Blog

Should you pay with points at checkout or take cash back instead?

A fixed checkout rate compared with cash redemption and with paying by card, with break-even arithmetic and a decision list for when pay-with-points loses.

You are at a checkout screen with a $200 cart. Under the card field there is a button: use your points. It shows a number of points, the cart total drops, and the whole thing takes two taps. The question is whether those two taps cost you less or more than the slower alternatives: paying with the card and redeeming points for cash later, or paying with the card and leaving the points alone.

The answer comes down to three rates, which this post puts on one table. The checkout rate says how many cents a point is worth when spent at that screen; that figure is the cents per point rate for this one use. The cash rate says how many it is worth as a statement credit or deposit. The earning rate says how many points the card would have given you for paying normally. pay with points wins only when its rate beats the other two combined. It often does not, and sometimes it does comfortably.

All figures below are illustrative. Your program's checkout rate, cash rate and earning rates are in its terms, and the terms change.

What the button actually does

Pay-with-points, in the various forms programs offer it, converts points into a payment toward a purchase at a rate the program sets. There are two common designs:

  • A checkout-time design, where you choose points as a payment method on a merchant's page or in a wallet, and the program covers some or all of the total.
  • A look-back design, where you make the purchase on the card and then ask the program to cover a past charge with points, which appears as a credit.

In both designs the program fixes the conversion. The rate is usually lower than the cash rate for general purchases and sometimes higher for travel bought through the program's own portal. A fixed rate is a design choice, not a market price, which is why it can beat cash in one place and lose to it in another.

Each time you spend points you make a redemption, and the questions that follow are mechanical: how many points does $200 cost under this design, what would the same $200 cost in points under the alternatives, and what do you give up or gain on the side?

The three rates on one cart

Say a program has these illustrative terms. They are made up for the example.

  • Cash or statement-credit redemption: 1.00 cent per point.
  • Pay-with-points at general merchants: 0.80 cents per point.
  • Pay-with-points toward travel in the program's portal: 1.25 cents per point.
  • Your card earns 2 points per dollar on this purchase when you pay with the card.

The cart is $200 at a general merchant.

Option A: pay with the card, then redeem points as a credit.

  • You earn 2 × $200 = 400 points on the purchase.
  • You redeem enough points to cover $200 at 1.00 cent: $200 ÷ $0.01 = 20,000 points.
  • Net cost: 20,000 − 400 = 19,600 points.

Option B: pay with points at checkout at 0.80 cents.

  • Points needed: $200 ÷ $0.008 = 25,000 points.
  • Suppose you earn nothing on the portion paid with points. Many programs do not award earning on a points-funded payment, though some do; the terms say.
  • Net cost: 25,000 points.

The difference: 25,000 − 19,600 = 5,400 points. At the cash rate of one cent each, that is $54 of value given up on a $200 purchase. Pay-with-points used 28 percent more points (25,000 ÷ 19,600 = 1.276) than Option A.

Option C: pay with the card and leave the points alone. You keep your balance, earn 400 points, and pay the $200 from your bank account. This is not a redemption at all; it is the baseline. Pay-with-points is a way of turning points into avoided spending, so the right comparison is what else those points could turn into.

The break-even rate

For a purchase of P dollars, a card that earns e points per dollar and a cash rate of c dollars per point, paying by card and redeeming for cash costs:

net points = P ÷ c − e × P

Pay-with-points at a rate r (in dollars per point), with no earning, costs P ÷ r points. It wins when P ÷ r is smaller than the net cost above, which happens when r is greater than the break-even rate:

break-even r = P ÷ (P ÷ c − e × P)

With P = $200, c = $0.01 and e = 2: break-even r = 200 ÷ (20,000 − 400) = 200 ÷ 19,600 = $0.010204, or about 1.02 cents.

So at this earning rate pay-with-points wins only if its rate exceeds roughly 1.02 cents. The general merchant rate of 0.80 cents does not clear it. The travel portal rate of 1.25 cents does: $200 ÷ $0.0125 = 16,000 points, which is 3,600 fewer than 19,600 and worth $36 at the cash rate.

Two points follow from the formula. A card with a higher earning rate raises the break-even, because the points you forgo by not paying with the card are worth more. And a program with a higher cash rate raises it too. The break-even is not fixed: it moves with your card and your redemption options, so the program's advertised rate cannot be judged without them. The points and miles value calculator can run the same arithmetic with your numbers.

Where pay-with-points tends to lose

At general merchants with a fixed rate below the cash rate. The 0.80-cent case above. The more the checkout rate lags the cash rate, the more you pay for the convenience.

When the portal price is higher. The portal's 1.25 cents (a shopping portal or travel portal run by the program) only helps if the price is competitive. Say the same hotel night is $200 on the hotel's own site and $250 in the portal. At the portal rate, $250 ÷ $0.0125 = 20,000 points. Against 19,600 net points in Option A at the $200 price, the portal loses by 400 points even though its rate is higher. A better rate on a worse price is not better value.

When you would earn a bonus by paying with the card. If the card earns a bonus rate for the category, the break-even climbs. At 5 points per dollar, the earn on $200 is 1,000 points, and the break-even becomes $200 ÷ (20,000 − 1,000) = $0.01053, or 1.05 cents.

When you are covering a purchase you would not have made. A button that makes spending feel free can bring forward a purchase you would have skipped. That is not a points question; it is a budget one.

When it blocks other protections. Purchase protection, extended warranty and return benefits are issuer or network benefits, and what they cover depends on how the purchase was paid for. Whether a points-funded payment qualifies is in the card's Guide to Benefits, not in federal law. Check it before using points on an expensive item.

Where pay-with-points can win

At a rate above the break-even. Travel through the portal in the example. A program can set a travel rate above its cash rate on purpose, because travel purchases keep points inside its ecosystem.

When it is the only way to use a small balance. If the cash redemption has a minimum and the checkout feature has none, pay-with-points might be the way to avoid leaving 3,000 points unused. A small balance in an account you will close is not worth losing.

When you want the speed. A credit or deposit can take a few days. Pay-with-points is immediate. If speed matters on a given purchase and the cost is small, that is a legitimate reason.

When you are about to lose the balance. An account you are closing, or one that is falling behind on payments, can forfeit points under many programs' terms. If the choice is between spending them at 0.80 cents and losing them, 0.80 cents wins. five ways earned rewards disappear: closure, delinquency and expiry explains where to find the language.

When the merchant offers a better deal for the payment method. Occasionally a program pairs a payment option with a promotion. Treat it like any rate: divide.

A second cart: a $320 flight in the portal

Run the same arithmetic on a larger purchase to see whether the answer holds. Say the program's portal sells a flight for $320, the same fare the airline sells directly, and the portal rate is 1.25 cents per point. The card earns 2 points per dollar when you pay with it, and the cash rate is 1.00 cent.

  • Pay by card, redeem for cash: $320 ÷ $0.01 = 32,000 points, less the 640 points earned (2 × $320), so 31,360 net points.
  • Pay with points in the portal: $320 ÷ $0.0125 = 25,600 points, assuming no earning on the points-funded part.
  • Difference: 31,360 − 25,600 = 5,760 points in favor of the portal, which is $57.60 at the cash rate.

The portal wins here for the same reason it won on the $200 cart: its rate of 1.25 cents is above the break-even of $320 ÷ 31,360 = 1.02 cents. The break-even barely moves with the size of the purchase when the earning rate and cash rate stay the same, so you do not need to redo the break-even for every cart, only whenever the earning rate, the cash rate or the price premium changes. What does change with size is the amount at stake: a 20 percent shortfall on a $20 purchase is $4, and on a $2,000 purchase it is $400.

Part points, part card

Many checkouts let you cover only some of the total with points. That makes a useful lever. Say the cart is $200 at the general merchant with the 0.80-cent rate, and you have a 10,000-point balance that will otherwise sit unused. Using all 10,000 points at 0.80 cents covers $80, and the remaining $120 goes on the card, earning 2 × $120 = 240 points.

Compare it with Option A: pay $200 on the card (400 points earned), then redeem 10,000 points for a $100 credit. Both routes use the 10,000 points, but the credit route is worth $100 against the checkout route's $80, a $20 difference, and it also earns 160 more points. The partial approach is therefore a way of limiting the loss, not of eliminating it. The only reason to choose it is a specific constraint: the points would otherwise be forfeited, or the cash redemption is unavailable to you today.

Returns, refunds and the second-order effects

The cart total is not the end of the transaction. If you return the item, the refund may go back to you as points, at the rate used at checkout, at a different rate, or as cash to the card. The terms differ. The safe habit is to look for the refund policy before you spend points on a purchase you might return, because a refund in points at a lower rate than you spent them at loses value in both directions.

A similar issue applies to earning. If you pay with the card and later return the item, the rewards you earned on it are generally reversed. what happens to your cash back when you return an online order follows what happens to cash back through a return, and the same logic applies to points.

Finally, taxes and shipping may or may not be covered by a points payment at checkout. If part of the total has to be paid by card anyway, the portion paid with points is smaller than the cart total, and the saving is smaller too.

A decision list

Work down these questions in order. Stop at the first one that settles it.

  1. Would I make this purchase anyway? If not, stop. Points are not free money.
  2. Is the checkout rate at least the break-even rate? Compute P ÷ (P ÷ cash rate − earning rate × P). If you do not know your program's rates, look them up on the redemption screen, not from memory.
  3. Is the price the same as I could pay elsewhere? If the points route has a higher price, include it: use the price you would pay in cash from the best source.
  4. Does my card earn a bonus on this purchase category? If so, the break-even is higher and pay-with-points is harder to justify.
  5. Is there a minimum or a remainder problem? If it strands points, count them as spent.
  6. Is there a protection or return issue? Check the Guide to Benefits and the refund terms for points-funded payments.
  7. Is my balance at risk of being lost? If an account closure, a delinquency or an inactivity rule threatens the points, use what you can at the best available rate before then.
  8. If everything else is a tie, prefer the option that is simplest to reverse. Cash redemption into a statement credit is hard to reverse; paying the card and leaving points alone is easy. For the credit's effect on the minimum payment, see does a cash-back statement credit count as my monthly payment?.

A longer view of the same trade

The checkout screen shows only one slice of a program's menu. Most programs also offer cash, gift cards, travel through a portal and, for some, transfers to partners. is pay with points at checkout a good deal or a trap? looks at the feature on its own terms, and cents per point: why the same 10,000 points can be worth very different amounts shows how to measure any redemption against the others.

If you earn cash back directly, none of this applies: the reward is already dollars and the choice is only how to receive it, which statement credit, deposit, check or gift card: how redemption changes value covers. If you earn points, the question is not whether pay-with-points is good or bad. The question is whether this redemption, at this rate, on this purchase, is better than the one next to it.

Key takeaways

  • Pay-with-points is a fixed conversion, and the useful comparison is against paying by card and redeeming points for cash, not against doing nothing.
  • The break-even rate is P ÷ (P ÷ cash rate − earning rate × P). With a 1-cent cash rate and 2 points per dollar it is about 1.02 cents, so a 0.80-cent checkout rate loses and a 1.25-cent portal rate wins.
  • In the illustration, paying with points at 0.80 cents cost 25,000 points against 19,600 net points for paying by card and redeeming for cash, a gap of 5,400 points or $54 at a cent each.
  • A higher rate on a higher price can lose: the same $200 stay at $250 in a portal costs 20,000 points, more than 19,600.
  • Check refund treatment and the card's benefits guide before using points on a purchase that might be returned or might need protection.
  • The one case where a poor rate is still right is a balance that would otherwise be forfeited, so redeem before closing an account or falling behind.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic