Blog
The Visa and Mastercard swipe-fee settlement: questions about what changes
Questions and answers on the reported Visa and Mastercard merchant settlement: what it does, what it leaves alone for cardholders, and who objects.
A revised settlement between Visa, Mastercard and merchants in a long-running swipe-fee lawsuit was announced in November 2025 and had won preliminary approval from a federal judge in Brooklyn by mid-2026, according to press coverage. It changes rules for merchants: the swipe fees they pay, which cards they must accept and when they can add a surcharge. It does not directly change what a cardholder pays or what a rewards card earns. Everything past that sentence is a question, and the answers below keep what is reported, what is estimated and what is argued apart.
The dated facts here come from press accounts of the court proceedings as of June 2026. Final approval had not been confirmed in what was found, so check the court-approved terms before relying on any detail.
What is this case about?
For years, merchants have sued Visa and Mastercard over interchange fees, the fee a merchant's bank pays the cardholder's bank on each card sale, and over the network rules that limit how merchants can respond. In plain terms, merchants argued that the rules kept fees higher than competition would. The card networks and issuers disagreed. The case is a class action, a lawsuit brought on behalf of a large group (here, merchants) rather than a single plaintiff, and the proposed deal is a settlement of it.
The settlement now before the court is a revised one. Reporting says an earlier proposed deal, valued around $30 billion, was rejected by a different judge, and the revised version announced in November 2025 is before Judge Brian Cogan of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York in Brooklyn. Visa and Mastercard have profiles on this site, but the settlement is a legal matter you can read about in the court's filings, not a feature of any card.
What are the reported terms?
According to the press coverage reviewed, the revised settlement includes:
- A fee reduction. Swipe fees fall by 0.1 percentage point for five years. One report cited the average fee at 2.36 percent.
- A cap for standard cards. Interchange on standard consumer cards would be capped at no more than 1.25 percent for eight years.
- Acceptance choice. Merchants could choose whether to accept three groups of cards separately: commercial cards, premium consumer cards and standard consumer cards. Coverage describes this as effectively ending the "honor all cards" rule for those categories. See honor all cards rule.
- More surcharging options. Merchants would get more ways to add a surcharge to card payments.
The $38 billion figure that appears in headlines is an expert estimate of merchant savings. It is not a payout, and no one is writing a check for $38 billion. Where a headline says "settlement worth $38 billion," it is describing a modeled benefit to merchants, and a modeled number depends on assumptions about merchant volume and behavior.
How much is 0.1 percentage point?
Small per sale, large in total. The fee a merchant pays in total, the merchant discount rate, also includes network and processor charges, so this uses only the interchange piece. Take the reported 2.36 percent as an illustration only. It is a cited average, not the rate on any particular card or merchant.
- On a $100 purchase, 2.36 percent is $2.36. A 0.1-point reduction would be $2.26, a saving of ten cents.
- On $1,000 of purchases, the figure goes from $23.60 to $22.60, a saving of $1.
- For a merchant with $500,000 of annual card sales, 0.1 point is $500 a year.
- For a merchant with $10 million of annual card sales, 0.1 point is $10,000 a year.
Notice what the arithmetic does and does not show. A ten-cent saving on a $100 sale can matter to a merchant with thin margins and a lot of transactions. It is not something a shopper would see as a price change on the shelf. That is the first reason the settlement does not translate directly into lower prices for you.
For how interchange layers into the total a merchant pays, one $100 sale: how interchange, network fees and the merchant's cut split follows one $100 sale through each party.
Does it change what I pay for things?
Not directly. The settlement changes the fees merchants pay and the rules they follow. It does not change the price on a product, your APR or your annual fee. Whether merchants lower prices because their costs drop slightly is a separate question. Merchant groups say lower fees help them, and some argue savings should reach customers. Banks argue that prices already include these costs for every shopper whatever card they use, so a drop would not change anyone's price in a visible way. The claims on each side are tested in swipe fee claims tested: do they raise prices, fund rewards, or both?. Because the settlement reduces fees by 0.1 point and caps standard cards, the aggregate effect on prices is likely small compared with the gap between the arguments, but no source reviewed measured it.
Does it change my rewards or cash back?
Not directly. The settlement changes merchant acceptance and fee rules. It does not set the rewards on any card, and it does not require an issuer to change a rewards program. What critics and issuers argue is that lower interchange could eventually pressure rewards, because interchange helps fund them. That is a debate, not a fact, and it is stated as an argument by the parties.
A little arithmetic shows why the argument comes up and why it is hard to resolve. Say a card earns 1.5 percent back, and the reported 2.36 percent average fee were applied to its spending. On $1,000, the issuer earns $23.60 and pays back $15. If the fee fell by 0.1 point, the issuer's revenue would fall by $1 to $22.60, still above the $15 reward. If the standard-card cap of 1.25 percent applied to the same spending, the issuer's interchange would be $12.50, below the $15 reward, so the issuer would need other revenue (interest, fees or a lower reward) to sustain the card. That is a hypothetical built on an average fee, not a forecast: real cards face different fees and different costs. The takeaway is that a standard consumer card with a rewards rate near the cap is where the argument bites, and premium cards with a higher fee schedule are affected differently. How cash back is funded is covered in where cash back comes from, and why it is never really free money.
What does "no honor all cards" mean at the checkout?
Today, under card network rules, a merchant that accepts a brand's credit cards generally has to accept all of that brand's credit cards, whether a basic cash-back card or a premium travel card with higher fees to the merchant. Under the reported terms, a merchant could choose to accept commercial, premium consumer and standard consumer cards separately.
In practice, this could mean a merchant declines a category of card. If you carry a premium card, a merchant that chose not to accept premium consumer cards would not take it, and a different card from your wallet would be needed. How many merchants would do this is unknown. Some merchants may use the choice and many may change nothing. The practical advice, if the settlement is approved and merchants change their policies, is to carry a second card from a different network and to look at the window decal or the payment terminal before you rely on one card.
Will I see more surcharges?
Possibly. The reported terms give merchants more surcharging options. A surcharge is a fee a merchant adds when you pay by credit card, and it is limited by network rules, by state law and by the merchant's actual cost of acceptance. Visa's merchant surcharge cap fell from 4 percent to 3 percent effective April 15, 2023, and Mastercard's was reported at 4 percent, though sources conflict. Debit and prepaid cards are excluded. Some states ban or restrict surcharging, with Connecticut and Massachusetts the clearest examples found, and cash discounts are generally allowed everywhere.
If you see a surcharge, the receipt should show it as a separate line. You can usually avoid it by paying with debit, cash or a different method if the merchant's policy allows. State rules vary, so your state attorney general's consumer office is the place to ask about a surcharge you think is not allowed.
Who objects, and why?
Reported objectors include the National Retail Federation, NACS (the convenience and fuel retailing association), Walmart and the Merchants Payments Coalition. Their general position, as described in coverage, is that the settlement does not go far enough: a 0.1-point reduction and a cap on standard cards leave the fee structure largely intact, and they would prefer stronger changes. A Second Circuit appeal was predicted after any approval.
Notice that the objectors are mostly merchants, not banks. A settlement that Visa and Mastercard agreed to is one they are willing to live with. The court's task is to decide whether the settlement is fair, reasonable and adequate.
Where does it stand?
As reported, Judge Cogan granted preliminary approval and called the deal "fair, reasonable, and adequate," while saying he was likely to grant final approval. The sources disagree on the date: one report put preliminary approval at June 9, 2026, and another at April 27, 2026. Final approval and the date of the fairness hearing were not confirmed in what was found. After a final approval, objectors could appeal, as noted, and terms often take effect on a schedule rather than immediately.
For a cardholder, the question to ask is practical: what do I need to do? As far as the reviewed coverage shows, nothing. You do not need to file a claim or change a setting because of the settlement itself. If a notice about a settlement reaches you, check that it comes from the court-approved administrator or the court's site, because scammers copy settlement notices. Never pay a fee to "claim" a payment, and never give a card number to a caller. If you receive a suspicious message, call the number on the back of your card and report it to the CFPB or the FTC.
What should a cardholder do now?
Short, concrete steps:
- Keep using your cards as you do. Nothing about the settlement requires action.
- Carry a backup. If a merchant chooses not to accept some card types, a second card from a different network is the simplest fix.
- Read surcharge lines. If a surcharge appears on a receipt, note the amount and the percentage, and compare it with the rules above.
- Watch for notices from your issuer, not from social media. If a rewards change ever follows, the federal 45-day notice rule applies to significant account changes, and the notice tells you how to respond.
- Date what you read. A claim from June 2026 is a snapshot. The court docket and the court-approved notice are the sources to check.
Who is affected, and how?
| Reported term | Merchants | Issuers | Cardholders |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.1-point fee reduction for five years | Lower cost per sale | Lower interchange revenue | No direct change |
| Standard consumer card cap, no more than 1.25 percent for eight years | Predictable cost on basic cards | Pressure on basic-card economics | No direct change; rewards debate |
| Separate acceptance of commercial, premium and standard cards | Can decline a category | Premium cards could be refused more often | A card may not be accepted everywhere |
| More surcharging options | Can recover costs from card payers | Neutral | May see surcharges on some receipts |
The table shows why the settlement is mainly a merchant-side event. The cardholder column is mostly "no direct change," with two places to watch: whether a card is accepted and whether a surcharge appears.
Five common misreadings
- "The settlement is $38 billion that merchants get." It is an estimate of savings to merchants, not a payment.
- "Swipe fees are going away." They fall by a reported 0.1 percentage point, and a cap applies to standard consumer cards. Interchange continues to exist.
- "My rewards are ending." Nothing in the reported terms sets or ends rewards. The rewards effect is argued, not established.
- "I can claim money." The reviewed coverage describes changes to merchant rules, not a consumer payout. Be careful with any message promising a payment.
- "It is final." Preliminary approval is not final approval, and an appeal was predicted.
Two more points of caution about sources. Some figures in this area, including the date of preliminary approval, differ between reports, and this post says so rather than choosing one. And the average fee of 2.36 percent was cited in coverage; actual fees differ by card type, merchant category and how the card is used.
How does this relate to the other swipe-fee fights?
Three separate efforts are often mixed up. The settlement is a court deal about merchant rules. The Credit Card Competition Act is a congressional proposal about routing, not passed as of August 2026, covered in The Credit Card Competition Act: what it would change and what each side says. The Illinois law on interchange fees is a state statute in federal court, covered in The Illinois swipe-fee law and its court fight, in the order things happened. Each could affect merchants and possibly rewards, and each has its own timeline. Reading the three as one story produces most of the confusion.
Key takeaways
- The revised Visa and Mastercard merchant settlement, announced in November 2025, reportedly lowers swipe fees by 0.1 percentage point for five years, caps standard consumer card rates at no more than 1.25 percent for eight years, lets merchants accept card categories separately and adds surcharging options.
- The $38 billion figure is an expert estimate of merchant savings, not a payout. Preliminary approval was reported in 2026 (sources disagree on the date); final approval had not been confirmed, and objectors predicted an appeal.
- It does not directly change what a cardholder pays or the rewards a card earns. Critics and issuers argue lower interchange could eventually pressure rewards; that is a debate, not a fact.
- Practical effects to watch: a merchant that declines certain card types, and more surcharges. Carry a backup card and read your receipts.
- You do not need to file anything. Be wary of messages about "claiming" settlement money, and call the number on the back of your card if something looks wrong.