Blog

Student loan payments and a card balance in one budget: a plan

A plan for a graduate with student loan payments and a card balance: list the debts, protect the minimums, build a small cushion and order the extra cash.

The first year out of school often brings three bills at once: a student loan payment that starts on a schedule, a card balance that grew during school, and a rent that is higher than the dorm was. The question "which do I pay first?" has a short answer and a long one. The short answer, for most people, is that every minimum gets paid every month and the extra goes toward whichever debt is most expensive and least forgiving. The long answer is the plan below, in seven steps, with a worked example so you can see the numbers move. It describes general mechanics. Your loan terms, your card agreement and your servicer are the sources for the real figures.

Step 1: Put every debt on one page

Write down, for each debt, five facts: the lender, the current balance, the interest rate, the minimum payment and the due date. A card's rate is its APR. A student loan's rate is stated in the loan documents or on the servicer's site, and a graduate with several loans will have several lines. Pull the numbers from the latest statements, not from memory. If you are not sure what you owe, the free credit reports at AnnualCreditReport.com list your accounts and balances, and how student loans show up on your credit report and your score explains how loans appear there.

Here is the example used through this plan. It is a labeled hypothetical with round numbers.

Debt Balance Illustrative rate Minimum Type
Student loan $18,000 6% $200 installment loan
Credit card $3,000 24% $90 Revolving

Priya earns $3,200 a month after tax. Her fixed costs are rent $1,350, utilities and phone $230, groceries $420, transport $280, insurance $110 and other spending $90. Those add to $2,480 (1,350 + 230 + 420 + 280 + 110 + 90). She has $720 left each month (3,200 minus 2,480).

Step 2: Pay every minimum on time, automatically

Before anything else, set up autopay for the minimum on every debt. A missed minimum has costs well beyond its size. On a card, a late payment can bring a late fee, which the sources describe as roughly $30 for a first late payment and about $41 for a repeat within six billing cycles, with issuers free to charge less and the fee capped at the minimum payment due. A payment more than 60 days late can allow the issuer to raise the rate on the existing balance. On a student loan, a delinquency can reach the credit report and stay seven years.

Autopay for the minimum is a floor. It does not mean you pay only the minimum. It means the worst month still pays the minimum. Look at the due dates, and if several fall in the same week, check whether the servicer or issuer lets you move a date. Many do, and a date that follows your pay date is easier to keep.

In Priya's case, the minimums are $200 plus $90, or $290. That leaves $430 of the $720 (720 minus 290).

Step 3: Build a small cushion first

Paying down debt with no cash reserve has a trap: the first surprise bill goes on the card, and the progress is lost. A small starter cushion, held in a savings account that is separate from the checking account, is a emergency fund at its smallest. How big it should be depends on the household. A round figure many people use for a starter is $500 to $1,000, which is an illustration here and not a rule, and a person with unstable income or dependents may need more. Emergency fund or debt payoff first? How to split your extra cash looks at how to split extra cash between the two.

For Priya, say she directs $100 of the $430 each month to the cushion until it reaches $1,000. That leaves $330 for the extra payment (430 minus 100). That cushion takes ten months to build (1,000 divided by 100), and she will adjust when it is done.

A simple budget makes this concrete. A budget does not need many categories. It needs the fixed costs, the minimums, the cushion transfer and the extra payment, in that order, and it needs a look at the real bank statement each month.

Step 4: Decide the order of the extra payment

With the minimums covered and a cushion started, the extra cash goes to one debt. Two common orders are:

  • Avalanche. Pay the highest-rate debt first. The debt avalanche approach minimizes the total interest, because each dollar goes where interest costs most.
  • Snowball. Pay the smallest balance first. The debt snowball approach can be more motivating because debts disappear sooner, though it can cost more in interest.

Both need minimums on everything else. The student loan and the card present a specific wrinkle: they are different kinds of debt. The card is revolving and has a high rate. The loan is an installment loan, probably at a lower rate, and federal loans typically come with repayment options such as changing the plan if income drops. A card usually has no such flexibility, apart from a hardship program some issuers run. That difference is a reason not to fall behind on the card, and it is also a reason that the card, not the loan, is normally the first target.

Run the arithmetic for Priya, whose card is at 24 percent and whose loan is at 6 percent. Twenty-four percent a year is 2 percent a month. On a $3,000 balance that is $60 of interest in the first month. Six percent a year is 0.5 percent a month, so on $18,000 it is $90 a month. The loan generates more dollars of interest, but each dollar of card balance costs four times as much interest as a dollar of loan balance (24 divided by 6). Extra cash saves interest at the rate of the debt it pays down.

Compare two eight-month plans, both using the same $330 extra plus the minimums.

Plan Card after 8 months Loan after 8 months Interest paid over the 8 months Total debt left
Card first (extra to the card) $0 about $17,104 about $975 about $17,104
Loan first (extra to the loan) about $2,743 about $14,418 about $1,120 about $17,160

Paying the card first costs about $146 less in interest over the eight months and leaves total debt about $56 lower (all figures rounded and based on monthly interest at one-twelfth of the annual rate). The gap widens each month the card is open. It would be smaller at a lower card rate, and it would vanish if the card were at the same rate as the loan. Your own rates decide it.

Step 5: Run the month-by-month schedule

For Priya, the card payment is the $90 minimum plus $330 extra, or $420 a month. Month by month, the card balance runs like this:

Month Interest at 2% Payment Card balance after
1 $60.00 $420.00 $2,640.00
2 $52.80 $420.00 $2,272.80
3 $45.46 $420.00 $1,898.26
4 $37.97 $420.00 $1,516.22
5 $30.32 $420.00 $1,126.55
6 $22.53 $420.00 $729.08
7 $14.58 $420.00 $323.66
8 $6.47 $330.13 $0.00

The card is gone in eight months, with about $270 of interest paid in all. Meanwhile the loan, paid at $200 a month, has fallen from $18,000 to about $17,104.

In month nine the $420 that went to the card does not go back to spending. It joins the loan, which is now paid $620 a month (200 plus 420). At that pace the loan, at the illustrative 6 percent, is paid off about 30 months later, around month 38 from the start, compared with ten years at $200 a month. Those figures assume a fixed rate and no new borrowing. The credit card payoff calculator and the debt avalanche vs snowball calculator let you try the same run with your own numbers.

There is one more thing to do as the card falls. If you stop using it for new purchases while you pay it down, the balance can only fall. If you keep using it and paying in full each month, the grace period applies to new purchases only if the prior balance was paid in full, so while a balance is carried, new purchases usually start accruing interest at once. six ways people lose their grace period without realizing it covers how that works.

When the numbers are different

The order in the example follows from two rates. Change the rates and the order can change, so it helps to know the rule behind it: extra money saves interest at the rate of the debt it pays down, and the highest rate gives the largest saving per dollar.

  • The card rate is lower than you think. Say the card were at 12 percent and the loan at 6 percent. The card would still cost twice as much per dollar, so the card still goes first, though the saving is smaller. The order flips only when the loan's rate is higher than the card's.
  • The loan is a private loan with a high rate. A private student loan can carry a rate that is higher than a card's, particularly a card with a promotional rate. If a loan's rate is above the card's, the avalanche puts extra cash on the loan, after confirming that the card's minimum is covered. Private loans usually have fewer repayment options than federal ones, which is a further reason not to let one fall behind.
  • The card is in a zero-percent promotion. If the balance sits at an intro rate of 0 percent for a stated period, the interest cost is nothing while the offer runs, so extra cash can go to the loan, provided the card balance is paid off before the promotion ends and the minimum is made every month. A missed payment can end a promotional rate in some agreements, so read the terms. Put the promotion's end date in your calendar the day you start.
  • The rates are equal. When two debts cost the same, the choice is about motivation and risk. Many people choose the debt that is harder to live with, such as the one that sends the most reminders.
  • Income is irregular. A graduate who freelances or works variable shifts can use the same plan with a lower fixed extra payment and a larger cushion.

If you have several cards and loans, the principle scales: rank the debts by rate, pay every minimum, put the extra on the top of the list and, when it is gone, move to the next one.

A monthly routine that takes twenty minutes

A plan survives when it turns into a habit. Pick a day soon after payday and do these things in order.

  1. Open each account and note the balance. Compare it with the schedule. A card balance higher than expected means new spending, and it is better to know in week one than month four.
  2. Confirm autopay worked. Look for the payment on each debt, not just in the bank account.
  3. Move the cushion transfer and the extra payment. Do both before anything else is spent. What stays in checking is for living on.
  4. Read the card statement line by line. Each line should be recognized. Anything that is not, or that is a charge you did not make, is a call to the number on the back of the card. A charge you did not make is handled as a billing error or unauthorized use, and the written-notice window is 60 days from the statement.
  5. Write one number down. The total of all debts, summed across accounts. Watching a single figure fall month after month is a reliable motivator, and it is easy to see if the total ever rises.

The plan has no secret. It asks for twenty minutes a month and a decision, made once, about where the extra cash goes.

Step 6: Plan for the month that goes wrong

A plan that has no room for a bad month will break. Three safeguards help.

  1. Keep the minimums sacred. If money is short, the minimums are paid and the extra payment is skipped. A skipped extra costs interest. A missed minimum costs fees and credit history.
  2. Know the order of relief. If you cannot pay a minimum, call early. For a federal student loan, a change of plan or a temporary pause may be available from the servicer, and the terms depend on current rules, so check studentaid.gov. For a card, ask whether the issuer has a hardship program, and how to ask your card issuer for a hardship program, call by call shows how the call goes.
  3. Do not borrow to pay a debt. A cash advance on the card to pay the loan starts interest at once, carries a fee and has no grace period. A "fix" offered by a company that asks for money first is a warning sign.

If rent, loan and card all come due on the same day with not enough for all of them, Rent, student loans and a card all due the same week. What gets paid first? sets out the order to protect.

Step 7: Review every quarter

A plan made in one month is out of date by the next raise. Every three months, do four things: update the balances and rates, check that autopay is still on, move any raise toward the extra payment before it is spent and check your credit report once. When the card is gone, decide on purpose what to do with the freed cash, because it will otherwise be absorbed by spending.

If your situation includes a lot of debt, a high balance on several cards or income that does not cover the minimums, a nonprofit credit counseling agency can review the whole picture, and a debt management plan is one option they explain. how to build a credit card payoff plan you can actually stick to covers the card side in more detail.

Common mistakes in this plan

  • Paying extra on the loan while the card carries 24 percent. The arithmetic above shows the cost.
  • Skipping the cushion. The first car repair then lands on the card.
  • Letting the loan go to default to pay the card. A card is not a reason to miss a loan payment, and a loan delinquency does lasting damage.
  • Forgetting that rates move. Most card APRs are variable and move with the prime rate, so recheck the card's rate.
  • Spending the freed cash. Decide its destination in advance.

Key takeaways

  • Pay every minimum automatically, then put the extra on the debt with the highest rate, which is usually the card. In the example, card-first saves about $146 of interest over eight months.
  • Build a small cushion in parallel, because an unplanned bill that lands on the card can undo the progress.
  • The card and the loan are different debts: federal loans typically have repayment options that cards lack, which is why falling behind on a card is the more dangerous mistake.
  • In the example, a $3,000 card at 24 percent is cleared in eight months with $420 a month, about $270 of interest, and the loan is then paid faster with the freed $420.
  • Review the plan every quarter, and call the servicer or issuer before a payment is missed.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic