Blog
Three cardholders with one $3,000 balance and three payment habits
Three labeled hypotheticals start with the same balance and rate and pay it three ways. Interest, time to payoff and total cost diverge, with every figure.
Three people open the same statement. Each owes $3,000 of revolving credit on a card with the same terms. One pays the minimum every month. One pays a flat $150. One pays the whole thing before the due date. A year later, one of them has paid hundreds of dollars in interest and still owes most of the balance, one has paid a fraction of that and is more than halfway done, and one has paid nothing beyond the $3,000. Their incomes and their cards are the same. Only the habit differs.
This article follows each of them in detail so you can see how interest, time and total cost diverge. The people, the rate and the minimum-payment formula are invented for illustration. Your card's terms are in your agreement and your statement, and the arithmetic here shows the mechanism, not a forecast.
The setup
All three are labeled hypotheticals with the same starting facts.
- The balance. Each has a $3,000 statement balance, from a single purchase, say a car repair. Each paid the previous statement in full, so they had a grace period when the purchase was made.
- The rate. An illustrative 24 percent APR, or 2 percent a month. This is a round number for easy arithmetic, not a market rate.
- No new purchases. They stop using the card for anything else, so the balance only changes through interest and payments.
- A simplification. Interest each month is the balance times 2 percent. Real issuers use daily balances, which changes the figures slightly, as the companion worksheet work out one month of card interest by hand with average daily balance shows.
- The minimum formula. The minimum payment is the month's interest plus 1 percent of the balance, with a floor of $25. Many cards use a design of this kind, but the numbers vary, and the formula for yours is in your agreement. Federal rules also require each statement to show how long it would take to pay off the balance at minimum payments.
The three are Ari, Bea and Cal.
The three habits
Each habit below gets the same treatment: what the person does, the month-by-month mechanics, and the totals. Read them in order, because each one explains something the next builds on. Cal's case is the baseline, since nothing is carried and nothing is charged. Ari's and Bea's cases show what changes when a balance is carried, and how a small difference in the payment rule produces a very large difference in the result.
Cal: pays the statement balance in full
Cal pays $3,000 by the due date. Because the previous statement was paid in full, the grace period applies, and the purchase carries no interest.
- Interest: $0
- Time: one cycle
- Total paid: $3,000
Cal's habit does not make the purchase cheaper. It makes borrowing it free for a few weeks. The price is that Cal needs $3,000 in cash by the due date, which is not available to everyone. The rest of this article is about what happens when it is not.
Ari: pays only the minimum
Ari pays whatever the statement says is the minimum. Month by month, here is how it unfolds, using the formula above.
| Month | Interest | Payment (the minimum) | Balance after |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $60.00 | $90.00 | $2,970.00 |
| 2 | $59.40 | $89.10 | $2,940.30 |
| 3 | $58.81 | $88.21 | $2,910.90 |
| 6 | $57.06 | $85.59 | $2,824.44 |
| 12 | $53.72 | $80.58 | $2,659.15 |
| 24 | $47.62 | $71.43 | $2,357.03 |
| 60 | $33.16 | $49.74 | $1,641.47 |
| 120 | $18.14 | $27.22 | $898.14 |
The first month shows the pattern. The payment is $90.00, which is $60.00 of interest (a finance charge on the statement) plus 1 percent of $3,000, which is $30.00. So of $90, two-thirds goes to interest and one-third reduces the balance. After a year, Ari has paid about $1,022.54 in total, of which about $681.69 was interest, and the balance has fallen by $340.85, from $3,000 to $2,659.15.
Because the minimum is a share of the shrinking balance, the payment shrinks too. It reaches the $25 floor around month 129, when the balance is about $820. From there Ari pays $25 a month until the last payment of $23.17.
- Time: 183 months, which is 15 years and 3 months
- Interest paid: $4,886.91
- Total paid: $7,886.91
A $3,000 repair ends up costing $7,886.91. The interest alone is $1,886.91 more than the original amount. And Ari never missed a payment, was never late and never did anything wrong in the narrow sense. The formula guaranteed the result. This is the situation the minimum-payment warning box is meant to show, with your actual numbers. How long will minimum payments take? Work out your own payoff date lets you work out your own.
Bea: pays a fixed $150 a month
Bea chooses a flat amount, $150, every month, which is about 5 percent of the original balance. It is not a large sum, and it is above Ari's first minimum of $90.
| Month | Interest | Payment | Balance after |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $60.00 | $150.00 | $2,910.00 |
| 12 | $38.10 | $150.00 | $1,792.91 |
| 25 | $5.24 | $150.00 | $117.27 |
| 26 | $2.35 | $119.62 | $0.00 |
In month 1, $60.00 goes to interest and $90.00 reduces the balance, the reverse of Ari's split. Because the payment does not shrink, the interest falls faster each month and the share going to the balance grows.
- Time: 26 months, a little over two years
- Interest paid: $869.62
- Total paid: $3,869.62, which is 25 payments of $150 plus a final $119.62
You can check the time with a formula: for a payment P on a balance B at a monthly rate r, the number of months is -ln(1 - rB/P) / ln(1 + r). Here r = 0.02, B = 3,000 and P = 150, so rB/P = 60/150 = 0.40, and the months are -ln(0.60) / ln(1.02) = 0.5108 / 0.0198 = about 25.8, which rounds up to 26.
The comparison
| Cal | Bea | Ari | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Habit | Pays the statement balance in full | Fixed $150 a month | Pays the minimum |
| First payment | $3,000 | $150 | $90 |
| Time to pay off | 1 cycle | 26 months | 183 months |
| Interest paid | $0 | $869.62 | $4,886.91 |
| Total paid | $3,000 | $3,869.62 | $7,886.91 |
| Extra cost over $3,000 | $0 | $869.62 | $4,886.91 |
Three observations stand out.
- Bea pays $60 more than Ari in the first month and saves about $4,017 in interest. The difference in the first payment is small. The difference in the result is large, because Bea's payment does not shrink as the balance falls.
- Ari's payment falls over time. A minimum that is a share of the balance gets smaller as the balance gets smaller, which stretches the payoff out. A fixed payment does the opposite.
- Cal's outcome depends on having the cash. It is not a better character. It is access to $3,000 by the due date, which is the reason the same article is useful to Ari and Bea.
Changing the rate, the payment or the habit
The three outcomes above are not fixed. They shift with the rate, with the size of the payment and with whether the card keeps being used. The next three tables and paragraphs change one thing at a time.
What the habit does at different rates
The same three habits behave differently at other rates. Here are Ari's and Bea's results at three illustrative APRs, on the same $3,000 with the same payment rules. Cal pays nothing in interest at any rate while the grace period holds.
| Illustrative APR | Bea, fixed $150: months | Bea: interest | Ari, minimum: months | Ari: interest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18% | 24 | $593.48 | 171 | $3,538.56 |
| 24% | 26 | $869.62 | 183 | $4,886.91 |
| 29.99% | 29 | $1,210.13 | 194 | $6,266.06 |
Moving from 18 to 29.99 percent adds about $617 to Bea's interest and about $2,727 to Ari's. A higher rate hurts every borrower, and it hurts most where the balance lingers longest. That is why the rate on a card you carry matters more than almost any other line in the Schumer box, and why moving a balance to a lower rate is a common tactic for people in Ari's position. How a 0% intro APR works and what it leaves out explains one version of it.
What the size of the payment does
Take Bea's habit and change only the fixed payment, with the rate held at 24 percent.
| Fixed payment | Months to pay off | Interest paid | Total paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| $80 | 71 | $2,600.45 | $5,600.45 |
| $100 | 47 | $1,627.31 | $4,627.31 |
| $150 | 26 | $869.62 | $3,869.62 |
| $200 | 19 | $602.32 | $3,602.32 |
| $300 | 12 | $381.10 | $3,381.10 |
Each extra dollar a month buys more than the last one costs. Going from $100 to $150 a month, $50 more, saves about $758 in interest and 21 months. Going from $200 to $300 saves about $221 and 7 months. The returns diminish, but they stay large in this range, which is why even a modest extra payment matters on a carried balance.
If Bea keeps using the card
The example assumes no new spending. Real life interrupts. Say Bea pays $150 for six months, then puts a $400 expense on the card, and there is no grace period on it because Bea is carrying a balance. In the simplified model, with the $400 added to the balance and charged 2 percent a month like the rest, Bea's balance after month 6 goes from about $2,432 to about $2,832, and the payoff stretches from 26 to 30 months. Total interest rises from $869.62 to about $1,092.24, an increase of about $222.62 for a $400 expense. That is more than half the amount of the purchase. It is the cost of using a card with no interest-free window, and it is the reason people who are paying a balance down often move everyday spending to a debit card or cash, if they can, until the balance is gone. That is a choice, not a rule, and it depends on your situation.
Which of the three are you?
Answer three questions about your card this month.
- Did you pay the last statement balance in full? If yes, you are in Cal's position, and what matters is keeping it that way.
- If not, what is your payment, and is it fixed or a share of the balance? A payment that shrinks as the balance falls is Ari's pattern. A payment that stays level is Bea's.
- What is the payment you could sustain, if you set it once and left it? A good answer is a number you can pay every month without borrowing elsewhere. Do not choose a payment that forces a cash advance next month.
If you are Ari, the cheapest first move is to choose a fixed payment at least as large as this month's minimum and not let it fall. If you cannot afford more than the minimum, call the number on the back of your card to ask about hardship options and talk to a nonprofit credit counselor.
One change Ari can make: pay a fixed amount
Suppose Ari decides to pay $90 every month, the same as the first minimum, and not let it shrink.
- Months to pay off: about 56
- Interest paid: about $1,993.25
- Total paid: about $4,993.25
The monthly payment in the first month is identical to what Ari was making. The only change is refusing to let the payment fall. That alone cuts the time from 183 months to 56 and the interest from $4,886.91 to about $1,993.25, a saving of about $2,893.66. It is the same money out of the pocket in month 1.
The 36-month payment from the warning box
Federal rules require the statement's warning box to show the payment that would pay off the balance in 36 months. For this example it can be computed. At a 2 percent monthly rate on $3,000 over 36 months, the payment is $3,000 x 0.02 / (1 - 1.02^-36) = about $117.70.
- Total paid over 36 months: about $4,237.13
- Interest: about $1,237.13
This is $27.70 a month more than Ari's first minimum and gets the balance to zero in three years instead of more than fifteen, with about $3,650 less interest than Ari paid. Actual boxes use your own numbers, and the figures here are for the invented example only.
What each cardholder could do next
Ari has the most to gain from a change. Ways to improve the outcome include paying a fixed amount that does not shrink, adding even a small extra each month, moving the balance to a lower rate if the fee and terms make sense, or asking the issuer or a nonprofit credit counselor about a hardship option if the minimum is hard to afford. what an extra $50, $100 or $200 a month does to a card payoff shows what extra payments do.
Bea can shorten the time by rounding up. Paying $200 instead of $150 would clear the same balance in about 19 months. how to build a credit card payoff plan you can actually stick to covers building a plan.
Cal should keep the habit and keep an eye on the due date, since a single shortfall can switch the grace period off. six ways people lose their grace period without realizing it lists the ways it is lost.
To run your own balance, the minimum payment calculator and the credit card payoff calculator take a balance, a rate and a payment.
What this example leaves out
A fair reading should note the limits of the example.
- It assumes no new spending. Real cards keep being used, which changes the balance and, without a grace period, adds interest from the day of each purchase.
- It assumes a constant rate. A variable rate moves with the index, and a promotional rate ends.
- It uses a simple monthly interest figure. Daily balances give slightly different numbers.
- It uses one example minimum formula. Yours may be 2 percent of the balance, a flat floor or some other design, and the outcome shifts accordingly.
- It ignores fees. A late fee or an annual fee would add to the cost.
- It does not say what anyone should do. Whether to use cash savings to pay in full is a personal decision about emergencies, other debts and cash needs. A nonprofit credit counselor can help weigh it.
Key takeaways
- On the same $3,000 balance at an illustrative 24 percent, paying in full cost $0 in interest, a fixed $150 a month cost $869.62 over 26 months, and the minimum cost $4,886.91 over 183 months.
- A minimum that is a share of the balance shrinks as the balance falls, so the payoff drags on; Ari's first payment of $90 and a fixed $90 a month would have cleared the balance in about 56 months instead of 183.
- A payment only $60 higher than the first minimum saved about $4,017 in interest, because the payment did not shrink.
- A grace period turns a short-term purchase into free borrowing, but only if the full statement balance is paid by the due date.
- To see your own version, find your rate and minimum formula in the agreement and run the numbers in a calculator before choosing a habit.