Blog

A checklist for auditing your subscriptions before you pick a streaming card

Twelve checks that turn a pile of recurring charges into one monthly figure, show which ones a streaming bonus would cover, and tell you what to cancel first.

Cards that pay extra on streaming and entertainment through a bonus category are priced against a number most people do not actually know: how much they spend on subscriptions each month. The guess is usually low, because recurring charges are designed to be forgotten. A video service signed up for a free trial, a music plan billed once a year, a news site that renewed at a higher price. Before choosing a card for streaming, find out what you pay, which of those charges a bonus would cover, and which you should cancel instead. Cancelling often saves more than any bonus rate can earn.

This post is a checklist of twelve steps, in order. It carries one invented household through the numbers so you can see each step produce a figure. The services, prices and rates are made up for illustration. Real services change prices, and a real card's terms are in its agreement and on its profile page.

Before you start

You need about an hour, twelve months of statements from every card and bank account you pay subscriptions from, and a spreadsheet or a sheet of paper with five columns: what it is, how much, how often, how it is billed and whether you use it. Twelve months, not one, because annual and quarterly charges do not appear in a single month's statement.

If you have a monthly review habit already, for example the one in a monthly statement review worksheet, line by line, in about 15 minutes, you have the raw material. If you want a broader recurring-charge audit that covers every kind of subscription and not just entertainment, a subscriptions audit worksheet for the recurring charges on your cards goes further than this post does.

The twelve checks

Check 1: Pull a full year of statements

Download or open twelve months of each statement for each card and for any bank account that pays subscriptions by direct debit. If your issuer offers an annual summary, use it for a cross-check, but go to the individual statements for the detail. A year catches the quarterly plan, the annual renewal and the price rise in month seven.

Check 2: Mark every recurring charge

Scan for charges that repeat at the same amount at regular intervals, and for charges with the same merchant name at different amounts. Mark each. Include the small ones: three or four dollars a month for cloud storage or an app feature add up. Do not decide yet whether to keep anything, and do not build a budget around the total until you have seen all of it. The job in this step is to find them all.

Check 3: Record the amount and the frequency

For each charge write the amount and how often it comes: monthly, quarterly, annually, or irregularly. If a price changed during the year, record the current price and note the change.

Check 4: Convert everything to a monthly equivalent

Divide annual charges by 12 and quarterly ones by 3, so every line is comparable. An annual $72 app plan is $6 a month. An annual $96 video plan is $8 a month.

Here is the example household's list after Checks 1 to 4. The services are invented.

Service Billing Monthly equivalent
Video service A $12 a month $12
Video service B $18 a month $18
Video service C $96 a year $8
Music service $11 a month $11
Online game subscription $17 a month $17
News site $5 a month $5
Cloud storage $3 a month $3
Meditation app $72 a year $6
Total $80

Check the total: 12 + 18 + 8 + 11 + 17 + 5 + 3 + 6 = 80. That is $960 a year ($80 x 12). The household thought it spent "about $50" on subscriptions.

Check 5: Note how each one is billed

The merchant on your statement is not always the service. A subscription can be billed:

  • directly by the service, which usually shows the service's name;
  • through a phone or app-store account, which shows the platform's name and may carry the platform's merchant code;
  • through a mobile carrier or a bundle with another product;
  • through a third-party reseller, such as a discount site that sells subscription access.

Write the billing path next to each line. It matters for rewards because the card sees the merchant that charged it, and the category follows that merchant. A video service billed through an app-store account is the platform's charge. Why marketplace and PayPal checkouts sometimes skip your bonus category explains why payment paths change the category.

Check 6: Check what your card's terms call streaming

Find the card's definition of the category. Streaming bonuses are often limited to video and music services. Gaming, news, cloud storage and fitness apps may be excluded or may be coded in other categories. If the terms list eligible services, check yours against the list. If they only describe a category in words, you cannot know without testing.

Check 7: Test the uncertain ones

For any subscription whose coding you cannot tell from the terms, look at how the charge earned on the card you pay with now. If you pay with a plain card that has no category bonus, you cannot learn anything from it, so ask the issuer of the card you are considering whether a given service counts, and keep the answer. A written answer is better than a chat guess.

In the example, suppose the household's research finds that the four video and music lines ($49 a month) count, that the online game subscription is uncertain, that the news site is coded as news and publishing and does not count, and that cloud storage and the meditation app do not.

  • Counted: 12 + 18 + 8 + 11 = $49 a month.
  • Uncertain: $17 a month for the game subscription.
  • Not counted: 5 + 3 + 6 = $14 a month.
  • Check: 49 + 17 + 14 = 80, the total.

Check 8: Ask whether you used each one in the last 60 days

For each line, answer honestly: did I open it in the last two months? The streaming wasteland is made of services that were used heavily for one show and then forgotten. A service you used once in two months and could rejoin at any time is a cancellation candidate, because rejoining for a month costs less than paying for the idle ones.

Also look for overlap. Two video services that carry similar content are not both indispensable.

Check 9: Check the renewal dates and the trial conversions

Find when each annual plan renews and mark it on a calendar. Look for any charge that started as a free trial and converted to paid. A calendar reminder one week before each annual renewal gives you a chance to cancel before the charge, which is easier than disputing it afterward. Note the date each price change began so the next one stands out.

Check 10: Cancel what you will not miss, and count the savings

Cancel before you choose a card. Then add up what you save.

In the example the household cancels video service C. It is the one used least and has the most overlap with A and B. The saving is $8 a month, or $96 a year. That one decision is worth more than the bonus it is trying to earn, as the next check shows.

Check 11: Price the bonus on what remains

Now compare a streaming card with a plain flat-rate card on the subscriptions you actually keep. Say the streaming card pays an illustrative 4% cash back on counted services and the flat card pays 2%. The gap is 2 percentage points on counted spending. (The cash back comparison calculator runs this comparison with your own figures.)

  • Counted before cancelling: $49 a month x 12 = $588 a year. The gap: $588 x 2% = $11.76 a year.
  • Counted after cancelling video service C: $41 a month x 12 = $492 a year. The gap: $492 x 2% = $9.84 a year.
  • Savings from cancelling: $96 a year, which is about 8.2 times the original bonus gap ($96 / $11.76 = 8.16) and about 9.8 times the post-cancellation gap ($96 / $9.84 = 9.76).

If the uncertain game subscription also counts, add $17 x 12 = $204 to the counted spending: $492 + $204 = $696, and the gap is $696 x 2% = $13.92 a year.

A streaming bonus of this size, a few dollars a month, cannot carry an annual fee. At a 2-point gap, a $95 fee needs $4,750 a year of counted subscription spending, about $396 a month, which is nearly five times the whole $80 this household pays for every subscription it has. If a streaming card has a fee, its value has to come from somewhere else, and the annual fee break-even calculator helps you find out where.

Check 12: Plan the switch so nothing lapses

Changing the card behind your subscriptions is an administrative job with one risk: a payment that fails because it is still tied to a card you stopped using, or to one that has been closed. Before you move anything:

  1. List every subscription with the card it is currently on.
  2. Add the new card as the payment method on each service first, then remove the old one.
  3. Check that autopay on both cards is still set, since a missed payment on the old card costs more than any bonus pays.
  4. Do not close the old card until at least one full billing cycle has passed with no charges from the old subscriptions. autopay, subscriptions and rewards when your issuer closes your card covers what happens when a card goes away unexpectedly.

The household's result in one table

Step Action Annual effect
Audit Found $80 a month in subscriptions, $960 a year Baseline, not a saving
Cancel Dropped video service C Saves $96
Streaming bonus 2-point gap on $492 counted Earns $9.84 over a flat card
Fee Choose a no-fee card $0
Total benefit beyond the audit $105.84

The arithmetic: $96 + $9.84 = $105.84. Less than ten percent of that total came from the card.

Special cases the checklist can miss

Bundles and carrier billing. A streaming service that comes with a phone plan, an internet plan or a membership you already pay for may show nothing on your card statement, or may show as part of a larger charge. It still counts in your audit as value you receive, and it should be compared against the standalone price before you pay for the same service twice. If the bundle is billed by the carrier, a card bonus on streaming will not apply to it at all.

Shared and family accounts. If several people split a plan, record only your own share, and note who pays the card. A household where one person pays for four services and the others reimburse in cash has a different bonus calculation from one where each person pays for their own, because only charges on your card count toward your rewards.

Annual plans with a discount. An annual plan is usually cheaper per month than the monthly one, and it pays off only if you keep the service for the whole year. If you tend to cancel after a few months, the annual price is the more expensive choice. Compare the annual price with the number of months you really use the service, not with twelve.

Price changes. Services raise prices, and a notice of the change is not always easy to spot. If you move a subscription to a new card, the next renewal is a good moment to read the notice.

Free trials that need a card. Trials that convert are a common reason people hold a subscription they never meant to keep. Put the trial's end date in your calendar the day you start it, and cancel at once if you do not intend to continue. Many services let you keep access until the end of the trial period even after you cancel, which means cancelling early costs you nothing.

When the card offers a credit instead of a bonus

Some cards offer a monthly statement credit toward a streaming service instead of a percentage back. The arithmetic is different, and it is easy to get wrong. Say a card credits up to $10 a month against one named service, and the household's plan for that service is $15 a month.

  • The credit covers $10 of the $15, so the household's own cost is $5 a month, a saving of $10 a month or $120 a year.
  • That is real money only because the household already pays for the service. If it would not otherwise subscribe, the credit is not a saving at all: it pays $10 of a $15 purchase the household did not need.
  • If the service costs $9 a month, the credit covers it fully, but only $9 of the $10 is used. The extra $1 does not carry over.

A credit of this kind should be valued at the amount you would pay anyway, and the rest ignored. The same principle applies to a bonus percentage, but the numbers are smaller. The question to ask about any streaming card is the same: what do I already buy, and how much of it does this card pay me for?

Questions to ask before you apply

Put these to the card's terms, or to the issuer in writing.

  • Which services does the streaming category include, and is there a published list?
  • Are video, music and gaming all covered, or only some?
  • Is there a spending limit on the bonus, and does it reset on the calendar year or the card year?
  • If a service bills through an app store or a bundle, does it count?
  • Is there a statement credit for a streaming service, and does it require enrolling? If so, how to use monthly dining and streaming credits so none go to waste covers how to use such credits without waste.
  • Does the card charge an annual fee, and what does the issuer's own benefits guide say about it?

Mistakes the audit prevents

  • Choosing a card for a category you overestimated. The $80 a month in the example was a surprise in both directions. Only $49 of it would count.
  • Counting the bonus without counting the cancellation. The cheapest dollar is the one you do not spend.
  • Forgetting annual charges. A year of statements finds the $96 plan. A month does not.
  • Switching cards and breaking a payment. A failed payment can lapse a service, trigger a late-payment problem on an old card and cost far more than the bonus.
  • Treating a statement credit as free money. A credit worth $10 a month is worth $120 a year only if you would pay for the service anyway.

Key takeaways

  • An audit of twelve months of statements usually finds more subscription spending than people expect: $80 a month in the example, against a guess of about $50.
  • Only some of the charges will count as streaming. The card's terms, the billing path and a test charge decide, and in the example $49 of $80 counted.
  • Cancelling a single overlapping service saved $96 a year, about eight times what the streaming bonus was worth ($11.76) over a flat-rate card.
  • A streaming bonus of a few dollars a month cannot justify an annual fee: at a 2-point gap, a $95 fee needs $4,750 a year of counted spending.
  • Move subscriptions to a new card one at a time, keep autopay on both cards and leave the old card open for a full cycle.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic