Blog

My tap payment failed but the chip worked. Why does that happen?

Why a tap can decline or ask for a chip or PIN while the same card works inserted: reader faults, card wear, issuer checks and avoiding a double charge.

You hold the card to the reader, it makes the wrong sound or flashes a message, you try again, and it fails again. Then you push the same card into the chip slot and the payment goes through. The card is fine. The account is fine. Something between the two ways of paying was not. The cause can be the reader, the card, the phone, the network or a decision by your issuer, and the failed tap is usually harmless. This article answers the questions people ask after it happens, in the order they tend to come up: why it failed, what the terminal and the issuer each did, why the chip then worked, whether you were charged twice, what to check and when to worry. It is general. Specific readers, cards and issuers behave differently, and the issuer is the source for what happened on your account.

Q: Is it the card, the reader or the bank that failed?

There are three places a tap can fail, and each looks a little different at the counter.

The radio link. A contactless payment needs the card's antenna and the reader's antenna to be close and lined up. The link has a range of a few centimeters and a particular sweet spot on each terminal, which may be above the screen or to one side. If the card is too far, held at an angle or moving, the reader does not complete the conversation. The terminal then shows "try again" or does nothing. This is the cause when the second tap, held steady in the right place, works.

The terminal's rules. A reader or a store's settings can decide that a tap is not allowed for this transaction. A terminal may require a chip for an amount above a limit it has been set to accept by tap, or it may be set to take contactless only at certain lanes, or it may have a software fault. In those cases the terminal prompts you to insert the card, and the payment then works.

The issuer's decision. The issuer receives the request and answers yes or no. A decline from the issuer comes with a message, usually "declined", and is a different thing from a failed read. The issuer may decline a tap that it would approve with a chip because its risk checks treat the two differently. That is the case where the chip works after the tap is declined, and it is covered below.

If the terminal never said "declined" and just wanted you to try again, the failure was probably in the first two places. If it did say "declined", the issuer was involved.

Q: Why would the issuer approve the chip but not the tap?

An issuer does not see your card. It sees a request that carries data about how the card was presented, plus the amount, the merchant and the time. A tap and a chip insert both use the same EMV chip standard, but they reach the issuer with different markers, and the issuer's fraud rules can weigh them differently. Four patterns explain most of these cases.

  • Count or total of recent taps. Many issuers ask for a chip or a PIN after a run of taps, or when the total of recent contactless purchases passes a threshold. The numbers are not published and differ by issuer and card, so treat any figure you see online as a guess. The point of the rule is to catch a lost card being used for a string of small purchases. A chip insert resets the pattern.
  • An unusual purchase. A tap for an amount that is high for you, at a type of merchant you rarely use, or in a place you have never been, can trigger a check. A chip insert, which requires the card in the reader, may be treated as a stronger signal that the card is present.
  • A counter inside the chip. A card's chip can keep internal counters of how many transactions it has authorized without going online to the issuer, and some cards require an online check or a chip transaction once a counter is reached. Whether yours does depends on the card, and the rule is one the issuer sets.
  • A problem with the account. An old address, a pending fraud review or a recently reissued card can make the issuer decline some payments and approve others. If the same card declines repeatedly, call the issuer.

After a successful chip insert, the next tap often works again. That is consistent with a counter or a risk rule that the chip reset, though you cannot see which rule applied from the counter.

Q: Why does a tap sometimes need a PIN or a signature?

Terminals and issuers choose how to verify that the person is the cardholder. For small contactless purchases, no verification is usually requested. For larger ones, or when the issuer wants more assurance, the terminal may ask for a PIN or a signature. A card issued without a PIN may not be able to give one, and then the issuer can decline the transaction or ask you to use another method. This is a decision by the issuer and the card's settings, and a PIN on a credit card is not the same as the PIN on a debit card. If you have never set one, ask the issuer whether the card has one and how to get it, which is useful to know before you travel.

Q: Did the failed tap charge me, and could I be charged twice?

Possibly the first, and you should check for the second. A failed attempt that reached the issuer and was approved but not completed at the terminal can leave an approval that has not turned into a sale. That shows up as a pending transaction and reduces your available credit. The issuer's system usually releases an unused authorization hold on its own after a short period, though how long depends on the issuer and the type of merchant, and it can take several days.

Here is a labeled example with invented numbers. Say you buy $47.18 of groceries. The first tap fails at the terminal, but the issuer had already approved it. The chip insert then approves the sale again. On your app you see two pending items of $47.18. Available credit is reduced by 2 times $47.18, or $94.36. If you had $500 of available credit before, it now shows $405.64 (500 minus 94.36). One of the two items is a duplicate that should drop off. If the app shows both as pending, wait. If both later post as charges to your statement, that is a different situation.

What to do, in order:

  1. Keep the receipt from the transaction that completed. If the terminal printed no receipt, take a photo of the screen.
  2. Open the issuer's app that evening, and again after two or three days. Note the pending items.
  3. If the duplicate falls off, nothing more is needed. The effect on your available credit was temporary.
  4. If both items post, you have a billing error, a charge for the same thing twice. Ask the store for a refund first if it is a small business and you are there, and tell the issuer. A written billing-error notice must reach the issuer within 60 days of the statement that shows the charge to preserve the statutory rights, and many issuers also take disputes by phone or app as a courtesy.
  5. If the amount is a large one, call the issuer on the number on the back of the card rather than waiting.

How to write a billing error letter under the Fair Credit Billing Act shows how to word a written notice.

Q: Is a failed tap a sign that someone is trying to use my card?

Usually not. A failed read or a store-side prompt has nothing to do with a thief. Still, a decline that surprises you, at a place you know you are, can be worth an alert check. Look at your issuer's app for a message about a blocked transaction, which some issuers send when a rule fires, and answer it if it is genuine and came from the app itself. Do not call a number from a text. If you are unsure, call the number on the back of the card. The questions of tap fraud and what is and is not documented are covered in Can a stranger steal from your card by tapping it in a crowd? Myths tested.

Q: Could the card itself be damaged?

Yes, and it is one of the more common reasons for a card that taps badly. The chip and the antenna wear. A card that has been bent, kept in a tight back pocket, run through a washing machine or left on a hot dashboard can lose the contactless function while the contact chip still works. The contact pads on the chip are a more direct connection than the radio link, so a card can keep working inserted after the tap stops. Signs of a worn card include taps that work only at certain readers, a cracked surface and a chip that is scratched.

If the card taps poorly everywhere, ask the issuer for a replacement. If a card is replaced, update any subscriptions and online accounts that use the old number, and see Got a replacement card after fraud? A checklist of accounts to update.

Q: Could my phone, case or other cards be getting in the way?

Yes. A few physical things interfere with a good read.

  • Several cards in a stack. If a wallet holds two contactless cards and you tap the whole wallet, the reader may see both and fail. Tap one card out of the wallet.
  • A metal case or a thick case. A phone with a metal plate, a ring or a wallet attachment that holds a card behind the phone can block or confuse the link.
  • A card held against the phone. Taping a card to the back of a phone, or keeping a card behind the case, can cause problems at the reader.
  • A magnetic accessory. A magnet or a magnetic card sleeve can interfere with some readers.

The remedy is to present one card or the phone alone, held flat and still at the reader's mark for a second or two. A phone payment is a token plus a one-time code, as what actually happens when you tap your phone to pay in a store describes, and fails for similar reasons.

Q: Is it the store's terminal? How can I tell?

If taps fail at one store, on one lane, and work elsewhere with the same card, the terminal is the likely cause. If they fail everywhere, the card or the issuer is more likely. The test is easy to run: try a different lane, or a different store. Report a failing terminal to the store, which is the party that can fix it. A store that is closing the till at that moment may be the reason for a failed batch of payments.

When a payment fails and the cause is unclear, Network, issuer or processor? Who to call when a card payment goes wrong explains who handles what, so you call the right party.

Two shorter questions

Q: Does a declined tap hurt my credit score?

No. A declined purchase is not reported to the credit bureaus and is not a late payment or an inquiry. Your report records accounts and how you pay them, not each purchase that an issuer approved or refused. A decline may be annoying and sometimes embarrassing, but it leaves no mark on your file. The one thing that can appear on a statement is a pending hold, as above, and it carries no penalty. Federal rules also bar penalty fees for declined transactions on a credit card, so a decline should not cost you a fee.

Q: Can I turn off tapping, or turn it on, for my card?

Some issuers let cardholders control contactless use, either in the app or by request, and others do not. Where it exists, the setting can be useful if you find taps unreliable or if you want to reduce what a lost card can do. It can also be a reason a tap fails: a card with tapping switched off, or a replacement card that has not been activated for contactless, will not complete a tap even though the chip works. If you recently received a new card and the first taps fail, check whether the issuer needs you to make a first chip-and-PIN purchase to activate the contactless function. Ask the issuer instead of assuming.

A short decision list for the register

  1. Tap once and hold still at the marked spot for two seconds.
  2. If it fails, take the card out of the wallet and try again, away from other cards and from the phone.
  3. If it fails again, insert the chip. It is the same card and the same issuer, with a stronger presence check.
  4. If the chip fails too, use a different card or method. Do not keep retrying the same one, since each attempt can create another pending hold.
  5. Keep the receipt and check the app within a day.
  6. If the card taps badly everywhere, ask for a new one.

When to call the issuer

Call the number on the back of the card, and not a number from a message, when any of these is true: the card declines repeatedly in different places, a hold or charge is duplicated and does not clear in a few days, you see a charge you do not recognize or the issuer's app shows an alert that you did not expect. If the issuer does not resolve a real problem, you can file a complaint with the CFPB.

Key takeaways

  • A failed tap that works on the chip usually points to the radio link, the terminal's rules or an issuer risk check, not a broken card. Hold the card still and alone at the reader's mark before concluding otherwise.
  • Issuers often ask for a chip or PIN after a run of taps or an unusual purchase. The thresholds are not published, and a chip insert resets the pattern.
  • A failed tap can leave a pending hold. Two holds of $47.18 reduce $500 of available credit to $405.64 until the extra one drops off.
  • If both items post, it is a billing error: keep the receipt, tell the issuer and follow up in writing within 60 days of the statement.
  • A card that taps poorly everywhere may be worn. Ask for a replacement and update the accounts that use the old number.

Terms used in this article

Latest on this topic