Blog

Where cash back comes from, and why it is never really free money

Cash back is paid from merchant swipe fees and from interest on balances. Follow a $100 sale and two invented cardholders to see who ends up funding whom.

Picture a $100 purchase on a card that pays 2 percent back. You get $2.00. The store handed over a bit less than $100. Somewhere between the two, a bank has to cover the $2.00, run the network, absorb fraud losses, answer the phone and still come out ahead. cash back is not a gift from the bank. It is a share of money collected from two other places, and which of the two is paying for yours depends on how you use the card.

This post follows the money in order: the merchant's fee, the interest from cardholders who carry a balance, and the smaller streams like annual and late fees. It then runs two invented cardholders through the numbers, because the same card can be a good deal for one and a bad deal for another. All dollar splits in the examples are illustrations with round numbers, not published prices, and the rewards rate is hypothetical.

The first source: the fee the merchant pays

When you tap a card, the merchant does not receive $100. It receives the sale minus a charge called the merchant discount rate, which is usually quoted as a percentage of the sale plus sometimes a small flat amount. That charge is split among the parties that made the payment possible:

  • The issuer, the bank that gave you the card, takes the largest part. This part is the interchange fee, and it is set by the card network (Visa or Mastercard, for example) for each category of card and transaction rather than by the bank itself.
  • The network takes a small fee for running the system that moves the message and the money.
  • The acquirer or processor, the company that handles the merchant's side, keeps a margin for its work.

Say a merchant's total charge on the $100 sale is 2.40 percent, or $2.40. In an invented split, $1.85 goes to the issuer, $0.15 to the network and $0.40 to the acquirer, which adds up to $2.40 and leaves the merchant with $97.60. For a longer walk through a single sale, see one $100 sale: how interchange, network fees and the merchant's cut split.

The 2.40 percent is not a real quote. For context, coverage of the 2026 Visa and Mastercard merchant settlement cited an average swipe fee of 2.36 percent, according to BNN Bloomberg, so the order of magnitude is reasonable. What any one merchant pays varies with the card, the merchant's size and how the sale was made.

Why the interchange does not cover a 2 percent reward

Now compare. The issuer received $1.85 of interchange on the sale, and it owes the cardholder $2.00. Before any other cost, the card loses $0.15 on this transaction.

Premium and rewards cards usually carry higher interchange than basic cards, and that is part of the design: the higher fee on a rewards card is what funds the reward. Even so, the issuer's costs do not stop at the reward. They include:

  • Fraud losses and the cost of fraud detection.
  • Customer service, statements, apps and compliance.
  • Credit losses when cardholders do not repay.
  • The cost of funds, the interest the bank itself pays to get the money it lends out.

A card that pays out more in rewards than it collects in interchange needs another source of revenue, and the other source is interest.

The second source: interest from cardholders who carry a balance

Interest is the money earned on revolving credit, balances that roll from one month to the next. The Federal Reserve's G.19 release reported that the average APR on credit card accounts assessed interest at commercial banks was 22.36 percent in the third quarter of 2026. A balance that costs 22 percent a year is far more profitable per dollar than a swipe fee of a couple of percent per sale.

Arithmetic shows the scale. Interest on a $3,000 balance carried for a year at 22.36 percent, ignoring compounding and payments, is $3,000 × 0.2236 = $670.80. To earn the same $670.80 from interchange at $1.85 per $100, the issuer would need $670.80 ÷ 0.0185 = $36,259 of purchases, roughly $36,300. That is what one carried $3,000 balance is worth to the issuer compared with a customer who pays in full and spends heavily.

The CFPB's 2023 Consumer Credit Card Market report estimated, as summarized in trade press, that issuers collected about $105 billion in interest and about $25 billion in fees in 2022. Treat those numbers as the report's estimate for one year, not a current figure, but the ratio makes the point: interest was several times larger than fees.

How many people carry a balance? In the Federal Reserve's survey of household economics for 2025, 45 percent of card owners said they had carried a balance at least once in the previous 12 months, and 37 percent of all adults had. TransUnion reported 178.0 million consumers carrying a bankcard balance in the third quarter of 2026. So the group paying interest is large, not a small fringe.

Smaller streams: annual fees and penalty fees

Annual fees fund part of the cost of premium cards, and they are paid whether or not the cardholder uses the benefits. Late fees and other penalty fees add to the total, but federal rules limit them: a late fee cannot exceed the minimum payment due, and the amount that is presumed reasonable is roughly $30 for a first late payment and about $41 for a repeat within six billing cycles, with issuers free to charge less. The CFPB estimated late fees at about $14.5 billion in 2022 in the same report. Fees are meaningful but small beside interest, and most of the discussion about rewards turns on the first two sources.

Two cardholders, one card

The card pays 2 percent cash back on everything. Both people spend $24,000 a year on it, which is $2,000 a month. The merchants' fees on that spending, at the invented $1.85 per $100 to the issuer, come to $24,000 × 1.85% = $444.

Dana pays in full every month. She earns $24,000 × 2% = $480 in cash back. The issuer received $444 of interchange from the merchants and paid out $480, a shortfall of $36 for the year before any other cost. Dana pays no interest, so for the issuer she is a net cost of at least $36 plus servicing and fraud costs. For Dana, the card is a pure gain, but the money did not come from her. It came from merchants and, through them, from prices.

Sam carries a balance. Same spending, same $480 of rewards. Sam also carries an average balance of $3,000 over the year at an illustrative 22.36 percent APR, which costs about $670.80 in interest. The issuer collects $444 of interchange plus $670.80 of interest, $1,114.80 in total, and pays out $480. After the reward, Sam's net position is $480 − $670.80 = −$190.80: the interest is bigger than the cash back, so Sam pays $190.80 more than Sam earns.

The difference is stark. The card worked in Dana's favor and against Sam, and the rewards rate was the same. The credit card interest calculator lets you run your own numbers for a balance and rate. If you want the same comparison with three households and different habits, a year of cash back versus a year of interest on a carried balance works through it.

The view from the issuer: a hundred cardholders

An issuer does not price its card one customer at a time. It prices a portfolio and expects the mix of customers to pay for the reward. A rough illustration with invented numbers shows why the mix matters.

Say an issuer has 100 cardholders on this 2 percent card. Each spends $24,000 a year. Fifty-five behave like Dana and pay in full. Forty-five behave like Sam, with an average carried balance of $3,000 at 22.36 percent. This is an illustration; it is not any issuer's real book.

  • Interchange from everyone: 100 × $444 = $44,400.
  • Interest from the 45 balance carriers: 45 × $670.80 = $30,186.
  • Total revenue before other income: $44,400 + $30,186 = $74,586.
  • Rewards paid to everyone: 100 × $480 = $48,000.

Rewards take $48,000 ÷ $74,586, about 64 percent, of this revenue. The remaining $26,586 has to cover fraud, credit losses, servicing, the cost of funds and profit. Interest supplies $30,186 ÷ $74,586, about 40 percent of revenue, from fewer than half of the customers.

Now take the interest away and suppose all 100 customers pay in full. Revenue is only the $44,400 of interchange, and rewards still cost $48,000. The card would lose $3,600 before any other cost. That is the reason cards that attract mostly full-payers tend to price differently: they may carry an annual fee, higher interchange categories, or a lower reward rate. It is not evidence about any specific card, only about the arithmetic any rewards card has to satisfy.

Who ends up funding whom

Whether rewards amount to a transfer from some households to others is a contested question, and the honest answer is that it depends on assumptions.

One argument holds that merchants pass the cost of swipe fees into everyone's prices, including the prices paid by people using cash or debit, and that rewards go mostly to cardholders who pay in full, who tend to have higher incomes. Another argument holds that rewards are competitive pricing: issuers compete for customers, rewards give a real benefit to the people who earn them, and merchants accept cards because cards bring sales. Both arguments are made by serious parties.

Some data bears on the first claim without settling it. In the Federal Reserve's 2025 survey, the share of cardholders who carried a balance in the previous year was 52 percent for those with household income under $25,000, 57 percent from $25,000 to $49,999, 50 percent from $50,000 to $99,999 and 37 percent for $100,000 or more. Higher-income cardholders were less likely to have carried a balance. That fits with the idea that interest income leans on lower- and middle-income households, but it describes groups, not how any specific card is funded, and it says nothing about prices.

Some merchants answer the fee in a visible way. They add a surcharge to card payments, or they offer a discount for cash. According to a law-firm alert, Visa lowered its surcharge cap from 4 percent to 3 percent effective April 15, 2023, and surcharges are banned or limited in some states, while cash discounts are generally allowed everywhere. The rules differ by card network and by state, so a surcharge you see at checkout is a good moment to look at the receipt and ask whether paying another way costs less. A surcharge that is larger than the merchant's actual cost of accepting the card is not permitted under the network rules, and your state attorney general is the place to ask about the state side.

For a fuller look at the merchant side, including whether prices are higher because of the fees, see swipe fee claims tested: do they raise prices, fund rewards, or both?.

What could change the arithmetic

Two things are being argued over in 2026, and neither has yet changed what you earn.

First, the Visa and Mastercard merchant settlement. According to BNN Bloomberg, a federal judge in Brooklyn granted preliminary approval in 2026 to a deal that would lower swipe fees by 0.1 percentage point for five years and cap standard consumer card rates for eight years, among other terms. Final approval was not confirmed in the sources reviewed. The settlement changes what merchants pay, not directly what cardholders earn, though issuers and critics argue that lower interchange could put pressure on rewards over time. That is a debate, not an established outcome. The Visa and Mastercard swipe-fee settlement: questions about what changes covers the details.

Second, the Credit Card Competition Act, a bill that would require the largest issuers to let merchants route transactions over a network other than Visa or Mastercard. As of August 2026 it had been introduced in the Senate, had picked up co-sponsors and had not passed either chamber, according to trade-press coverage.

If either one eventually lowers issuer revenue, issuers could respond by trimming rewards, raising fees or leaving the product as is. No one can say which, so a reader should treat any promise about rewards in a year or two with caution.

If your balance is now bigger than your rewards

If Sam's column describes you, the useful move is not to give up the card but to deal with the balance. Start with the statement: the interest charged each month and your payment are on the first page. The credit card interest calculator shows what an extra payment does to the payoff date, and how to build a credit card payoff plan you can actually stick to lays out a plan that keeps every minimum payment current. If the balance feels unmanageable, a nonprofit credit counseling agency can review your whole situation, and the number on the back of your card reaches the issuer's own hardship team. A complaint about how the account was handled can go to the CFPB.

What to do with this

You do not have to refuse rewards on principle. You do have to decide what you are doing with the card. Here is a short set of questions:

  1. Did I pay the full statement balance last month, and the month before? If yes, the rewards are a straightforward gain.
  2. If I carried a balance, did the interest exceed the rewards? Compare the two lines on your statement. In Sam's case it did.
  3. Am I spending more because the card pays me to? A reward of 2 percent on a $100 purchase you would not have made is a $98 net loss.
  4. Which payment method is cheapest for the merchant, and does the merchant give a discount for it? Some merchants offer cash discounts, and surcharge rules vary by state and network.
  5. Is the card's rewards rate worth its annual fee? A fee turns the rate into a net figure, and the card's own profile and the issuer's terms are the places to check the current fee and rate.

Key takeaways

  • Cash back is paid out of two kinds of money: swipe fees merchants pay, and interest cardholders pay on balances they carry. Annual and penalty fees add a smaller third stream.
  • On the invented numbers, interchange of $1.85 per $100 does not fully cover a 2 percent reward, so interest from other cardholders helps fill the gap.
  • The same card can pay one cardholder and cost another. In the example, Dana earned $480 and paid nothing; Sam earned $480 but paid $670.80 in interest.
  • Who ultimately funds rewards is argued both ways. The data show higher-income cardholders are less likely to carry a balance, but that does not prove how any given card is funded.
  • Court and legislative changes to swipe fees are in play in 2026, and none has yet changed what a cardholder earns. Check the card's own terms before assuming a rewards rate will last.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic