Cash back comparison calculator
Put the same monthly spending on up to three cash back cards and see which earns the most after its annual fee, with bonus-category caps handled.
Runs entirely in your browser: nothing you enter is sent or stored by this site. Results are estimates for planning, not a quote or advice.
How to use it
Enter what you spend in a typical month in five groups: groceries, gas, dining, travel and everything else. Then describe up to three cards: the cash back percentage each pays in each group, its annual fee, and, if it has one, the yearly cap on bonus-rate spending. A sign-up bonus is optional and counts in year one only.
The results table updates as you type. It shows rewards earned, the fee, the net value after the first year, the net value in year one with the sign-up bonus, and the net as a share of your spending. A sentence under the table names the card that earns the most after fees.
The three starting cards are made up so the page works on first load. Replace every number with the terms on the cards you are actually looking at.
How the math works
All spending is annual: monthly amount times 12. For each card, the rate in the Everything else box is the base rate. Any group whose rate is higher than the base is a bonus group.
- Groups at or below the base rate earn their own rate on all spending in the group.
- Bonus groups share one yearly cap. The cap is filled with the highest rates first. Spending inside the cap earns the group's rate; the rest of that group's spending earns the base rate.
- Everything else earns the base rate.
- Rewards = the sum of spending times rate, divided by 100.
- Net value = rewards minus the annual fee. Year-one net value = net value plus the sign-up bonus.
With no cap entered, every bonus group earns its full rate.
Worked example (the starting numbers). Yearly spending is $6,000 on groceries, $1,800 on gas, $2,400 on dining, $1,200 on travel and $12,000 on everything else: $23,400 in all.
- Card A pays 2% everywhere: 23,400 x 2% = $468.00, no fee, so $468.00 net.
- Card B pays 6% on groceries and 3% on gas and dining, 1% on the rest, with a $6,000 cap and a $95 fee. Groceries use the whole cap: $360.00. Gas, dining, travel and everything else earn 1%: $18.00 + $24.00 + $12.00 + $120.00 = $174.00. Rewards $534.00, minus the fee, $439.00 net.
Card A comes out $29.00 ahead. Remove Card B's cap and its rewards become $360.00 + $54.00 + $72.00 + $12.00 + $120.00 = $618.00, or $523.00 net, which puts Card B $55.00 ahead.
What it assumes
- Every dollar of spending in a group earns that group's rate, and the same spending goes on every card.
- Cash back is worth face value: 3% is three cents back per dollar spent.
- The bonus cap is a yearly dollar amount of spending, shared by all of a card's bonus groups.
- Annual fees and sign-up bonuses are the amounts you type; the tool does not look up any card.
Where it stops being right
Many cards cap bonus rates per quarter or per month, rotate categories, or require activation; this tool uses one yearly cap and fixed categories. Issuers define "groceries" and "dining" by merchant category codes, so a purchase you think of as dining may earn the base rate. Statement credits, welcome offers that pay in points, and foreign transaction fees are not modelled. For cards that earn points rather than cash, use the card combination rewards optimizer, which lets you set a value per point.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026