Blog

Flat-rate or category cash back? Working out which earns you more

A repeatable worksheet totaling your monthly spending on a flat-rate card and a bonus-category card, with two labeled households and the caps that matter.

A flat-rate card is a promise that every purchase earns the same percentage. A category card is a promise that some purchases earn more and the rest earn less, usually with a limit on how much of the higher rate you can collect. Which one is ahead is not a matter of taste or of the headline number on the ad. It is a sum, and the inputs to the sum are your own monthly spending, which neither card's marketing knows.

This post gives you that sum as a worksheet and runs it twice, for two invented households whose spending looks different. The rates, caps and spending amounts are all hypothetical and round, chosen so the arithmetic is easy to check. They are not any real card's terms. For a real card's current rates, use its profile and the issuer's published terms, and for the question of the spending level at which one card overtakes the other, see at what monthly spending does a bonus-category card beat a flat-rate card?.

The two cards in the example

Card F is a flat-rate card. It earns 2 percent cash back on every purchase, with no categories to track and no cap.

Card C is a category card with an invented structure that resembles a common design:

  • 5 percent on groceries (a bonus category), on the first $500 of grocery spending each month (the cap), and 1 percent on grocery spending above that.
  • 3 percent on gas.
  • 1 percent on everything else.

Neither card has an annual fee, and both are paid in full each month, so no interest enters the sum. Both pay cash back at face value. Those assumptions are doing real work, and a later section shows what happens when they fail.

The worksheet

You need about three months of statements. Use an average month, not your best or worst.

  1. List your monthly spending by category. Use the categories Card C rewards (groceries, gas) and lump the rest into "everything else." Split out any category whose total is large, such as dining, so you can see the effect.
  2. Total the month. Add every category. This is your total card spending.
  3. Flat-rate earnings. Multiply the total by the flat rate.
  4. Category-card earnings. For each category, multiply the spending by the card's rate, applying any cap. For a capped category, earn the bonus rate on spending up to the cap and the base rate on the rest.
  5. Compare. Subtract one from the other. Multiply by 12 for a year.
  6. Stress-test. Change the biggest category by 20 to 30 percent and rerun. If the answer flips, treat the choice as close.

The cash back comparison calculator runs steps 3 to 5 for several cards at once, and the card combination rewards optimizer can map a whole wallet. The reason to do it by hand once is that you will see where the number comes from.

Household one: Rosa, a grocery-heavy household

Rosa's average month looks like this.

Category Monthly spend
Groceries $700
Gas $150
Dining $200
Utilities and bills $400
Everything else $550
Total $2,000

The total is $700 + $150 + $200 + $400 + $550 = $2,000.

Card F: 2% of $2,000 = $40.00.

Card C: work through each line.

  • Groceries: the first $500 earns 5%, which is $25.00. The remaining $200 earns 1%, which is $2.00. Subtotal $27.00.
  • Gas: 3% of $150 = $4.50.
  • Dining: 1% of $200 = $2.00.
  • Utilities and bills: 1% of $400 = $4.00.
  • Everything else: 1% of $550 = $5.50.

The total is $27.00 + $4.50 + $2.00 + $4.00 + $5.50 = $43.00.

Card C earns $3.00 more a month, which is $36.00 a year. The advantage is real and small. It comes entirely from the $500 of groceries at 5 percent, which contributes $25.00 against $10.00 on Card F ($500 × 2%), a gain of $15.00 that is partly given back by the 1 percent rate on everything else.

Household two: Theo, a spread-out household

Theo's average month looks different.

Category Monthly spend
Groceries $350
Gas $60
Dining $400
Utilities and bills $500
Everything else $890
Total $2,200

The total is $350 + $60 + $400 + $500 + $890 = $2,200.

Card F: 2% of $2,200 = $44.00.

Card C:

  • Groceries: 5% of $350 = $17.50. (The $500 cap is not reached.)
  • Gas: 3% of $60 = $1.80.
  • Everything else, meaning dining, bills and the rest: $400 + $500 + $890 = $1,790 at 1% = $17.90.

The total is $17.50 + $1.80 + $17.90 = $37.20.

Card F earns $6.80 more a month, or $81.60 a year. Theo's bonus categories are small, and the 1 percent rate on most of his spending costs him more than the bonuses return.

The comparison between the two households is the lesson. The same two cards, the same rates, the same total scale of spending, and opposite answers. A flat-rate card quietly wins when your spending is spread across many categories, and a category card wins when a few categories hold a large share of your spending.

Stress test: Rosa's groceries rise

Say Rosa's grocery spending rises from $700 to $900 a month because she is feeding more people, and everything else is unchanged. Her total is now $2,200.

  • Card F: 2% of $2,200 = $44.00.
  • Card C: groceries earn $25.00 on the first $500 and 1% of the remaining $400, which is $4.00, for $29.00. Add gas $4.50, dining $2.00, bills $4.00 and everything else $5.50. The total is $29.00 + $4.50 + $2.00 + $4.00 + $5.50 = $45.00.

Card C leads by $1.00. Her extra $200 of grocery spending raised Card F's earnings by $4.00 (2 percent) and Card C's by only $2.00 (the 1 percent over the cap), so the gap narrowed from $3.00 to $1.00 even though she spends more on the category the card favors. The cap is why. Once spending passes it, a category card becomes a worse flat-rate card.

That is the test to run on any category card: how much of your spending in the bonus category falls under the cap, and what happens to the rest.

What the worksheet leaves out

The sum is clean because it assumes four things. Each can fail.

You pay in full. If you carry a balance, the interest can exceed the rewards on either card. At an illustrative 24 percent APR, a $1,000 balance costs about $20 a month in interest, which is nearly half of Rosa's $43 monthly reward. That kind of arithmetic is in a year of cash back versus a year of interest on a carried balance. If you carry a balance, the choice of rewards card is a second-order question.

Rewards are cash at face value. If the cards pay points, the value of a point decides the answer. cents per point explains the unit. Cash back and statement credits are typically worth 1 cent per point, and a higher value needs a redemption that you actually make. Use the lowest value you are confident of.

Purchases are coded to the category you assume. A card pays a bonus on what the issuer's systems classify as groceries or gas, which can differ from your idea. A warehouse club, a superstore, a delivery app or a marketplace may not count. Why did my grocery run miss the grocery bonus? How merchant codes decide explains why a grocery run can miss a bonus. If a fifth of Rosa's "grocery" spending is coded otherwise, her bonus is smaller than the sum shows.

There is no fee and no effort cost. A fee changes the sum immediately, and should a cash-back card with an annual fee ever beat a no-fee one? covers that choice. Effort is a cost too. A category card may require activation, tracking caps and keeping two cards in your head. If tracking costs you more in attention than $3 a month is worth, that counts.

Using both cards

You are not forced to pick one. A household can use a category card for its category and a flat-rate card for everything else. Take Rosa again. The highest-earning split of her original $2,000 month puts the first $500 of groceries and all of the gas on Card C, and everything else on Card F.

  • Card C: $500 of groceries at 5% is $25.00, and $150 of gas at 3% is $4.50.
  • Card F: the other $1,350 (the $200 of groceries above the cap, $200 of dining, $400 of bills and $550 of everything else) at 2% is $27.00.

The total is $25.00 + $4.50 + $27.00 = $56.50, which is $16.50 more than Card F alone ($40.00) and $13.50 more than Card C alone ($43.00). The extra comes from stopping Card C's 1 percent rate from touching any spending, because every dollar that Card C would earn 1 percent on is earned at 2 percent on Card F.

Two cards earn more, with two costs. You must remember which card to use where, and you now hold two accounts to pay on time. If a missed payment on the second statement costs a late fee and interest, the extra $16.50 a month is gone quickly. Whether to hold more than one card is its own question, and the answer depends on how you handle your finances. The simplest honest summary is that the gain from a second card is real in this example and small enough that a household with limited attention can reasonably skip it.

Read the cap before you count on the bonus

A cap has three features worth checking, because they change the sum.

  1. The size of the cap. A $500 monthly cap on a 5 percent category means the most the bonus can add over a 1 percent base is $20 a month (4 points on $500).
  2. The period. A cap can reset monthly, quarterly or yearly. A longer period is kinder to lumpy spending.
  3. What happens above it. Spending above the cap earns the base rate or a lower rate, and a few cards simply stop paying.

Here is how the period changes the result. Say a card pays 5 percent on groceries up to $500 a month, and a second card pays 5 percent up to $1,500 a quarter. Both pay 1 percent beyond the cap. A shopper whose grocery spending is $200, $800 and $800 across three months spends $1,800.

  • Monthly cap: month one earns 5% of $200 = $10.00. Months two and three each earn 5% of $500 = $25.00 plus 1% of $300 = $3.00, which is $28.00 each. The quarter totals $10.00 + $28.00 + $28.00 = $66.00.
  • Quarterly cap: 5% of the first $1,500 = $75.00, plus 1% of the remaining $300 = $3.00. The quarter totals $78.00.

The quarterly cap pays $12.00 more on the identical spending, because the quiet month's unused room carries into the loud ones. With perfectly even spending, the two come out the same, which is why the period matters only to households whose grocery bill moves around, say with guests, holidays or a bulk-buying month.

If the category card pays points instead of cash

Suppose Card C paid points at the same structure: 5 points per dollar on the first $500 of groceries, 1 point on grocery spending above that, 3 on gas and 1 on everything else. The value of a point then decides the result, and the sum changes in one place: multiply the points by what you realistically get per point.

Rosa's points under this version are 500 × 5 = 2,500 on capped groceries, 200 × 1 = 200 on the rest of the groceries, 150 × 3 = 450 on gas and $1,150 × 1 = 1,150 on everything else, for a total of 4,300 points a month. Card F still pays $40.00 in cash.

Value of a point Card C's monthly value Compared with Card F's $40.00
0.8 cent $34.40 $5.60 behind
1.0 cent $43.00 $3.00 ahead
1.5 cents $64.50 $24.50 ahead

Each value is 4,300 times the point value: 4,300 × $0.008 = $34.40, 4,300 × $0.010 = $43.00 and 4,300 × $0.015 = $64.50. The break-even value is $40.00 divided by 4,300, which is about 0.93 cent per point. If you will really redeem at a value above that, Card C is ahead for Rosa. If you will redeem for cash at 1 cent, it is ahead by $3.00. A value of 1.5 cents requires redemptions that cost you effort and may not always be available. Published valuations of points differ from one publisher to another, so use the lowest figure you are confident of.

Fill in your own sheet

Copy this table and fill in a typical month. The rates in the headings are the ones from the example; replace them with the cards you are considering.

Category Your monthly spend Flat card at 2% Category card rate Category card earns
Groceries (to the cap) 5%
Groceries (above the cap) 1%
Gas 3%
Dining 1%
Utilities and bills 1%
Everything else 1%
Total

Add the "Your monthly spend" column and multiply by the flat rate. Add the last column. Subtract. Then change the largest figure by a quarter and redo it.

Do the sheet with a few months of statements, because one month can mislead. A month with a big grocery stock-up or a vacation can swing the comparison, and the year is what counts.

Check your prediction against a real month

A worksheet is a forecast. After one or two months on a card, test it.

  • Compare the total. Add the rewards the card reports for the month and compare with your sum. A big gap usually means a category you assumed was counted was not.
  • Look at the biggest purchases. One or two large transactions often decide the month. Check how each was coded.
  • Look for returns. A refunded purchase generally reverses the rewards it earned, which lowers the month's total.
  • Update the inputs. If your real spending was different from the average you used, rerun the sum with the new figures. The point of the worksheet is that you can.

A short decision rule

If you want a rule of thumb that is grounded in the arithmetic:

  • If no single bonus category is more than about a quarter of your spending, a flat-rate card is probably ahead.
  • If one or two categories make up a large share and fit under the card's caps, a category card may be ahead.
  • If the two are within a few dollars a month, choose by effort and by the other terms of the cards, and let the tie go to the simpler one.

These are heuristics from the invented numbers above. Run your own. For a plain guide to choosing among flat-rate cards, see how to choose a flat-rate cash back card and which criteria matter, and for the trap of changing spending to chase a category, see spending more to earn more: how chasing cash back costs you money.

Key takeaways

  • The answer comes from your own spending mix. In the example the same two cards gave Rosa a $3.00 monthly edge on the category card and Theo a $6.80 edge on the flat-rate card.
  • A cap turns a category card into a flat-rate card with a lower rate for any spending above it. Raising Rosa's grocery spending by $200 narrowed the category card's lead from $3.00 to $1.00.
  • Rerun the sum with the biggest category 20 to 30 percent higher and lower. If the winner flips, the choice is close and effort, fees and simplicity should decide it.
  • The sum assumes you pay in full, that rewards are cash at face value, that purchases are coded as you expect and that no fee applies. If any assumption fails, redo the sum.
  • Using both cards can beat either one alone, at the cost of two accounts to manage.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic