loan save money? Work out the total cost

A worksheet comparing the total interest and fees on your cards with a loan, including an origination fee taken from the proceeds and the effect of the term.

A loan advertised at a lower rate than your cards sounds like it must save money. Sometimes it does. Sometimes the lower rate is offset by an origination fee, or stretched over so many months that the total cost is higher than leaving the cards alone, or compared against a payment that nobody was actually going to make. Whether a consolidation loan saves money is an arithmetic question with a definite answer for your numbers, and this worksheet is how you find it.

You will need a statement for each card (balance and APR), the offer from the lender (amount, rate, term and any fee), and a calculator or spreadsheet. The household in the examples is invented, and its rates, fees and terms are illustrations, not market figures or any lender's offer.

What a consolidation loan does and does not change

A debt consolidation loan is an installment loan: you borrow a fixed amount, pay it back in equal monthly installments over a fixed term, and use the money to pay off other debts. A personal loan used this way is usually unsecured, so no collateral is pledged. (Loans secured by a home are a different product with different risks; see Should I use a HELOC to pay off credit cards? The trade-offs.)

The loan changes four things at once: the interest rate, the number of months, the shape of the monthly payment (fixed instead of shrinking), and the fees. It does not change what you owe. It moves the debt to a new lender on new terms. Because several things change together, the cost can move in either direction, and the only reliable test is to compute total cost on both sides.

The household and its cards

Our invented household owes $7,000 across three cards and can pay $300 a month toward them.

Card Balance APR First month's interest
A $3,000 26% $65.00
B $2,500 22% $45.83
C $1,500 18% $22.50
Total $7,000 about 22.9% blended $133.33

The blended rate is the total interest divided by the total balance, annualized: ($133.33 × 12) ÷ $7,000 is about 22.86%. A loan has to beat that figure after fees to be worth considering, but as the examples show, the rate by itself is not the whole test.

Step 1: the baseline, paying the cards in place

The baseline is what you would really do with the cards if you never took the loan. The honest version uses the payment you would actually make, not the minimums and not an amount you only hope to afford.

For the household, the baseline is $300 a month, all of it going to the highest-rate card first and the others getting whatever is left as balances fall (the debt avalanche order). Running the numbers with the monthly shortcut:

  • Card A is cleared in month 12, Card B in month 23 and Card C in month 31.
  • Total interest is $2,099.48.
  • Total paid is $9,099.48.

Write down two figures: the monthly payment ($300) and the total interest ($2,099.48). Everything else is measured against them. If you do not have a calculator that handles several cards, use the credit card payoff calculator or work each card out with the formula in What monthly payment clears my card in 24 months? Work it out.

Step 2: how much you must borrow

If the loan charges an origination fee taken out of the proceeds, you receive less than you borrow. To pay off $7,000 of cards, you must borrow more than $7,000.

Amount to borrow = amount you need ÷ (1 − fee rate)

Suppose the offer has a 5% origination fee (illustrative). Then $7,000 ÷ 0.95 = $7,368.42. The fee is $368.42, which is deducted at closing, leaving exactly $7,000. You owe interest on the full $7,368.42, not on the $7,000 you actually used. Many people overlook this: a 5% fee does not cost 5% of the amount you needed, but a little more, and the loan accrues interest on the fee as well.

One caution about rates. Some loan offers quote an APR that already reflects the origination fee, while others quote an interest rate with the fee listed separately. Read the disclosure to see which you have, so you do not count the fee twice. In this example 15% is the interest rate, and the fee is counted separately.

Step 3: the loan payment

Use the fixed-payment formula, with r as the interest rate divided by 12 and n as the number of months:

payment = loan amount × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n)

For a 15% rate, r = 0.0125. For a 36-month term:

  1. (1.0125) raised to the 36th is about 1.563944.
  2. The reciprocal is about 0.639409, and 1 − 0.639409 = 0.360591.
  3. The first month's interest on $7,368.42 is $92.11.
  4. $92.11 ÷ 0.360591 = about $255.43.

The same arithmetic for other terms gives the table below.

Term Monthly payment Total repaid Interest plus fee (total cost)
24 months $357.27 $8,574.48 $1,574.48
36 months $255.43 $9,195.43 $2,195.43
48 months $205.07 $9,843.29 $2,843.29
60 months $175.29 $10,517.65 $3,517.65

The "total cost" column is total repaid minus the $7,000 you actually used. It includes the interest and the $368.42 fee.

Step 4: compare at the same monthly payment

The trap is comparing a loan payment against a card payment that is not the same size. A quick look at the table can mislead: the 36-month loan costs $2,195.43 and the baseline cards cost $2,099.48, so the loan looks slightly worse. But the loan's payment is $255.43 and the baseline payment is $300. They are not the same plan. Two fair comparisons are available.

Comparison 1: same payment as the loan. If the household paid only $255.42 a month on the cards, the cards would take 38 months and cost $2,642.55. Against the 36-month loan's $2,195.43, the loan saves $447.12. The loan helps here because its 15% rate is well below the cards' blended rate, and that gap more than covers the fee.

Comparison 2: same payment as the baseline. If the household pays $300 a month on the loan, instead of the required $255.43, and the lender allows extra payments without penalty (check), the loan is paid off in 30 months. Interest is $1,488.95, and with the fee the total cost is $1,857.37. Against the baseline's $2,099.48, the loan saves $242.11.

So at the same payment, the 15% loan beats the cards in both comparisons. The savings are real but modest next to the $7,000 in play, and they depend on the 5% fee. Which brings us to the sensitivity checks.

Step 5: stress-test the loan

A loan that wins by $242 can lose if a term changes. Vary one input at a time and recompute against the $2,099.48 baseline, with a $300 payment on the loan.

The fee. At a 15% rate:

Origination fee Amount borrowed Months at $300 Interest plus fee vs baseline $2,099.48
0% $7,000.00 28 $1,328.09 saves $771.39
3% $7,216.49 29 $1,637.61 saves $461.87
5% $7,368.42 30 $1,857.37 saves $242.11
8% $7,608.70 31 $2,208.75 costs $109.27 more

An 8% fee at the same 15% turns a winner into a loser. The fee is the cost most often left out of a first comparison.

The rate. With a 5% fee and a $300 payment, a 14% rate costs $1,732.94, 15% costs $1,857.37, 16% costs $1,985.94 and 18% costs $2,259.64. The break-even against the baseline falls between 16% and 18%. A loan at a rate in that range, with that fee, would cost more than the cards.

The term. Look at the 60-month row again. Its payment, $175.29, is far below $300, and that is the attraction. But its cost is $3,517.65, which is $1,418.17 more than the $2,099.48 baseline. A household that chooses it for the low payment and then pays only that amount is paying more in total than if it had simply kept the cards and paid $300. The loan is not the problem there; the stretched term is.

The baseline payment. If the household could only really manage $175.30 on the cards, the baseline would be 70 months and $5,131.93 in interest, and the 60-month loan at $175.29 (cost $3,517.65) would be the cheaper plan. The same loan can look good or bad depending on which payment you honestly compare it with.

The worksheet to fill in

Complete these lines for your own cards and your own offer.

Line What to write
1 Total balance on the cards you would pay off
2 Blended APR (total monthly interest × 12 ÷ line 1)
3 Payment you would actually make on the cards
4 Total interest if you pay that amount in place (calculator)
5 Loan fee rate, in percent
6 Amount to borrow: line 1 ÷ (1 − fee rate as a decimal)
7 Loan interest rate and term in months
8 Loan payment from the formula or the credit card consolidation loan calculator
9 Total repaid (payment × months)
10 Total cost: line 9 − line 1
11 Total interest in place at the loan's payment (line 8)
12 Total interest in place at the baseline payment (line 4)
13 Savings versus line 11: line 11 − line 10
14 Savings versus line 12 (only if you will pay the line 3 amount on the loan; recompute months)

If line 13 and line 14 are both positive, the loan beats the cards on cost. If one is negative, look at what made the difference: the fee, the term or the payment.

Reading a loan offer line by line

The worksheet is only as good as the inputs, and the inputs come from the offer. Before computing anything, find these items in the lender's written terms, and if you cannot find one, ask.

  1. Loan amount and amount you receive. If these differ, the difference is a fee. The amount you receive is what pays the cards.
  2. Interest rate and APR, and whether the APR includes fees. If both are shown, the gap between them is a clue to how much the fee costs over the term.
  3. Fixed or variable. A fixed rate gives a fixed payment. A variable rate can move, and then the payment or the term can move with it.
  4. Term in months. This is the number that most changes the total cost, so compute at more than one term if the lender offers a choice.
  5. Origination fee, as a percent or dollar amount, and how it is collected. Deducted from the proceeds is the case modeled above. A fee added to the balance is slightly different, though it is still money you pay.
  6. Late fee and returned-payment fee. These are charged if a payment is late or fails, and they differ from card fees.
  7. Prepayment. Is there a charge for paying early, and do extra payments go to principal? Many consumer loans have none, but it is a term to confirm, not to assume.
  8. How the money is delivered. Some lenders pay your card issuers directly, which removes the temptation to spend the cash. Others deposit the proceeds in your account and leave it to you to pay the cards. If the money is deposited, pay the cards the same day.
  9. What happens if a payment is missed. A card has grace and a range of hardship options. Check what the lender offers.

If an offer is a prequalification or a "rate range," ask which rate you would actually receive after the full application, since the rate depends on your credit and the final figure can differ from the range.

Run the worksheet again for every serious offer. Two offers with the same monthly payment can differ by hundreds of dollars in total cost because one has a fee and the other does not. And if the strongest offer on the table still does not beat the baseline, that is a result, not a failure: it tells you that paying the cards on a plan is the cheaper route for your numbers.

What the worksheet leaves out

The arithmetic compares dollars. A few things it does not capture need judgment.

  • New charges. The calculation assumes the cards stay at zero. If they do not, the household has the loan and new card debt. seven ways a card consolidation loan backfires, including running cards up again covers this and six other ways a loan goes wrong.
  • Credit effects. A loan application usually involves a hard credit inquiry, and a new installment account changes your credit mix and account age. A prequalification that uses a soft inquiry can show likely terms first; see how to shop for a consolidation loan using prequalification.
  • Approval and the actual offer. The rate and fee you are offered depend on your credit and may differ from advertising, so compute with the actual offer.
  • Prepayment terms. If you plan to pay more than the required payment, check that extra payments are allowed and applied to principal.
  • Protections. Card debt has billing-dispute rights under federal law. A loan payment is a fixed contractual obligation; before choosing it, make sure you can afford it through a rough patch, because a missed loan payment has its own consequences.
  • A fourth path. A nonprofit credit counselor can review whether a debt management plan or another route suits you better; consolidation loan, balance transfer or paying cards in place? sets the main options side by side.

Beware of anyone who contacts you offering to consolidate or settle your cards and asks for money up front. Call the number on the back of your card if you are unsure whether a contact is genuine, and use the CFPB complaint process if a lender or collector treats you unfairly.

Key takeaways

  • A consolidation loan changes the rate, term, payment and fees together, so only a total-cost comparison at the same monthly payment tells you whether it saves money.
  • An origination fee is deducted from the proceeds, so you must borrow more than you need: $7,000 at a 5% fee means borrowing $7,368.42.
  • In the example, a 15% loan with a 5% fee saved $242.11 against cards paid at $300 a month; at an 8% fee it cost $109.27 more.
  • A long term lowers the payment and raises the total: the 60-month loan cost $1,418.17 more than the cards at $300 a month.
  • Stress-test the fee, the rate, the term and your real baseline payment, and remember the loan only helps if the emptied cards stay empty.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic