Blog

How a product change works and what carries over to the new card

Converting a card to another at the same issuer: what stays (account, history, usually the limit), what changes (rewards, fee, benefits) and bonus questions.

A product change converts the account you already have into a different card from the same issuer. You do not open a new account and you do not close the old one: the issuer changes which product the account is. The account's history normally continues, but the rewards, annual fee, benefits and sometimes the account number change with the new product. If you are thinking about closing a card because of its fee, this is the option to understand first. It does not apply everywhere. Issuers decide which conversions they allow, and many cards have no conversion path at all.

The idea in one paragraph

Inside an issuer's systems, a credit card account is a record: an owner, an open date, a balance, a limit, a payment history, and a product code that determines the pricing and the benefits. A product change edits the product code and, if needed, creates a new card number and plastic. The record remains. That is why the open date and payment history usually stay, why the credit limit often stays, and why the issuer does not need to treat the change as a new application. It is also why the change is the issuer's to approve: the new product has its own rules about who can hold it and how it can be reached from another one.

What usually carries over

The table lists the common pattern. "Usually" means the pattern is widespread, not that every issuer follows it, and details vary between issuers and even between product pairs at the same issuer. Ask each question before you agree.

Item What usually happens
Account open date and payment history Stay with the account. The account's tradeline on your credit report generally continues, and its age keeps counting
Credit limit Often stays; the issuer may adjust it, and different products have different limit ranges
Current balance Stays. You still owe it, and you still have to pay by the due date
Account number May stay, or a new number and card may be issued
Authorized users Usually continue, but each may receive a new card and the new product may have different fees for them
Autopay setup Typically stays linked to your bank account; check it after the change
Digital wallet and saved merchant numbers May need updating if the card number changes
Credit report entry The account may be shown under the new product name, or the old name may remain; it is typically the same account line

On the credit side, the main reason people like a product change over a closing plus a new application is the continuity of the account. length of credit history is about 15 percent of a FICO Score in the general model, according to FICO's published description. When the same account continues, the age that it contributes continues too. How the credit bureaus display the converted account is up to the issuer's reporting, so check your report afterward.

What usually changes

  • The annual fee. The new product has its own fee, which may be lower, zero or higher. The annual fee on the new product and the date it starts are among the first things to confirm.
  • The rewards structure. Earning categories, rates and redemption options belong to the product. A card that earned five times on one category may earn a flat rate afterward, or nothing special at all.
  • Benefits. Travel insurance, rental-car coverage, purchase protection, lounge access and statement credits that came with the old card typically end. The new card's Guide to Benefits lists what it includes and when.
  • APR and fees. The new product has its own interest rates and fees, published in its pricing table. Ask in writing what rate will apply to your current balance and to new purchases, and compare it with the old one. APRs are variable and move with the prime rate, so ask for the margin, not only today's number.
  • The network or tier. Some conversions move the account from one payment network or card tier to another, which can affect acceptance abroad and the benefits that depend on the tier.
  • Eligibility for the old product's bonus. This is covered below.

A downgrade is a conversion to a card with a lower fee and fewer benefits, and an upgrade is the reverse. When an issuer arranges a downgrade as a courtesy to keep a customer who was about to cancel, it is sometimes called a soft landing downgrade. These labels are informal. What matters is what the issuer's written confirmation says.

Rewards: the question that costs the most when it is wrong

Of all the items, rewards are where an uninformed conversion can lose real money. Two patterns, with a labeled example. Say the account holds 60,000 points, and the program's cash redemption value is 1 cent per point. Cash redemption is typically worth about 1 cent per point, and travel redemptions can be worth more or less, so any point value is an estimate.

Pattern one: the new card earns in the same program. Some issuers run one rewards program across several cards, and the points sit in the program, not on one card. If the old and new cards are both in the program, a conversion usually leaves the points where they are. In the example they remain 60,000 points, worth $600 at 1 cent each if you cash them out.

Pattern two: the new card is in a different program or earns cash back. The old points may be converted at a ratio the issuer sets, cashed out, or lost. Say the issuer offers to convert at 1 cent per point and deposit the result as a statement credit: 60,000 × $0.01 = $600. Say it instead offers nothing, and the points disappear. The gap between those two outcomes is $600, which is more than most people save by dropping a fee for a year or two. An issuer will not always volunteer which one applies, so ask.

Before you agree, find out:

  1. Whether the points will stay, convert, or be forfeited, and at what ratio.
  2. Whether you can redeem first. If the program has transfer partners, whether you can transfer the points before the change. Do not assume a partner's value; check it with the partner.
  3. Whether any pending bonus, such as one still being earned toward a minimum spend, survives.
  4. What happens to any certificates or credits you have not yet used.

The annual fee and the calendar

Timing around the fee can matter as much as the choice of product. A common sequence runs like this:

  1. The fee posts on or around the account anniversary and appears on a statement.
  2. You decide the card is not worth it, or you have a better use of the money.
  3. You call and ask for a product change. The issuer may refund some or all of the fee if the change is made soon after it posts; some issuers do and some do not.

A labeled example of what a pro-rata refund would look like if an issuer offered one: say the fee is $150 and it posted two months ago. The remaining ten months of the year are $150 × 10 ÷ 12 = $125. Some issuers refund the whole fee within a window of weeks after it posts, some refund nothing, and a refund is not a legal requirement in general. Read the cardmember agreement or ask the issuer.

If the fee has not yet posted, converting before the anniversary can avoid it. when the annual fee posts, and what happens if you cancel around it shows how the days around the fee line up, and I have an annual fee card I barely use. Keep, downgrade or close it? compares the three choices of keeping, downgrading and closing when the fee is the issue.

What a product change does to your credit

The effect depends on three things:

  • Inquiries. A product change is commonly handled without a new application. Many issuers do it without a hard inquiry, because you are not asking for new credit. Some issuers may ask for a review, and the issuer can tell you whether one is involved before you agree. If it is, a single hard inquiry usually lowers a FICO Score by fewer than five points and is weighed for about a year, according to FICO.
  • Account age and history. The account continues. Compared with closing the card, this keeps the account's age and its limit in your file. The close-a-card utilization impact calculator shows what closing would do to your utilization, which is what you avoid by converting.
  • Limit. If the limit stays, utilization does not change. If the issuer lowers it, the utilization on the account may rise, so confirm the new limit before you agree. For an example of the arithmetic, see a checklist of what changes before you close a credit card.

Welcome bonuses and later eligibility

Two questions come up. The first is whether the product change earns a welcome offer on the new card. As a rule it does not: welcome offers are generally tied to opening a new account, and a converted account is not a new account. Some issuers make exceptions, and the terms of any offer you are shown are the document that decides.

The second is whether the conversion affects your future eligibility for a bonus on one of the issuer's cards. Several issuers are widely reported to apply internal rules, such as limits on repeat bonuses within the same product family over a period of years, but these are not published by the issuers and they change. A product change might or might not reset or start such a clock, and the issuer's representative may not be able to say. If a future welcome offer matters to you, ask this explicitly and note the answer. welcome bonus describes how offers are typically structured, and the issuer's offer terms govern.

When the issuer changes your card without asking

Sometimes the issuer, not you, ends a product and moves cardholders to another one, or changes a card's terms. For a credit card account, federal rules require written notice at least 45 days before the effective date of a rate increase or other significant change to account terms on an open-end account that is not secured by a home (12 CFR 1026.9(c)(2)(i)(A)). That notice must tell you that you may reject the change before its effective date. A valid rejection stops the change from applying and cannot be treated as a default, but the issuer may close the account to new use. The right does not apply once your minimum payment is more than 60 days late. A change-in-terms notice is the document that carries this information, and it is worth reading line by line when it arrives.

An issuer-initiated conversion is different from one you request. When you ask for a product change, you are agreeing to the new terms, so the rejection right in the notice rules is not the tool. When the issuer moves you, you have the notice and the choice to reject, and rejecting may lead to the account being closed to new purchases, so compare the new terms with your alternatives before you decide.

How to request one

  1. List what you use. Check the last twelve months of statements for categories you earn in, credits you used and benefits you have claimed.
  2. Check the issuer's website or app for the cards it offers as conversions. Some issuers list them in the account's menu.
  3. Call the number on the back of your card or use secure messaging. Ask what products the account can be converted to, not only the one you have in mind.
  4. Ask the questions in this post: limit, rewards, fee timing and refund, APR on the current balance, authorized users, new card number, effect on any bonus or credit.
  5. Get the terms in writing before you agree, through the secure message center or a letter.
  6. After the change, check the next statement, the credit report and every autopay and saved card, and update the ones that need it.

When a product change is not the answer

  • The new product has no feature you need, and the only reason you are keeping the account is the history. A small fee that you can afford may be the better choice, or closing may be fine.
  • The issuer does not offer a conversion path from your card. You may then choose between keeping it, closing it, and applying for something new.
  • Your goal is a better rewards fit, not a lower fee. A new account has costs of its own, including an inquiry and a reset of new-account effects, but it may earn a welcome offer. The decision needs arithmetic on both sides.
  • You are carrying a balance, and your actual problem is the interest. A conversion does not lower the balance. A payoff plan, a balance transfer or a nonprofit credit counselor addresses the balance.

Key takeaways

  • A product change edits an existing account instead of opening a new one, so the open date, payment history and usually the credit limit continue.
  • What changes is the product: rewards, annual fee, benefits, APR and sometimes the card number. Ask for each in writing before you agree.
  • Rewards are the item most likely to be lost. Find out whether points stay, convert or vanish, and redeem first if the answer is unclear. In the example, 60,000 points at 1 cent were worth $600.
  • A product change usually does not earn a new welcome offer, and the effect on later bonus eligibility is the issuer's internal rule, so ask.
  • If the issuer changes your card, you have a 45-day notice and a right to reject; if you request the change, you are accepting the new terms.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic