Blog

Red flags in credit card offers marketed to people with bad credit

A checklist of warning signs in offers aimed at weak credit, from fees that eat the line to missing bureau reporting and pressure to act now, with what to do.

Weak credit makes people targets. A person who has been declined by mainstream issuers is more willing to accept terms that a person with good credit would refuse, and some companies build their whole offer around that willingness. Many cards for fair or damaged credit are legitimate products with real costs and real use. Others are priced so that the fees consume the credit line, do not report to the credit bureaus or are not what they claim to be. The two kinds can look alike in an advertisement. They look different in the fine print and in how the company behaves before you have signed.

This checklist is a way to tell them apart. It is organized by the stage at which each warning sign appears: before you apply, in the offer, in the fine print and after you have paid something. The figures are invented examples. An actual card's terms are in its disclosure box and agreement, and for a legitimate lender the whole set can be found before you pay anything.

How to use the list

Count the warning signs, but weigh them. A few are serious on their own, such as a request to pay a fee before you see any terms, a refusal to say whether the account reports to the credit bureaus or a demand for your bank login by text. Others are cautions that mean "read more carefully." A single caution does not make a card bad. Several together, or any serious one, is a reason to walk away.

Before you start, gather a pen and either the offer or its web page. Save the page, or take screenshots, because offers change. And if the contact reached you by phone, text or email that you did not request, do not use any link or number in it. Find the company yourself through an independent search and compare.

Before you apply: where the offer came from

Red flag 1: you did not ask for it, and it came by call, text or email with pressure

A mailed prescreened offer from a recognizable issuer is a normal thing. A call, text or email out of the blue that says you are "pre-approved" and must "act today" is different. Legitimate offers do not disappear in an hour. A message that creates urgency is trying to stop you reading the terms.

What to do. Do not click links or call numbers in the message. Look up the company's website yourself and check whether the offer exists there. If you think the message is a scam, you can report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. If you already clicked and entered information, call the number on the back of any real card you hold and consider placing a credit freeze, which is free.

Red flag 2: it asks for sensitive details before an application

Legitimate applications ask for your name, address, income and Social Security number, usually on the issuer's own secure site, as part of a clear application. A message that asks for your online banking password, a copy of your card or a one-time code before any application is a phishing attempt, whatever it promises.

What to do. Never share a one-time code, a bank login or a full card number with someone who contacted you. Check that the site address is the issuer's own, and enter details only after you have found it yourself.

Red flag 3: "guaranteed approval" paired with a fee to apply

Secured cards are easier to qualify for, and some issuers advertise high approval odds. But "guaranteed," combined with a charge to see the offer, to apply, or to "process" your application, is a pattern to avoid. Say the offer says you will be approved if you pay a $79 "membership" fee first. You have paid before you know the credit line, the APR or whether the account will report.

What to do. Ask what the fee buys and where it appears in the agreement. If the answer is vague or you cannot see the terms first, stop. Real card fees appear in the disclosure box, the schumer box, and are charged to the account after it opens.

In the offer: what is on the page

Red flag 4: no disclosure box, no agreement, no APR

A credit card offer in the United States must state its main terms in a standard table, the Schumer box, in an application or solicitation. If you cannot find a table that lists the APR, the fees, the grace period and how interest is computed, you are not being given what you need. Ask for the cardholder agreement. A lender that will not show it before you apply is telling you something.

What to do. Do not proceed without the table. If you only have an ad, find the issuer's own site.

Red flag 5: the fees take a large share of the credit line

This one deserves arithmetic. Federal rules limit the total fees charged in the first year after an account is opened to 25 percent of the credit limit, and late, over-limit and returned-payment fees are excluded from that cap. On a $300 limit, the cap is $75. On a $400 limit, it is $100.

Say a card offers a $400 limit. The offer shows a $95 annual fee, a $75 program fee and a $12 monthly servicing fee. In the first year the non-penalty fees are $95 + $75 + (12 × $12) = $314. The 25 percent cap on a $400 limit is $100, so $314 is more than three times what the rule appears to allow. Even before the rule, the picture is poor: $170 of fees posted right at the start would leave only $230 of the $400 available to spend, which is 42.5 percent of the line consumed by fees, and then $12 a month more.

What to do. Add the first-year fees and divide by the limit. If the result is over 25 percent, the offer may be breaking the rule, or it may be structured differently from how it reads, and either way you should ask the issuer to explain it in writing. If the answer is unsatisfactory, you can file a complaint with the CFPB. A card with a legitimate fee structure will usually fit within the cap with room to spare.

Red flag 6: it will not say whether it reports to the credit bureaus

A card that you are told "builds credit" but which does not report to the credit bureaus builds nothing. Ask which of the three, Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, the issuer reports to, and whether the report includes the credit limit and payment history. A refusal or a dodge is a serious warning. A card that reports to one bureau only is not necessarily a scam, but it builds a thinner record, and a lender that pulls a different bureau sees nothing.

What to do. Ask in writing, save the answer, and check your free reports from AnnualCreditReport.com after two or three months to confirm the account appears.

Red flag 7: it is not a credit card, or it works only in a catalog

Some products marketed to people with bad credit look like cards but work only to buy from the company's own catalog or website, usually at marked-up prices, or are prepaid or debit products described in credit-card language. A catalog-only card may report to bureaus and may not. Its price is paid in the markup.

What to do. Ask where the card can be used, and whether it has a network logo that works wherever that network is accepted. Compare the prices in the catalog with the same item elsewhere. If you want a card that builds credit, a secured credit card from a recognizable issuer, with its deposit refundable, is often a more direct route, and a checklist for choosing a secured card without paying for the wrong things explains what to check.

Red flag 8: it promises to repair or erase your credit

An offer for a card that says it will "fix" your credit or "remove negative items" is describing a different service. Negative items such as late payments, collections and charge-offs can generally be reported for seven years, and only an item that is wrong or can be verified as incorrect can be disputed away. A card does not erase history.

What to do. Ignore the claim. If you have errors in your reports, you can dispute them directly with the bureaus, for free, and the bureau must reinvestigate within 30 days of receiving the dispute.

In the fine print: what the agreement says

Red flag 9: junk fees and fees for things that should be free

Read the schedule for fees that look unusual: a fee to increase your limit, a fee to make a payment by phone, a monthly fee for "account maintenance" that is not an annual fee in disguise, a fee for the card to be mailed. Each might be legal. Several together on a small line add up.

Penalty fees have limits. A late fee cannot exceed the dollar amount associated with the violation, and the late-payment safe harbor figures are about $30 for a first late payment and about $41 for a repeat within six billing cycles, according to law-firm summaries, with the usual caveat that the exact amounts are inflation-adjusted and sources differ. Issuers can charge less. No penalty fee may be charged for a declined transaction, for inactivity or for closing the account. An agreement that lists one of those is a red flag.

What to do. List every fee with its dollar amount, then add the ones that apply in the first year. The credit card rates and fees table shows ordinary ranges for comparison.

Red flag 10: a very high APR and a short grace period, or none

A card for weak credit can carry a higher APR than a card for strong credit, and that is normal pricing for risk. What is not normal is a rate so high that a single month's balance becomes unmanageable, combined with no grace period, so interest starts on day one. Say a card charges an illustrative 35% on a $300 balance: $300 × 0.35 ÷ 12 = $8.75 a month. That is not ruinous for one month but climbs quickly if you carry it, and it is a sign that the product is priced for people who will carry balances.

What to do. Plan to pay in full. If you cannot, work out the monthly interest at the stated rate and decide whether you can afford the card at that price. The a checklist for judging a subprime or credit-builder card issuer post covers what a reasonable issuer looks like.

Red flag 11: the deposit is not refundable, or its return is vague

If the product requires a deposit, it should say how and when the deposit is returned, and under what conditions. A deposit that is described as a "fee," or that can be kept after you close the account in good standing, is a fee in disguise.

What to do. Look for the specific sentence about the return, with a time frame. If it is not there, ask.

After you have paid something

Red flag 12: you cannot reach anyone, or the company will not give you the account terms

After you have paid, a legitimate issuer provides an account, a login, a statement and a way to contact it. If you have paid and received no card, no terms and no answer, you may have been scammed.

What to do. Contact the company with a written request for the agreement and for a refund of any fee. If it is a card you hold on a real account, call the number on the back of the card. If you paid by credit card, you can dispute the charge with that card's issuer, and a billing-error dispute must reach the issuer in writing within 60 days after the statement showing the error was sent. File a complaint with the CFPB at consumerfinance.gov, report the company to the FTC, and consider contacting your state attorney general. If you gave out a Social Security number or other personal data, consider a fraud alert or a credit freeze, which is free to place and lift.

What a legitimate offer looks like

For contrast, a sound card for fair or damaged credit usually has these features: the terms are visible before you apply, the fees are modest and listed in the disclosure box, the first-year fees fit well within the 25 percent cap, the issuer states which bureaus it reports to, a secured product explains the deposit and its return, and the issuer is reachable through a number on its own site and a physical address. It may still be expensive relative to a card for strong credit, and that is the price of the risk. What it does not do is hide the price.

Key takeaways

  • A request for a fee before you see the terms, or for a bank login or code by text, is a serious red flag. Stop and find the issuer yourself.
  • Add the first-year fees and divide by the credit limit. Federal rules cap first-year fees at 25 percent of the limit, with late, over-limit and returned-payment fees excluded. In the example, $314 on a $400 limit was far over.
  • Ask which bureaus the card reports to, and confirm on your free reports after a few months.
  • No product erases history. Negative items can generally be reported for seven years, and errors can be disputed for free.
  • Federal rules bar penalty fees for declined transactions, inactivity or closure, so an agreement that lists one is a warning.
  • If you paid and got nothing, dispute the charge in writing, call the number on the back of the card you used and file complaints with the CFPB and FTC.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic