Blog

Store card myths about easy approval, constant deals and credit building

Seven common claims about store cards, from easy approval to credit building, tested one at a time against how approval, interest, scoring and acceptance work.

Store cards carry a lot of folklore. Some of it comes from retailers' marketing, some from friends who got a card at a register and some from half-remembered advice about credit. A few claims are partly true, which is what makes them stick. This post tests seven of them, one at a time, against how approval, interest, scoring and card networks work.

A store card is a card issued in the retailer's name, usually by a bank behind the scenes. It may be a private-label card, which works only at that retailer and its affiliates, or a co-brand card, which carries a payment network's logo and works wherever that network is accepted. The terms of any particular card are on its disclosure box and agreement, so this post uses invented figures to show how the mechanics work. For the lenders behind these cards, see who is actually the lender behind a store or co-brand card?.

Myth 1: "Store cards are easy to get"

Verdict: sometimes easier, never guaranteed.

Some store cards are aimed at shoppers with fair or limited credit, and an issuer may approve applicants a general-purpose issuer would decline. That is the kernel of truth. But "easy" is a relative word. A store card application still produces a hard inquiry on your credit report. The issuer still checks your file, your income and your obligations. A decline is possible, and an approval may come with a small limit.

The cost of a failed attempt is not zero. A hard inquiry usually lowers a FICO Score by fewer than five points and is weighed for about a year, though it can stay on the report for up to two. If you are declined, you have the inquiry and no card. If you are declined, the issuer must send an adverse action notice with the main reasons, or tell you how to request them, within 30 days of a completed application. Read it, because it tells you what the issuer saw.

Check for yourself. Ask whether the retailer offers a prequalification step that does not affect your score. If it does not, treat each application as a one-shot attempt, and avoid applying to several stores in the same week.

Myth 2: "Store cards always save you money"

Verdict: only if you pay in full and you would have bought the item anyway.

The discount at opening and the coupons later are real. So is the cost of carrying a balance, and the pull to spend more than you planned. The arithmetic for a single purchase is on the worksheet in Should I open the store card for the checkout discount? Do the arithmetic, but here is the short form. Say a $340 balance, after a 15% discount on a $400 purchase, sits on a card at an illustrative 28% APR. Monthly interest is $340 × 0.28 ÷ 12 = $7.93. The $60 discount is gone after about 7.6 months at that balance.

Then add the less visible costs. If the card's promotions make you buy $200 more than you planned in a year, a 15% "saving" on that is $30, but you have spent $170 net on things you did not plan to buy. Retailers know this, which is part of why they offer the deal.

Check for yourself. Look at your own past three months at the store. If you would have bought the same things without the card, and you will pay in full, the card saves what the offer says. If not, the saving may be smaller than it looks.

Myth 3: "A store card is a good way to start building credit"

Verdict: it can work, but it is not the best-fitted tool for most beginners.

A store card reports to the credit bureaus, as most cards do, and a clean payment record on any card builds history. So the claim is partly right. Three things limit it.

First, check that it reports. Many store cards report to the bureaus, but some do not report to all three, and the practice varies by issuer. Ask.

Second, the limit is usually small and tied to one retailer. A limit of $300 or $500 with a $200 balance is high credit utilization. Say your limit is $500 and your balance at statement time is $340. Utilization is 340 ÷ 500 = 68%. Experian says utilization above about 30 percent starts to weigh more heavily on scores, while FICO does not publish a magic number and lower is generally better. To keep it at 30 percent on a $500 limit you would hold the reported balance to $150.

Third, a retailer's card is built for a retail customer, not for a person learning credit. A first card that earns its keep through everyday use, with a general-purpose network, may give more flexibility. For a person with a thin file, other starting points are compared in a comparison of secured cards, builder loans and authorized-user status, and the student and starter options are in a student-versus-starter comparison.

Check for yourself. Before applying, ask whether the account reports to Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, and what its likely limit is. If you will not use the card often, a different first card may be a better use of an inquiry.

Myth 4: "A store card works only at that store"

Verdict: depends on the type.

A private-label card works at the retailer and its affiliates, because the retailer and the issuer operate a closed system. A co-brand card carries a network logo, so it works wherever that network is accepted, and it often has a rewards structure tied to the retailer. The two look alike at the register. The difference is in the application and the card itself.

Why it matters: a private-label card gives you one place to use it, so it will not help you with other purchases, and its credit limit will not help your general capacity. A co-brand card can serve as an everyday card. Its rates and fees are not always like those of a general-purpose card, though, and its benefits differ by card.

Check for yourself. Look at the card, or the application, for a network logo. If it has none, assume it is private-label, and ask where it can be used.

Myth 5: "Opening a store card will raise my score because it adds credit"

Verdict: it may help a little later and often dips first.

A new account affects several parts of a score. The hard inquiry takes a few points. The new account lowers the average age of your accounts, which is one input to the length-of-credit-history part of a score. A new credit limit adds available credit, which can lower overall utilization if you keep the balance low. The net effect is usually small and can be positive or negative.

The average-age effect has simple arithmetic. Say you have three accounts aged 4 years, 2 years and 1 year. The average age is (4 + 2 + 1) ÷ 3 = 2.33 years. Add a brand-new store card with age 0, and the average becomes (4 + 2 + 1 + 0) ÷ 4 = 1.75 years. That is a drop of about seven months. length of credit history is about 15 percent of a general FICO Score, and the models treat the average age as one of several inputs, so the effect is modest. For someone with a long history it is smaller; for someone with a thin file it is larger.

Check for yourself. If you plan to apply for a mortgage, auto loan or another card within a year, think about whether the small dip and the lowered average age are worth the discount. If not, wait until after the larger application.

Myth 6: "No interest for six months means free financing"

Verdict: it may be, but a deferred-interest promotion can charge back-interest.

Many store promotions are deferred interest financing, which is different from a true 0% APR. Under deferred interest, interest accrues from the purchase date during the promotion, and it is waived only if the entire balance is paid by the end. If any balance remains, the accumulated interest is charged to the account.

Here is a simple version. You buy a $600 item on a six-month deferred-interest promotion at an illustrative 28% APR. If you pay $550 over the six months and $50 remains on the last day, the interest accrued during the promotion on the declining balance, not on $50 alone, may be added. The exact amount depends on the agreement's method. If you paid nothing until the end, the simple estimate is $600 × 0.28 ÷ 12 × 6 = $84.00. You would then owe $84 of interest on a $50 remainder. A true 0% promotion would charge no interest on the amount you had paid down, and only the regular rate on what remained.

The difference between the two is explained in Deferred interest vs a true 0% APR: how to tell the offers apart, and how deferred interest is charged back when you miss the deadline shows the back-charge month by month.

Check for yourself. Look for the phrase "if paid in full" in the promotion. If you see it, assume deferred interest, and set a payment plan that clears the balance a month before the end.

Myth 7: "If I don't use it, it doesn't matter, and closing it is always bad"

Verdict: both halves are shortcuts.

An unused store card is still an open account, and its limit and age are still in your file. That is a small positive. But the issuer may close an inactive account, and the closure is its choice. A closed account in good standing stays on your report for years, but its limit leaves your total available credit. Federal rules bar a penalty fee for inactivity or closure, so there is no fee for letting it sit, unless the card has an annual fee, which would be charged on an account you are not using.

Closing it yourself is not always bad. If a card has an annual fee and you will not use it, closing is reasonable. If it has no fee and you may use it again, keeping it open costs nothing. The sums for a given account are in the close-a-card utilization impact calculator. A useful rule: do not close a no-fee card with a long history only because you do not like the store. Close one to avoid a fee or because you cannot trust yourself with it.

Check for yourself. Look at the age of the card and its fee. If it is old and free, leave it open and use it occasionally on autopay for a small item. If it has a fee or tempts you, closing it is a legitimate choice.

When a store card does make sense

The myths above could suggest that store cards are always a bad idea. They are not. They are a good fit in a narrow, identifiable situation, and it helps to say what that looks like.

A store card tends to make sense when all of these are true: you already shop at the retailer regularly, so the coupons and discounts apply to things you buy anyway; you pay the full statement balance every month, so no interest is charged; you have read the disclosure box and know the APR, the fees and whether the card is private-label or co-brand; and you do not need the account for credit building, because you have other accounts that do the job.

Say a household spends $150 a month at a home improvement store and the card gives 5% back on those purchases, an illustrative figure. That is $7.50 a month, or $90 a year, on spending that was already planned. If the card has no annual fee and the household pays in full, the $90 is a straightforward gain. It does not make sense to increase spending to earn more rewards. A $90 reward on $1,800 of spending is a 5% rebate. A $90 reward on $3,600 of spending, double the planned amount, is only 2.5% of a larger outlay, and $1,800 of it was not needed.

A store card makes less sense for the household that wants to use it to cover a shortfall, because store card APRs can be high, or for one that wants a general-purpose card and is tempted by a single day's discount. In those cases a general-purpose card may serve the purpose better, and a retailer's discount can sometimes be had through a coupon or sale without opening an account.

A short checklist before you accept

  • Can I read the disclosure box before I sign? If the cashier cannot show it, I can apply later.
  • Is the APR something I can afford if I slip once?
  • Is the card private-label or co-brand, and where will it work?
  • Does it report to all three bureaus?
  • If there is a financing promotion, is it deferred interest?
  • Will I pay the first statement in full? Can I set autopay for the full statement balance today?
  • Is there a better use of an inquiry in the next twelve months?

If the answers are comfortable, the offer may be worth taking. If two or more are not, the discount is likely worth less than it seems.

Putting the seven together

A table of the verdicts:

Claim Mostly true? The part that matters
Easy to get Sometimes easier Still a hard inquiry, still a decline risk
Always saves money Only if paid in full Carrying a balance can erase the discount
Good for building credit Possibly Check reporting, small limit means high utilization
Works only at the store Depends on type Private-label versus co-brand
Adds credit, raises score Rarely at first Inquiry and lower average age
No interest means free Sometimes Deferred interest can charge back
Unused cards don't matter Partly The issuer can close it, and a fee still counts

A store card is a legitimate product for a person who shops at that store often, pays in full and reads the terms. It is a poor fit for a person who is shopping for credit-building or for relief from a tight budget. If you are weighing a specific offer, the worksheet linked above gives you the numbers, and the disclosure box gives you the terms.

Key takeaways

  • Store cards can be easier to get than some general-purpose cards, but an application still costs a hard inquiry, and a decline is possible.
  • The discount is real only if you pay in full and would have bought the item anyway. At an illustrative 28% APR, $340 costs about $7.93 a month to carry.
  • A small store limit makes utilization high quickly. A $340 balance on a $500 limit is 68%.
  • Check whether the card is private-label or co-brand, since that decides where it works.
  • "No interest if paid in full" usually signals deferred interest, which can add months of back-interest if any balance remains.
  • A new account lowers the average age of your accounts. In the example, three accounts averaging 2.33 years fell to 1.75 years.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic