Blog

Grocery bonus caps: how to calculate what you earn after you pass the cap

A worksheet for finding your real blended rate when a bonus category stops at a spending limit, and whether a second card for the overflow earns its keep.

A card that pays a high rate of cash back on groceries usually pays it only up to a limit. The same logic applies to any bonus category, including the rotating categories that change each quarter. Spend past the limit and the rate drops, often to the card's base rate. The advertised number is therefore the rate on the first slice of your spending, and what you actually earn is a blend of that rate and the lower one. How much lower the blend sits depends on how fast you reach the limit, and that is a calculation you can do on one sheet of paper.

This post is a worksheet. It gives you the inputs, the seven steps and the formulas, then fills them in three times with invented numbers so you can see the pattern before you use your own. All rates, limits and spending amounts below are illustrations. They are not any card's current terms, which are in the card's agreement and on its profile page.

What you need before you start

Gather five numbers from your card's rewards terms and your own statements. Write them in the first column of the worksheet table further down.

  • B, the bonus rate. The rate the card pays inside the cap.
  • C, the cap. The amount of spending (or, on some cards, of rewards) after which the bonus stops, and the period it covers: a month, a quarter or a year.
  • R, the rate after the cap. Often the base rate; check the terms, because some cards pay nothing extra and a few pay a reduced bonus.
  • S, your qualifying spending in the same period as the cap. Only count stores that the card's definition covers. Why that is tricky is covered in Why did my grocery run miss the grocery bonus? How merchant codes decide.
  • F, the rate on a second card. The rate you could earn on the overflow if you paid with a different card, such as a flat-rate card.

One trap comes first. Look at whether the cap is on spending or on rewards. "5% back on up to $500 a month" is a spending cap. "Earn up to $25 a month in bonus cash back" is a rewards cap. The two are convertible: a rewards cap divided by the bonus rate gives the equivalent spending cap. A $25 rewards cap at a 5% bonus rate is the same as a $500 spending cap, because $25 divided by 5% is $500. Do the conversion first so all your numbers are in the same unit.

The seven steps

  1. Fix the period. Is the cap per statement cycle (a billing cycle), per calendar month, per calendar quarter, per account year or per calendar year? Everything below must use the same period for C and S. If the cap is quarterly, find S for a quarter.
  2. Total your qualifying spending, S, for that period. Use the statements. Count only purchases the card actually treats as in the category.
  3. Split S into the part under the cap and the part over it. Under the cap: the smaller of S and C. Over the cap: S minus C if S is larger than C, otherwise zero.
  4. Compute the rewards. Rewards = (under-cap spending x B) + (over-cap spending x R).
  5. Compute your blended rate. Blended rate = rewards divided by S.
  6. Price the overflow on a second card. Rewards with a second card = (under-cap spending x B) + (over-cap spending x F). The gain from the second card is over-cap spending x (F minus R).
  7. Find when the cap runs out. Divide C by your monthly qualifying spending. The answer, rounded up, is the month in which the limit is hit. That is the month you need to switch cards.

That is the whole method. Here it is with numbers.

Example 1: a monthly cap

Say a card pays an illustrative 5% on groceries up to $500 of spending each month, then 1%. A household spends $900 a month at stores that count. A flat card would pay 2%.

  • Step 3: under the cap is $500; over the cap is $900 - $500 = $400.
  • Step 4: rewards = ($500 x 5%) + ($400 x 1%) = $25 + $4 = $29.
  • Step 5: blended rate = $29 / $900 = 3.22%.
  • Step 6: with the overflow on the 2% card, rewards = $25 + ($400 x 2%) = $25 + $8 = $33, and the blended rate is $33 / $900 = 3.67%. The gain from a second card is $400 x (2% - 1%) = $4 a month, or $48 a year.
  • Step 7: $500 / $900 = 0.56, so the cap covers a little over half of each month's spending. If spending is spread evenly over a 30-day month, the limit is reached around day 17: $900 / 30 days is $30 a day, and $500 / $30 is 16.7 days.

The headline is 5%, the blend is 3.22%, and a second card brings the blend to 3.67%. The extra 0.45 percentage points (3.67 minus 3.22) are worth $4 a month. Whether $4 a month is worth the bother is a personal call, and the last section gives a rule of thumb.

Example 2: an annual cap

Say a card pays 6% on groceries up to $6,000 of spending in a calendar year, then 1%. The household spends $1,100 a month, which is $13,200 a year.

  • Step 3: under the cap is $6,000; over the cap is $13,200 - $6,000 = $7,200.
  • Step 4: rewards = ($6,000 x 6%) + ($7,200 x 1%) = $360 + $72 = $432.
  • Step 5: blended rate = $432 / $13,200 = 3.27%.
  • Step 6: with the overflow on a 2% card, rewards = $360 + ($7,200 x 2%) = $360 + $144 = $504, a blended rate of $504 / $13,200 = 3.82%. The gain is $7,200 x (2% - 1%) = $72 a year.
  • Step 7: $6,000 / $1,100 = 5.45. Five months of spending is $5,500, so the household reaches the limit during month 6, after $500 of that month's $1,100.

A shopper would feel the limit differently under this design than under a monthly cap. Under Example 1 the household reaches the cap every month and must switch cards every month. Under Example 2 the household earns the full bonus for five months, then spends seven months at the lower rate. The second card is useful for seven months a year, and the gain, $72, is spread over them: about $10.29 a month ($72 / 7).

Example 3: a cap on rewards, not spending

Say a card pays 3% on groceries but "up to $50 in bonus cash back per quarter." Convert it first. $50 / 3% = $1,666.67 of spending. The household spends $2,000 a quarter, and the rate after the cap is 1%.

  • Step 3: under the cap is $1,666.67; over the cap is $2,000 - $1,666.67 = $333.33.
  • Step 4: rewards = $50 (the capped bonus) + ($333.33 x 1%) = $50 + $3.33 = $53.33.
  • Step 5: blended rate = $53.33 / $2,000 = 2.67%.
  • Step 6: with a 2% second card, rewards = $50 + ($333.33 x 2%) = $50 + $6.67 = $56.67, a gain of $3.33 a quarter.

Here the headline is 3% and the blend is 2.67%, a small gap because the overflow is a small share of the spending. The second card would add $3.33 a quarter, about $13 a year. For most people that is not worth a second card in the wallet. Without the conversion in the first step, this example would be hard to see.

Example 4: two categories sharing one cap

Many cards pay the same bonus on more than one category and apply one cap to all of them. Say an illustrative card pays 4% on groceries and on gas combined, up to $6,000 of combined spending a year, then 1%. A household spends $7,200 a year on groceries and $3,000 on gas, which is $10,200 of qualifying spending.

  • Step 3: under the cap is $6,000; over the cap is $10,200 - $6,000 = $4,200.
  • Step 4: rewards = ($6,000 x 4%) + ($4,200 x 1%) = $240 + $42 = $282.
  • Step 5: blended rate = $282 / $10,200 = 2.76%.
  • Step 6: with a 2% second card for the overflow, rewards = $240 + ($4,200 x 2%) = $240 + $84 = $324, a blended rate of 3.18% ($324 / $10,200 = 3.176%). The gain is $42 a year.

Compare that with the household that reads the card as "4% on groceries and 4% on gas" and expects about $408 ($10,200 x 4%). The shared cap is where the $126 difference between $408 and $282 goes. Nothing is hidden: the terms say "combined." The mistake is in running the sums on each category alone.

The worksheet table

Print this or copy it to a note and fill in the right-hand column. The three examples are shown for reference.

Line What to enter Example 1 (monthly) Example 2 (annual) Example 3 (quarterly, rewards cap) Your numbers
Period Cap period Month Year Quarter
B Bonus rate 5% 6% 3%
C Cap, as spending $500 $6,000 $1,666.67
R Rate after cap 1% 1% 1%
S Your qualifying spending $900 $13,200 $2,000
Under cap Smaller of S and C $500 $6,000 $1,666.67
Over cap S minus C, or 0 $400 $7,200 $333.33
Rewards Under x B + over x R $29 $432 $53.33
Blended Rewards / S 3.22% 3.27% 2.67%
F Second card's rate 2% 2% 2%
Rewards with a second card Under x B + over x F $33 $504 $56.67
Gain Over x (F - R) $4 a month $72 a year $3.33 a quarter

Common ways the numbers go wrong

Most errors come from the inputs, not the formulas. These are the ones worth checking before you trust a result.

  • Wrong S. Counting spending at stores the card does not treat as groceries makes your blended rate look better than it is. Count only what earned the bonus on past statements.
  • Mismatched periods. A quarterly cap compared against monthly spending gives nonsense. Convert everything to the cap's period.
  • A cap shared across categories. Some cards apply one cap to several categories together, such as groceries and gas. If yours does, add the categories' spending into S before you divide.
  • A cap that resets on a different date than you expect. A card year that starts on an account anniversary resets in a different month than a calendar year. The terms say which.
  • Timing at the edge of a period. A purchase made on the last day of a cap period can post to the next one. Whether the cap follows the purchase date or the posting date depends on the card, which is a reason to keep a margin near the end. how cash back is earned, rounded and posted, from swipe to statement explains how purchases move from swipe to statement.
  • Returns. A refund may reduce your qualifying spending and may or may not give back cap room. Check the terms, because the answer decides whether a return near the limit costs you the bonus on a replacement purchase.
  • Other people's spending. Spending by an authorized user on your account generally counts toward the same account's cap. A household with two cardholders on one account hits the limit sooner than the account holder expects.

Is a second card worth it?

The gain in step 6 is the number to weigh. It has to cover three costs, and none of them is a fee unless the second card has one.

  1. Any annual fee on the second card. If the second card charges one, the gain must exceed it by a margin. The annual fee break-even calculator does the fee arithmetic.
  2. Attention. You have to remember to switch at the right moment and keep the second card in your wallet or wallet app. If the switch is forgotten for a month in Example 2, the household loses $11 ($1,100 x (2% - 1%)), roughly a month of that gain.
  3. Risk of a mistake that costs more than the gain. A missed payment on a second card costs a late fee and can add interest on a balance, which dwarfs a few dollars a month. Autopay on both cards, set to at least the minimum, removes most of that risk, but the balance stays your responsibility.

A rough rule: if the gain is less than about $50 a year, treat the second card as optional. If it is more than about $150 a year, the arithmetic favors it as long as you will realistically manage two cards. Between those figures, the decision depends on whether you already carry a good fallback card for other spending. These thresholds are judgment calls, not rules, and a reader with a different tolerance for effort may place them elsewhere.

Another way to read the same arithmetic is to avoid the cap by changing the card instead of adding one. If your qualifying spending is far above the cap, a flat-rate card earns the same rate on every dollar and requires no switching. four households, four grocery budgets: what a grocery card really pays prices that comparison for four households, and at what monthly spending does a bonus-category card beat a flat-rate card? finds the break-even spending directly.

Keeping track as the period runs

A running tally takes two minutes a week and prevents a late surprise.

  • Many card apps show the bonus earned so far in the current period. If yours does, use it, and treat the figure as a check on your own tally and not a replacement for it.
  • If it does not, keep a note with the cap, the period end date and the spending so far. Update it after each grocery trip, using the pending amount.
  • Set a reminder for when the tally reaches about 80% of the cap. For a $500 cap, that is $400.
  • After the period ends, compare your tally with the rewards on the statement. A gap larger than a few dollars is worth a question to the issuer. If it still looks wrong after that, the CFPB complaint process is open to you.

The cash back comparison calculator and the card combination rewards optimizer can run the same arithmetic with your own figures, including the second-card case.

Key takeaways

  • A bonus cap makes the advertised rate apply only to the first slice of spending. Your real rate is a blend: rewards divided by qualifying spending.
  • Before anything else, convert a rewards cap to a spending cap by dividing it by the bonus rate, and make sure every figure uses the cap's own period.
  • With the illustrative terms above, headline rates of 5%, 6% and 3% blended down to 3.22%, 3.27% and 2.67%, and a second card at 2% lifted them only to 3.67%, 3.82% and about 2.83%.
  • The gain from a second card is the overflow times the difference between its rate and the post-cap rate. If that comes to less than about $50 a year, the extra card is optional.
  • Check whether the cap resets on the calendar or on your account anniversary, and whether it follows the purchase date or the posting date. Those two details move the month in which you hit the limit.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic