Compare cards
Prime Visa (Amazon) vs Costco Anywhere Visa Card by Citi
Two no-fee store cards that each need a paid membership; the choice turns on Amazon and Whole Foods spending against gas, dining and travel.
Who should choose which
Both cards have no annual fee, but each depends on a paid membership that its profile does not price into the card: an eligible Amazon Prime membership for the Prime Visa, and an active paid Costco membership in your name for the Costco Anywhere Visa Card by Citi. NerdWallet lists Costco's Gold Star at $65 and Executive at $130 a year. Those memberships are a cost to count before choosing.
Choose the Prime Visa if you already pay for Prime and spend regularly at Amazon.com and Whole Foods Market, which earn 5% back (as of November 2026), as do Audible and Chase Travel purchases. It also pays 2% at gas stations, restaurants and local transit, and 1% elsewhere.
Choose the Costco Anywhere Visa if you already hold a Costco membership and spend on gas, dining and travel. It pays 5% on gas at Costco, 4% on other eligible gas and EV charging, 3% on restaurants and eligible travel, 2% on other Costco and Costco.com purchases and 1% elsewhere. The 5% and 4% gas rates share a $7,000 yearly cap, then 1%.
The number that decides it: where the dollars go
Say a household spends $20,000 a year: $3,000 at Amazon.com and Whole Foods, $4,000 at gas stations other than Costco, $4,000 at restaurants and $9,000 on everything else, none at Costco.
- Prime Visa: 3,000 x 5% = $150; 4,000 x 2% = $80; 4,000 x 2% = $80; 9,000 x 1% = $90. Total $400.
- Costco Anywhere Visa: 3,000 x 1% = $30; 4,000 x 4% = $160; 4,000 x 3% = $120; 9,000 x 1% = $90. Total $400.
The two tie in this example. Moving $1,000 from Amazon and Whole Foods to gas changes the result by $60: the Prime Visa loses $50 - $20 = $30 and the Costco card gains $40 - $10 = $30. So Amazon-heavy spending favors the Prime Visa, and gas, dining and travel favor the Costco card.
The rewards also arrive differently. Chase's page states each point is worth $0.01 toward Amazon.com purchases, and says redemption values vary for other options. The Costco card issues its cash back once a year as a certificate after your February statement closes, redeemed at U.S. Costco warehouses (or by ACH deposit if you earn at least $300, per Citi's benefits page of November 2025).
Welcome offers differ: the Prime Visa lists an Amazon Gift Card on approval for Prime members who do not hold an Amazon Visa or Prime Visa, and Chase's page showed both $150 and $200 in November 2026, so confirm the amount. The Costco profile lists no welcome offer.
What is the same
Both are Visa cards with no annual fee and no foreign transaction fee, with purchase APRs that overlap: 18.99%-27.74% variable on the Prime Visa and 18.99%-27.49% on the Costco card, as listed in November 2026. Neither lists an intro APR on the pages read.
What neither does
Neither earns more than 2% on general spending, and each ties its highest rate to one retailer's ecosystem. The Prime Visa has a Chase approval pattern, 5/24, that is widely reported but not published; see chase 5/24 rule.
When to choose neither
For flat cash back anywhere without a membership, the Costco profile points to Citi Double Cash Card and Chase Freedom Unlimited. Shoppers without Prime may prefer the Amazon Visa, which Chase lists at 3% at Amazon.com, Audible, Whole Foods and Chase Travel. The cash back comparison calculator tests your own spending mix.
Side by side
| Prime Visa (Amazon) | Costco Anywhere Visa Card by Citi | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Store and retail | Store and retail |
| Annual fee | $0 | $0 with an active paid Costco membership |
| Purchase APR | 18.99%-27.74% variable (as of November 2026) | 18.99%-27.49% variable on purchases and balance transfers (as listed by NerdWallet and CNBC, November 2026) |
| Intro APR | — | No introductory APR (as listed by NerdWallet) |
| Balance transfer fee | Greater of $5 or 4% of each transfer (as of November 2026) | 5% of each transfer, $5 minimum (as listed by CNBC, November 2026) |
| Cash advance APR | 28.74% variable (as of November 2026) | — |
| Cash advance fee | Greater of $5 or 4% of each transaction (as of November 2026) | — |
| Foreign transaction fee | No foreign transaction fee (as of November 2026) | No foreign transaction fee |
| Late fee | Up to $39 (as of November 2026) | — |
| Penalty APR | Up to 29.99% variable (as of November 2026) | — |
| How it earns | 5% back at Amazon.com, Audible.com, Whole Foods Market and on Chase Travel purchases with an eligible Prime membership; 2% back at gas stations, restaurants and local transit and commuting, including rideshare; 1% back on all other purchases; limited-time Prime Card Bonus offers of 10% or more on selected Amazon items (as of November 2026) | 5% cash back on gas at Costco; 4% on other eligible gas and EV charging (5% and 4% share a $7,000 yearly cap, then 1%); 3% on restaurants and eligible travel; 2% on other Costco and Costco.com purchases; 1% on everything else (as of November 2026) |
| Welcome offer | Amazon Gift Card loaded on approval for Prime members who do not hold an Amazon Visa or Prime Visa; Chase's page showed both $150 and $200 in November 2026, so confirm the amount (offers change) | — |
| Issuer | Chase | Citi |
| Network | Visa | Visa |
| Type | Co-brand store card | Store and retail |
| Status | Open to new applicants | Open to new applicants |
| Credit needed | Good to excellent | Excellent (NerdWallet lists 720 or better as the recommended score) |
| Best suited to | Amazon Prime members who spend regularly at Amazon.com and Whole Foods Market. | Costco members who spend heavily on gas, dining and travel and want a no-fee card. |
| Key benefits |
|
|
| Drawbacks |
|
|
Facts come from each profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. APRs are variable and offers change: confirm on the issuer's own page before you apply.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026