Blog

What the 5/24 rule is, how it is counted and why it is not official

What the widely reported 5/24 approval practice says, how to count it with dates, why issuers do not publish it and how it fits ordinary underwriting.

"5/24" is shorthand for a pattern that card enthusiasts have reported for years: Chase commonly declines most of its cards when an applicant has opened five or more personal credit cards, from any issuer, in the past 24 months. Everything in that sentence needs a hedge, and the hedge is the point of this post. The rule is not law. It is not published by the issuer. It is inferred from what applicants report. It still shapes how a lot of people sequence their applications, so it helps to know exactly what is claimed, how the count works and where it stops.

This post explains the pattern, shows how to count it with dates, and sets it beside ordinary underwriting. It does not tell you to avoid or pursue any card.

What is actually claimed

According to widely cited guides to issuer application rules, the claim is this: Chase commonly declines most of its cards if the applicant has opened five or more personal cards from any issuer in the previous 24 months. The reports add a few details: some business cards that do not report to a personal credit file reportedly do not count, while others do. Capital One business cards are reported to count, for example, while some business cards from Chase, American Express, Citi and Barclays are reported not to.

A separate reported practice sometimes gets bundled into the same discussion: Chase is also described as applying a 48-month restriction on the welcome bonuses for its Sapphire cards, so that someone who received one on a Sapphire Preferred or Sapphire Reserve in the past 48 months may not receive another. That is a rule about bonuses, not about approval, and it is a different question.

Two cautions apply to all of it. These are internal issuer policies that change without notice. And they come from third-party reports, so each should be read as "commonly reported," never as a guarantee. The profile of the issuer, Chase, carries what it has published; this post does not state any of its current terms.

Why it is "not official"

Nobody outside the issuer can see its decision models. What exists outside is a body of reported experience: people post that they applied, how many cards they had opened and recently, and whether they were approved. Patterns in those reports became a rule of thumb, and the number five and the number twenty-four stuck because they fit the reports.

That has several consequences.

  • The issuer has not confirmed the rule. An issuer is not required to publish its internal approval criteria, and these rules are not in the cardmember agreement or the pricing disclosure.
  • The reported rule can be wrong or out of date. Policies can change without notice, and a report from several years ago may not describe today's practice.
  • The reported rule is a summary of a more complex process. An approval decision usually weighs many things, and "5/24" is one reported input.
  • Different people report different results. Some applicants over the line are reportedly approved, and some under it are declined, which is what you would expect if the number is a rough marker for something else.

The right way to hold the rule is as a probability: if you are over the line, a decline is more likely, according to reports. It is not a switch.

How the count works

The arithmetic is simple. The count is the number of personal credit cards you opened in a rolling 24-month window. "5/24" is read as "five cards in 24 months," and the reported threshold is that five or more is the problem zone and four or fewer is under it.

Several points govern the count.

  • It is based on opening dates, not on when you applied or when the card arrived. The date shown on a credit report as the account's open date is the closest public proxy.
  • The window rolls. Each day, accounts opened exactly 24 months ago drop out of the count.
  • It looks backward from the day you would apply, not from today. If you are at five and an account is about to age out, the count at the planned application date is what matters.
  • It counts cards, not inquiries. An application that was declined, or an inquiry with no account opened, is not an opened card.

A worked count

Say today is November 16, 2026. These accounts are a made-up example for one person, Alex. The 24-month window reaches back to November 16, 2024.

Account Type Opened Inside the window?
Card A Personal card Dec 2024 Yes
Card B Personal card Mar 2025 Yes
Card C Personal card Aug 2025 Yes
Card D Personal card Jan 2026 Yes
Card E Personal card Apr 2026 Yes
Card F Personal card Oct 2023 No, more than 24 months ago
Card G Business card that does not report to the personal file Feb 2026 Reportedly not counted
Auto loan Installment loan Jun 2025 Not a card

Alex's count: five personal cards in the window (A, B, C, D and E). That is "5/24." Card F is outside. Card G is a business card that is reported not to count for this purpose, which you can verify against the reports for the issuer and card in question, because it differs by issuer and card. The auto loan is not a card, and descriptions of the practice are about credit cards.

When does Alex drop to four? Card A was opened in December 2024. Twenty-four months after that is December 2026. After that date, the window no longer includes it, and the count falls to four. If Alex's application is planned for early January 2027, the count on that date is four: B, C, D and E.

So Alex's choice is concrete: at five today, the reported practice suggests a decline is likely for the issuer in question, and waiting about a month changes the count. Nothing about this tells Alex whether to apply. It tells Alex where the line is.

The 5/24 and new-account tracker does this arithmetic with your own dates, and how to count your own 5/24 status from your credit report walks through it step by step.

What counts and what is reported to vary

Descriptions of what counts differ, and some of the differences are not settled.

  • Personal cards from any issuer are described as counting, not just Chase cards.
  • Business cards are described as depending on whether the issuer reports them to your personal credit file. Reports differ by issuer, and reports can change.
  • Accounts where you are an authorized user, store cards and co-brand cards are described differently across sources. Check a current source and your own credit report before you assume anything.
  • Loans such as mortgages, auto loans and student loans are described as not part of the count, because the practice concerns cards.
  • Accounts you opened and then closed reportedly still count while they are inside the window. Closing a card does not remove its opening date from your report.

When a source and your own situation do not match, the useful check is your own credit report. It shows which accounts are present, their open dates and whether they are personal. A free copy is available from each bureau; AnnualCreditReport.com is the official site.

Counting mistakes people make

Most miscounts come from the same few places.

  1. Counting from the application date. The count uses open dates. A card you applied for in December but that was approved and opened in January is dated January.
  2. Counting inquiries. An inquiry with no account opened is not an opened card, though it may matter for other reasons.
  3. Forgetting a card. A card opened years ago for a store discount, or an account opened during a move, may sit in the window when you have stopped thinking about it. Read the report, not memory.
  4. Assuming a product change resets the date. When an issuer converts an existing account to another card, the account is usually the same one and keeps its original open date, but issuers handle this differently, so check how the date appears on your report.
  5. Treating a closed card as gone. Closing an account does not remove it from the count while its open date is still inside the window.
  6. Adding dates in the wrong direction. The test is 24 months back from the day you would apply, not 24 months from today.

Run the count twice, once for today and once for the date you are actually considering, and write both numbers down.

Why an issuer would care about recent accounts

The reasoning is ordinary underwriting, even if the specific rule is not published. A lender deciding whether to extend credit looks at risk. Opening several accounts in a short time can mean a person is stretching, is building rewards across many cards, or is otherwise a different risk than someone with a steady file. Scoring models also reflect this: the "new credit" part of a FICO Score, about 10 percent of the general model, looks at recent accounts and inquiries.

An issuer can also have goals that are not about risk. A rewards card with a large bonus costs money; an issuer may prefer to offer it to customers who are likely to keep and use the card instead of those who open many cards for bonuses. That is the practice often called churning, and approval-count practices are widely understood as a reaction to it.

Practices of this kind are sometimes called a velocity rule. The term describes a limit on how many accounts open in a period, whether per issuer or across issuers. Different issuers are reported to have different versions. A comparison of the commonly reported ones is in issuer application rules compared: velocity, lifetime and family limits, and the myths around them are tested in myths about 5/24 and other card approval rules, tested one by one.

What 5/24 is not

  • It is not a law or a regulation. No federal rule limits how many cards you may open or sets a count for approval.
  • It is not a credit-score measure. It is not part of FICO or VantageScore, and it does not appear on your credit report.
  • It is not a promise at four. Being under the line does not guarantee approval. Income, score, debts, recent inquiries and the issuer's relationship with you still matter.
  • It is not necessarily applied to every card or every issuer. Reports describe it as applying to most of one issuer's cards, not all products, and other issuers are reported to use different rules.
  • It is not a verdict on you. If you are over the line, it says something about the count, not about your finances.
  • It is not the only thing that matters. Inquiries, balances, income and payment history all feed into any decision.

If you are denied

If an application is declined, a creditor that takes adverse action must give a notice with specific reasons, or the right to request them, generally within 30 days of a completed application. That is the adverse action notice. Read it. The reasons given may mention recent accounts or inquiries, or something else entirely, and they tell you more than a forum post can.

You can ask the issuer to look at the decision again. That is called reconsideration, and the usual route is a call to the issuer's reconsideration line, using the number on the issuer's own site or your decline letter, never a number from an advertisement. You can also add information, such as income that was not on the application, if it is accurate. A reconsideration is not guaranteed to change the result, and in some cases a second try can lead to another hard inquiry, so ask what to expect before you proceed.

Every application is a hard inquiry, and a decline still leaves one. A single inquiry usually lowers a FICO Score by fewer than five points and is weighed for about a year, according to FICO's published guidance. That is small; the habit of applying repeatedly after declines is the larger risk.

Who should care, and who need not

For many people, 5/24 never matters. If you have two or three cards, opened over many years, the count is small, and the rule is not a constraint. It matters mainly to people who open several personal cards in a couple of years, often for rewards, and then want a card from the issuer reported to use it.

If you are in that group, the useful steps are descriptive: know your count, know the dates when it will fall, and know that other issuers have their own reported limits, which you can look up before you apply. If you are not in that group, the useful step is to know that the rule exists, so a forum post does not make you worry about a limit you are nowhere near. If you want to think about how many cards suit your own finances, see How many credit cards is too many? A decision list for your situation.

Key takeaways

  • 5/24 is a widely reported pattern, not an issuer-published rule: Chase commonly declines most of its cards when an applicant has opened five or more personal cards in 24 months.
  • The count is the number of personal cards opened in a rolling 24-month window, measured by account open date, backward from the day you would apply.
  • What counts is described differently across sources, especially for business cards, authorized-user accounts and co-brand cards; your own credit report is the check.
  • It is a rough marker for ordinary underwriting concerns about new credit, not a law, a score or a guarantee at four.
  • If you are declined, read the adverse action notice for the actual reasons, and ask about reconsideration before applying again.
  • Many people with a few older cards are nowhere near the line.

Terms used in this article

Related issuers

Related tools

Latest on this topic