Blog
Premium card credits you will use versus credits you will chase
A checklist for sorting a premium card's credits into spending you already do and spending you would invent to claim them, with a worked tally against the fee.
Every premium card advertises a total: the face value of all its credits added together. The number is large and accurate, and it is almost never what the card is worth to you. A credit is worth only the part of it that you would have paid for anyway. The rest is either money you will forget to claim or a reason to spend that you did not have before.
This post is a checklist for sorting a card's credits into those two groups and adding up the first. It uses an invented card and invented credits, with round numbers, so the arithmetic is easy to check. Substitute your card's credits, which are listed on its profile and in the issuer's published terms and guide to benefits. The credit amounts, schedules and conditions change, so use the current terms and not what you remember.
What a credit is, and what it is not
A statement credit is a reduction in your balance that the issuer applies after you make a qualifying purchase. It is not cash and it cannot be withdrawn. You make a purchase, the issuer posts a credit against it and the cost of the purchase falls by the credit's size. If you make no purchase, you get nothing.
Premium credits come in a few shapes:
- A flexible credit, such as one that applies to any travel purchase.
- A merchant or category credit, which applies only at named merchants or in a named category, such as dining at participating restaurants.
- A subscription credit, tied to a particular service.
- A fee credit, which reimburses a specific charge such as a trusted-traveler application.
- A portal credit, which applies only if you book through the issuer's own travel site.
Each shape has its own limits. The common ones are a reset period (monthly, quarterly, annually or every few years), enrollment, a qualifying merchant list and a cap on each use. The card's own pages state them, and the Guide to Benefits entry explains the document that sets out the rules for protections and some benefits.
The central idea of this checklist is the usable value of a credit:
usable value = the smaller of the credit's face value and the spending you would have done anyway in that category and period
If a credit is $20 a month and you spend $12 a month on a qualifying service, the usable value is $12 a month, not $20. If a credit is $300 a year for travel and you would have spent $1,200 on travel anyway, the usable value is $300.
The checklist, credit by credit
Make a list of every credit on the card, then answer these questions for each. Write short answers.
- What is its face value per year? If it resets monthly, multiply by 12. If it pays once every few years, divide by the number of years.
- How does it reset? Monthly and quarterly credits are easier to lose than annual ones, because a missed period is gone.
- Did I spend in this category in the last 12 months? Look at statements. Do not rely on memory.
- How much did I spend, and how often? A credit that needs a steady monthly habit is different from one that needs a single purchase.
- Would I have made the purchase without the credit? If the answer is yes, the credit counts. If the answer is "I would not have, but it seems fine," it does not.
- What does it take to claim? Enrollment, an extra step at checkout, a portal, a code, a specific merchant or a minimum amount all add effort and risk of missing it.
- What is the catch on price? A portal rate or a merchant that charges more than the alternative can eat the credit.
- What happens if I forget? If the credit is lost with no way back, count a realistic probability that you will forget some of it.
If a credit fails question 3, 5 or 7, you are looking at a credit you will chase, not one you will use.
Three buckets
After answering, sort each credit into a bucket:
- Use anyway. You spent at least the credit's amount in the category in the last year, you would do it again and claiming is easy. Count it at its usable value.
- Might use. You spent something in the category, but less than the credit, or claiming takes effort. Count the amount you spent, and discount it further if the effort is real.
- Chase. You did not spend in the category, or you would only do so because the credit exists. Count it at zero.
The third bucket is the dangerous one, because the credit makes the spending look free. It is not. Here is what chasing costs.
What chasing costs: a worked example
Say the card has a $200 annual hotel credit that applies only to bookings made through the issuer's travel portal. You were not planning a hotel stay. A friend mentions that you could use the credit on a weekend away.
You find a room at $260 through the portal. The credit covers $200. You pay $60 out of pocket for a night you did not plan, plus the cost of getting there and eating while you are there.
- If the weekend is worth more to you than the $60 plus the other costs, the credit helped you take a trip you wanted.
- If it is not, you spent $60 and a weekend to receive a credit that the card advertised as $200 of value.
The same logic applies to a dining credit. A $50 quarterly credit at participating restaurants is free only if you were going to eat there. If you spend $65 to use it, the credit covers $50, you pay $15 and you have eaten a meal you could have made at home, which cost you maybe $8. In effect you paid $7 more than the meal was worth to you. That is a small loss. Multiply it across several credits and four quarters, and it adds up.
The test is not whether you got something. It is whether the total you spent in cash is less than what you would have spent without the credit. The price of the credit is the extra spending it caused.
A worked tally with an invented card
Meet Card P, an invented premium card with a $700 annual fee. Its credits, and what one cardholder, Jordan, found when going through the checklist:
| Credit | Face value per year | Jordan's spending in the category | Usable value | Bucket |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $300 annual travel credit, any travel purchase | $300 | $1,200 on flights and hotels | $300 | Use anyway |
| $50 quarterly dining credit, participating restaurants | $200 | 2 quarters with $50 or more spent | $100 | Might use |
| $20 monthly streaming credit | $240 | $12 a month on one qualifying service | $144 | Use anyway |
| Trusted-traveler fee credit, $120 every four years | $30 | Will renew within the cycle | $30 | Use anyway |
| $200 hotel credit, portal only | $200 | Prefers booking direct | $100 | Might use |
| $10 monthly ride-share credit | $120 | Rides in 5 months at $10 or more | $50 | Might use |
| Total | $1,090 | $724 |
The usable total is $300 + $100 + $144 + $30 + $100 + $50 = $724. That is 66 percent of the $1,090 face total ($724 ÷ $1,090 = 0.664), and it is only 3 percent more than the fee ($724 − $700 = $24). The numbers show a typical result: credits that look like they exceed the fee by $390 ($1,090 − $700) in fact cover it with almost nothing to spare.
