Blog

Should you spend points now or save them for a bigger trip?

A decision guide for savers: the extra value of waiting against devaluation, expiry and a trip that never happens, with break-even math and a question list.

Saving points makes sense when three things are true: you have a specific goal with a price you can look up, the goal returns meaningfully more per point than what you could redeem for today, and the chance you will really take it is high. If any of the three is weak, spending sooner is the better default. Most decisions fall apart on the third condition, because a trip imagined for years is not the same as a trip booked.

This post turns that rule into a decision you can run on your own balance. It sets out the criteria, puts numbers on the trade, shows three labeled households, and ends with a list of questions. All figures are illustrations with round numbers. They show how to reason, not what any program charges.

The two sides of the trade

Waiting has a benefit and three costs, and a good decision names all four.

The benefit is the extra value from a larger redemption. Higher-value uses tend to cost more points or miles up front: a long-haul trip, a premium cabin, a week at a good property. If those return more cents per point than the small redemptions available now, the gap is the premium for waiting.

The costs are separate risks.

  1. Program risk. What a point buys can fall without any change to your balance. That change is called devaluation, and anatomy of a points devaluation, from first rumors to the new chart follows one from first signs to the new price list.
  2. Expiry or inactivity risk. Some programs end or reset points after a period with no activity, and card-held currencies can be tied to an open account. Do points and miles expire? How inactivity rules work covers how those rules work and where to find yours.
  3. Plan risk. The trip may not happen. Schedules change, seats may not be available when you look, someone's health or job changes. A premium that exists only for a trip you never take is worth nothing.

A fourth cost is subtler: opportunity cost. Points held for two years are points you did not use for the weekend away you could have taken this spring. That is not a loss in dollars, but it is a trip not taken, and for some people that is the point of having a rewards card in the first place.

Putting numbers on the premium

Start with the size of the benefit. Say Sam holds 50,000 points and adds about 2,500 a month through ordinary spending. Two redemptions are on the table, with all figures illustrative.

  • Now: a domestic roundtrip for 25,000 points plus $6 in taxes, against a $410 cash fare. Value = $410 − $6 = $404. Rate = $404 ÷ 25,000 × 100 = 1.62 cents.
  • Later: an international trip for 80,000 points plus $90 in taxes, against a $1,500 cash fare. Value = $1,500 − $90 = $1,410. Rate = $1,410 ÷ 80,000 × 100 = 1.76 cents.

The first thing to see is how small the premium per point is: 1.76 against 1.62, or 0.14 cents. Saving for the big trip is not the same as getting a much better rate. The big trip is simply bigger. If the gap in rates is that narrow, waiting has to earn its keep on grounds other than efficiency, such as wanting that particular trip.

Now the timing. To reach 80,000 points from 50,000 at 2,500 a month takes 30,000 ÷ 2,500 = 12 months. If Sam spends 25,000 now, the balance drops to 25,000 and the goal takes 55,000 ÷ 2,500 = 22 months. So spending now delays the big trip by 10 months. That is the true price of the short trip, and it can be read two ways: it is either 10 months of waiting or a choice to take two trips on a different schedule. After 22 months, the plan that spent first and the plan that waited have done the same two things. The order differs, and so does the exposure: one plan has had 80,000 points exposed for most of the period while the other has had less.

A model for the premium and the risk

For a larger gap in rates the trade is sharper. Say Mara has 90,000 points and compares two plans.

  • Three small trips at about 1.4 cents per point: 90,000 × $0.014 = $1,260.
  • One big trip at about 1.9 cents per point: 90,000 × $0.019 = $1,710.

The premium for waiting is $1,710 − $1,260 = $450. Now add the risk that the big trip fails to happen and the points end up as a cash-out at one cent, worth 90,000 × $0.01 = $900. That is $810 less than the success case.

Let q be the chance the big plan fails. The expected value of waiting is (1 − q) × $1,710 + q × $900. Set it equal to the $1,260 from spending: $1,710 − $810q = $1,260, so q = $450 ÷ $810 = 0.556. Waiting is better, in expectation, as long as the chance of failure is below about 56 percent, and spending is better above that.

Read that carefully. It does not say "wait if you are 44 percent sure". It says the premium of $450 can absorb a lot of risk, and that when a rate gap is wide, waiting wins unless failure is the more likely outcome. When the gap is narrow, the break-even moves quickly. Rerun the model with Sam's rates on 80,000 points. Spending at 1.62 cents returns about $1,296 and the big trip at 1.76 cents returns about $1,408, so the premium is only about $112. The downside, a cash-out at one cent, is $800, which is $608 below the success case. The break-even chance of failure is $112 ÷ $608 = 0.18, so waiting wins only if you are more than about 82 percent sure the trip will happen.

The model also leaves out some features of real life. A devaluation reduces the success case rather than turning it into the cash floor, so it behaves like a partial failure. A trip that fails in one year might be rescheduled in the next. And a program that cuts prices or runs a transfer bonus can improve the success case. The honest conclusion is the shape of the trade: a wide rate gap, a specific goal and a program that has treated members fairly favor waiting, while a narrow gap, a vague goal and a risky program favor spending.

The criteria

Turn the model into five criteria you can score yourself.

Criterion Favors saving when Favors spending when
Goal A specific trip with a looked-up points price "Something big someday"
Rate gap The target returns clearly more cents per point than current options The gap is a few tenths of a cent
Program A track record of stable prices and honored bookings Recent changes, a merger or a card issuer change
Time You can book within a year The goal is years away
Expiry Earning activity keeps the balance alive Inactivity rules or card closure put points at risk

No single row decides. If three or more point to spending, the default should be spending. If four or more point to saving, saving is reasonable, with a booking date as a discipline.

Three households

Rosa has 18,000 points and no plan. She earns slowly and has no trip in mind. The balance would cash out at one cent for $180. A saved balance this small has to grow a long way before it buys anything large, and meanwhile it sits exposed to a program she does not follow. Rosa's criteria all point to spending: no goal, no way to check a rate gap, no time frame. The sensible use is a redemption she would be glad of now, whether a cash-out or a small trip she wants, and a habit of using future earnings on a regular rhythm so that a balance never grows large without a purpose.

Kwame has 140,000 points and a family trip in 14 months. He has looked up the price: the trip costs 120,000 points for the family on the dates he wants, at a cash price high enough that the rate is well above his one-cent floor. The goal is specific, the rate gap is wide and the timing is under two years. Saving is the right choice, with two disciplines. He sets a date by which he will book as soon as seats are available, so the plan does not drift. And he keeps a cushion: if prices rise by 10 percent, the trip costs 132,000 points, so he wants at least that in the account when booking opens. That leaves a margin of 140,000 − 132,000 = 8,000.

Lin has 70,000 points on a card she plans to close in three months. Her balance is tied to the card, and she does not yet know what happens to it when the account closes. Her first task is not to compare trips but to find out. What happens to my points when I close or downgrade the card? covers the questions to ask, and five ways earned rewards disappear: closure, delinquency and expiry lists where forfeiture language tends to appear. If the points would be lost or converted at a worse rate, the decision is made for her by a deadline, and the right plan is to use them before closing or to move them somewhere they survive. In her case the rule is that an expiry or closure date overrides the premium for waiting.

Ways to split the difference

You do not have to choose entirely. A few structures capture part of the premium while limiting the risk.

  • Ladder. Divide the balance into two parts: spend the first on something you would enjoy in the next few months, and save the second for the larger goal. If a devaluation arrives, only the saved portion is exposed.
  • Floor and ceiling. Decide the lowest rate you will accept (for example, one cent) and the amount you will hold above it. Anything that can be redeemed at your floor with certainty is, in effect, cash. Anything held above it is a bet.
  • A use-by date. Set a date, perhaps one year out, by which the saved points will be used or reallocated. This turns an open-ended plan into one that can fail visibly.
  • A trigger. Pre-commit to a response: if the program announces a change, you will book what you can in the window or cash out. Decisions made in advance tend to be calmer.

If you decide to save: how to hold a balance well

Saving is a plan only if it is maintained. A saved balance left to itself tends to drift, and the drift is where the risks in this post do their damage. A few habits keep a saving plan honest.

Keep the goal priced. Look up the points price of the trip at the start and again every quarter or so. If the price moves, you learn about it while you can still react. The record also tells you how fast the goal is moving relative to your earning: if the price rises 5 percent a year and you earn 20 percent more points a year, you are gaining on it, and if it is the other way around you are not.

Check availability early. A price in points is only useful if a seat or room exists at that price. Some programs show award availability months ahead, and a look at the calendar before you commit tells you whether the plan is realistic. If you find that cheap seats rarely appear for your dates, the effective premium is smaller than the chart suggests, and the decision should be rerun with a lower expected rate.

Keep the account alive. Make sure the balance cannot lapse through inactivity while you wait. If your program has a rolling clock, one small qualifying purchase each year may be enough, and the timing should be in a calendar.

Decide in advance what you will do if the price moves. If the target trip rises 25 percent in points, will you still go, change the destination, or cash out? A decision made in advance is easier to follow than one made after a program announcement.

Do not let the goal grow. A common pattern is that the target moves up as the balance rises: 60,000 becomes 80,000, then 100,000, and the trip never arrives. Write the goal down and set a date. When the balance meets it, book.

Annual fees and the cost of waiting

Points held on a card with an annual fee carry a cost every year you hold them. Say the fee is $95 and the card earns 24,000 points a year, which at your personal 1.4 cents is $336 of value. The fee takes $95 of it, leaving $241. If you hold the balance for three years without redeeming, you have paid $285 in fees against a balance that is subject to program risk. The fee is not a reason to spend points, but it is a reason to make sure the plan is going somewhere. A balance that grows while a fee is paid is an investment with a known cost and an uncertain return.

A decision list

Work through these in order and write the answers down.

  1. What specific trip or purchase am I saving for, and what does it cost in points today?
  2. What would I do with the points if I spent them now, and what rate does that return?
  3. What is the difference in cents per point between the two? Is it wider than a few tenths of a cent?
  4. How likely is it that I will book the big trip within a year? Be honest: closer to a coin flip or closer to certain?
  5. Does anything threaten the balance: an inactivity rule, a card I may close, a program that has recently changed?
  6. What is my floor, and how much of the balance sits above it?
  7. What date will I decide to book, redeem or reallocate?

If you cannot answer questions 1 and 7, the plan is not yet a plan. The points and miles value calculator helps with questions 2 and 3, and what a point is worth to you, with a worksheet to find out gives a longer method for valuing a balance.

Key takeaways

  • Saving is justified by a specific goal, a clearly better rate and a high chance of booking; the last condition is the one most plans fail.
  • The premium for waiting can be narrow: 1.76 against 1.62 cents per point in the example, so the bigger trip was a different trip, not a much better rate.
  • With a $450 premium and an $810 downside, waiting beat spending unless the chance of failure exceeded about 56 percent; with Sam's narrow premium the threshold drops to about 18 percent.
  • An expiry or card-closure deadline overrides the premium for waiting, so find those rules before anything else.
  • Ladders, floors and use-by dates let you capture part of the premium while limiting exposure, and an annual fee turns an idle balance into a recurring cost.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic