Blog

Why choosing to pay in dollars at a foreign terminal usually costs more

How dynamic currency conversion works at terminals and ATMs abroad, who sets its exchange rate, and why paying in local currency is the safer default.

You tap your card at a restaurant in Lisbon and the screen asks a question in friendly English: pay 200.00 EUR, or pay in USD? Paying in your own currency sounds like the considerate option. You will see the dollar amount before you commit, there is no mystery about what the charge will be, and sometimes the screen says there is no fee. It is also the option that, in the usual case, costs you more. The service behind that question is called dynamic currency conversion, and understanding who does the conversion and who earns on it explains why travelers are commonly told to decline it.

This is a mechanics post. It explains the two routes a foreign purchase can take, shows a worked example with labeled hypothetical numbers, and gives a short procedure for declining. It is not a promise that declining is cheaper in every case, and the post says where the answer can go the other way.

The prompt you will see

Dynamic currency conversion, often shortened to DCC, is an offer made at the moment of payment to convert a foreign-currency price into your card's home currency. It appears in a few forms:

  • At a card terminal. After you insert, tap or swipe, the screen or the printed slip offers a choice between the local currency and dollars. Some terminals ask you to choose on screen. Others show a slip with a line to tick and sign.
  • At an ATM. After you enter the amount, the machine says it can convert the withdrawal to dollars for you and shows a rate, sometimes described as a "guaranteed" rate, and asks you to accept or decline.
  • At a hotel or restaurant desk. A clerk may ask if you would like the bill in dollars and run the card for the dollar total.
  • Online. A foreign merchant's checkout may offer to display and charge prices in dollars.

The language is designed to sound helpful: "pay in your currency," "see your exact cost," "no fee," "guaranteed rate." Some terminals pre-select the dollar choice, and some staff select it for you without asking. None of that is illegal in itself, and network rules for merchants generally expect the choice to be offered and your consent to be given, but the offer is a commercial service, not a favor.

Two routes for the same purchase

A foreign purchase can be converted into dollars in one of two places. The difference between those places is the whole story.

Route 1: you pay in the local currency. The merchant charges 200 euros. The merchant's bank, called the acquirer, sends the transaction through the card network in euros. The network converts the euros into dollars at its own exchange rate when the transaction is processed, and your issuer posts the dollar amount to your statement. If your card has a foreign transaction fee, the issuer adds that percentage on top of the converted amount. If your card has no foreign fee, the converted amount is all you pay. This is currency conversion done by the card network.

Route 2: you accept DCC. The merchant, or the company that runs its terminal, converts the price into dollars at the terminal before the transaction goes to the network. The charge is then sent to your issuer already in dollars. The rate used is the one the DCC provider chose, which is typically the market rate plus a markup. The merchant's processor generally shares in that markup, which is why DCC is offered so eagerly and why it is not shown to you as a line item.

Notice what Route 2 does not do: it does not remove the exchange-rate spread. It moves the spread from the card network to the terminal operator, and the terminal operator tends to set a larger spread than the network's.

Who sets the rate, and who is paid for it

In Route 1 the rate comes from the network. Card networks publish the rates they apply and update them regularly; the rate applied to a given purchase is generally the rate in effect when the transaction settles, which can be a day or more after you tapped. That timing is one reason the final statement amount can differ slightly from what you expected, and it is a normal feature of the process, not an error. Your issuer's added foreign fee, if any, is stated in the cardholder agreement and shows on your statement as a separate line.

In Route 2 the rate comes from the DCC provider. The provider and the merchant (or ATM operator) share the revenue from the markup, according to commonly described industry practice, though the terms of those arrangements are private. Your issuer is out of the picture on the conversion. Some issuers still apply their foreign fee to a purchase that has been converted to dollars at the terminal, because the merchant is foreign even though the amount is in dollars. Others do not. Your agreement defines which purchases carry the fee, and the Do I pay foreign transaction fees on online orders from abroad? post covers that question for online orders.

The result is that an offer which feels neutral to you is a revenue line for the merchant's side of the transaction. That does not make the person at the counter dishonest. It does mean the offer is not built around finding you the cheapest rate.

A worked example

Here is a labeled hypothetical to show the arithmetic. The exchange rate below is an illustration chosen for easy math, not a current rate, and the markup and fee percentages are illustrations, not any provider's or issuer's terms.

Say you owe 200 euros, and the market exchange rate is $1.10 per euro. Assume, for the example, that the network's rate matches the market rate.

Route How it is calculated You pay
Route 1 on a no-foreign-fee card 200 × $1.10 $220.00
Route 1 on a card with a 3% foreign fee $220.00 × 1.03 $226.60
Route 2 (DCC) with a 4% markup 200 × $1.10 × 1.04 $228.80
Route 2 (DCC) with a 2% markup 200 × $1.10 × 1.02 $224.40

Reading across the rows:

  • On a no-foreign-fee card, DCC is always more expensive than Route 1, because Route 1 has no added percentage. At a 4% markup you pay $8.80 more ($228.80 − $220.00).
  • On a card with a 3% foreign fee, the comparison depends on the size of the DCC markup. At 4%, DCC costs $2.20 more than Route 1 ($228.80 − $226.60). At 2%, DCC costs $2.20 less ($224.40 − $226.60). The break-even markup is the same as the fee: 3%.
  • If your card charges its foreign fee on the DCC transaction too, which some issuers do, DCC is worse by the whole fee: in the 4% case, $228.80 × 1.03 = $235.66, which is $15.66 more than the no-fee-card Route 1 amount.

So the honest summary is: DCC is a bad bargain on a card with no foreign fee, may be a close call on a card with one, and is clearly worse when a double charge can happen. In the second case, you cannot tell which way it goes unless you know the terminal's markup, and the terminal almost never tells you.

Why you cannot decide at the counter

The reason travelers are advised to decline is less that DCC is always more expensive and more that you cannot verify the price on the spot.

  • The markup is rarely shown as a percentage. You see an exchange rate, perhaps labeled "guaranteed." To know the markup, you would need the market rate at that minute and a calculator. In some places the law requires the markup to be disclosed against a published reference rate, but in many places you will see only the final dollar number.
  • The comparison is not offered. You are not shown what Route 1 would cost, because that conversion has not happened yet. You see one dollar number and one local number.
  • You are not at your sharpest. You are standing at a counter with a line behind you, in a language you may not speak, and the amount looks right.

A rule that does not depend on any of that is easier to follow. If the default is "always pay in the local currency," you never have to compare. The cost of that rule is that, in the sometimes-cheaper case above, you lose a couple of dollars. The cost of the opposite rule is that, in the usual case, you lose several.

ATMs and contactless payments

ATMs. The same offer appears after you enter your withdrawal amount. The machine shows a dollar total and says it will convert for you. If you accept, the operator sets the rate. If you decline, your bank converts the amount at the network's rate. Declining is the default advice here for the same reason. The machine's operator fee, and your own bank's fee, are separate charges and are not affected by your choice. The Card with a foreign fee, card without one, or cash? A trip compared comparison looks at the cost of carrying cash.

Tapping to pay. With a tap or a mobile wallet, the prompt can appear before or after the tap, depending on the terminal. A contactless payment does not change the conversion mechanics. Your phone supplies a token and the terminal and processor take it from there, as what actually happens when you tap your phone to pay in a store describes. If the currency choice shows up on the terminal's screen after you have tapped and you do not want DCC, look for a button or a prompt to change currency before it completes. If it has already gone through, check the receipt. Many merchants can void a same-day transaction and run it again in the local currency, though policies vary. It is worth asking politely, because a void is far easier than a dispute afterward.

How to decline, step by step

  1. Know the local currency before you pay. Look at the price tag, the menu or the bill. If the screen shows two amounts, the one in the local currency is the choice you want.
  2. When the terminal asks, choose the local currency. It may be labeled with the country's currency code, such as EUR, GBP or JPY, or simply "local currency." Avoid the choice labeled USD or "your currency."
  3. If staff ask whether you want to pay in dollars, say you will pay in the local currency.
  4. Read the screen before you tap or enter your PIN, since the choice can be one tap away from the wrong option.
  5. Check the receipt. A DCC slip typically shows two currencies, an exchange rate and sometimes a line such as "I accept the conversion" with a signature field. Do not sign it if you chose the other route.
  6. If you were converted without a clear choice, ask the merchant to void and re-run the transaction. If that does not work, contact the issuer by the number on the back of your card and explain that you were not given a real choice. The issuer will tell you whether it treats this as a dispute.
  7. At an ATM, press the option to decline the conversion and continue in the local currency.

When accepting is a reasonable choice

DCC is not a scam, and there are cases where a traveler may choose it knowingly. A person who values knowing the exact dollar figure at the moment of purchase may accept the premium for certainty. A person on a fixed daily budget who wants to avoid a surprise at statement time might do the same. A merchant who offers DCC with a clearly disclosed, low markup may be a close call or even cheaper than a card that adds a foreign fee, as the 2% row in the example shows. The advice to decline is a default for people who would otherwise have no way to compare, not a ruling on every case.

The cost of being wrong in either direction is small on a coffee and larger on a hotel bill, which is why large payments deserve the most attention. The foreign transaction fee calculator helps you run the same comparison for your own totals, and a pre-trip checklist for avoiding foreign card fees puts the decline step on a list you can carry.

Key takeaways

  • DCC moves the currency conversion from the card network to the terminal operator, which sets its own rate and shares in the markup; paying in the local currency leaves the conversion with the network.
  • On a card with no foreign fee, accepting DCC costs more in every case, by the size of the markup; on a card with a foreign fee, DCC can be slightly cheaper or slightly more expensive depending on whether its markup is below or above the fee percentage.
  • Some issuers apply their foreign fee even to a purchase converted at the terminal, which can charge you twice; check the agreement.
  • You usually cannot see the markup at the counter, so "always choose the local currency" is a rule that works without a calculator.
  • If you were converted without a real choice, ask the merchant to void and re-run the sale, and call the number on the back of your card if that fails.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic