Blog

How to judge the fees on a card for fair or bad credit

Why cards for fair or bad credit often carry more fees, how the first-year 25 percent cap works, and seven criteria for judging if the cost is worth it.

When a score is low or a credit history is thin, the choice of cards narrows, and the cards that remain often come with more fees. A card might charge an annual fee, a one-time setup fee, a monthly servicing fee, or some mix of them, and a small credit limit makes each dollar of fees take a larger bite. At the same time, a card like this can be a useful way to build a payment history, which is the largest part of a credit score. The question is not whether such cards have fees but whether the total cost is worth what the card delivers.

This post gives you a way to answer that for a specific offer. It explains why these cards carry more fees, describes the federal cap that limits first-year fees, works one invented comparison with arithmetic, and ends with seven criteria and a decision list. It does not recommend any card, and it cannot say what any real card charges today. Each issuer's profile and the card's own agreement carry the current terms. All figures below are invented illustrations.

Why these cards usually cost more

Issuers price risk. A card for someone with a limited or damaged record has a higher chance of going unpaid, and the issuer has less information to judge whom to trust. Three things follow.

  • Higher interest rates. Rates on cards for fair or bad credit tend to be at the high end of what the market offers. The Schumer box on any offer shows the rate and whether it is variable.
  • More fees. An issuer that expects higher losses may try to recover some of the cost through fees, and with a small credit line, fees make up a bigger share of what it earns.
  • Smaller limits. Starting limits are often low, a few hundred dollars. A low credit limit means that a fee of $75 is a large fraction of the line.

None of this makes a card unfair or a bad choice. It means the price of the card is different, and you need a way to measure the price in terms you understand. Secured cards, where you put down a refundable deposit that typically sets your limit, are a different structure and often charge less in fees, but they tie up your own money. reading the fee section of a cardholder agreement line by line explains how to find every fee in an agreement, which is the first step in any of this.

The rule that limits first-year fees

Federal card rules put a ceiling on fees in the first year after an account is opened. Total fees charged in that year may not exceed 25 percent of the credit limit. Late fees, over-limit fees and returned-payment fees are excluded from that cap, so it covers the fees that are part of the card's design, such as annual, setup and monthly fees.

Some arithmetic shows what it means.

  • On a $300 limit, 25 percent is $75. Fees of annual, setup and servicing type cannot add up to more than $75 in the first year.
  • On a $500 limit, 25 percent is $125.
  • On a $1,000 limit, 25 percent is $250.

The cap is worth knowing for two reasons. It limits how much a card can charge in the first year relative to what it offers. And it says nothing about the second year. After the first year the cap no longer applies, and a card that is cheap in year one can cost far more in year two. A card's fee schedule should tell you when each fee begins, and that is the line to find.

The cap also does not reduce what a fee does to your usable credit. If fees are billed to the card, they use up part of the limit on day one. A $500 limit with a $75 fee billed to the card leaves $425 to spend, which is 15 percent less than the headline limit. A card that bills the fee to a bank account leaves the full limit but costs you the same money.

An invented comparison, with arithmetic

Here are three invented offers for someone with fair credit. They are not real cards.

Offer A: unsecured Offer B: unsecured Offer C: secured
Credit limit $500 $300 $200
Money you put up none none $200 refundable deposit
Year-one fees $75 annual $60 setup plus $15 annual none
Fees from year two $75 annual plus $12.50 a month $15 annual plus $10 a month none

Year one. Offer A costs $75, which is 15 percent of its $500 limit and under the 25 percent cap of $125. Offer B costs $60 + $15 = $75, which is 25 percent of its $300 limit, exactly at the cap of $75. Offer C costs nothing in fees, though it ties up $200 of your money for the year.

Usable credit on day one. Offer A, if the fee is billed to the card, leaves $500 - $75 = $425. Offer B leaves $300 - $75 = $225. Offer C leaves its full $200.

Cost as a share of usable credit in year one. Offer A: $75 / $425 = 17.6 percent. Offer B: $75 / $225 = 33.3 percent. Offer C: 0 percent in fees.

Year two. Offer A's fees are $75 + 12 x $12.50 = $75 + $150 = $225, which is 45 percent of the $500 limit. Offer B's fees are $15 + 12 x $10 = $15 + $120 = $135, which is 45 percent of the $300 limit. Offer C's are still zero.

Three-year total fees. Offer A: $75 + $225 + $225 = $525. Offer B: $75 + $135 + $135 = $345. Offer C: $0, plus the cost of having $200 unavailable. If that $200 could have earned, say, an illustrative 3 percent in a savings account, the cost is $200 x 0.03 = $6.00 a year, or $18.00 over three years, not counting that the deposit is returned when the account closes or graduates.

The pattern is the point. Year one can look cheap and year two expensive. A card whose cost doubles after twelve months is a different proposition from one with flat costs, and the fee table does not always say so on its first page. If a card lets you move to a lower-fee product after a year of on-time payments, the year-two cost may never apply to you, which is why the exit path matters as much as the entry price.

Seven criteria for judging a card's fees

Use these in order. Each is a question you can answer from the offer's terms.

  1. What is the total fee in the first year, and what share of the limit is it? Compare it with the 25 percent cap. A card at or near the cap is spending nearly all of its allowed fee room.
  2. When does each fee start, and what is the cost in year two and year three? Look for monthly servicing or maintenance fees that begin after the first year.
  3. Are fees billed to the card or paid separately? A fee billed to the card reduces usable credit, and a card with high fees and a low limit may leave you almost nothing to spend.
  4. Does the issuer report to all three bureaus? A card helps build a record only if the issuer reports your payments to the credit bureaus. Ask which bureaus receive the report, and see whether the card's terms say so. A card that reports nothing is a loan you pay fees on, with none of the credit-building benefit. credit bureau and credit report explain who sees what.
  5. Is there a path to a better card or lower fees? Some issuers review an account after a period of on-time payments and may raise the limit, lower fees or move you to a different product. Others do not. A secured credit card often has a graduation path where the issuer returns the security deposit and converts the account, though terms vary by issuer.
  6. What is the APR, and will you carry a balance? If you pay in full every month, the APR hardly matters and the fees are the whole cost. If you carry a balance, interest adds to fees. On a $300 balance at an invented 29 percent APR, interest is about $300 x 0.29 / 12 = $7.25 a month, which on top of a $12.50 monthly fee is $19.75 a month.
  7. Is the card what it says it is? Check that you are dealing with a real card issuer, that the terms are in writing before you commit, and that nothing is charged before you have an account. A request to pay a fee by gift card, wire transfer or app to "guarantee" approval is a scam sign, not a fee. Never pay a stranger who calls or messages you about a card, and if a message claims to be from a bank, call the number on the back of a card or on the bank's own website, not the one in the message.

A decision list

Take an offer through these questions. The answers do not tell you what to do, but they show where the offer sits.

  • Is the first-year fee total under 25 percent of the limit, and under what share of usable credit? If it is at the cap, ask why the card charges so much.
  • Is the second-year cost clearly stated? If you cannot find it, the card may not tell you.
  • Does it report to all three bureaus, and does the issuer say so in writing? If not, ask.
  • Is there a stated way to move to a lower-fee card? If so, how long does it take and what does the issuer review?
  • Could a secured card do the same job? If you have the deposit and can leave it untouched for the period, a secured card may cost less in fees. It costs the use of your money and is not for everyone.
  • Would you pay the balance in full each month? If not, the interest is part of the price and should be counted.
  • Is there a free alternative? A free secured card, a credit-builder loan from a credit union, or becoming an authorized user on someone's account in good standing can add history in different ways. Each has its own risks, and the primary cardholder stays responsible on an authorized-user account.

If most answers are favorable, the fees may be a fair price for what the card delivers. If several are unfavorable, the card's cost is high relative to what it does, and waiting or choosing another route is a reasonable thing to consider.

What the offer page may not tell you

Offer pages are built to get an application, and the numbers that matter most to a careful reader are often one click away. Before you apply, look past the headline for these.

  • The full fee schedule. The summary may show the annual fee and not the monthly charge that starts later. Open the full terms and read the fee list to the end.
  • How the starting limit is set. An offer may advertise a range, such as "up to" a large figure, and then give most applicants the low end. The limit you are given, not the one advertised, is what the 25 percent cap and your usable credit are measured against.
  • Whether the limit can change. Some cards review accounts for increases after on-time payments, and some do not. If the product has no path upward, a low limit stays low.
  • What counts as a payment on time. Look at the due date, the cutoff time and how payments are credited, since a late fee on a card with a small line can be a large share of what you can spend.
  • Whether a deposit is returned, when and how. For a secured card, the terms should say when the deposit comes back, whether it is applied to a balance and what happens if you close the account with a balance.

If an answer is not in the terms, ask in writing before applying. A reply in writing is worth more than a promise on the phone.

Checking the first statement against the cap

After you open an account, use the first statements to confirm that the issuer is following the rules. Take an invented card with a $500 limit. The cap on first-year fees, excluding late, over-limit and returned-payment fees, is 25 percent of $500, or $125. Suppose by the end of the first year you find these fees on your statements: an annual fee of $75, a setup fee of $55 and monthly charges of $0 in year one. The total is $75 + $55 = $130, which is $5 above the $125 cap. In that case, the issuer has charged more than the rule allows, and you can ask for a refund of the excess.

Start with a call to the number on the back of your card, and ask the representative to explain how the fees fit under the first-year limit. If the answer is not satisfactory, put the question in writing and keep a copy. If the issuer still does not correct it, the CFPB complaint process is the next step. Keep the original agreement, the dates when each fee posted and the credit limit you were given, since those numbers decide the answer. Late, over-limit and returned-payment fees are excluded from the cap, so do not count them in your total.

Be careful with one case. If your limit was raised during the year, the cap's base can depend on the limit in effect, and the details are in the rule and in your agreement. A professional, such as a nonprofit credit counselor, can help if you are unsure.

What to do if you already have one

If you already hold a card like this, the same arithmetic tells you what to do next.

Key takeaways

  • Cards for fair or bad credit often cost more because issuers price for higher risk, and a small limit makes each fee a larger share of the line.
  • Federal rules cap total first-year fees at 25 percent of the credit limit, with late, over-limit and returned-payment fees excluded, but the cap says nothing about year two.
  • In the invented example, one card's fees rose from $75 in year one to $225 in year two, which was 45 percent of its $500 limit, so always find the fee schedule for later years.
  • Check whether fees are billed to the card, whether the issuer reports to all three bureaus, and whether there is a path to a lower-fee product.
  • Never pay a fee to a stranger to guarantee approval, and compare the offer with a secured card or other credit-building options before deciding.

Terms used in this article

Latest on this topic