Blog

How debt settlement programs work, and where the costs hide

A settlement program has you stop paying creditors and save instead. A worked example shows the fees, growing balances, credit damage and tax bill that follow.

A debt settlement program works like this: you stop paying your credit cards, you send a monthly deposit to a savings account instead, and when the account holds enough, the company offers each creditor a lump sum that is smaller than the balance. If a creditor accepts, the debt is closed for the lower amount. The company then collects a fee. Nothing in that sequence is guaranteed. Creditors are not obliged to accept an offer, and while the savings build, your accounts go unpaid.

That is the whole mechanism, and it is why the cost of a program is rarely the number on the sales call. The costs sit in the months between "stop paying" and "settled": added interest, late fees, damage to your credit history, calls and sometimes lawsuits, the company's fee, and a possible tax bill on the amount forgiven. This article walks through the mechanism in order, then runs one labeled example with the arithmetic so you can see how the pieces add up.

The sequence a program follows

Programs differ in the details, but most follow the same six steps.

  1. Enrollment. You list your unsecured debts, usually credit cards and similar accounts, and agree to a monthly deposit. The company states how many months it expects the program to last.
  2. A dedicated account. The deposits go to an account in your name at an independent bank, not into the company's own pocket. You can see the balance. This account is the settlement fund.
  3. You stop paying the creditors. This is the step that surprises people. Creditors will not usually negotiate a smaller payoff with someone who is current and able to pay, so programs rely on accounts becoming past due. Sometimes the company tells you to stop; sometimes the structure makes it the default.
  4. The fund grows. For months, nothing is being paid to anyone but the fund. Meanwhile each card moves from late to seriously late. After about six months without a payment, issuers commonly charge-off a card account, which is an accounting write-off and not forgiveness.
  5. Negotiation. When the fund is large enough to make an offer worth considering, the company contacts a creditor or the collector holding the debt and proposes a lump sum. The creditor accepts, counters or refuses. The company usually negotiates one account at a time, and the larger or older balances tend to be settled as the fund permits.
  6. Payment and fee. If you approve an agreement, the fund pays the creditor and the company's fee is taken. You should have the agreement in writing before any money leaves the account.

Notice what the creditor sees across steps 3 to 5: a customer who stopped paying. From the creditor's side, the offer of a lump sum is a way to collect something from an account that has been producing nothing.

Why a creditor would accept less than it is owed

A creditor accepts a smaller payment when it expects that to be better than the alternatives. A charged-off account is already on the issuer's books as a loss. Collecting through a collector costs money and may recover little, and suing costs more and takes years. A prompt lump sum has a certain value; a long chase has an uncertain one. That logic is why settlements happen at all.

The same logic explains why nothing is guaranteed. A creditor that believes you can pay more, that is already in court, or that simply has a policy of not settling through third parties can say no. Different creditors behave differently, and the same creditor behaves differently at different times. No company can promise a percentage in advance, whatever the marketing says. For how a collector's counteroffer should be judged, see A collector offers to settle for half. Work out whether to accept.

A worked example with the numbers

Every figure below is an illustration, not a market rate or any company's price. Say Sam has four cards with a combined $24,000 balance at an illustrative 24% APR, which is 2% a month. Sam enrolls in a program that asks for $500 a month and charges a fee of 20% of the enrolled debt. The fee and the settlement percentage are assumptions chosen to be easy to follow.

The balances do not stand still. Sam stops paying. For about six months, before the issuers charge off, interest keeps accruing at 2% a month:

  • $24,000 × 1.02^6 comes to about $27,028 from interest alone.
  • Late fees add more. If each of the four cards charges roughly $30 for the first missed payment and roughly $41 for each of the next five, that is 4 × $30 + 20 × $41 = $940, an illustrative maximum, since issuers can charge less and fees cannot exceed the minimum payment due.

Call it $27,000 at the point of settlement, which is conservative because it leaves the late fees out. If a card also moves to a penalty rate (the Penalty APR on many cards is near 30%, according to published guides), the figure is higher.

The settlement. Say the creditors accept 55% of the balance they hold at settlement. That is $27,000 × 0.55 = $14,850.

The fee. The fee is 20% of the $24,000 that was enrolled: $4,800.

The total. $14,850 + $4,800 = $19,650.

Item Amount
Enrolled balance $24,000
Balance owed when settled (illustrative) $27,000
Settlements at 55% of that $14,850
Company fee, 20% of enrolled $4,800
Total paid out of the fund $19,650
Deposits over 36 months at $500 $18,000

The fund runs short by $1,650, and $19,650 ÷ $500 is 39.3, so the program takes about 40 months, not 36. If the creditors had accepted 40%, the settlements would be $10,800 and the total $15,600, a little over 31 months of deposits. If they had accepted 70%, the settlements alone would be $18,900 and the total $23,700, about 47 months. The settlement percentage moves the timeline, and you do not control it.

Notice also what the 55% settlement means against the original $24,000. Sam pays $19,650 in total to clear $24,000 of enrolled debt, about 82 cents per dollar enrolled, after months of damage. That is a saving, but a far smaller one than "pennies on the dollar" suggests, and it can be negative if the settlements come in high or the program drops out part way.

Where the costs hide

The balance keeps growing

Interest and late fees keep adding to every unpaid card until the issuer charges off, and some collectors and debt buyers keep adding after that, depending on the contract and state law. A program that begins with $24,000 negotiates a larger number. Ask any company to show the settlement math against the projected balance, not only the enrolled amount.

Your credit history takes the hit

Payment history is the largest single factor in FICO scores, about 35 percent according to FICO's published weights. Every month that four cards go unpaid adds another late mark. The negative entries can be reported for seven years, counted from the first missed payment plus 180 days. A settled account is typically reported as settled for less than the full balance, and many lenders read that as a negative. The delinquency is the damage; the settlement ends the debt but not the record. A companion article covers the report side, I settled a card debt for less. What about taxes and my credit report?.

Collection calls and lawsuits remain possible

A program does not stop a creditor or collector from calling, and it does not stop a lawsuit. A creditor that sues and wins gets a judgment, and depending on your state a judgment can lead to wage garnishment or a claim on bank funds. The settlement fund is your own money in your own name, so in some states a judgment creditor may be able to reach it. A company can reasonably say it has handled many cases; it cannot promise you will not be sued.

The fee

Fees are typically a percentage of the debt, charged account by account as settlements are completed. A federal rule, the FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule, bans debt relief companies that sell by phone from charging fees before they have settled or reduced a debt, effective in 2010, and hiring attorneys does not exempt a company from the ban. The rule also requires that the fund sit in an account you own that you can leave without penalty, as the FTC describes it. Those rules help, but they do not make the fee small.

A possible tax bill

Debt forgiven can count as taxable income. In Sam's example, $27,000 minus $14,850 is $12,150 forgiven. Depending on Sam's finances, some of that may be excluded and some may not, so the real cost might include a tax bill. A tax professional can work out which. The details are in the companion article on settlement taxes.

Creditors that refuse

If one creditor will not settle, the program has no way to close that account, and the cost of waiting for that one account compounds. The settled accounts are done. The refusing account is still late, still growing and may be in court.

What you will see while you wait

The waiting months are not quiet, and knowing the pattern in advance makes them easier to handle. In the first month or two you will usually see late notices, a late fee on each statement, and reminder calls or texts from the issuer. After roughly the third or fourth missed payment the tone changes: the issuer may close the card to new purchases, send a final-demand letter, and move the account toward collections. After a charge-off, the account may be assigned to a collection agency or sold to a debt buyer, and the calls and letters now come from a different name, one the program may not have told you about.

Each of those contacts is a decision point. A collector that is a third party has duties under federal law, including sending a written validation notice, and you can ask for it in writing, a step covered in how to request debt validation from a collector, step by step. A letter that says you are being sued is different from a collection letter and has a deadline; ignoring it can end with a default judgment. If you enroll in a program, keep every letter and tell the company about each one on the day it arrives, because a suit changes what the company can do and what the fund should be used for.

Keep your own record as well: the date you stopped paying each card, the balance on that date, and every settlement offer in writing. That file is how you check the company's figures against the creditors' and how you answer a mistake on a credit report later.

Who this tends to fit, and who it does not

Debt settlement is contested, and both sides have a point.

The case for it. Someone with a large unsecured balance, income too thin to pay it down, and a realistic view that bankruptcy may be the alternative can see settlement as a way to resolve debts for less than owed without a court case. A structured program can also help people who would otherwise spend the money instead of saving it.

The case against it. The costs above are certain while the savings are not. It is a poor fit for someone who can still make payments, who is near a major credit application such as a mortgage, who is already being sued, or who cannot save the monthly deposit reliably, since a stalled fund leaves behind a pile of delinquent accounts and no settlements.

What fits better in some situations. A nonprofit credit counseling agency can set up a debt management plan, which usually keeps accounts current. Many issuers have hardship programs that lower the rate or payment before an account goes delinquent, covered in how to ask your card issuer for a hardship program, call by call. A bankruptcy attorney can explain Chapter 7 and Chapter 13, and many offer a first consultation. None of these is better in general; the right one depends on income, the amount owed and what is at risk.

Questions to ask before you enroll

Use this as a checklist when a company explains its program. A company that answers clearly and in writing is easier to evaluate; vague answers are information too, and how to spot a debt relief scam before you sign or pay anything lists the warning signs.

  • What is the fee, as a percentage and in dollars, and when exactly is it charged?
  • Where does my money sit, whose name is the account in, and can I withdraw it at any time?
  • Will you stop my payments? What happens to each account while I save?
  • How long does the program usually run, and what is that based on?
  • What happens if a creditor refuses, or sues me?
  • What will my credit reports show at each stage?
  • Is anyone calling me to explain the tax consequences, and should I ask a tax professional?
  • What happens to the fee and the fund if I leave?

Run your own numbers before you decide. A payoff tool such as the credit card payoff calculator shows what staying current would cost in interest and time, so the comparison is between two real totals and not a sales figure.

If a card account is giving you trouble, call the number on the back of your card and ask what hardship options exist before you do anything else. If a company or collector treats you unfairly, you can file a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and your state attorney general's office also takes complaints about debt settlement companies.

Key takeaways

  • A settlement program rests on a sequence: stop paying, save, then negotiate. The nonpayment period is where most of the cost builds up.
  • The company's fee is only one cost. Interest, late fees, credit damage, a possible lawsuit and a possible tax bill all follow from the same sequence.
  • In the labeled example, $24,000 of enrolled debt cost $19,650 and about 40 months, not 36, because balances grew and the fee was added.
  • Creditors decide whether to settle and for how much. Any promise of a percentage is a hope, not a term.
  • Settlement is one option among several; a payment plan, a hardship program or bankruptcy advice may fit a given situation better, and each deserves a real comparison before you stop paying anyone.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic