Blog

Why some cards charge no annual fee and others charge hundreds

How issuers fund a card, why rewards and perks can outrun what merchants and interest pay, and what an annual fee buys you, with a labeled toy ledger.

A card's annual fee is a price for a bundle of things. A card with no fee has to pay for itself from other sources of income, so its rewards and perks are limited by what those sources can fund. A card with a large fee has an extra source of income, paid directly by the cardholder, which lets the issuer offer more rewards, credits and services than merchants and interest alone would cover. That is the whole explanation in two sentences. The rest of this post fills in the mechanism, so that when you see a fee, you can ask what it is paying for and whether you are the customer the card was priced for.

Every figure in the toy ledgers below is invented and labeled as an illustration. Real issuers do not publish their economics card by card, and this post names no issuer's rates, fees or terms. Those are on each card's profile.

Where a card's money comes from

A card issuer earns money from three broad sources.

  1. Merchant fees, often called interchange. When you pay with a card, the merchant does not receive the full amount. A fee comes out of it, a share of which flows to the issuer as an interchange fee. The rest goes to the networks and payment processors. Merchants build the cost into prices, which is why the topic is argued about in the courts, as in the Visa and Mastercard settlement that was before a federal judge in 2026. Press coverage of that settlement cited an average swipe fee of 2.36 percent, a merchant-side figure, not what an issuer keeps.
  2. Interest. Cardholders who do not pay the full statement balance pay interest. The CFPB's 2023 Consumer Credit Card Market report, as reported by secondary sources, estimated that issuers collected about $105 billion in interest and about $25 billion in fees in 2022. Those figures are estimates from the most recent edition we could find, and the report is the place to check them.
  3. Fees charged to the cardholder. Annual fees, late fees, cash-advance fees, balance-transfer fees and others. The same CFPB report put late fees at about $14.5 billion of the 2022 total, according to secondary summaries.

Underneath all three is a fourth source that does not appear on the ledger: the value of the relationship. An issuer that gives you a card may also hold your checking account, offer you a loan or a mortgage, and see your spending data. Banks vary in how much weight they place on that.

Which of these sources matters most depends on the customer. A person who pays in full every month produces merchant-fee income and no interest income. A person who carries a balance produces both. The Federal Reserve's survey of household economics found that 45 percent of cardholders carried a balance at least once in the prior 12 months in 2025, so the second group is large, and it is the reason some of the economics of rewards cards are debated.

A toy ledger for a no-fee card

Say a no-fee cash back card is used by a household that spends $20,000 a year and pays in full every month. Invented numbers:

Item Amount
Issuer's share of merchant fees at an illustrative 2% of $20,000 +$400
Cash back paid at 1.5% −$300
Servicing, fraud losses, statements, customer calls and marketing (illustrative) −$60
Left over +$40

At those figures, the no-fee card makes $40 on a customer who pays in full, which is not much. A customer who carries a balance changes it. Say another household has the same spending but averages a $3,000 balance at an illustrative 22% APR. That is roughly $660 in interest over the year ($3,000 × 0.22), which on the toy ledger turns the $40 into a much bigger number before counting the extra credit risk. That is why critics argue that households who carry balances help pay for the rewards of households who do not, and why issuers argue that interest compensates them for the risk of lending unsecured. Both positions describe the same ledger. Neither is a statement about any one card.

The practical takeaway is that a no-fee card's rewards rate is bounded. If the merchant fee income is about 2 percent in this toy world and the card pays out 1.5 percent, there is not much left for anything else. A card that paid out 3 percent on every purchase with no fee would lose money on a customer who pays in full, unless it earned it back some other way.

A toy ledger for a card with a large fee

Now take a premium card. Say a cardholder spends $30,000 a year, pays in full and gets a rich package: high rewards in a few categories, a set of credits, travel insurance and airport lounge access. Invented numbers:

Item Without a fee With a $350 fee
Issuer's share of merchant fees at 2% of $30,000 +$600 +$600
Annual fee $0 +$350
Rewards at an average of 2% −$600 −$600
Cost of credits, lounge visits and insurance −$250 −$250
Servicing and other costs −$100 −$100
Net −$350 $0

Without a fee, the package loses $350 per customer, because the rewards alone use up the merchant fee income and the perks come on top. With a fee set at the size of that gap, the card breaks even. Real card economics are more complicated and not published, but the structure holds: when the rewards and perks cost more than merchant fees and interest cover, the fee is what bridges the difference. That is why a premium card is hard to offer without one.

Two consequences follow. First, the fee is a rough signal of how much the issuer is giving away, which is why premium and luxury cards carry larger ones. It is not proof that the package is good value for you. Second, the fee is not the issuer's profit, since much of it goes straight back out in rewards and perks.

The fee as a filter

A fee also changes who holds the card. People who will pay $300 a year are, on average, people who expect to use the card a lot. Issuers can then design perks for that group, such as credits, lounge access and concierge services, knowing that the people who sign up have chosen to pay for them. An issuer cannot offer the same package to every applicant for free. Many cardholders who sign up for a premium card do not use every benefit, and it is reasonable to expect that card pricing takes this into account. That is one more reason to value credits at what you would use rather than at the list price, which how to count statement credits against an annual fee honestly explains how to do.

A fee also attaches a cost to the decision to keep a card, which is why renewal notices matter: after the first year the cardholder has to decide again. A reminder letter is a point at which many people re-do the sum, and some do not. five annual fee mistakes that quietly cost cardholders money describes what happens when they do not.

Different fees for different reasons

Not all annual fees do the same job. The main kinds:

  • Premium and charge-card fees. The toy ledger above. High rewards and perks, funded by the fee, for people who spend a lot and will use the benefits. Examples of the type are cards such as The Platinum Card from American Express and Chase Sapphire Reserve; their current fees and benefits are on their profiles and change over time. Press coverage in 2025 reported that several widely held premium cards raised their fees and added new credits at the same time, which is the pattern the toy ledger would predict: richer packages cost more.
  • Mid-priced rewards cards. A smaller fee that funds somewhat richer earning than the no-fee version, often in a few categories or on travel. The break-even point is lower and so is the margin for error, which is where the worksheet in how to work out whether a card's annual fee pays for itself is most useful.
  • Co-brand cards. Airline and hotel cards often charge a fee that covers perks such as checked bags or status benefits. Part of the economics here is that the airline or hotel typically sells its points to the issuer, which makes the fee only one piece of a three-party arrangement.
  • Credit-builder and subprime cards. Some cards for people with limited or damaged credit charge a fee, and often a high one in proportion to the credit line, because the issuer faces more losses from this group. Federal rules limit this: in the first year after an account opens, the total of most fees may not exceed 25 percent of the credit limit (late, over-limit and returned-payment fees are excluded from that cap). On a $300 limit, that means $75, and on a $500 limit $125. Whatever its size, the fee has to appear in the card's schumer box, the standard table every application must display.
  • No-fee cards. Funded by merchant fees, interest and the broader relationship. The rewards are generally simpler and lower, the benefits fewer. A no-fee card suits someone who is not sure they will use a fee card's features.

Why fees have been in the news

Annual fees on several widely held premium cards were raised in 2025, according to press coverage, with new credits added at the same time. That reflects the structure above: when issuers add rewards and perks, the cost has to come from somewhere, and a fee is the most direct place. It also shows why a fee should be re-examined when it changes, since the package you signed up for is not the package you hold.

A second pressure is the subject of an open debate. The Visa and Mastercard merchant settlement that a federal judge in Brooklyn preliminarily approved in 2026, as reported by the press, would lower some merchant fees for a period and give merchants more say over which cards they accept. It changes what merchants pay and how they accept cards. It does not directly change what a cardholder pays or the rewards a card earns. Some issuers and industry groups argue that lower merchant fees could eventually put pressure on rewards, and critics of the current system argue that merchant fees raise prices for everyone, including people who do not use rewards cards. That is a debate, not an outcome, and the settlement was still subject to final approval and appeals as of the latest coverage found. If rewards or fees do change because of it, the change would come through the notice process described above.

The takeaway for a cardholder is modest and practical. The economics behind a fee are not fixed, and the arrangement that made a card worth its price last year may not hold next year. A yearly review is how you notice.

What the law says about annual fees

Federal rules do not set the size of an annual fee. They set how it is disclosed and how it can change. The terms must be shown in the Schumer box, a standard table in applications and solicitations. In the first year after an account opens, an issuer generally may not raise a fee or charge, and the 25 percent first-year cap above applies. After that, an issuer that wants to raise a fee on an open account must give written notice at least 45 days before the change takes effect, and the notice must say that the cardholder can reject the change before its effective date. A valid rejection stops the change from applying, though the issuer may close the account to new use. My card's annual fee just went up. What are my options? is a walkthrough of that process.

Whether a fee is refundable if you cancel soon after it posts is a matter of the cardmember agreement, not federal law, so read the agreement or ask.

How to tell whether you are the customer the fee is priced for

The toy ledgers explain why a fee exists. They say nothing about whether a particular fee is worth paying. For that, the questions are personal:

  1. How much do I spend on the card each year, and in which categories? A card priced for people with large spending in a few categories will not reward a household with small, scattered spending.
  2. Which benefits would I use without the card? Count only those.
  3. Could a no-fee card earn nearly as much on my spending? If a no-fee card earns most of what the fee card does, the fee has to buy something else.
  4. Do I pay in full? A fee card is priced mostly for people who do. A household that carries a balance usually has more to gain from lowering its rate or its balance than from a richer rewards package.
  5. Would I notice the fee if it went up? If the answer is no, you probably have not been checking.

The annual fee break-even calculator turns the first three questions into a number, and Annual fee or no annual fee? Three households run the numbers shows what the answers look like for three different households.

Key takeaways

  • A card's rewards are funded by merchant fees, interest and cardholder fees. A no-fee card can only give away what those sources cover, and a fee adds a direct source.
  • In the labeled toy ledger, a premium package lost $350 per customer without a fee, and a fee of that size brought it to break-even. The fee is a rough signal of how much the issuer is giving away, not of how much it is worth to you.
  • A fee also filters who holds the card, which is why perks are designed for heavy users and why face value overstates what most cardholders get.
  • Fees do different jobs on premium, mid-priced, co-brand and credit-builder cards, and federal rules cap most first-year fees at 25 percent of the limit and require 45 days' notice of a rise afterward.
  • Ask whether you are the customer the fee was priced for: your spending, the benefits you would use anyway, the no-fee alternative and whether you pay in full.

Terms used in this article

Related credit cards

Related tools

Latest on this topic