Blog

Prepaid cards for a teen, a trip and a budget: when each one fits

Three labeled households use prepaid cards for a teen allowance, a foreign trip and a monthly spending cap, with the fee arithmetic and where each plan breaks.

A prepaid card does one thing very well: it limits how much can be spent to the amount on it. Three households use that limit for three different reasons. One wants a fifteen-year-old to practice spending without a credit line. One wants a fixed amount at risk on a trip abroad. One wants a spending cap that no willpower is needed to enforce. Each plan works in some respects and fails in others, and the failures are mostly about fees, holds and the things a prepaid card does not do. The households and numbers below are made up, and the fees are invented to make the arithmetic concrete. Real products differ and change, so use the fee schedule and agreement for the card you are considering. How the product works in general is covered in how a prepaid card works: loading, fees and what protects your balance; this article assumes you have read it or will.

Household one: a teen allowance

The situation. The Okafors have a fifteen-year-old, Chidi, who gets $40 a week for lunches, bus fare and the occasional game download. Cash goes missing and he cannot pay online. His parents consider a prepaid card for teens that they load from their phone.

The setup. The program lets a parent load by transfer from a bank account at no charge, view every purchase in an app and lock the card instantly. It charges a hypothetical $2.50 a month.

The numbers.

  • Weekly allowance: $40
  • Per year: $40 x 52 = $2,080
  • Monthly average: $2,080 / 12 = about $173.33
  • Card fee: $2.50 x 12 = $30 a year
  • Fee as a share of the money loaded: $30 / $2,080 = about 1.4 percent

For a household that otherwise pays the allowance in cash, 1.4 percent buys a record of every purchase and a lock if the card is lost. Whether that is worth it is the family's call.

What works. The card cannot go negative, so the worst case of a spending mistake is a declined payment, which is a safe way to learn. A parent sees the pattern, for example that most of the money goes on Tuesdays and Thursdays to the same shop. Chidi can use the card online and in stores, which cash does not allow.

What does not. A prepaid card builds no credit history, as Does a debit card build credit? Debit versus credit card myths, tested explains. If the Okafors want Chidi's history to start early, the routes that report are different: an authorized user arrangement on a parent's card, or later a student card or a secured credit card. For anyone under 21, a credit card in their own name generally requires either an independent ability to make the minimum payments or a cosigner, guarantor or joint applicant aged 21 or older who can, so a parent's role is built into the rules. a first card for a teen: debit, prepaid or authorized user compared sets out the three options for a teenager.

A second limit: some retailers and services will not accept a prepaid card for certain things, such as recurring subscriptions or deposits. A teen who tries to book something that needs a credit card will meet this.

Where the plan breaks. If Chidi's parents let the balance sit untouched for months, an inactivity fee may start. If the card is unregistered, a lost card means a lost balance. Registering it in a parent's name or the program's required identity process is the first step, and the parents should check what the program says about replacing a lost card and its balance.

Household two: a foreign trip

The situation. The Reyes family is spending ten days abroad and wants to limit how much of their money is exposed if a card number is stolen. They consider loading $600 onto a travel prepaid card for daily spending and keeping a regular credit card for hotel and emergencies.

The comparison. Say they compare the prepaid card with a credit card that charges a foreign transaction fee. Foreign transaction fees run about 3 percent on cards that charge one, and many travel cards charge none, so the comparison depends on which card they would otherwise carry. The numbers below are invented.

  • Credit card with a 3 percent foreign transaction fee: $600 x 3 percent = $18.00
  • Prepaid card with a $5 purchase fee, a 2 percent load fee and no foreign fee: $5 + ($600 x 2 percent = $12) = $17.00

Nearly the same: a $1 difference. If the family already holds a credit card with no foreign transaction fee, the credit card costs $0 in this comparison and the prepaid card costs $17. The prepaid card's advantage is not price. It is that it caps the amount at risk to $600 and keeps the main card numbers out of everyday use. The foreign transaction fee calculator lets you test your own rates.

The currency question. A merchant abroad may offer to charge in dollars instead of the local currency. That is dynamic currency conversion, and the exchange rate it uses usually includes a markup, so paying in the local currency is generally the better choice; why choosing to pay in dollars at a foreign terminal usually costs more shows the arithmetic. This applies to any card, prepaid or credit.

Holds and rentals. Hotels commonly place an authorization hold for the stay plus an extra amount for incidentals. Say the hotel holds $400 on the card for four nights. On a $600 prepaid balance that leaves $200 for the rest of the trip until the hold drops after checkout. On a credit card, the same hold reduces available credit instead of cash. Many car rental companies set extra conditions on debit or prepaid cards, such as larger holds or additional checks, and some require a credit card; ask before relying on a prepaid card there.

Fraud and recovery. If the Reyes family's prepaid card is stolen, what they recover depends on whether it is registered and on the program's terms. A credit card's federal liability cap of $50 on unauthorized use and the billing-error procedure are separate protections. If they see a charge they did not make, they call the number on the back of the card. A travel card often has a number that works from abroad; they should write down both numbers before leaving and keep them apart from the cards.

Where the plan breaks. The balance runs out, and the family has no way to top up quickly on a Sunday. A card that cannot be reloaded from an app is a problem when a $90 dinner meets a $60 balance. They carry a backup, and they spend from the credit card for anything with a deposit.

Household three: a spending cap

The situation. Maya earns a steady paycheck and keeps overspending on restaurants and outings. She sets a budget of $300 a month for them, and she wants the limit to be enforced rather than remembered. She considers loading a prepaid card with $300 on the first of each month.

The numbers.

  • Monthly cap: $300
  • Daily pace over a 30-day month: $300 / 30 = $10
  • On day 12 the expected spend is $10 x 12 = $120. If Maya has spent $140, she is $20 ahead of pace.

When the balance reaches zero, the card is declined and the month's fun money is done. No fee, no interest, no argument with herself about whether she can afford it.

What works. The cap is physical. A prepaid card with no overdraft cannot spend more than the balance. If she loads it by direct deposit split from her paycheck, there may be no load fee, and if the monthly fee is waived for direct deposit the card costs nothing. A related approach, with no prepaid card at all, is a separate checking account or savings pocket with its own debit card, which some banks offer without monthly fees; Maya should compare. cash, debit or credit, and how the way you pay changes what you spend looks at how the payment method changes spending.

What does not. It is a cap on one category, so Maya has to remember to use the card only for that category. It also makes a few things inconvenient: a refund goes back to the card, so the balance can sit there; a hold at a restaurant reduces the balance until it settles; and if she reaches for her main card when the prepaid card is empty, the cap has failed. Willpower moves from "do not spend" to "do not switch cards."

Where the plan breaks. The month ends with $40 left and a monthly fee of, say, $5 plus an inactivity fee later if she stops using the card. She either closes the card and takes the balance out, or reloads and keeps it going. If the program charges to cash out, she should look at that fee schedule before she starts.

A fourth case: the card that was never registered

Not every prepaid card is chosen with a plan. Say Dan buys an open-loop prepaid card off a rack, pays $150 in cash and tucks it in his wallet as a spending buffer. He spends $35 on a first trip to the store, leaving $115, and then loses his wallet on a bus.

  • If the card was never registered, the issuer has no record that it is Dan's. Depending on the program, the remaining $115 may be unrecoverable, since anyone who found the card could spend it, and the issuer would have no way to tell the difference.
  • If the card was registered, Dan can call the number on the card's website or the paperwork, report it lost and ask for a replacement with the remaining balance. With an invented $5 replacement fee, he would get $115 - $5 = $110 back on a new card.

The gap between those two outcomes, up to $110 in this case, is the reason the registration step is worth doing the day you buy the card. Some programs will not let you reload a card that is not registered, which is a hint that the issuer treats the two kinds differently. Check the terms for the card in your hand; do not assume.

Which tool for which goal

A short decision list to run before you buy any card for any of the three purposes:

  1. The goal is to start a credit history. A prepaid card cannot do this. Look at an authorized-user arrangement, a student card or a secured card, and remember the under-21 rule.
  2. The goal is a hard spending limit. A prepaid card does it, as does a bank sub-account with its own debit card, which may cost less. Compare monthly fees.
  3. The goal is to cut the cost of foreign spending. Compare the total cost with a credit card that charges no foreign transaction fee before you pay for a prepaid card. The price may be a wash or worse.
  4. The goal is to protect a large online purchase. A credit card, with its statutory billing-error procedure and a 60-day written-notice deadline, is generally the stronger tool than prepaid.
  5. The goal is to teach. A prepaid card works best when a parent actually looks at the app with the teen every week and talks about the pattern. The card does not teach; the conversation does.

Putting the three side by side

Household Goal What the card does well What it does not do
Okafor Teach a teen to spend within a limit Cannot go negative; parent can see and lock Build credit; work for everything that needs a credit card
Reyes Cap exposure on a trip Limits amount at risk; keeps main card numbers separate Beat a no-fee credit card on cost; handle hotel holds and rentals as smoothly
Maya Enforce a monthly cap Hard limit with no overdraft Stop her from using another card

The common thread: a prepaid card is a spending limit with a payment network attached. It is useful when the limit is what you need, and less useful when you need credit, dispute rights or a way to rent a car.

Questions to ask in any of the three situations

  1. What does the card cost for how I will actually use it? Count loads, withdrawals and months, and multiply.
  2. Is it registered, and what happens to the balance if it is lost?
  3. Does the program say the balance is held at an FDIC-insured bank, and does it say that coverage passes through to cardholders?
  4. How do I report a charge I did not make, and what is the deadline?
  5. What happens to a leftover balance, and what does it cost to take it out?
  6. Is there a better tool for this purpose, such as a card with a parent-controlled spending limit, a bank sub-account or an authorized-user card?

If you meet a stranger, a caller or a website that tells you to pay a bill, a fine or a "fee" with a prepaid card or gift card, that is a scam; stop and call the issuer at the number on the back of your card if you have already sent anything.

Key takeaways

  • A prepaid card's strength is a hard limit: it cannot spend more than the balance, which suits a teen allowance, a trip budget or a monthly cap.
  • It does not build credit; for a teen the routes that report are an authorized-user arrangement, a student card or a secured card, and under 21 a credit card in the teen's own name needs independent ability to pay or a cosigner.
  • On a trip the price difference against a credit card can be small (in the example $17 against $18), so the reason to choose prepaid is the cap, not the savings, and hotel holds and car rentals can use up or exclude a prepaid balance.
  • Register the card, read the fee schedule, and count your own loads and withdrawals; in the allowance example the card cost $30 a year on $2,080, about 1.4 percent.
  • Anyone who asks you to pay with a prepaid card is running a scam, so call the number on the back of your card if you have sent numbers.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic