Blog

Starting credit with a secured card, builder loan or authorized user

Three routes to a first reported account compared on cost, risk, what gets reported and who controls it, with a worked example and a short decision list.

Someone with no credit history needs one thing: an account that appears on the credit reports and shows a record of on-time payments. There are three common ways to get it. You can open a secured card and put down a deposit. You can take a credit-builder loan, where the money you borrow is held back until you have paid it off. Or you can be added as an authorized user on someone else's card. Each produces a reported account, but they differ in what they cost, what the scoring models see, what can go wrong and who is in charge of the account while it lives.

This is a comparison, not a recommendation. Which route suits a person depends on how much cash they can set aside, whether they have a relative with good credit who is willing to help, and how much risk they can tolerate from someone else's habits. The first-year plan that follows any of the three is in how to build credit from scratch, month by month for a year.

What each route is

A secured card

A secured credit card is a regular credit card backed by a security deposit that you give the issuer. The deposit typically sets your credit limit, so a $200 deposit typically produces a $200 line. Use is reported to the bureaus the way an ordinary card's is, and some issuers review the account after a period of on-time payments and may move you to an unsecured card and refund the deposit, a step called graduation. Terms vary by issuer: one issuer cited in a Bankrate guide has a $200 minimum deposit, but that is one example, not a rule. The deposit is refundable under the issuer's terms, typically when the account is closed in good standing or converted.

A secured card is a revolving account: you can borrow and repay up to the limit again and again, and the balance you carry from month to month determines interest.

A credit-builder loan

A credit-builder loan works in the opposite order from an ordinary loan. The lender does not hand you the money at the start. It places the loan amount in a locked account, such as a savings account or certificate of deposit, and you make monthly payments. When you have paid the loan (or, in some designs, along the way), the funds are released to you. The lender reports your payments to the bureaus as an installment loan, an account with a fixed number of payments and a fixed amount. Designs vary, and so do fees and the interest rate, so the loan's terms matter more than its name.

An authorized user

An authorized user is a person added to someone else's existing card. The primary cardholder stays legally responsible for the balance. The authorized user can usually make purchases, but is not liable for the debt. If the issuer reports the account for authorized users, it can appear on the user's report as a tradeline and be included when the scores are calculated. Whether it appears, and how much weight the models give it, depends on the issuer's reporting and the scoring model. FICO and VantageScore typically include authorized-user tradelines if the issuer reports them, though FICO 8 is generally described as lessening the effect, and there is no official statement on exact weight, so no number should be assumed.

The comparison

Secured card Credit-builder loan Authorized user
Upfront cost A refundable deposit, often a few hundred dollars Often little or nothing up front; payments start immediately Usually none
Ongoing cost Possible annual fee; interest only if you carry a balance Interest and fees built into the payments Usually none, though some cards charge an authorized-user fee
Type of account Revolving Installment Whoever's account it is, usually revolving
What gets reported Balance, limit, payment history Payments and balance on the loan The primary's account history, if the issuer reports it
Who controls it You You The primary cardholder
Main risk Overspending, a late payment, fees Paying interest on money you cannot use; missing payments Someone else's late payments or high balance showing on your file
Needs approval? Yes, though usually not based on score Yes, usually lenient The primary must agree and the issuer must accept
How it ends Deposit returned if you close in good standing or graduate Funds released at the end Either side can generally end it by asking the issuer
Builds your own record? Yes Yes Only as much as the account is reported and weighted

A worked cost comparison

Here is an illustration with invented round numbers. None of them is a rate or fee from any lender.

Secured card. Say the deposit is $200, with a $0 annual fee in one version and a $39 annual fee in another. The deposit comes back in either case if you close the account in good standing. The real costs are the fee, if any, and what the $200 would have earned elsewhere. At an illustrative 4 percent savings rate, $200 earns $8 a year, so the second version costs $39 + $8 = $47 in a year, and the first costs about $8 in forgone interest. If you pay the statement balance in full every month, you pay no interest on the card.

Credit-builder loan. Say the loan is $600, repaid in twelve monthly payments of $52. The total you pay is 12 × $52 = $624, and the $600 is released to you at the end. Your net cost is $624 − $600 = $24. During the year you cannot use the money, and if the lender holds the funds without paying interest, you are lending to it for free. A missed payment would be reported as a late installment payment.

Authorized user. Say a parent adds you to a card that has a $5,000 limit and a $500 balance. The reported utilization on the account is 500 ÷ 5,000 = 10 percent, a figure that, if the issuer reports it for you, will be part of your file. If the parent runs the balance up to $4,000, the same account reads 80 percent, whether or not you spent anything. The authorized-user route can cost nothing and still carry the most exposure, since the quality of your tradeline depends on a person whose habits you do not control. The reverse is also true: a decade-old account in good standing can add a long history to a young file.

In the tally, the secured card has the highest cash outlay up front but it is returned, the builder loan has a small known net cost, and the authorized-user route has the lowest cash cost but the least control.

What the scoring models see

The general FICO formula weights payment history at about 35 percent, amounts owed (including credit utilization) at about 30 percent, length of history at about 15 percent, new credit at about 10 percent and credit mix at about 10 percent. VantageScore 4.0 uses different weights. Each route touches those factors differently.

  • Secured card: adds payment history, a revolving limit and utilization, and starts the clock on length of history.
  • Credit-builder loan: adds payment history and an installment account to a file that may have only revolving ones, which can help the mix, though mix is a smaller factor.
  • Authorized user: can add an older account's age and limit to your file at once, which is the one way to borrow length of history, with the caveat that scoring models may discount it.

None of this means one route produces a higher score than another. The effects are small, the models differ and the outcome depends on what else is in the file.

Who controls the account, and what that means

Control is the difference people overlook.

With a secured card or a builder loan you control the account, which means you also control every mistake. A late payment is yours, and so are the fees. With an authorized-user arrangement the person in charge is the primary cardholder. If that person misses a payment, the account may show the late payment on your report if it is reported to you. If the two of you fall out, the primary can generally remove you, and the history may vanish from your report with the removal. This is why people who use the route often write down the expectations first: who pays, what the balance will be kept below, and what happens if the relationship changes. authorized user on a card: three households, three score outcomes walks through how this plays out, and Should I add someone as an authorized user? Both sides of the choice covers the primary's side.

A further caution: some companies sell "authorized user tradelines," charging a stranger's fee to add you to an account they hold. Nothing about the free routes requires this, and lenders and scoring companies have reason to be wary of it. Paying to be added to a stranger's card is not the same thing as a relative adding you.

Rules that touch the choice

Age. Under 21, federal rules for card applicants require either an independent ability to make the minimum payments or a cosigner, guarantor or joint applicant aged 21 or older who can. A student with no income therefore may not be able to open a card alone. A secured card still needs an application and, for those under 21, the same showing of ability to pay or a cosigner, so the authorized-user route can be the simplest way in for a teen.

Immigration status and identification. Policies on ITIN and passport applications vary by issuer and change, and secured cards are generally the easiest route for new arrivals.

Scams. Be wary of any "credit builder" product that asks for a fee before delivering anything, or that promises a score. Compare any such offer with the free routes above before paying anyone.

Three hypothetical people, three different fits

These are illustrations, not typical cases.

Dana has steady part-time income, $300 saved and no one in the family with credit to share. A secured card fits: Dana controls the account, the deposit is hers and comes back, and a $20 monthly charge paid in full builds a record. The danger is spending near the limit, since a $300 limit reaches 50 percent utilization at only $150.

Luis has no savings to spare but a parent with a ten-year-old card, a low balance and a habit of paying in full. Being added as an authorized user brings that history into his file at no cost, if the issuer reports authorized users. The hazard is dependence: if the parent's balance rises or a payment slips, the account hurts both of them, and Luis has no say. He might add a secured card later, when he can, so that part of his file is his own.

Priya is disciplined with fixed bills but tends to overspend on a card with a visible limit. A credit-builder loan suits her because the payment is fixed and the lender holds the money. The cost is the net $24 in the earlier example, and the benefit is a lump sum at the end that doubles as savings. The risk is that an installment account alone does not give her any revolving history, so she may want a card eventually.

None of the three is "right" in the abstract. Each matches a person's cash, relationships and habits.

A short decision list

Ask the questions in order.

  1. Do you have cash you can set aside for several months to a year? If you do, a secured card or a credit-builder loan is open to you. If not, the authorized-user route may be the only one that costs nothing now.
  2. Do you have someone with a long, clean card history who would add you and keep the balance low? If yes, the authorized-user route can add history quickly. If the answer is "maybe," ask them what they would do if they ever missed a payment.
  3. Do you want a card you can spend on, or a forced saving habit? A secured card gives you a card. A builder loan gives you a payment obligation and a lump sum at the end.
  4. Can you manage a revolving line without carrying a balance? If not, a builder loan's fixed payments may be easier to hold to.
  5. Does the issuer or lender report to all three bureaus? Ask, because an account that reports to one bureau builds only that file.
  6. Is there a path to an unsecured card or a refund? Ask what the review schedule and the conditions are.

Some people use two routes together: an authorized-user spot to bring in an aged account, and a secured card of their own, so that the record does not depend on one person's habits. That is a choice, not a requirement.

What to check in the terms

  • Secured card: the deposit amount, whether it is refundable and how, the annual fee, the APR, the bureaus it reports to, and the review policy for graduation. how a secured card works, from deposit to graduation follows the path.
  • Credit-builder loan: the total of the payments, any fees, whether the funds earn interest, when the funds are released, and what happens if a payment is missed. a checklist for judging a subprime or credit-builder card issuer gives questions to ask of any lender in this space.
  • Authorized user: whether the issuer reports authorized users, whether there is a fee, and how to be removed.

If something goes wrong and the issuer will not help, you can use the CFPB complaint process, and a wrong entry on a credit report can be disputed with the bureau.

Key takeaways

  • All three routes produce a reported account, but they differ in cost, control and risk.
  • A secured card needs a refundable deposit and gives you full control; a credit-builder loan produces installment history at a small known cost; an authorized-user spot costs little but ties your file to someone else's habits.
  • The effects on scores are real but modest and depend on the model and on what else is in your file.
  • Under 21, the federal age rule can limit card routes, and being added as an authorized user may be the simplest way in.
  • Before choosing, ask which bureaus the account reports to and what happens when it ends.

Terms used in this article

Latest on this topic