Blog

Is a welcome bonus worth it? Work out what the spend really costs

A thirteen-line worksheet that nets a bonus against rewards you would earn anyway, the annual fee, interest and spending you would not otherwise do.

A welcome bonus looks like free money because the headline is only the reward. The real question is what you give up to get it. You give up the rewards your current card would have earned on the same spending, possibly an annual fee, possibly interest, and, if the required spending is more than you would normally do, the cost of buying things you did not need. Net those against the reward and you have the number that matters.

This is a worksheet, so it is built to be repeated with your own figures. Every example below uses invented round numbers labeled as illustrations. None describes a real card's current offer. Pull the real numbers from the offer terms on the day you apply, or enter them in the welcome bonus calculator if you prefer a form.

The sum in one sentence

Net value of the bonus = what the reward is worth to you, plus what the new card earns on the required spending, minus what your current card would have earned on that same spending, minus the annual fee, minus any interest you expect to pay, minus the cost of spending you would not otherwise have done.

That is the entire method. The rest of the post defines each part so you do not fool yourself on any of them.

The worksheet

Copy these lines onto paper or a spreadsheet. The right-hand column is the first worked example, introduced after the table.

Line What to enter Example 1 (Maya)
A Reward quantity (points, miles or dollars) 50,000 points
B Value per point in cents (use your honest figure) 1.0 cent
C Bonus value in dollars (A × B ÷ 100) $500
D Required spend (the minimum spend) $4,000
E Spending you would do on a card anyway in the window $3,200
F Extra spend needed (D − E, never below zero) $800
G Rewards the new card earns on D (base earning) $40
H Rewards your current card would earn on D $80
I Annual fee charged in the first year $95
J Interest you expect to pay $0
K Part of F you would not otherwise buy $300
L Net value: C + G − H − I − J − K $65
M Break-even bonus value: H + I + J + K − G $435

Line M is the most useful number on the sheet. It says how much the reward must be worth for you to come out even, and you can compare it with the reward on offer before you read anything else.

Line A and B: the value of the reward

If the bonus is cash back or a statement credit, line C is the dollar amount and you are done. If it is points or miles, you must choose a value per point, and this is where most bonus math goes wrong. Cash-back style redemptions are typically worth 1 cent per point. Anything higher requires transfers to airline or hotel partners or travel redemptions that suit how you actually travel. Published estimates differ by publisher: The Points Guy's mid-2026 valuations, for example, put some bank transferable currencies at roughly 2 cents a point, while other guides give wider ranges. Those are opinion-based estimates, not guaranteed values.

The honest rule is to use the value of the best redemption you have actually used or would actually book in the next year, and to use 1 cent if you cannot name one. A reward you will not redeem well is worth the cash-out rate. The related post welcome bonus in points, miles or cash back: how to compare them compares the reward types, and the points and miles value calculator helps if you want to test a specific redemption. Terms like cents per point make more sense after you have done the sum once.

The sensitivity matters, as Maya's example shows. Her reward is 50,000 points:

Value per point Bonus value (C) Net value (L)
0.8 cent $400 −$35
1.0 cent $500 $65
1.5 cents $750 $315
2.0 cents $1,000 $565

Each row is the same sum with a different C: for 0.8 cent, $400 + $40 − $80 − $95 − $0 − $300 = −$35. The bonus swings from a loss to a gain on the valuation alone, which is why an optimistic valuation makes almost any bonus look good.

Lines D to F: how much spending is extra

The minimum spend requirement is a total, not an increment. If you already put $3,200 of ordinary spending on cards in the window (groceries, fuel, utilities, insurance, phone, a recurring subscription), then only $800 of the $4,000 is extra. Be strict about E. Count only spending you would genuinely have done, and only the share you can put on a card without a surcharge or fee. Rent paid through a service that adds a fee, or a tax payment with a processing charge, is not free spending. It is a purchase of a few percentage points.

If E is larger than D, line F is zero and you may not need to change a single habit. If E is much smaller than D, the worksheet is telling you something: either the offer does not fit your life, or you would be pulling forward purchases you will make later, which is the cleverer case covered by line K.

Lines G and H: what you give up by switching cards

Every dollar you put on the new card to meet the threshold is a dollar you did not put on the card you already use. If your current card earns, say, 2% cash back, then $4,000 of spending would have earned $80 there. The new card earns a base rate on that same $4,000 (Maya's earns 1 point per dollar, so 4,000 points, or $40 at 1 cent). The difference between G and H is the quiet cost of the exercise.

Some new cards earn more than the old one on the same spending, in which case G exceeds H and the line helps you. The sum treats either case honestly. What you should not do is ignore H, which makes the bonus look $80 better than it is.

Line I: the annual fee

If the card charges an annual fee and the first year is not waived, include it in full. If the first year is waived and you plan to keep the card past the first anniversary, the fee returns in year two; this worksheet covers the first year only, and the keep-or-cancel decision belongs to a different sum. The companion worksheet how to work out whether a card's annual fee pays for itself handles recurring credits and benefits you use every year. Leave out any credit that you would not use without the card. A statement credit for a service you do not buy is not an offset.

Line J: interest, the bonus-killer

Interest is the one cost that can swallow the whole reward, and it is entirely under your control. If you pay the statement balance in full by the due date every month, new purchases ride the grace period and J is zero. If you carry a balance, interest starts accruing on new purchases too, because the grace period is generally lost when a prior balance is not paid in full.

Say Sam, a second labeled household, cannot pay Maya's $4,000 off in full. Sam carries $2,000 for two months at an illustrative 25% APR. The monthly rate is 25% ÷ 12, about 2.08%, so one month costs about $2,000 × 0.0208 = $41.67, and two months about $83. That ignores compounding and any payments made in between, so it is an approximation. Sam's net moves from Maya's $65 to roughly −$18, found as $65 − $83. The sum shows that a mid-sized bonus on a card you will carry a balance on is not a bonus.

The honest question for line J is not "will I carry a balance?" but "if my paycheck were late once, could I still pay the full statement?" If the answer is no, put a realistic interest figure on the line, or do not chase the offer.

Line K: the spending you would not do

K is the line people leave blank. It is the cost of anything you buy only to reach the threshold. If you buy a $300 item you did not need, you have spent $300 to receive an object you do not value; if you can resell it for $200, the loss is closer to $100 plus the effort. Price the item at its cost to you after you subtract what you could honestly recover.

Not all extra spending is waste. Prepaying a bill you will owe anyway, buying a gift you were going to buy next month, or replacing something that is wearing out are real uses of money you were going to spend. They cost you the time value of the money, which is small, and nothing else. In Maya's example, $500 of the $800 gap was this kind of purchase, so only $300 goes on line K.

The pacing post, how to pace a minimum spend without buying things you do not need, gives a practical way to find that $500 without inventing purchases. Its stop rule is the same idea as line K: if the plan needs spending you cannot justify, the plan is the problem.

Two more worked examples

Example 2: a no-fee card and a small bonus. Priya's offer is $200 cash back for $1,500 of spending in three months. The card has no annual fee. She would put $1,800 on a card in that window, so F is zero and K is zero. Her current card earns 2%, so H is $30 on $1,500. The new card earns 1.5%, so G is $22.50. She pays in full, so J is zero.

Net = $200 + $22.50 − $30 − $0 − $0 − $0 = $192.50. Break-even (line M) = $30 + $0 + $0 + $0 − $22.50 = $7.50, so a $200 reward clears the bar by a wide margin. Cases like this are why a small bonus can beat a large one: the large one comes with a fee and a spending target that cost more than the difference.

Example 3: a big bonus with a big threshold. Lee's offer is a reward the terms value at about $900 at 1.5 cents per point, a $6,000 threshold, and a $250 first-year fee. Lee normally charges $2,500 in the window, so F is $3,500. Lee's current card earns 1.5%, so H is $90 on $6,000, and the new card earns 1%, so G is $60. Pressed honestly, Lee admits that only $1,000 of the $3,500 gap is spending that would happen anyway, such as prepaying a few bills. The other $2,500 would be purchases Lee does not want, so K is $2,500.

Net = $900 + $60 − $90 − $250 − $0 − $2,500 = −$1,880. Without K the sum would read $620, which is why K cannot be left blank. As written, the plan fails. Lee would need a lower threshold, an offer with a longer window, or a way to move more existing spending onto the card before it makes sense to apply.

Costs the worksheet cannot price

A few things stay outside the sum because they have no clean figure:

  • The hard inquiry and the new account. A single inquiry typically lowers a FICO Score by fewer than five points and is weighed for about a year, according to FICO guidance as widely reported, though it can remain on the report for up to two years. A new account also lowers the average age of your accounts. If you plan a mortgage or an auto loan in the next several months, this has a cost.
  • Eligibility. The offer may exclude you. Widely reported issuer rules about how many recent accounts you may have opened are not published by the issuers, so read the terms and treat any count-based rule as a probability, not a fact.
  • Your time. Tracking a threshold, saving statements and checking that the reward posted all take attention. A $65 net result may not repay it.
  • Taxes. Whether any part of a reward is treated as income depends on the facts and the way the issuer reports it. Ask a tax professional, and keep the terms.

A decision rule you can use

  1. Fill in the worksheet using your honest value per point, not the best case.
  2. If line L is negative, stop.
  3. If K is more than zero and K is more than half of L, stop or shrink the plan until K falls.
  4. If L is positive but smaller than the value of your time and the effort of tracking, consider skipping it.
  5. If L is comfortably positive with K at or near zero, and you pay the statement in full, the bonus is worth chasing on this arithmetic.

The sum does not tell you which card to apply for. It tells you whether a particular offer, for a person with your spending, nets out ahead. For the wider picture of when bonus chasing helps, breaks even or backfires, see chasing sign-up bonuses: three households, three very different results.

Key takeaways

  • The bonus is only the headline. Net it against the rewards your current card would have earned on the same spending, the first-year annual fee, expected interest, and any spending you would not otherwise do.
  • Use 1 cent per point unless you can name a redemption you actually use. A change from 0.8 to 1.5 cents per point moved Maya's labeled example from a $35 loss to a $315 gain.
  • Interest erases a bonus quickly: at an illustrative 25% APR, carrying $2,000 for two months costs about $83, enough to turn a $65 gain into a loss.
  • Line M, the break-even bonus value, lets you compare an offer with your needs before doing anything else.
  • Extra spending is acceptable only when it is something you were going to buy anyway; otherwise line K can outweigh the entire reward.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic