Blog

What triggers a returned payment fee and how to avoid one

Bounced bank payments, closed accounts and wrong routing numbers can reverse a card payment and bring a fee. Seven mistakes, with a timeline and a fix for each.

Imagine that Sam pays a card bill online on the 14th, a day before it is due, sees a confirmation and moves on. On the 17th a notice arrives: the payment was returned, a fee was charged, and the account is now past due. Sam did everything in the right order and still ended up late. What happened is that the bank behind the payment refused it after the card issuer had already accepted it, and a payment that is reversed is treated as if it had never been made.

A returned payment is one of the more avoidable card fees, and it is also one of the most confusing, because the person who pays it often did not know anything was wrong. This post explains the mechanism, lists seven mistakes that cause returned payments, follows one hypothetical returned payment through its costs, and ends with a checklist and a plan for what to do if one happens to you. It uses invented numbers, labeled as illustrations.

What a returned payment is

When you pay a card by electronic transfer from a bank account, the transfer does not clear instantly even if the issuer shows your payment right away. Issuers commonly post the payment to your account at once, which frees up your available credit, and then wait for the bank to confirm that the money really moved. If the bank refuses, because the account lacks funds, the account number is wrong, the account is closed, or for another reason, the transfer comes back to the issuer as a return, usually within a few business days. The issuer then reverses the payment, adds a returned-payment fee, and may add a late fee if the due date has passed.

Checks work the same way in slower motion. A paper check or a check sent through an online bill-pay service is credited, deposited and, if the bank refuses it, returned. A returned check carries the same consequences as a returned electronic payment.

A payment rejected at the moment you submit it is a different and less harmful case. If you type a routing number that fails the format check, the page usually refuses it right away. Nothing reaches the issuer, nothing is reversed and no fee follows. But nothing counts as a payment either, and the due date keeps getting closer. The costly failures are the ones the system accepts at first and refuses later.

What the fee is, and what limits it

A returned payment fee is a penalty fee, so the federal rules in Regulation Z apply. A penalty fee may not exceed the dollar amount associated with the violation, which for a returned payment is generally tied to the minimum payment that was due. An issuer may not charge more than one penalty fee for a single event or transaction. And it may not charge a penalty fee for a declined transaction, for inactivity or for closing the account.

The "single event" rule is the one that matters most in practice. A payment that is both late and returned can look like two problems, a late payment and a returned one, but a single payment that fails is generally one event. Whether a particular sequence counts as one event or two depends on the facts and on the agreement, so if you are charged both a late fee and a returned-payment fee over the same payment, ask the issuer to explain, in writing if the answer is vague. The fee amount is in your agreement's fee table. late fee myths about double charges, resets and grace days covers the double-charge question in more depth.

Federal rules do not set a single dollar figure for the fee. The reported safe-harbor levels for late fees, roughly $30 for a first violation and about $41 for a repeat within six billing cycles, are general reference points, and sources differ on exact figures, so your agreement's number is the one to rely on.

Seven mistakes that cause returned payments

1. Paying from an account without enough money

This is the most common cause, and it is rarely a case of having no money at all. It is a case of timing. A rent check clears before the card payment arrives. A pending purchase has not posted yet but will. Two autopays pull from the same account on the same day. A paycheck is a day later than you expected. The balance you saw in the app was not the balance the bank sees when the transfer arrives.

Prevention: keep a cushion in the account that pays your cards, and count every bill that draws from it. how to set up your cards so a missed payment is nearly impossible shows how to size that cushion.

2. Typing a wrong account or routing number

A single swapped digit can send a payment to the wrong place or to nowhere. Many entry pages check the routing number's format and catch some typos, but a wrong account number at the right bank can pass the format check and fail later. The risk is highest for one-time payments, where you type the numbers fresh each time.

Prevention: copy the numbers from a voided check or from your bank's own account page, not from memory, and save the account in the issuer's payment screen so you do not retype it. After the first payment from any newly saved account, check that it posted and stayed posted.

3. Using a closed or changed account

Accounts that used to work can stop working without any action on your part. You may have closed an account and forgotten the card payment was tied to it. A bank may have merged with another and changed routing numbers. A fraud replacement may have given you a new account number. A saved payment source in an issuer's system does not update itself.

Prevention: whenever you change, close or are told to change a bank account, list everything that pulls from it and update each one, cards included.

4. Paying on the last day

A payment made on the due date leaves no room for error. If it returns two days later, you are already past due and cannot fix it in time. A payment made five days early that returns still leaves days to try again before the due date.

Prevention: pay several days ahead, especially from a new account or after an account change. The extra days cost nothing when you pay the statement balance, since the interest-free grace period runs to the due date regardless of when in that window you pay.

5. Blocking the payment on the bank side

Some banks let you set filters on electronic withdrawals, such as a debit block that refuses any pull from a company you have not approved. These are useful security tools, but they can reject a card payment that you started yourself if the issuer's name is not on the approved list. The same happens if you have asked your bank to stop payments to a company and forget the instruction.

Prevention: if you use a debit block or an approved-payee list, add each card issuer to it, and review it when you add a card.

6. Writing a bad check

A paper check can fail for reasons other than a low balance. The written and numeric amounts disagree, the signature is missing, the check is dated too far in the future or past, or the account number on the face is wrong. Checks sent by mail also run late, and a returned check can arrive after the due date.

Prevention: pay electronically when you can. If you mail a check, send it with several extra days and include the account number as the issuer asks.

7. Stopping a payment you did not mean to stop

If you cancel an electronic payment that has not yet been withdrawn, you may free the money, but if the payment was meant to cover a due date and you do not replace it, the account goes late. People sometimes cancel an autopay instruction to change its amount and forget to restore it.

Prevention: after any change to an automatic payment, confirm in the account that the new instruction is active and shows the date and amount you want.

One returned payment, followed through

Here is a hypothetical that shows how the pieces combine. All numbers are invented.

  • The statement balance is $1,500.00. The minimum payment is $35.00. The payment due date is the 15th.
  • On the 14th, the cardholder pays the full $1,500.00 electronically from a checking account holding only $900.00. The issuer posts the payment and shows a zero balance.
  • On the 17th the bank returns the payment. The issuer reverses it. The balance returns to $1,500.00, the minimum payment is now past due by two days, and the interest-free period for that balance is at risk.
  • The issuer charges a returned-payment fee. Suppose the agreement says up to $30.00. It is below the $35.00 minimum, so the cap does not bind.

The cost has several pieces:

Item Amount Note
Returned-payment fee $30.00 Capped at the minimum payment due
Late fee on the same payment $0 if treated as the same event Ask the issuer how it applied the rule
Interest on the $1,500 balance if it stays unpaid for a full cycle up to about $30.00 At an illustrative 24 percent APR, about 2 percent a month: $1,500 x 0.02
Extra interest on any new purchases varies Depends on the agreement
Total visible cost up to about $60.00 Before any credit-score effect

The invisible costs matter more. A payment that is 30 or more days past due is generally reported to the credit bureaus as late, and a late payment can stay on a report for seven years. A payment more than 60 days late can trigger a Penalty APR on existing balances, after notice. In this example the cardholder has about four weeks from the 17th to pay at least the minimum before reaching the 30-day mark, plenty of time if they notice and act.

How much interest the reversal costs depends on speed and on the agreement. If the cardholder repays the full $1,500.00 on the 20th, three days after the return, daily interest at the illustrative 24 percent is $1,500 x 0.24 / 365 = $0.9863 a day, or about $2.96 over three days. That is the low end. If the agreement treats the missed payment as a lost grace period and charges interest on the balance from the start of the cycle, the cost can approach the full-cycle figure in the table. The agreement's grace-period wording decides which applies, which is another reason to read it. Either way, speed is the cheapest protection you have. The danger is the cardholder who does not notice, because the returned-payment notice went to an email they do not read. The late payment cost calculator helps put numbers on a miss.

What to do after a payment is returned

  1. Pay again right away, from an account you have confirmed. Use a different method if you can, a different account or a debit card payment on the issuer's site. Do not retry the same failed method without finding the reason.
  2. Find the cause. Look at the bank's record of the attempted transfer and the issuer's note. If the bank says insufficient funds, fix the balance. If it says closed or invalid account, correct the account details.
  3. Call the number on the back of your card. Explain what happened, confirm the payment arrived, and ask whether the fee can be reversed as a courtesy. Note the date, the representative's name and what was said. how to ask your card issuer to reverse a late fee has the approach, and I paid on time but was charged a late fee. What went wrong? helps if the payment appears to have been on time.
  4. Check your bank for its own fee. A returned payment can trigger an insufficient-funds fee from your bank as well, and that is separate from the issuer's.
  5. Review the next statement. Confirm that the reversal is posted, the fee is what the agreement says, and no extra interest or second penalty fee appears.
  6. Dispute errors in writing. If the bank sent the money and the issuer failed to credit it, you have a billing question, and the CFPB complaint process is available if the issuer will not fix it.

A pre-payment checklist

  • Is the account I am paying from open, in my name and funded above the amount, counting every other bill that will draw from it this week?
  • Did I copy the routing and account numbers from my bank or a voided check?
  • Is the payment scheduled several days before the due date?
  • Does my bank's debit block or approved-payee list allow this issuer?
  • After the payment, did I confirm it posted and, a few days later, that it was not reversed?
  • Does the issuer have my current email and phone, so a returned-payment notice reaches me?

Key takeaways

  • A returned payment is a payment the issuer accepted and your bank later refused, and the issuer treats it as if it was never made.
  • Seven mistakes cause most of them: low funds, wrong numbers, a closed or changed account, last-day payments, bank-side blocks, bad checks and cancelled payments.
  • Federal rules cap the fee at the dollar amount tied to the violation, allow one penalty fee per event, and bar penalty fees for declined transactions.
  • In the example, a returned $1,500 payment cost up to about $60 in fee and interest, and the larger risk was a 30-day late mark on a credit report if nobody noticed.
  • Pay early, keep a cushion, check that every payment posted and stayed posted, and call the number on the back of your card to ask for a reversal.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic