Blog

Primary versus secondary rental car coverage on a credit card

What the two kinds of card rental coverage pay, in what order, how each interacts with your own auto policy and the rental company's waiver, with worked totals.

Both kinds of rental car coverage pay for damage to or theft of the rental vehicle. They differ in who pays first. With primary rental car coverage, the card pays first and your own auto insurance is not involved. With secondary coverage, the card pays only what your own insurance does not, so you file with your personal insurer first and the card picks up what is left, such as a deductible. Neither kind typically covers liability or injuries, and both usually require you to decline the rental company's own damage waiver and to pay for the rental with that card.

The card comparison tool can put two cards' listed benefits side by side. The rest of this post sets the options side by side with worked totals, so that you can see what a claim would cost under each, and lists the questions that decide which you are relying on. It does not state any card's coverage, because those terms differ by card, change, and are published only in each card's Guide to Benefits.

What the card's coverage is, and is not

Rental coverage on a credit card is a benefit offered by the card issuer or the card network. It is not federal law and not an insurance policy that you buy at the counter. Its terms, caps and exclusions are in the guide to benefits, and they can change. In general, this kind of benefit:

  • Covers collision damage and theft of the rental vehicle, and may include certain related costs. Which related costs, such as towing, an administrative fee or the rental company's charge for the time the car is out of service, depends on the card.
  • Does not cover liability. If you hurt someone or damage another person's property, card coverage generally does not respond. Liability comes from your personal auto policy, a supplemental liability product the rental company sells, or a separate policy.
  • Does not cover injuries to you or your passengers. Medical costs follow your health or travel insurance.
  • Does not usually cover your belongings in the car.
  • Requires that you decline the rental company's collision damage waiver and pay for the rental with the card. If you accept the waiver, the card coverage may not apply. If you pay with another card, it does not apply either.

These conditions are the common thread in published guides, but the details are the card's. Treat any summary, including this one, as a guide to what to look for.

What "primary" means

A primary benefit pays first. If you damage the rental car, you file the claim with the card's benefit administrator, not with your auto insurer. The card reimburses covered costs up to its limit, and your personal policy, with its deductible and its effect on your premiums, stays out of it.

That has three practical effects.

  1. No claim on your own record. A claim paid by the card does not appear as a claim on your auto policy, so it is not counted when the insurer sets your renewal rate.
  2. No personal deductible. The card's benefit is not reduced by a deductible in the way your policy's would be, though the card may apply its own limits.
  3. A simpler path. You deal with one party, the benefit administrator, with the paperwork described in I dented a rental car. How a card's rental coverage claim works.

Primary coverage tends to appear on a premium card and some travel and business cards, but many cards have none, and the type can differ between cards from the same issuer. Check the specific card, not the issuer.

What "secondary" means

A secondary benefit pays after other coverage. If you damage the rental car, you first make a claim with your personal auto insurer, if your policy covers rental cars. Once that insurer has paid what it will, the card may reimburse part of what remains, commonly the deductible and sometimes other costs your policy excludes.

The consequences differ from primary:

  1. You may have a claim on your record. The insurer may count it, and your premium could rise at renewal. That is a cost the card does not cover.
  2. You pay the deductible first, and then seek reimbursement from the card for it, if the card covers it.
  3. It only helps if you have personal coverage that extends to the rental. If you do not own a car, or your policy does not cover rentals, secondary coverage may have nothing to sit behind. Some cards will act as primary in that situation, and others will not. The guide says which.
  4. There are more parties and more paperwork. Two claims are open, and each has its own forms.

A secondary benefit is still worth having. It can pay a deductible that would otherwise come out of your pocket. But it is not the same product as primary.

The options side by side

Here is how the choices compare. "Waiver" means the rental company's collision damage or loss damage waiver, which transfers responsibility for damage to the rental company in exchange for a daily fee.

Rental company's waiver Card with primary coverage Card with secondary coverage Your personal auto policy alone
Who pays first for damage The rental company The card benefit Your personal insurer Your personal insurer
Cost to you A daily fee No added cost beyond the card's fee No added cost beyond the card's fee Your deductible, any premium increase
Your insurance involved Usually not No Yes Yes
Requires declining the waiver No, you buy it Typically yes Typically yes Yes
Covers liability Not by itself No No Depends on your policy
Main catch Cost per day Exclusions and limits Premium effect and deductible Rental use, business use, location limits

A worked comparison with invented numbers

The arithmetic below uses a made-up incident so you can see how the options compare. It is an illustration, not a prediction of what any insurer or card would pay.

Say a renter, Camila, has a one-week rental. While parked, another driver hits the car. The rental company bills her:

  • Repair: $2,400
  • Loss of use, the revenue the company says it lost while the car was in the shop: $300
  • Administrative fee: $150
  • Total billed: $2,400 + $300 + $150 = $2,850

Her personal auto policy has a $500 collision deductible. Her renewal premium rises by an illustrative $200 a year for three years after a claim.

Option A: the rental company's waiver. The waiver costs an illustrative $25 a day, so 7 × $25 = $175 for the week. Because she accepted it, the company does not bill her for the damage. Out of pocket: $175.

Option B: a card with primary coverage, covering all three charges. She declined the waiver and paid with the card. The card benefit reimburses $2,850, assuming the loss of use and administrative fee are covered. Out of pocket: $0, no insurance claim, no premium change. If the card does not cover loss of use, she pays $300; if it also excludes the fee, $450, so the total would be $2,400 reimbursed and $450 out of pocket.

Option C: a card with secondary coverage. She files with her insurer first. Suppose the insurer pays the repair minus the deductible: $2,400 − $500 = $1,900, and does not pay loss of use or the fee because her policy excludes them. The card reimburses the deductible, $500, and, if its terms allow, the $300 and $150, a total of $950. If the card covers all of it, her out of pocket for the incident is $0. But her premium rises $200 a year for three years, so her real cost is 3 × $200 = $600. If the card does not cover the $450 of other charges, her cost is $450 + $600 = $1,050.

Option D: no waiver and no card coverage. She pays everything: $2,850.

Option Out of pocket if all charges are covered Out of pocket if loss of use and the fee are excluded
A. Waiver $175 $175
B. Primary card $0 $450
C. Secondary card, with a premium rise $600 $1,050
D. No coverage $2,850 $2,850

The numbers are invented, but the pattern is general. Primary coverage comes out ahead because it keeps your insurer out of it. Secondary coverage can leave you with a premium cost that does not appear on the claim. The waiver is a certain cost every rental whether or not anything happens, and none of the others is. And the details of what counts as "covered" can swing the totals by hundreds of dollars, which is why you read them before you rent.

Exclusions to look for

Whatever the type, read the exclusions in the card's guide to benefits. The ones that most often matter are:

  • Vehicle types. Some cards exclude exotic or expensive cars, certain trucks and large vans, motorcycles and antique vehicles.
  • Rental length. Coverage may stop after a number of consecutive days, so a long rental can be partly outside it.
  • Country or region. Some countries are excluded, and rules for rentals abroad can differ from those at home.
  • Who is driving. Coverage usually extends only to drivers listed on the rental agreement, not to anyone who borrows the car.
  • How the car was used. Off-road driving, racing or driving under the influence are typical exclusions.
  • Which costs are covered. Loss of use, administrative fees, towing and diminished value are treated differently from card to card.
  • Business use. A personal auto policy may exclude a rental used for business, and a card's benefit may have its own rule.

If your rental falls into any of these, you may not be covered, and the rental company's waiver or a separate policy may be the only protection.

What to ask your own auto insurer

Secondary coverage depends on your personal policy, so its terms matter even if you plan to rely mostly on the card. A ten-minute call or a look at the policy documents settles most of it. Ask these things.

  • Does my collision and comprehensive coverage extend to a rental car? Many personal policies do for ordinary personal use, but some limit it by country, by length of rental or by type of vehicle.
  • What is my deductible for a rental? It is often the same as for your own car, and it is the amount a secondary card benefit may reimburse.
  • Does the policy pay loss of use, administrative fees and towing charged by the rental company? Some do not, and those are the charges that most often cause surprise bills.
  • Is business use covered? Renting a car for work can be treated differently from renting for a vacation.
  • How would a claim affect my premium? An insurer cannot predict it, but it can tell you how its claims record works.
  • What liability limits do I have? Liability is not covered by any card benefit, so the limits on your policy are what protects you if you injure someone or damage property.

If you do not own a car, you may have no personal policy to ask. In that case look at whether the card benefit steps up to primary when there is no other coverage, and consider a non-owner auto policy or the rental company's liability product. A licensed insurance agent can explain the options for your state.

What to say at the rental counter

The counter is where many people change their minds under pressure. Having your answer in advance helps. Rental agents are often paid for selling the waiver, and the way they describe your risk may be more alarming than your actual exposure. You do not have to argue, only to be clear.

  1. Ask to see the daily cost of the waiver and of any supplemental liability. Know the price before you decide.
  2. If you are relying on your card, decline the waiver in full when asked. Do not accept a partial or "just the deductible" waiver unless your card's guide says it is allowed, since the benefit may be void if you accept any part of it.
  3. Pay for the rental with the card that carries the coverage, and make sure the whole rental is charged to it. The rental company will place a hold, so confirm there is room on the card.
  4. Walk around the car before leaving. Photograph or video every panel, the wheels, the roof, the windshield and the interior, and note the odometer and fuel level. Make sure the agent records existing damage on the paperwork. A date-stamped video is your best evidence if there is a dispute later.
  5. Check who is listed as a driver, and add anyone else who will drive.
  6. Keep the rental agreement and the closing receipt, since you may need them for a claim.

If you cannot decide on the spot, it is fine to take a minute, or to step to the side. A decision made calmly and in writing is better than one made with a queue behind you.

Questions to settle before you rent

Work through these in order before the counter.

  1. Which card will I pay with, and does it have rental coverage? Find the type, primary or secondary, in the guide.
  2. Does my personal auto policy cover rentals, and where? Ask the insurer or read the policy. Find the deductible and whether it covers loss of use.
  3. Would a claim raise my premium? Ask what happens at renewal after a claim.
  4. Is this rental inside the card's limits? Vehicle type, days, country.
  5. Will I decline the waiver in full? Many benefits void if you accept part of it.
  6. Do I need liability coverage? If neither your policy nor the card provides it, ask the rental company about supplemental liability or look at a separate policy.
  7. Who else will drive? Add them to the agreement if they are covered.
  8. Is the card a joint account with another person, or in my name? The benefit generally applies to the cardholder named on the account.
  9. What will the rental company place on my card? A hold can tie up part of the limit. See authorization hold for how holds work, and be sure the card has enough room.

A short note listing the card, the coverage type and the exclusions that matter for this trip takes five minutes and is worth carrying.

The choice in plain terms

There is no single right answer, and the choice depends on what you value.

  • If you want to keep your insurer out of it, primary coverage on a card you will pay with is the cleanest option, and you decline the waiver.
  • If you have a low deductible and do not mind a claim on your record, secondary coverage may be enough.
  • If you prefer certainty and are willing to pay for it, the rental company's waiver removes the question for a daily fee.
  • If you have neither card coverage nor an insurer that covers rentals, the waiver or a separate policy is the way to avoid a large bill.

For a broader look at when a purchased policy is a better fit than card benefits, see should you buy a travel insurance policy or rely on your card?. And if a claim is denied, why card travel insurance claims get denied and how to avoid it explains common reasons.

Key takeaways

  • Primary coverage pays first and keeps your own insurer out of it. Secondary pays only after your policy, usually the deductible and some extras.
  • Both usually cover collision damage and theft of the rental, not liability or injuries, and require you to decline the rental company's waiver and pay with that card.
  • In the worked example, the primary card left the renter with $0 to $450 out of pocket, a secondary card $600 to $1,050 counting a premium rise, and no coverage $2,850.
  • Exclusions on vehicle type, rental length, country, drivers and covered costs often decide whether coverage applies, so read the card's guide to benefits.
  • Confirm your card's coverage type, your own policy's rental terms and your liability cover before you reach the counter.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic