Blog
A breach notice arrived: three cases, card number, SSN or just a password
Three households get similar breach letters about different data. A card number, an SSN and a password stay useful to thieves for very different lengths.
The envelope says that a company you did business with, or one that served a company you did business with, has suffered a security incident. The second paragraph lists what was involved. That paragraph is the one to read twice, because it decides what you do. A card number can be replaced in a day. A password can be changed in a minute. A Social Security number can never be changed in any practical sense, and it will be useful to a thief for as long as you live. The same letter, with different data in the list, calls for three different responses. This article follows three invented households through those three cases, after a short section on whether the letter is genuine.
First, is the letter real?
phishing and breach notices have a way of arriving together. Criminals know that people expect a notice after news of a breach, and they send fake ones that point to a look-alike site, ask you to "verify" your details or offer a "free service" that harvests information. A genuine letter and a fake one can look alike, so check the letter before you act on it.
- Do not use the link, the QR code or the phone number in the notice until you have checked them. Find the company's website yourself, by typing the address or by a search, and look for a notice there. A real breach is usually described on the company's own site.
- Look for what the letter does not ask for. A real notice describes what happened, what data was involved and what you can do. It does not ask you to send your Social Security number, a card number or a password in reply.
- Check whether you do business with the sender. Notices can come from a company you never dealt with directly, such as a vendor or a health-care provider's billing service, and that is real. Matching the sender to a company you know, or to news coverage of the incident, helps.
- Look at the offer. A free credit monitoring offer is common in real notices, and the letter normally gives a code and an enrollment site. Be wary of an offer that asks for payment information.
- State rules require notices in many cases, and they vary. Your state attorney general's office can tell you whether a notice has been filed, and some post the notices they receive.
If the letter fails these checks, do not act on it. Report it to the company at an address you found yourself, and to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. If it passes, move on to the case that matches the list of exposed data.
Matching the data to the response
The question to ask of any notice is how long the exposed data stays useful to a thief, because that sets the length and strength of your response.
| Exposed data | How long it stays useful | What it can be used for | First response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Card number, expiry, security code | Until the card is replaced | Unauthorized card charges | Replace the card, watch alerts |
| Social Security number, date of birth | Practically for life | Opening accounts, tax and benefit fraud | Freeze credit files, watch reports |
| Email address and password | Until the password is changed everywhere it is used | Account takeover, phishing | Change passwords, turn on two-step sign-in |
| Name, address, phone | Long, but weak alone | Targeted phishing and scams | Be alert to messages that use them |
| Several of the above together | The longest-lived item sets the response | A fuller impersonation | Combine the responses |
The three households below each have one main item in their letter. Real letters often have several, and you then combine the responses.
Case 1: Maya and the card number
Maya, a labeled hypothetical, receives a letter from an online retailer. The exposed data is her card number, expiration date and security code from a purchase last spring. No Social Security number or password was involved.
What the exposure means. A card number with its expiry and security code is what a thief needs to make online purchases on that card, the typical harm from a data breach of card data, charged online without the card in anyone's hand. But the data is short-lived. When the card is replaced, the old number stops working. The exposure ends when she acts.
What Maya should do.
- Call the number on the back of the card, not a number in the letter. Say that the card number was in a breach notice, and ask the issuer to replace the card. Some issuers will do this on request, and some may want to see a charge first. Ask what they recommend.
- Look over recent statements for charges she does not recognize, including small ones. Charges on the card are unauthorized charge disputes if she did not make them. Federal law caps her liability at $50, and if only the account number was stolen the CFPB says she generally has no liability for unauthorized use. She should report anything that looks wrong, in writing within 60 days of the statement that shows it, to keep the statutory protections.
- Turn on alerts for card transactions, so any attempt reaches her at once.
- Update the places that store the old number once the new card arrives. Got a replacement card after fraud? A checklist of accounts to update walks through that, and after you report card fraud: what happens day by day, and what you still owe covers what follows a report.
- Do not pay for a "protection service" because of this letter. The fix is a new number.
What Maya does not need. A credit freeze is not required for a card-number-only exposure, since card numbers do not open new accounts. She can still do it if she wants extra peace of mind, since it is free, but the replacement is what ends the risk. If the letter also mentions other data, she moves to the next case.
The cost. A few phone calls, a short wait for a new card and the effort of updating stored payment details.
Case 2: Luis and Ana and the Social Security number
Luis and Ana, also invented, receive a letter from a health-care billing vendor that served their clinic. The exposed data includes their names, dates of birth, addresses and Social Security numbers. No card numbers were involved.
What the exposure means. This is the long-lived case. A name, address, date of birth and Social Security number are the core details a lender uses to open credit in someone's name, and the number cannot be reissued as a card number can. The risk is identity theft: new accounts, loans, tax fraud or benefit claims. It may not show up for months or years, because a thief can hold the data and use it later. The right response is a lasting one, and it does not depend on any single account.
What Luis and Ana should do.
- Place a credit freeze at each of the three nationwide bureaus, for each of them. A freeze is free to place and to remove. A bureau must place it within one business day of a phone or online request and lift it within one hour of such a request. It blocks most new creditors from viewing the file, which blocks most new account fraud. They write down the PINs or passwords and keep them offline.
- Pull all three credit reports from AnnualCreditReport.com, the official site for free reports, and read them for accounts and inquiries they do not recognize. If they find one, Build an identity theft recovery plan with the FTC, bureaus and issuers and A card I never opened is on my credit report: hour, day and week plan give the steps.
- Consider a fraud alert in addition. An initial fraud alert lasts at least one year. credit freeze, fraud alert or credit lock: how they differ and when sets out what each does. A freeze is usually the stronger tool for the long term.
- Think about the other uses. Tax returns, benefits and medical identity can be misused with the same details, and these have their own agencies. They watch for a rejected tax return, a notice about income they did not earn and medical statements for care they did not receive.
- Set a calendar reminder to check the reports at three months and then every few months, and again each year.
- Take the free monitoring offer if one is included, as an extra. It does not replace the freeze. A breach letter offers free credit monitoring. Should I sign up for it? explains how to weigh it.
What Luis and Ana do not need to do. They do not need to close their accounts or change their Social Security numbers, which can be done only in rare cases and is not a routine step. They do not need to panic. A freeze, regular checks and attention to mail turn a large exposure into a managed one.
The cost. About an hour to place six freezes, and some friction each time they apply for credit, since they must lift a freeze first. For most households the friction is the price of the protection.
Case 3: Tomas and the password
Tomas, an invented example, gets an email from a photo-sharing service. A database of email addresses and passwords was exposed. Tomas used that password at the service and, he realizes with a sinking feeling, on two other sites, one of which is his email account.
What the exposure means. An email address and password let a thief try to sign in, and thieves try the same pair on other sites, since many people reuse passwords. If the reused password opens his email, the thief can reset the passwords of other accounts. The risk is account takeover. The data stops being useful once the password is changed everywhere it was used and two-step sign-in is on.
What Tomas should do, in order.
- Change the email password first, from a device he trusts, to a new password that he has never used. Email is the master key to resets.
- Change the password at the service in the notice, and at every other site that used the same one. He lists them by searching his email for account messages.
- Turn on two-step sign-in on email and financial accounts. App-based codes or passkeys are generally regarded as stronger than text-message codes.
- Check email settings for forwarding rules or filters he did not make, and the list of signed-in devices.
- Be alert to messages that mention the service, since criminals use breach details in convincing phishing. He does not read codes aloud to callers.
- Use a different password for every important account from now on. A password manager makes that practical, and he picks one he trusts.
- Check his card and bank accounts for anything unusual, to make sure the reuse did not reach financial sites.
What Tomas does not need. A credit freeze is not required for a password-only exposure, though if the letter mentions identifying details, he should look at Case 2. He also does not need to pay for a "dark web" service because of this letter. Changing passwords and adding a second step does the main work.
The cost. An evening of changing passwords, and some time to get used to a password manager.
Two cases that blend
A letter often lists more than one item, and the response combines the matching steps.
- Card number plus Social Security number. Replace the card at once, and freeze the credit files. The card fix is quick, and the freeze is the lasting one.
- Email address plus partial card number. A partial number, such as the last four digits, is not enough to make charges, but it helps a criminal pose as the issuer. Treat messages about the card with care and verify through the app or the number on the back of the card.
- Name and address only. Little can be done with those alone, and the main risk is convincing scams that use them. Do not act on a call or message just because the sender knows your address.
What to do with the letter itself
Keep it. It is the record of what was exposed and when you were told, and it may matter if misuse appears later. Note the date you received it, the offer's code and its deadline. If the company's notice includes a date range for the exposure, compare it with your statements for that period.
If the letter offers credit monitoring, check the enrollment deadline and what the offer asks you to provide. Do not give more than the offer reasonably needs, and do not enter payment information for a free service. If you are unsure, ask the company at a number you found yourself.
If a company mishandles your data and you believe it has not met its obligations, your state attorney general is the place to ask, and the CFPB takes complaints about financial companies at its website.
Key takeaways
- Read the list of exposed data first, because it sets how long your risk lasts: a card number ends when the card is replaced, a password when it is changed everywhere, a Social Security number never.
- Verify the letter before acting on it. Use the company's real site, not a link, QR code or number in the notice, and never reply with personal details.
- Card number only: call the number on the back of the card, replace it, watch alerts and update stored payments. The liability cap for unauthorized use is $50.
- Social Security number: freeze all three credit files, pull the reports, watch for tax and medical misuse, and keep checking. A freeze is free and lasts until you lift it.
- Password: change email first, change every reused password, turn on two-step sign-in and be wary of messages that use breach details.