Blog

The Illinois swipe-fee law and its court fight, in the order things happened

Illinois tried to bar swipe fees on sales tax and tips. A dated timeline of the lawsuit, the preemption argument and the 2026 delay, with no outcome predicted.

A state law, a bank lawsuit and a federal regulator's rule have been tangled together since 2024 over one narrow idea: when you pay a restaurant bill with a card, the swipe fee should not be charged on the sales tax and the tip. Illinois passed a law, the Interchange Fee Prohibition Act, to that effect. Banks sued, courts reversed and re-reversed, and by mid-2026 the law had been blocked for most banks and its start date pushed back a year. This is a timeline of what happened, in order, with the point where the record stops.

Nothing here predicts how the case ends. The sources reviewed run through June 2026, and later developments could not be verified, so the last section says what was not found.

The idea in one example

A card network charges an interchange fee, usually a percentage of the transaction amount plus a few cents, and the merchant pays it as part of what it pays to take cards, a bundle called the merchant discount rate. When a $50 restaurant meal arrives with $4 of sales tax and a $10 tip, the card is charged $64. The fee is normally computed on the full $64.

Illinois' argument was that the sales tax goes to the government and the tip goes to the server, so neither is revenue for the restaurant, and neither should carry a fee that someone else is collecting. A labeled hypothetical with an illustrative 2.0 percent fee shows the stakes on one table:

  • Fee on the whole $64 charge: $64 x 0.02 = $1.28
  • Fee on the $50 meal only: $50 x 0.02 = $1.00
  • Difference: $0.28 per check, which is about 22 percent of the original fee ($0.28 / $1.28 = 0.219)

Twenty-eight cents is nothing to a diner and meaningful to a restaurant that runs thousands of checks a month. The same arithmetic shows why the law mattered to banks: across millions of transactions, a fee computed on the tax and tip portions is real revenue.

Why sales tax and tips draw the attention

The tax and tip portions have three features that make them an easy target for a state legislature. First, the merchant never keeps them: the tax is remitted to the state and the tip passes to staff, so a fee on them is a cost with no matching revenue. Second, the amounts are large for some businesses. In a sit-down restaurant, tax plus a customary tip can add a quarter or more to the pre-tax bill. On the $50 meal above, $14 of the $64 charge, or 22 percent of the total, is tax and tip. Third, the card payment is processed as one amount, so the networks and processors would have to separate the pieces, and that is the practical question the banks raised: whether the data to do it is passed along and whether the cost of changing systems is reasonable. The sources reviewed give the arguments only in outline, and the reader should treat the mechanics as a description of the dispute, not a finding.

2024: Illinois enacts the law

The Illinois Interchange Fee Prohibition Act (IFPA) was enacted in 2024. As described in the sources reviewed, it would bar interchange fees on the sales-tax and tip portions of card transactions and would limit how card data can be used. The sources do not describe every provision, and the text should be read on the Illinois General Assembly's website before relying on any detail.

State laws like this are one of the ways the swipe-fee debate plays out when Congress does not act. A federal proposal covering routing is described in The Credit Card Competition Act: what it would change and what each side says, and a court settlement covering merchant rules is described in The Visa and Mastercard swipe-fee settlement: questions about what changes. The Illinois law is the third approach: a single state telling banks and networks how a fee may be calculated.

The lawsuit

Illinois Bankers Association v. Raoul, in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, is the main case in the sources reviewed. Raoul is the Illinois attorney general, the state official who would enforce the law and so the named defendant. The plaintiffs, bank trade groups, argued that the state law could not apply to national banks and was preempted by federal law. In a dispute like this, one side asks the court to block the law before it takes effect, and the other argues the state may regulate within its powers.

The key idea is preemption. The card networks and the issuing banks sit on opposite sides of the fee. Under the U.S. Constitution, federal law can override a conflicting state law. A national bank is chartered under the National Bank Act and supervised by the OCC, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, which has long taken the position that certain state laws cannot limit what a national bank may do. Whether a given state law falls within that principle is the question the courts have been asked to resolve.

February 2026: a district court ruling

In February 2026 the district court issued a ruling in the case. The sources reviewed do not describe it in detail, and this timeline does not fill the gap. What matters for the order of events is that a later appellate decision vacated it.

April 2026: the OCC issues an interim final rule

In April 2026 the OCC issued an interim final rule asserting that the National Bank Act preempts the Illinois law as applied to national banks. An interim final rule takes effect while public comment is still open, which makes it a quick way for an agency to state its position. The plaintiffs relied on it, and it changed the legal ground under the case. Whether the rule itself will withstand challenge is a separate question that could not be verified.

May 8, 2026: the Seventh Circuit resets the case

On May 8, 2026 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit vacated the district court's February 2026 ruling and remanded the case. To "vacate" is to set aside the ruling, and to "remand" is to send the case back to the lower court to consider again. The appellate court acted after the OCC's April rule, so the district court would be asked to look at the case with the OCC's position in the record. One legal-trade summary described the Seventh Circuit as hitting the reset button. It did not decide the case on the merits; it sent it back for a fresh look.

June 1, 2026: a permanent injunction, and a delay

Two things happened on June 1, 2026.

  1. Judge Kendall permanently enjoined the IFPA's interchange-fee limitation for national banks, federal savings associations, out-of-state state banks and payment card networks. An injunction is a court order that stops someone from enforcing or following a law or rule. "Permanent" here means it follows a decision on the merits, though it can still be appealed. Illinois-chartered state banks and credit unions remained subject to the law.
  2. The Illinois General Assembly passed SB 3645, which would postpone the IFPA's effective date from July 1, 2026 to July 1, 2027. The source noted that the governor's signature was still needed.

Further Seventh Circuit appeals were expected after the June ruling.

Who is covered, and who is not

The permanent injunction splits issuers into groups. Here is the split as the reviewed sources describe it:

Type of institution Covered by the injunction (law blocked)? Subject to the IFPA's limit?
National banks Yes No, as long as the injunction stands
Federal savings associations Yes No
State banks chartered outside Illinois Yes No
Payment card networks Yes No
Illinois-chartered state banks No Yes
Credit unions No Yes

The split can look strange: the biggest card issuers in the country are national banks or out-of-state banks, so the law as blocked leaves much of the market untouched. If your card is issued by a national bank, the IFPA's fee limit would not apply to transactions on that card as long as the injunction holds. If your card is issued by an Illinois credit union or an Illinois-chartered bank, the sources say it remained subject. To find out which type of institution issues your card, see how to find out which bank really issued your credit card and the main kinds of card issuer and how each one behaves differently.

Note that the effective date of the law, postponed by the legislature, matters too: if the delay was signed, the law's fee limit would not apply to anyone before July 1, 2027, even those not covered by the injunction. Whether it was signed could not be verified.

Three cardholders, three issuers

These are labeled hypotheticals, built from the injunction's reported scope as of June 2026, not from any particular account.

  • Dana holds a card from a large national bank. Her issuer is covered by the injunction, so the Illinois fee limit would not apply to her card's transactions while the order stands.
  • Marcus holds a card from a bank chartered in another state. The sources list out-of-state state banks among those covered by the injunction, so his card is in the same position as Dana's.
  • Lena belongs to a credit union chartered in Illinois. Under the reported terms, credit unions remained subject to the law. If the law took effect for her institution, the fee limit would apply to the tax and tip portions of her card transactions, although nothing in that would change her APR or her statement.

In all three cases the cardholder sees nothing different at the register today. The fee lives between the merchant and the card system, which is why this fight can run for years without a cardholder noticing it.

What an ordinary cardholder should take from it

You do not pay interchange directly; the merchant does. A law that changes how interchange is computed would first change the merchant's costs. Whether any savings reached diners or whether banks would change rewards or fees in response is argued by both sides, and the swipe-fee claims on both sides are tested in swipe fee claims tested: do they raise prices, fund rewards, or both?.

What the Illinois fight shows about the system is broader:

  • A state can pass a law and still not control the market. When the biggest issuers are federally chartered, state law may not reach them.
  • Different issuers are treated differently. The same law can bind a credit union and not a national bank, so who issues your card matters.
  • Courts change the picture fast. In 2026 alone the case moved from a district court ruling to a vacatur, an agency rule and a permanent injunction in a few months.
  • Delay is part of the story. Legislatures can move the start date as litigation proceeds.

If you want to know which law governs your card, the framework is set out in Which law applies to my card? Three households in three states.

How to follow a case like this one

Press coverage lags the docket. If you want to follow the case without relying on headlines:

  1. Find the case name and court. Illinois Bankers Association v. Raoul, N.D. Ill., and its appeal in the Seventh Circuit.
  2. Read the newest order, not the newest article. Court websites and legal-news services post orders, and the order says what the court actually did.
  3. Check the date on every claim. A statement true on June 1 may have been overtaken.
  4. Separate three levels: the legislature's act (the IFPA, SB 3645), the courts' orders (injunction, vacatur) and the agency's position (the OCC's rule). Each can change independently.
  5. Do not predict. Sources that say the law "will" be struck down or upheld are guessing. The honest status is a list of dated events.

Words you will see in the docket

  • Injunction: a court order that stops a law or rule from being enforced, or stops a party from acting.
  • Vacate: to set aside a ruling so it no longer stands.
  • Remand: to send a case back to a lower court for further work.
  • Preemption: the principle that valid federal law overrides a conflicting state law.
  • Interim final rule: a rule that takes effect before public comment finishes.
  • Plaintiff and defendant: the side that sued (here, the bank trade groups) and the side that was sued (here, the state's attorney general).

What could not be verified

The record found for this article ends in June 2026. These questions were open in the sources, and no answers were found:

  • Whether the governor signed SB 3645 and moved the effective date to July 1, 2027.
  • Whether an appeal was filed after the June 1 permanent injunction, and what the Seventh Circuit did with it.
  • Whether the OCC's preemption rule produced later rulings in this or other cases.
  • How the court's reasoning applied to Illinois-chartered banks and credit unions, which remained subject.

If any of these matters to you as a merchant, a lender or an Illinois resident, the Illinois attorney general's office, the court docket and a licensed attorney are the right sources. The CFPB's page on its role is summarized in What the CFPB does for credit card holders, and what has changed since 2025, which also explains why a state attorney general is often the right contact for state-law questions.

Key takeaways

  • Illinois' 2024 Interchange Fee Prohibition Act would bar interchange fees on the sales-tax and tip portion of card transactions. On the illustrative $64 check above, that is 28 cents of a $1.28 fee at 2.0 percent.
  • The litigation, Illinois Bankers Association v. Raoul, moved quickly in 2026: a February ruling, an OCC preemption rule in April, a Seventh Circuit vacatur on May 8, and a permanent injunction on June 1 for national banks, federal savings associations, out-of-state state banks and card networks. Illinois-chartered banks and credit unions stayed subject to the law.
  • The legislature passed SB 3645 on June 1, 2026 to delay the effective date from July 1, 2026 to July 1, 2027, pending the governor's signature. Whether it was signed and what happened on appeal was not verified.
  • Cardholders do not pay interchange directly, so effects on prices, rewards or fees are arguments, not facts. Check your issuer's type and the date of every claim.

Terms used in this article

Latest on this topic