Blog

A checklist of what changes before you close a credit card

Eight checks before closing a card: balance, points and credits, recurring charges, utilization, account age, fee timing, alternatives and the paper trail.

Closing a card takes one phone call and cannot easily be undone. Some issuers will reopen an account on request and others will not, and a new account in its place is a new application. The call is worth making after you have gone through the checks below, in roughly this order. Each section ends with the question it is meant to answer, and the last one gives you a short version to print. The worked numbers use invented limits and balances, and the example rates are illustrations, not market figures.

How to use the checklist

Pull up three things before you start: your most recent statement for the card, your latest credit report, and the card's benefits page or cardmember agreement. You can get free credit reports from each of the three bureaus through AnnualCreditReport.com. The goal is not to talk yourself out of closing the card. It is to know exactly what you are giving up and when, so that the closing is a decision, not a reflex.

If the reason is that the card is compromised, stop and call the number on the back of the card first. A card that has been used fraudulently usually does not need to be closed: issuers can block the old number and issue a new one on the same account, which keeps your history intact. If the issuer's response seems wrong, the CFPB takes complaints at its website.

Check 1: the balance and the payments

Question: what do I owe, and what happens to it? Closing an account does not erase what you owe on it. The account closure stops new purchases, and the balance remains. You will usually still receive statements, and interest continues to accrue on a balance carried after closing under the cardmember agreement's terms. If a promotional rate applied to a balance, ask what happens to it.

Go through these:

  1. Find the full payoff amount, including interest that will accrue between now and the date the payment arrives. A statement balance is not always the amount needed to bring the account to zero.
  2. Decide how you will pay it. If you plan to pay the balance by moving it to another card, that is a balance transfer with its own fee and rate, and the arithmetic is different. Do not use a cash advance to pay off a card.
  3. Check pending charges and refunds. A pending charge that posts after the account is closed may be declined, and a return credited after closure may be handled by a check or a transfer. Ask the issuer how it treats those.
  4. Remove autopay that draws from your bank for this card, or keep it long enough to pay the final balance. If autopay is the only thing keeping the account current, closing it without a plan can lead to a missed payment. autopay, subscriptions and rewards when your issuer closes your card covers the same ground when the issuer is the one closing.

Check 2: points, cash back and credits

Question: what rewards or credits will I lose? Rewards earned on the card are the most common thing people forfeit by closing. Whether they survive depends on the program. In some programs points sit in a pool that is shared across several cards, and closing one card leaves the points available as long as another eligible card stays open. In others, points belong to the card account and are lost, or must be redeemed within a short time, when the account closes. The program's terms or the card's profile on this site explain which kind of program you are in.

A labeled example: Say the account holds 38,000 points and the program redeems for cash at 1 cent each. Cash redemptions are generally worth about 1 cent per point, and travel redemptions can be worth more or less, so points values are estimates, not promises. The cash value in this example is 38,000 × $0.01 = $380. That is what closing without redeeming could cost.

Go through these:

  1. Find your points or cash back balance and redeem or transfer it before closing, if the program allows it. Ask whether the issuer will let you move points to another card in the same program.
  2. List unused credits and certificates: annual travel or dining credits, free night certificates, companion passes. A credit that renews on your account anniversary may not be recoverable once the card is closed. A statement credit that has not yet posted is worth checking too.
  3. Check pending rewards, such as a welcome offer you are still earning or a bonus that posts after a statement. Closing a card before a bonus posts can cancel it.
  4. Think about the benefits you may be using without noticing: rental-car coverage, purchase protection, travel insurance, lounge access, cell phone protection. The card's Guide to Benefits lists what is covered and for how long after closure. Benefits such as extended warranties generally apply to purchases made while the account was open, and the terms vary.

Check 3: recurring charges and linked accounts

Question: what will break when this number stops working? A closed card number can cause failed payments on things you forgot were attached to it.

  1. Look at the last three statements and list every recurring charge: streaming and software subscriptions, insurance premiums, gym memberships, utility and phone bills, charitable gifts.
  2. Move each one to another card or to a bank account before the closing date. Some merchants require a new authorization.
  3. Check the digital wallet, ride-sharing and delivery apps, travel profiles and any retailer where the card is saved.
  4. Look for hotel, rental car or airline reservations held on the card number. Some bookings need the same card present at check-in.
  5. Check authorized users. If someone has a card on the account, tell them and decide what happens to the account on their file. Removal can change that person's credit file, so give them notice.
  6. Check anything that sends refunds to the card, such as a pending return or a deposit.

Check 4: credit utilization

Question: how much total limit am I removing, and what does it do to the ratio? credit utilization is the share of your total revolving limits that you are using. Closing a card removes its limit from the denominator, so the ratio rises unless you also reduce balances.

A labeled example. Say you have three cards:

Card Limit Balance
Card A $8,000 $0
Card B $4,000 $2,500
Card C $3,000 $500
Total $15,000 $3,000

Before: $3,000 ÷ $15,000 = 20 percent.

If you close Card C, which has a small balance, you still owe $500, and the remaining limits are $12,000. If you pay Card C to zero first, the total balance is $2,500 and the ratio is $2,500 ÷ $12,000 = 20.8 percent.

If you close Card A instead, which has no balance, the total limit falls to $7,000 and the balance stays $3,000: $3,000 ÷ $7,000 = 42.9 percent. A card with no balance is the one whose closing does the most damage to the ratio, because all of its limit disappears and none of its balance does. Experian says utilization above roughly 30 percent starts to weigh more heavily on scores, and FICO does not publish a magic number. The close-a-card utilization impact calculator runs this arithmetic for your own cards, and how a credit limit change moves your utilization, worked out by hand shows the steps by hand.

If you plan to apply for a mortgage or an auto loan within the next several months, give the timing particular attention. card habits in the months before a mortgage application, in order describes how lenders read recent changes.

Check 5: account age and credit mix

Question: is this the account that holds up my history? length of credit history is about 15 percent of a FICO Score in the general model, and credit mix and new credit are about 10 percent each, according to FICO's published description. The oldest account on your report is the one to look at.

  1. Look at your credit report and find the open date of each card.
  2. Identify the oldest account and the average age of your accounts if the report or a score service shows it.
  3. Understand that a closed account in good standing generally continues to appear on your credit report, and how long it does and how a scoring model treats it are questions for the bureaus and for the particular model. The report is the best evidence. A closed account does not necessarily vanish from your history the day you close it, but it also will not keep growing in the way an open account does, and it cannot help utilization.
  4. Count your accounts. If this is your only card, or one of two, the file may become thin, which is a different problem from losing a few months of age.
  5. Consider what you will open next. A new account adds a hard inquiry and resets the average age downward, so closing an old card and opening a new one in the same year works against both.

Check 6: the fee and the calendar

Question: when do I pay, and when do I get something back? The timing of a closing around an annual fee matters in both directions.

  1. Find the date the annual fee posts, usually on or near the account anniversary. Issuers generally have to give notice before significant changes to account terms, but you should look at the actual statement.
  2. If the fee has not yet posted, closing or changing the card before the date avoids it. when the annual fee posts, and what happens if you cancel around it lays out how the days around the fee run.
  3. If the fee posted recently, ask the issuer whether it refunds the fee in whole or part when an account is closed soon after it posts. Some do and some do not, and a refund is not required by law in general. A fee of $95 posted four months ago would leave eight months of the year, so a pro-rata refund would be $95 × 8 ÷ 12 = $63.33 if the issuer offered one. This is an illustration, not a promise any issuer makes.
  4. Check for a penalty. Federal rules bar a penalty fee for account closure, so a closing fee is not allowed as a penalty; if a charge surprises you, ask the issuer to explain it and use the CFPB complaint process if the explanation is unsatisfactory.
  5. Use up the benefits first if the account is close to renewal and you are not going to keep it, but only for purchases you would make anyway.

Check 7: alternatives to closing

Question: is there a way to get what I want without closing? Before you close, ask whether a different arrangement achieves the same goal.

  • A product change converts the account to a different card at the same issuer. You keep the account and its history, and may stop paying a fee. What carries over and what does not is explained in how a product change works and what carries over to the new card.
  • A retention offer is a fee waiver, statement credit or bonus points that an issuer sometimes offers when a customer says they are about to cancel. There is no guarantee, and you should not call only to ask for one. The decision framework is in I have an annual fee card I barely use. Keep, downgrade or close it?.
  • Keeping the card open and quiet. A no-fee card with no balance costs nothing and holds its limit. Issuers can close accounts that are inactive for a long time, so ask the issuer what its policy is. A small recurring charge that is paid in full by autopay can keep an account active, as long as it is a purchase you would make anyway and you check the statement.
  • Asking for a lower limit is possible on some cards if the reason is the fee or the temptation, and the arithmetic is in the worksheet above.

Check 8: the paper trail

Question: how will I prove it was done, and how will I check it?

  1. Close the account only by phone or in writing, using a channel the issuer offers. Ask for the date it will be effective.
  2. Ask for a confirmation in writing, by mail or in your secure messages, and save it.
  3. Destroy the card and remove it from every digital wallet after the closing is confirmed.
  4. Check your credit report one to two statement cycles later. The account should show as closed, and usually as closed at your request. If it shows anything that is wrong, dispute it with the bureau. A bureau must reinvestigate within 30 days of receiving the dispute, which can extend by up to 15 days if you send more information.
  5. Recompute your utilization at the next statement and compare it with the arithmetic you did.
  6. Keep the record of any points or credits you redeemed, in case there is a dispute over them later.

The short version to print

  1. I know the payoff amount and have a plan to pay it.
  2. I have redeemed or transferred rewards and used any credits I would otherwise lose.
  3. I have moved every recurring charge and checked wallets, reservations and apps.
  4. I have calculated utilization with and without the card, and no loan application is imminent.
  5. I know the card's open date and whether it is my oldest account.
  6. I know when the annual fee posts and what a refund would be, if any.
  7. I have asked about a product change, a retention offer and keeping the card open.
  8. I will get written confirmation and check my credit report afterward.

Key takeaways

  • Closing an account does not erase the balance. Plan the payoff, and move or end autopay deliberately.
  • Rewards and credits are often the largest thing forfeited. Find the balance, check whether the program pools points, and redeem first.
  • A card with no balance can do the most harm to utilization when closed, because its whole limit leaves the denominator: in the example, 20 percent became 42.9 percent.
  • A closed account in good standing generally continues to appear on a credit report, but it stops helping utilization and stops growing in age. Look at your own report for the details.
  • A product change, a retention offer or leaving the card open can often achieve the goal without closing it. Get any closing confirmed in writing and check your report afterward.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic