Blog
Hire a debt settlement company or negotiate yourself? Both sides
Settlement company or do it yourself? A side-by-side comparison with break-even arithmetic, shared risks, who each path may suit and when another route fits.
Both paths aim at the same result in a debt settlement: a creditor accepts a lump sum smaller than the balance and closes the account. They differ in who does the talking, who does the saving and who takes a share of the result. A company brings negotiating experience and structure and charges a fee for it. Negotiating yourself costs nothing in fees and a good deal in time, nerve and paperwork. Neither path removes the risks that come from falling behind on payments, which are the same on both.
This comparison sets out what each path involves, puts one set of numbers next to both so you can see the break-even point, and describes who each path may suit. It does not recommend either one. A third group of options, covered near the end, may fit some households better than either.
What each path involves
With a company. You enroll, agree to a monthly deposit into an account in your name, and the company negotiates account by account when the fund is large enough. You usually stop paying your creditors during the program. The company takes a fee, typically a percentage of the debt, only after a settlement is completed. The full sequence is in how debt settlement programs work, and where the costs hide.
On your own. You pick the accounts, choose when to make offers, call or write each creditor or collector, and decide whether a counteroffer is acceptable. You save in your own account. You may also try to resolve the debt before it goes past due, by asking the issuer for a hardship arrangement, which is a different, lower-damage route described in how to ask your card issuer for a hardship program, call by call. If the account has already been charged off or sold, you deal with whoever owns it now.
In both cases the creditor is deciding what is worth accepting, so the result depends on the creditor and the account at least as much as on who is negotiating.
Side by side
| Question | Settlement company | Doing it yourself |
|---|---|---|
| Who negotiates | The company's staff | You |
| Direct cost | Fee, typically a percentage of the enrolled debt, after each settlement | None, apart from your time and any postage |
| Who saves the money | You, in a dedicated account in your name | You, in an account you choose |
| Stop paying creditors | Usually yes, as part of the program | Your choice, but a lump sum offer is stronger when the account is already past due |
| Effect on credit reports | Late payments, charge-offs, settled-for-less status | The same, if you stop paying; less if you resolve it before the account goes late |
| Lawsuit risk | Remains; the company cannot prevent one | Remains; you can respond to a suit directly |
| Calls from collectors | May continue until accounts settle | You can send a written request to stop contact to a third-party collector |
| Tax on forgiven amount | Possible; the same rules apply | Possible; the same rules apply |
| What you need | Steady monthly deposits and patience | Time, organization, willingness to make calls and negotiate |
| Written agreements | Ask for each one before any money moves | Ask for each one before any money moves |
The table makes the main point visible: almost every row, apart from the fee and who is on the phone, is the same for both paths.
The numbers: where the fee changes the result
The following is an illustration, not a market rate or any company's prices. Say Alex owes $15,000 across three cards at an illustrative 24% APR, 2% a month. Alex stops paying, and after about six months the issuers charge off the accounts. Interest alone takes the balance to $15,000 × 1.02^6, about $16,892, which we round to $16,900 for the example (late fees are left out, so the real figure could be higher).
The company charges a fee of 20% of the enrolled debt: $15,000 × 0.20 = $3,000. The company route costs the settlement amounts plus $3,000. The do-it-yourself route costs only the settlement amounts. The next table assumes the same settlement percentage on both paths.
| Settlement as a share of the $16,900 | Settlement amount | Company path (plus $3,000 fee) | Do-it-yourself path |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40% | $6,760 | $9,760 | $6,760 |
| 50% | $8,450 | $11,450 | $8,450 |
| 60% | $10,140 | $13,140 | $10,140 |
| 70% | $11,830 | $14,830 | $11,830 |
At the same settlement percentage, the company path always costs $3,000 more. That is not the realistic comparison, though, because the company's argument is that it gets a better percentage than you would. The break-even point is the percentage-point gap that makes the fee pay for itself:
$3,000 ÷ $16,900 = 0.1775
So the company has to win a settlement about 18 percentage points lower than Alex would have obtained alone. If Alex alone would have settled at 55%, the company must settle at about 37% or lower for the two totals to match, and anything better than that is a gain from using a company. If Alex alone could get 55% and the company only gets 50%, Alex has lost $3,000 and gained $845 on the settlement amount, a net cost of about $2,155.
Two other numbers matter. Time: at $500 a month, saving $8,450 takes 16.9 months and saving $11,450 takes 22.9 months. The company path takes about six months longer here because the fund must also cover the fee, and the longer an account sits unpaid, the longer the credit damage and the legal exposure continue. Second, convenience: the company path may mean fewer phone calls for you, which is a real benefit that has no line in the table.
These numbers use round assumptions to show the method. Your own accounts, creditors and fee terms will differ, and the useful exercise is to rerun the break-even using the real fee quote and your real balances. A payoff tool such as the credit card interest calculator helps estimate what interest will add while accounts are unpaid.
What a company can and cannot do
A company can organize a program, keep you on a deposit schedule, know how to approach different creditors and collection agencies and handle the negotiation conversations. It is an advantage if you dislike the calls or fear making a mistake.
A company cannot lawfully take a fee before it has settled a debt when it sells by phone, as the FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule has provided since 2010, and hiring attorneys does not change that. It cannot make a creditor agree. It cannot stop a lawsuit, and it cannot prevent late fees and credit damage from accumulating on accounts that are unpaid. Ask any company what happens if you are sued, because a suit can change the program's plan.
What you can do yourself
Negotiating alone is a skill you can learn, and the tools are free. In outline:
- Take stock. List each debt, who holds it, the balance and whether it is charged off or with a collector. Find out who currently owns each one; for a collector, ask for the validation notice in writing, covered in how to request debt validation from a collector, step by step.
- Decide what you can pay. A lump sum offer is stronger when you have the cash. Build the fund first, and do not promise an amount you do not have.
- Make the offer in writing or follow a call with a letter. State the amount, that it is in full settlement and that it is conditional on a written agreement.
- Never pay before the agreement is in writing. The letter should name the account, the amount, what it settles and what the creditor will report. A collector offers to settle for half. Work out whether to accept helps judge an offer.
- Keep proof. Save the agreement and the payment record. You may need them for credit report disputes and for taxes.
The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act limits what third-party collectors may do, such as how often they may call, and gives you a way to tell them to stop writing or calling in some respects. It does not generally apply to an original creditor collecting its own account, so issuer calls follow different rules.
Risks both paths share
- Credit damage. Stopping payment brings late entries and charge-offs whichever way you negotiate. The record can be reported for seven years from the first missed payment plus 180 days, and a settled account does not erase it.
- Lawsuits. A creditor can sue. If it wins, a judgment can lead to wage or bank account collection under state law. Responding to a suit matters more than any negotiation; see I was sued over a credit card debt. What do I do?.
- Taxes. Forgiven debt can be taxable income. See I settled a card debt for less. What about taxes and my credit report?.
- No guarantee. Some creditors will not settle, and those that do may want more than you can pay.
- Time-barred debts. A very old debt may be past the statute of limitations, and in many states a partial payment can restart the clock. Check before you pay anything.
Three short cases
These are labeled hypotheticals, built to show how the same choice plays out differently.
Case one: one card, one lump sum. Morgan has a single card that has been charged off and sold to a debt buyer, and a relative has offered a one-time gift. Morgan asks the buyer for validation, confirms the debt is real and within the time limit, and offers a lump sum in writing. There is one creditor and one conversation, and a company's fee would be a large share of a small result. Doing it alone is straightforward here, as long as the agreement is in writing before the money moves.
Case two: six cards, no spare time. Riley works two jobs, has six cards with a combined balance of about $30,000, cannot take calls during the day and has been sleeping badly. Riley can save $600 a month. Here the value of a company is partly that someone else handles the conversations, and Riley may reasonably choose to pay for that. The point of the break-even arithmetic is to make the price visible: on a $30,000 enrollment a 20% fee is $6,000, which is about ten months of Riley's deposits, so the company would need to produce a meaningfully better result for the choice to make financial sense, and Riley should compare it with a nonprofit plan before deciding.
Case three: behind, but not yet late. Jordan has two cards, is one month behind on one of them and has a small emergency fund. Jordan calls the issuer on the number on the back of the card, explains the situation and asks about a hardship plan. Neither a company nor a settlement may be needed, because the account has not been charged off and a lower rate or payment may keep it current. If that fails, the other paths are still open.
The common thread is that the right choice depends on the number of accounts, the amount saved, the condition of the accounts and how much of the work you can do, and not on a general rule.
Who each path may suit
A company may suit someone who has several accounts, a steady ability to save but little energy or confidence for negotiating, a debt level that makes bankruptcy a real alternative, and a clear view of the fee and the risks. It may suit someone who would otherwise let the accounts drift.
Doing it yourself may suit someone with a few accounts, a lump sum or a way to build one, patience for phone calls and letters, and a wish to keep the fee. It also suits someone who can still catch up before the accounts go delinquent, because the best outcome may be no settlement at all.
Neither may suit someone who can still make payments, who has a mortgage or other major credit application coming, who is already being sued or whose debts are mostly secured or priority obligations. A company is a poor fit when the deposits are unrealistic, and doing it yourself is a poor fit when the stress of collection calls is likely to push you into an agreement you cannot afford.
When a different route fits better
- Hardship program. If you are not yet far behind, an issuer's hardship arrangement may lower the rate or payment without a delinquency.
- Debt management plan. A nonprofit agency negotiates lower rates and one monthly payment, and the plan usually keeps accounts current. The tradeoffs are in debt management plan, consolidation loan or do-it-yourself payoff?.
- Bankruptcy. For some households, chapter 7 bankruptcy or Chapter 13 resolves card debt in a way settlement cannot, through a court process. An attorney can explain the effects, and many offer a first consultation.
- Staying the course. For a household that can pay but at a higher cost than it likes, a payoff plan with a lower rate may be the cheapest path.
If you are unsure, a free session with a nonprofit credit counselor is a low-risk way to see the options. If a card issuer or collector treats you unfairly in any path, you can use the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's complaint process, and for any account you still have, the number on the back of the card is the place to ask about hardship help.
Key takeaways
- The difference between the two paths is the fee and who does the work; the credit damage, lawsuit risk and tax exposure are the same either way.
- A company's fee pays for itself only if it wins a settlement lower than you would have got alone. In the labeled example, that gap is about 18 percentage points.
- A company cannot guarantee a creditor's acceptance, stop a lawsuit or prevent late fees on accounts that are unpaid.
- Doing it yourself is cheaper in dollars but demands time and written agreements for every payment.
- A hardship program, a debt management plan or bankruptcy advice may suit some households better than either path, and a nonprofit counselor can help sort them out.