Blog
Lost card, stolen number, charges before you reported: work out your liability
A step-by-step sum for your own situation that applies the federal $50 cap to a lost card, a stolen number, and charges made before and after your report.
You can work out, in about ten minutes, the most the law allows your issuer to hold you responsible for when a credit card or its number is used without your permission. You need three things: a list of the charges you did not make, the time and date you reported the problem to your issuer, and an honest answer to one question: was the physical card lost or stolen, or was only the account number taken?
This is a worksheet, not an essay. It gives you the steps, a blank table to fill in on paper or in a notes file and three worked cases with every sum shown. The cases use invented amounts and are labeled as hypotheticals. The rule behind the sums is federal: a cardholder's liability for unauthorized use of a credit card is capped at $50, the issuer carries the burden of proving the conditions for even that $50, and if only the account number was stolen, the cardholder generally has no liability. Reporting a lost or stolen card before it is used means no liability. That is the law's floor. Your issuer's own zero liability policy may go further, and the sum you will do tells you what the law alone would allow, which is the number to know if the policy does not apply. the $50 limit on unauthorized charges: what it covers and what it does not explains the rule, and this post applies it.
What you need before you start
Gather four things.
- Your statements and the app's transaction list from the period of the problem. Include pending items, because a pending transaction can become a posted charge, and note the posting date when it does.
- The time of your report, to the minute if you can. The call to the issuer on the number on the back of your card is the report that counts for this sum. If you called and also wrote, use the earlier time. If you have the representative's name or a reference number, note it.
- The facts about the card: was it physically lost or stolen, or still with you?
- The date and amount of any charge you cannot explain, and of any charge you can.
Open the lost or stolen card checklist if you have not yet reported. The sums matter less than the call.
Step 1: Separate your charges from the ones you did not make
Go line by line and mark each charge as one of three types.
- Mine: I made it or knowingly let someone make it.
- Not mine: I did not make it and did not permit it. This is an unauthorized charge.
- Unsure: I do not recognize it yet.
Check the unsure ones before you count them. Look for a family member's purchase, a trial that converted to a paid plan, a hotel or rental deposit and a store that bills under a parent company's name. If you gave someone the card and they spent more than you intended, those charges are generally treated as authorized unless you had told the issuer their use was no longer allowed, so talk to the issuer about them separately and do not include them in the sums below.
Write your list in a table like this one:
| # | Date and time | Merchant | Amount | Type (mine, not mine) | Before or after my report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||||
| 2 | |||||
| 3 |
Step 2: Mark each unauthorized charge before or after your report
Take the time you reported and compare each unauthorized charge's time. The statement may show only a date, and the app's pending view may show a time. If you cannot tell, ask the issuer for the time of authorization, and write down what it says.
Charges after your report are simple: once the issuer has notice, you have no liability for later unauthorized use of that card. Charges before your report are the ones that matter for the cap.
Step 3: Decide which rule applies
Answer one question: was the physical card lost or stolen?
- Yes, the card itself was lost or stolen. The $50 cap applies to unauthorized charges made before you reported.
- No, only the account number was taken, from a breached merchant, a phishing page or an online checkout. You generally have no liability under federal law. If you have the card in hand and the charges are online or by phone, this is usually your case, and card-not-present fraud describes how it happens.
- A mix. The card was stolen and the number was also used online, or you are not sure. Treat the charges made with the physical card, such as chip or tap purchases in person, under the first rule, and the online ones under the second, and let the issuer help you sort it out.
Step 4: Do the sum
For the physical-card case:
- Add the unauthorized charges made before your report. Call the total B.
- Your maximum liability is the smaller of $50 and B.
- Charges after the report add nothing.
For the account-number-only case, the maximum liability is generally $0.
If your issuer's zero-liability policy applies, your actual liability may be $0 either way. The sum above is the legal ceiling.
Your worksheet lines:
| Line | What to write | Your figure |
|---|---|---|
| A | Time and date of your report | |
| B | Sum of unauthorized charges before A | |
| C | Sum of unauthorized charges after A | |
| D | Physical card lost or stolen? (yes or no) | |
| E | If yes, the smaller of $50 and B | |
| F | If no, generally $0 | |
| G | Charges the issuer should remove (B plus C, less the liability on line E or F) |
Three worked cases
The sums below follow the steps above, with every figure shown.
Case 1: A stolen wallet, with charges before the report
Hypothetical, with invented amounts. A wallet is stolen on a Monday. The cardholder notices at 3:30 p.m. and calls the issuer at 3:45 p.m. Three unauthorized charges posted before 3:45: $18.75 at a gas station, $42.10 at a pharmacy and $96.00 at an electronics store. At 5:10 p.m. the thief tries $75.00 at another store, and it is declined.
- B, charges before the report: $18.75 + $42.10 + $96.00. Adding: $18.75 + $42.10 is $60.85, and $60.85 + $96.00 is $156.85.
- C, charges after the report: the $75.00 attempt was declined and, even if it had been approved, there is no liability for use after notice. Charged to the cardholder: $0.
- D: yes, the physical card was stolen.
- E: the smaller of $50 and $156.85 is $50.
So the most the law allows the issuer to ask of this cardholder is $50, and the other $106.85 is the issuer's loss. If the issuer waives the $50 under its policy, the cardholder owes $0. In the meantime the charges reduce available credit: on a hypothetical $2,500 limit, the $156.85 leaves $2,343.15 of available credit until the issuer credits the account.
Case 2: Only the number was stolen
Hypothetical, with invented amounts. A cardholder opens a statement on the 12th and finds two online charges, $212.40 and $9.99, from merchants they never used. The card is in the wallet. They call the same day.
- B: $212.40 + $9.99 = $222.39.
- D: no, the physical card is not lost or stolen. Only the number was used.
- F: generally $0.
The amount of money is larger than in Case 1, and the liability is smaller. That surprises people. The cap is about the use of a lost or stolen card. Where only the number was taken, the cardholder generally has no liability under federal law. My card is in my wallet but fraud charges appeared. How is that possible? explains how a number leaves a card that never left your hand.
The small charge is worth a note. A $9.99 charge is often a thief's test of whether the number works, and a larger charge follows. If you see a small charge you do not recognize, report it the same day and do not wait for the big one.
Case 3: A small loss before the report, and a lot after
Hypothetical, with invented amounts. A card falls out of a coat on Friday evening. The cardholder does not notice until Saturday at 9 a.m., when they call to report it. One unauthorized charge of $32.00 posted Friday night. Charges totaling $140.00 posted on Saturday after the call, and one more of $55.00 on Sunday.
- B: $32.00 only, because it is the only charge before the report.
- C: $140.00 + $55.00 = $195.00. No liability for these.
- D: yes.
- E: the smaller of $50 and $32.00 is $32.00.
So the maximum is $32.00. The cap is a ceiling, and $32.00 is below it. The Saturday and Sunday charges, $195.00, are not the cardholder's. Where a charge posts after the report but was authorized before it, as can happen with a pending item, ask the issuer how it treated it and note the authorization time.
What changes if one fact changes
The sum is sensitive to a few facts, and it helps to see how. Take Case 1 again, with $156.85 of unauthorized charges before the report on a stolen card, and change one thing at a time.
| If this changes | New liability ceiling | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Only $30.00 posted before the report, not $156.85 | $30.00 | The cap is the smaller of $50 and the charges, and $30.00 is smaller |
| The cardholder reported before any charge posted | $0 | Reporting before use means no liability |
| The same charges were made online with only the number | $0, generally | A number-only theft carries no liability under federal law |
| Charges before the report total exactly $50.00 | $50.00 | The two amounts are equal |
| The charges were made by a relative who had the card with permission | Not an unauthorized-charge sum | Permitted use is treated as authorized unless the issuer was told otherwise |
The pattern is that three facts drive the result: whether the physical card was taken, when you reported and whether you permitted the use. The dollar total of the fraud matters only up to $50.
Reading your own statement for the sum
Many people struggle not with the arithmetic but with the evidence. A few habits make the worksheet reliable.
- Use the transaction time where you can. Statements usually show only the date. The app often shows more, and the issuer can tell you the time of authorization for a particular charge.
- Expect pending items to move. A pending charge may post a day or two later at a slightly different amount, and a pending charge can also drop off. Re-check the list after a few days and update the table.
- Watch for charges that look recurring. If a thief signed the card up for a subscription, charges may come monthly. Ask the issuer to close the merchant and to block future charges, and ask whether it will remove all of them, including ones posting after the report.
- Do not mix in your own charges. Include only the charges you did not make. If an authorized charge is mixed in, the sum will be wrong and the issuer will notice.
- Keep the original and a marked copy. Highlight on the copy.
If the amounts on your statement and your table disagree, trust the statement, correct the table and tell the issuer about the difference. The figures the issuer works from are its own records, and the worksheet is your check on them.
What the sums do not tell you
The worksheet gives you a legal ceiling, not a prediction. A few things sit outside it.
- Charges you authorized. Even if you were deceived, those are decided on other grounds. scam payment or unauthorized charge: why your protections can differ covers them.
- Debit cards and bank accounts. Different rules apply, with a different structure and clock. Check your bank's agreement.
- Your issuer's policy, which may waive the $50 or add conditions. Read it, and see zero liability myths: what the promise actually covers and what it does not.
- Business cards, whose agreements can differ.
After the sum: three more lines
The liability sum is one part. These next steps keep the result intact.
- Send a written notice. Written notice of a billing error must reach the creditor within 60 days after the statement showing the error was sent. If the statement was sent on November 10, the 60th day is January 9 (20 days to November 30, 31 more to December 31, then 9 more). work out your dispute deadlines from the statement date: a worksheet shows how to count for your own statement, and How to write a billing error letter under the Fair Credit Billing Act builds the letter.
- Keep paying what is not in dispute. A missed payment on the rest of the account can cost more than the disputed amount.
- Review the next two statements. Late-posting and test charges can appear after the first report. after you report card fraud: what happens day by day, and what you still owe follows what usually happens after a report.
If the issuer asks you to pay more than your worksheet says is the legal maximum, ask for the reason in writing and for the section of the agreement or the law it relies on. A complaint through the CFPB complaint process is available if you do not get a satisfactory answer.
Key takeaways
- Your legal maximum for a lost or stolen card is the smaller of $50 and the unauthorized charges made before you reported. Charges after your report add nothing.
- If only the account number was taken, you generally have no liability, even when the charges are large.
- Do the sum from your own list: separate your charges from unauthorized ones, mark each before or after the report time and apply the rule that fits the facts.
- The sums are the legal ceiling. An issuer's zero-liability policy may make your actual cost $0.
- Report the same day by calling the number on the back of your card, then send a written notice within 60 days of the statement.