Two of the lines are worth a note. The streaming credit's usable value is $144 and not the $240 on the page, because Jordan spends only $12 a month on a qualifying service. And the trusted-traveler credit is worth $30 a year only if Jordan really will apply or renew in the cycle. The fee for Global Entry is $120 for five years, according to U.S. Customs and Border Protection, and TSA PreCheck is $85 or less for five years, according to the TSA, so a card credit that reimburses the fee once is worth as much as the fee and no more. Credit amounts and cycles vary by card, and the Global Entry entry and Does my card pay for Global Entry? How the fee credit works cover how these credits are applied.
Adjust for the chance you will forget
The "Might use" lines were already discounted for how much Jordan would spend. A second discount is for forgetting. Monthly and quarterly credits that need action are the easiest to lose. If Jordan thinks there is a 20 percent chance of missing each of the dollars in the three "Might use" lines, the usable value falls from $250 to $200 on those lines ($100 + $100 + $50 = $250; × 0.8 = $200), and the total falls to $674, which is $26 below the fee.
The adjusted total is not a prediction. It shows that a result of a few dollars either way is within the noise of the assumptions. A card whose credits cover the fee by a wide margin is a different case from one that covers it by $24.
The same card, a different life
The tally depends on the person. Here is the same invented card used by Riley, who barely travels but lives a different routine. Riley found these usable amounts:
- Travel credit: $200 of travel spending in the year, so $200 of the $300 is usable.
- Dining credit: eats weekly at participating restaurants, so all four quarters at $50, which is $200.
- Streaming credit: pays for two qualifying services totaling $20 a month, so $240.
- Trusted-traveler credit: no plans to enroll, so $0.
- Hotel credit through the portal: no hotel stays, so $0.
- Ride-share credit: commutes by ride-share and uses $10 every month, so $120.
The usable total is $200 + $200 + $240 + $0 + $0 + $120 = $760, which is $60 above the $700 fee. Riley travels far less than Jordan and still comes out slightly ahead on credits, because Riley's routine happens to match the credits. That is the useful finding: the credits fit particular habits, and the sum depends on whether yours match, not on how much you travel or how well you plan.
It also shows why two people can look at the same card and reach opposite conclusions in good faith. The credits are not the card's value in the abstract, and the checklist exists so that you answer for your own year.
Keep a credit calendar
Credits are lost mostly through resets, so a calendar is the cheapest way to raise the usable value. Three details matter.
- Monthly credits. Set a recurring reminder for the first of each month, or better, move the payment for a qualifying service to the card so that the credit is used automatically. A $20 monthly credit used in nine months of the year returns $180 of $240, and the three missed months cost $60.
- Quarterly credits. Four periods a year, each lost if missed. A $50 quarterly credit used in three of four quarters returns $150 of $200.
- Annual credits. Find out whether the year runs from January or from the card's anniversary, which are different dates. A credit that resets on the anniversary can be used twice in a short stretch if you time it, or lost entirely if you do not know the date. The card's terms say which applies.
Some credits post slowly. A statement credit can take a billing cycle or more to appear, so check that it did, and keep the receipt in case you need to ask. If a credit does not appear after a qualifying purchase, call the number on the back of the card and ask. A complaint about how the issuer handled it can go to the CFPB.
What to do when the tally is close
When the usable total is near the fee, the credits are not the reason to hold the card. The benefits that decide are the others: earning rates on your spending, protections you would use, lounge access you would visit and status. how a premium card pays for its lounges, credits and perks explains why the credits are designed with conditions, and how to count statement credits against an annual fee honestly covers the method of counting. Then you have three choices:
- Keep it, if the rest of the benefits make the card worth it at your level of spending.
- Change it, by asking the issuer whether a version with a lower fee is available, which is sometimes possible without closing the account. I have an annual fee card I barely use. Keep, downgrade or close it? covers the options and what each does to your credit.
- Close it, before the fee posts, if the tally says the card does not pay. Closing a card can affect your credit score, so look at the effect first.
The annual fee break-even calculator turns the usable total and other benefits into a net figure, so you can see the result before the next renewal.
Habits that raise the usable total honestly
You can raise the usable value without inventing spending:
- Match the credit to existing bills. If you already pay for a streaming service, a gym or a ride-share, check whether the credit covers it, and switch the payment to the card.
- Put reset dates in a calendar. Monthly and quarterly credits are easier to use when a reminder arrives before the period ends.
- Use the issuer's app, which often shows which credits are unused.
- Ask before you chase. Before you buy something to use a credit, say out loud what you would do without it.
- Review twice a year. Once at the half-way point and once two months before the fee posts.
None of these require extra spending, which is the difference between using a credit and chasing it.
Key takeaways
- A credit's usable value is the smaller of its face value and the spending you would have done anyway. A $20 credit on a $12 purchase is worth $12.
- Sort credits into use anyway, might use and chase. Count the first at its usable value, the second at what you actually spend and the third at zero.
- Chasing a credit means spending money you would not have spent. A $200 portal credit on a $260 room you did not need costs $60 and a weekend.
- On the invented card the credits advertised $1,090, but the usable total was $724, only $24 above the $700 fee, and a modest allowance for forgetting put it below the fee.
- If the usable credits only just cover the fee, decide on the other benefits, and review the card before the fee posts.