Blog
At what monthly spending does a bonus-category card beat a flat-rate card?
Two illustrative cards, one flat and one with a capped bonus category and a lower base rate, compared in tables to find the spending mix where each one wins.
The question sounds like it should have a dollar answer: at how much spending does the category card pull ahead? It does not, quite. The break-even for a card with a bonus category is not mainly a total. It is a share: the fraction of your spending that falls in the bonus category. And because bonus categories come with caps, the cap puts a ceiling on how much total spending the category card can ever win at. Once you see the formula, you can test any pair of cards in a minute.
This post derives the break-even for two invented cards, shows it in tables, and then extends it to other rates so you can read off the threshold for the cards you are considering. Everything is hypothetical. The rates and caps are round numbers chosen to make the arithmetic visible, and they describe no real card. The companion post Flat-rate or category cash back? Working out which earns you more works through two households' monthly spending line by line, and this one asks the opposite question: what spending mix makes the choice a tie?
The two cards
| Feature | Card A (flat) | Card B (category) |
|---|---|---|
| Base rate | 2% on everything | 1% on everything outside the bonus category |
| Bonus category | None | 4% on one everyday category, such as groceries |
| Cap | None | The 4% applies to the first $6,000 a year in the category, then 1% |
| Annual fee | $0 | $0 |
Card A is a flat-rate card. Card B has a bonus category with a cap and a lower base rate than Card A. Both pay cash back at face value and both are paid in full, so interest is not part of this comparison.
We use annual figures because caps are often set per year or per quarter, and a year smooths out lumpy months. To think in months, divide by 12. A $6,000 annual cap is $500 a month, as in the companion post.
The formula
Let T be total yearly card spending and G the yearly spending in Card B's bonus category. Let C be the part of G that is under the cap, so C is the smaller of G and $6,000.
- Card A earns 2% of T, which is 0.02 × T.
- Card B earns 4% on C, plus 1% on everything else. The everything-else amount is T − C. So Card B earns 0.04 × C + 0.01 × (T − C).
Simplify Card B. Multiply out: 0.04C + 0.01T − 0.01C = 0.01T + 0.03C.
Card B beats Card A when 0.01T + 0.03C is more than 0.02T. Subtract 0.01T from both sides: 0.03C is more than 0.01T. Divide by 0.03: C must exceed T ÷ 3.
In words: Card B wins only if more than one-third of your total spending is in the bonus category and under the cap. The one-third comes straight from the rates. The flat card beats the category card's base rate by 1 point (2% less 1%), and the category card beats the flat card in its category by 2 points (4% less 2%). Each dollar in the bonus category gains 2 points over the flat card, each dollar outside it loses 1 point, so the category must hold at least one dollar in three to come out even.
Reading it in a table
Here are four total spending levels. For each, the table shows the bonus-category spending that Card B needs, which is one-third of the total, and whether that is possible given the $6,000 cap.
| Yearly total spending | Under-cap category spend needed to break even (T ÷ 3) | Possible under the $6,000 cap? |
|---|---|---|
| $12,000 | $4,000 | Yes |
| $18,000 | $6,000 | Exactly at the cap: a tie at best |
| $24,000 | $8,000 | No: the cap stops at $6,000 |
| $36,000 | $12,000 | No |
This is the cap's ceiling effect. Because C can never exceed $6,000, the card can never win once T ÷ 3 exceeds $6,000, which means once T exceeds $18,000. A card with a 4% bonus on $6,000 a year of spending cannot beat a 2% flat card for any household that spends more than $18,000 a year in total, however its spending is distributed. The cap multiplied by three is the maximum.
The general rule for a capped category: the total spending ceiling is the cap divided by the break-even share. With a one-third share, ceiling = 3 × cap.
| Yearly cap on bonus rate | Total spending ceiling (3 × cap) |
|---|---|
| $3,000 | $9,000 |
| $6,000 | $18,000 |
| $12,000 | $36,000 |
A household that spends far more than the ceiling gets almost no benefit from the category card, because the capped bonus is a small slice of a large total.
Three households tested
Apply the formula to three households with invented spending.
Household 1 spends $15,000 a year, with $6,000 in the bonus category (40 percent of the total).
- Card A: 0.02 × $15,000 = $300.
- Card B: 0.01 × $15,000 + 0.03 × $6,000 = $150 + $180 = $330.
Card B is $30 ahead. The category share, 40 percent, is above the one-third threshold.
Household 2 spends $24,000, with $7,000 in the category (29 percent of the total, and above the cap).
- Card A: 0.02 × $24,000 = $480.
- Card B: C is capped at $6,000, so 0.01 × $24,000 + 0.03 × $6,000 = $240 + $180 = $420.
Card A is $60 ahead. The share is under one-third anyway, and the $1,000 above the cap earns only 1 percent.
Household 3 spends $12,000, with $3,000 in the category (25 percent).
- Card A: 0.02 × $12,000 = $240.
- Card B: 0.01 × $12,000 + 0.03 × $3,000 = $120 + $90 = $210.
Card A is $30 ahead. The share is below one-third.
The pattern: the winner depends on the share, and large spenders do not escape the cap. Household 2 spends the most in the category and still loses, because its total is high.
Other rates: the threshold for your cards
The one-third figure is specific to a 2 percent flat card, a 1 percent base and a 4 percent bonus. The general formula has the same shape. The break-even share of spending that must be in the bonus category is:
(flat rate − category card's base rate) ÷ (bonus rate − category card's base rate)
For a 2 percent flat card, here is the threshold for different category cards.
| Category card's bonus rate | Base 1% | Base 1.5% |
|---|---|---|
| 3% | 50.0% | 33.3% |
| 4% | 33.3% | 20.0% |
| 5% | 25.0% | 14.3% |
| 6% | 20.0% | 11.1% |
Check a cell by hand. With a 5 percent bonus and a 1.5 percent base: (2 − 1.5) ÷ (5 − 1.5) = 0.5 ÷ 3.5 = 0.143, or 14.3 percent. Check another: 3 percent bonus and 1 percent base: (2 − 1) ÷ (3 − 1) = 0.5, or 50 percent.
Two things leap out of the table. A higher bonus rate lowers the share you need, but only slowly. And the base rate has a bigger effect than most people expect: moving the base from 1 percent to 1.5 percent cuts the needed share from one-third to one-fifth at a 4 percent bonus. A card with a weak base rate is demanding. A card that pays 1.5 percent outside its categories is much more forgiving.
If the flat card pays something other than 2 percent, replace it in the formula. A 1.5 percent flat card against the 4%/1% category card needs (1.5 − 1) ÷ (4 − 1) = 0.5 ÷ 3 = 16.7 percent in the category.
What happens if you use both cards
The break-even above compares using one card for everything. If you hold both, you can send the capped category spending to the category card and everything else to the flat card. The earnings become 4 percent on C and 2 percent on the rest of T:
Earnings = 0.04 × C + 0.02 × (T − C).
Apply it to the three households.
| Household | Card A alone | Card B alone | Both cards, split | Split minus Card A |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 ($15,000 total, $6,000 category) | $300 | $330 | $240 + $180 = $420 | +$120 |
| 2 ($24,000 total, $7,000 category, $6,000 under the cap) | $480 | $420 | $240 + $360 = $600 | +$120 |
| 3 ($12,000 total, $3,000 category) | $240 | $210 | $120 + $180 = $300 | +$60 |
For Household 2: C = $6,000 so 0.04 × $6,000 = $240, and the remaining $18,000 at 2 percent is $360, which makes $600. The $1,000 of category spending above the cap goes on Card A at 2 percent, which beats Card B's 1 percent on it.
The split always beats the flat card alone, by 2 points on the capped category spending, as long as the bonus rate is above the flat rate. That is the real reason people hold both. The cost is the second account and the attention it takes. The extra in these examples is $60 to $120 a year, which a household should weigh against the time and risk of managing two cards.
The same test in monthly terms
Many people think in months, so here is the same comparison with the cap expressed as $500 a month. The break-even share is still one-third, and the ceiling is still three times the cap, which is $1,500 a month in total spending.
| Monthly total spending | Category spend needed (one-third) | Possible under $500 a month? |
|---|---|---|
| $1,000 | $333 | Yes |
| $1,500 | $500 | Exactly at the cap |
| $2,000 | $667 | No |
Say a household spends $1,200 a month and has $450 in the category. One-third of $1,200 is $400, and $450 is above it and under the cap. Card B earns 0.01 × $1,200 + 0.03 × $450 = $12.00 + $13.50 = $25.50. Card A earns 0.02 × $1,200 = $24.00. Card B leads by $1.50 a month, or $18 a year. The household is above the threshold, and not by much, which is the situation where the second-order costs (effort, coding risk, a quarter in which spending dips) can erase the lead.
What an annual fee does to the winning zone
Add an illustrative $95 annual fee to Card B and leave Card A at $0. Card B's net becomes 0.01T + 0.03C − $95, and it beats Card A when 0.03C − 0.01T is more than $95. That is a much tighter test.
Take the best case for Card B, where the category spending is at the $6,000 cap. Then 0.03 × $6,000 = $180, and the condition is $180 − 0.01T > $95, which means 0.01T < $85 and T < $8,500. So a $95 fee means Card B can win only if total yearly spending is under $8,500, with practically all of it in one category. A quick check at T = $7,000 and C = $6,000: Card B earns $70 + $180 − $95 = $155, and Card A earns $140, so Card B leads by $15. At T = $8,500 and C = $6,000: Card B earns $85 + $180 − $95 = $170 and Card A earns $170, which is a tie. At T = $15,000, the Household 1 level, Card B's net is $330 − $95 = $235 against $300, which is $65 behind.
The odd result is worth stating plainly. In this design, a fee card with a capped bonus is not a card for heavy spenders, because the cap holds back the benefit while the flat card's earnings keep growing with spending. A fee card makes sense when the bonus is large, the cap is high or the card has other benefits that you would use, which is a different calculation from the one here. should a cash-back card with an annual fee ever beat a no-fee one? sets out that decision in full.
Where the simple sum goes wrong
The formula is exact for the invented cards. For real ones, the inputs are slippery. These are the usual ways the break-even misleads.
- Merchant coding. A card pays the bonus on purchases that the issuer's system classifies as the category. A purchase you think of as groceries may not be coded that way. If C is smaller than you believe, the break-even moves against the category card. See do a cash back card's bonus categories match your actual receipts? for the test.
- Caps that reset on a schedule. A quarterly or monthly cap can leave room unused in quiet periods. Annual figures hide that. The more uneven the spending, the lower the real bonus.
- Rotating categories. A card whose bonus categories change every quarter, and that may need activation, makes the share you earn depend on how well the quarter's list fits your spending. rotating categories explains the design, and how rotating bonus categories work, from activation to quarterly caps works through the arithmetic.
- Annual fees. A fee comes off the category card's earnings and raises its threshold. An annual fee, say an illustrative $95, comes off the category card's earnings before the comparison, and the section above on fees shows how much it narrows the winning zone. should a cash-back card with an annual fee ever beat a no-fee one? covers how to carry a fee through the sum.
- Spending that follows the card. If the bonus makes you buy more in the category, you are no longer comparing the same household. spending more to earn more: how chasing cash back costs you money covers how that goes wrong.
When the numbers are close
Most real comparisons land within a few dollars a month, and then the arithmetic stops deciding. A few considerations tend to break the tie, and none of them is about rewards.
Simplicity. A flat-rate card asks nothing of you. A category card asks you to know which purchases count, to notice when you approach a cap and to keep the right card in hand at the right register. A household that will do that gladly can treat the effort as free. A household that will forget half the time should price the effort in, because a bonus you forget to collect earns the base rate.
Risk of change. Issuers can change earning rates and caps with notice. A category card's edge rests on a rate and a cap that someone else can adjust, and with a $1.50 monthly lead a small change flips the answer. A flat-rate card's lead, when it has one, is usually less sensitive to a single change.
The rest of the wallet. If you already hold a flat-rate card, adding a category card for one category is the split in the table above, which beat the flat card alone in every example. If you hold neither, the first question is which single card you would use for everything, and that points back to the flat-rate side unless your category share clears the threshold.
What you do with the rewards. Cash back that you actually redeem is worth its face value. A bonus that comes as points, or as a credit you may not use in time, is worth what you realistically get from it, which can be lower. The Flat-rate or category cash back? Working out which earns you more post shows how the value of a point changes the sum.
A five-step test for any pair of cards
- Write the flat rate (F), the category card's base (b) and bonus (r), and the cap.
- Compute the break-even share as (F − b) ÷ (r − b).
- Compute the ceiling as the cap ÷ share. If your total spending is over it, the category card cannot win.
- Find your own share from three months of statements: category spending under the cap, divided by total spending.
- Compare your share with the break-even. If it is within a few points, run the full dollar sum in the cash back comparison calculator and treat the choice as close.
Key takeaways
- A bonus-category card beats a flat-rate card only when the share of spending in the bonus category is above (flat rate − base) ÷ (bonus − base). For a 2% flat card against a 4% bonus and 1% base, that share is one-third.
- A cap sets a ceiling on total spending: with a $6,000 annual cap and a one-third threshold, no household spending over $18,000 a year can come out ahead with the category card alone.
- The base rate matters as much as the bonus. Raising the base from 1% to 1.5% cut the threshold from 33.3% to 20.0% at a 4% bonus.
- Holding both cards and sending only the capped category spending to the category card beat the flat card alone in every example, by $60 to $120 a year, at the cost of a second account.
- Fees, merchant coding, rotating categories and changed spending can all move the answer, so test your own statements before choosing.