Blog

Five myths about what points and miles are worth

Five common beliefs about point values tested against how redemptions are priced, with checked arithmetic on where each holds and where it breaks.

Most of what people believe about the value of points is half true. That is what makes the beliefs durable: each one is correct in some situation, and each one fails in the situation the holder is actually in. This post takes five of them one at a time, states the claim at its strongest, runs a test with numbers you can check, and gives a verdict.

Every figure in the tests is an illustration with round numbers, not any program's real price. The tests are meant to be repeated with your own balance, and the points and miles value calculator will do the division if you would rather not.

Myth 1: "A point has one fixed value"

The claim. Each point is worth some set number of cents, and that number is what a balance is worth.

The test. Say a hotel program charges a flat 20,000 points for a standard room, on any night. That is a fixed points price. Now look at three nights for the same room at cash prices of $120, $200 and $340.

  • $120 ÷ 20,000 × 100 = 0.6 cents per point.
  • $200 ÷ 20,000 × 100 = 1.0 cents per point.
  • $340 ÷ 20,000 × 100 = 1.7 cents per point.

The points did not change and neither did the room. The value of a point is a ratio, and the ratio depends on the cash price you compare it with. A point has no value on its own, in the way a coupon has no value until you know what it is applied to.

The verdict. False as stated, and the lesson is stronger than "it varies". A cents per point figure belongs to a redemption, not to a currency. A published number is an average over redemptions a publisher chose, and how to value a point, and why published valuations disagree shows how far the choice can move it. The accurate statement is that a program has a range, with a floor set by its cash option and a ceiling set by its best realistic use.

What is partly right in the myth is that for some uses the rate really is fixed. A cash-out at a posted rate, a statement credit and a catalog gift card all convert at a stated figure. That is why those uses make a good floor: they are the only ones where the myth is true, and for that reason they are rarely the best ones.

Myth 2: "A point is always worth one cent, like cash back"

The claim. Treat every point as a cent. It is simple, and it is what cash back pays.

The test. Take a balance of 10,000 points and the illustrative options a typical bank program might present:

Use Rate Value of 10,000 points
Spend at a checkout screen 0.7 cents $70
Cash or statement credit 1.0 cents $100
Travel through the program's portal 1.2 cents $120
Partner flight after a transfer, net of taxes 1.8 cents $180

The spread from $70 to $180 is the same balance spent four ways. If the rule of thumb is one cent, the person who spends at a checkout screen loses $30 relative to the rule, and the person who transfers to a partner for a flight gains $80 relative to it. The rule is right only for the cash option.

The verdict. Useful as a floor and wrong as a model. One cent is a sensible default for a program that offers a cash-out at that rate, because a redemption that falls below it is a loss against a simple alternative, and pay with points at a checkout is the common place that happens. should you pay with points at checkout or take cash back instead? works through the break-even. But treating one cent as the ceiling as well as the floor leaves value on the table for holders who can use a transfer partner and have the flexibility to find space. If you will only ever take cash, then a point is a cent, and a card that pays one cent in cash back is the cleaner product.

Myth 3: "More points means a richer program"

The claim. A program that gives you 100,000 points for a spending goal beats one that gives 30,000.

The test. The unit of the currency is arbitrary. Say Program A values its points at an illustrative 0.6 cents and Program B values its points at 2.0 cents.

  • 100,000 points × $0.006 = $600.
  • 30,000 points × $0.02 = $600.

Same value, wildly different balances. The balance size tells you how the program chose its unit, much as a price in yen tells you little about how expensive something is until you know the exchange rate. The same logic applies to earning: a card that pays 5 points per dollar in a currency worth 0.6 cents returns 5 × 0.6 = 3.0 percent, while a card that pays 1.5 points per dollar in a currency worth 2.0 cents returns 1.5 × 2.0 = 3.0 percent. Identical returns, and one of them looks more than three times as generous at the register (5 versus 1.5).

The verdict. False. Compare programs by value delivered, which means points earned times cents per point on the redemptions you will use. A big number on a welcome offer is a reason to run the multiplication, not a reason to be impressed. The same applies to airline miles: miles and points are both units, and what a unit buys depends on the program's award prices, not on how many of them there are.

Myth 4: "If I save them, they will be worth more later"

The claim. A growing balance is an investment. The longer you hold, the more it can buy, and the bigger the eventual trip.

The test. The balance grows, but so can the price, and the price is outside your control. Say a roundtrip you want costs 30,000 points today and you hold 60,000.

  • Today: 60,000 ÷ 30,000 = 2.0 trips.
  • If the program raises the price of that trip by 20 percent to 36,000 points: 60,000 ÷ 36,000 = 1.67 trips.

The same balance lost a third of a trip without a single point being removed. That change in what points buy is called devaluation, and it tends to arrive with short notice. anatomy of a points devaluation, from first rumors to the new chart follows one from rumor to new chart.

To be fair to the myth, waiting can also help. A program might run a transfer promotion that adds a 20 percent bonus to points moved to a partner. Then 60,000 points become 72,000 partner points, and 72,000 ÷ 30,000 = 2.4 trips. Prices can also fall in a sale. The honest comparison is between a known price now and an uncertain price later, and an uncertain price has a downside that the holder alone absorbs.

The verdict. Mostly false as a general rule. Points are a promise that a company can edit, not an asset that compounds, and cash balances in a bank do not carry that risk. Saving for a specific, priced goal is reasonable. Saving with no goal in the hope the points will appreciate is a bet against the program's habits. should you spend points now or save them for a bigger trip? turns this into a decision with criteria.

Myth 5: "An award ticket is free"

The claim. If a flight costs points, it costs no money.

The test. Government taxes and airport fees on a ticket are owed whether you pay with cash or points, and some carriers add their own surcharges to award bookings. Say a long international trip costs $900 in cash and 60,000 points plus $180 in surcharges and taxes.

  • Value received = $900 − $180 = $720.
  • Rate = $720 ÷ 60,000 × 100 = 1.2 cents per point.
  • If the same booking had only $12 of government taxes: ($900 − $12) ÷ 60,000 × 100 = 1.48 cents.

The charge on the first booking cut the rate by about 19 percent: (1.48 − 1.2) ÷ 1.48 = 0.19. A "free" ticket with a $180 co-pay is a discounted ticket, and the discount is smaller than the headline suggests. what you still pay on an award ticket in taxes, fees and surcharges explains what the charges are and why they vary by airline and route.

The verdict. False on the money and true on the structure. Points replace the base fare, not the taxes. If the cash fare you are comparing with is low, a points price plus a co-pay can be worse than buying the ticket, and that is why the comparison should use the price you would really pay.

Where the myths come from

Each myth has a source, and the sources are worth knowing because they explain why the beliefs keep returning.

The first source is simplicity. A single number is easy to remember and to repeat, so "a point is a cent" or "a point is two cents" travels further than "it depends on the redemption". The second is promotion. Offers are written to show the largest number, so a welcome bonus is stated in points, in a currency whose unit the issuer picked, and the value of those points is left to the reader. The third is survivorship: people talk about the spectacular redemption and not the catalog purchase, so the stories you hear skew toward the top of the range. The fourth is that points feel free. Money you earned by spending does not register as a price, and a redemption that costs points feels as if it costs nothing, which dulls the instinct to compare.

None of these is dishonest. Each one is a natural shortcut. The correction is a habit, not a rule: put a dollar figure and a points cost on every redemption before you decide.

Applying all five: one balance, audited

Say Dana holds 80,000 points and believes, from a published figure of about 2.0 cents, that they are worth $1,600. She decides to audit that belief against what she would really do. The numbers are illustrative.

  • A flight she would buy anyway. Cash fare $430. The award costs 28,000 points plus $11 in taxes. Value = $430 − $11 = $419. Rate = $419 ÷ 28,000 × 100 = 1.50 cents.
  • Two hotel nights. Cash price $180 a night, $360 in all. The points price is 16,000 a night, or 32,000 points. Rate = $360 ÷ 32,000 × 100 = 1.13 cents.
  • The remainder as cash. 80,000 − 28,000 − 32,000 = 20,000 points at one cent is $200.

Total value is $419 + $360 + $200 = $979 on 80,000 points, or $979 ÷ 80,000 × 100 = 1.22 cents. Her belief overstated the balance by $1,600 − $979 = $621, which is 39 percent of the believed figure.

Now trace the five myths through the audit. The rates she found, 1.50, 1.13 and 1.00, show that no fixed value applied (Myth 1) and that one cent was the floor but not the whole picture (Myth 2). Her balance of 80,000 points says nothing about its worth until it is multiplied by a rate (Myth 3). If she waits a year and the flight's price rises 20 percent to 33,600 points, the same $419 of value now costs 5,600 more points, and her rate on that line falls to $419 ÷ 33,600 × 100 = 1.25 cents (Myth 4). And the $11 in taxes came off the top of the flight's value (Myth 5), a small amount here and a large one on a long-haul ticket.

The audit does not tell Dana what to do. It tells her that her balance is worth about $979 on a realistic plan, and that the extra $621 in her head was a feature of a published number, not of her redemptions. That is a much better thing to know before deciding whether a card's annual fee is justified by its rewards.

A scorecard

Myth Verdict What survives
One fixed value per point False Cash and credit options convert at a fixed rate
Always one cent Floor, not model One cent is a reasonable minimum if cash-out exists
More points, richer program False Compare value earned, not units
Saving raises value Mostly false A known goal and a known price can justify waiting
Award tickets are free False Points replace the fare, not the taxes

What is true after all

Debunking can overshoot, so it is worth saying what the tests did not overturn. Points can be worth meaningfully more than a cent in the right circumstances: published estimates for large bank programs cluster around two cents, and a holder with flexible dates and access to partners can sometimes reach it. Cash back is worth exactly what it says, which makes it the right benchmark for anyone who does not want to do the work. Waiting can pay, when the goal is priced and the program has a record of honoring bookings. And a flight bought with points can be an excellent use of a balance. Each of these is conditional, and the conditions are the part that the myths leave out.

How to test the next claim you hear

New myths arrive with each promotion, and the same four questions catch most of them.

  1. What is the cash alternative? Every value claim has a dollar figure hiding in it. Ask what the cash price is and whether you would have paid it.
  2. What does it cost beyond points? Taxes, fees, resort charges, and the points you stranded when the price did not divide evenly.
  3. What is the unit? Convert the claim to cents per point before comparing it with anything else.
  4. What would have to be true? A claim of 3 cents per point needs a seat that exists, a route you would fly and a price you would have paid. If the claim fails on any one, it is not your number.

The idea behind all four is to move from "this is what points are worth" to "this is what these points return on this redemption". The second sentence has an answer. The first does not, and any source that gives you a single figure without a redemption attached is selling a story.

Key takeaways

  • A point has no value without a redemption attached: the same 20,000-point room returned 0.6, 1.0 or 1.7 cents depending on the cash price of the night.
  • One cent per point is a good floor, because cash and statement credit typically convert at that rate, but it is not a model for transfer or travel redemptions.
  • Balance size is not value: 100,000 points at 0.6 cents and 30,000 points at 2.0 cents are both $600, and 5 points at 0.6 cents earns the same 3.0 percent as 1.5 points at 2.0 cents.
  • Points can lose purchasing power without being removed: a 20 percent price rise turned 2.0 trips into 1.67, while a transfer bonus could turn the same balance into 2.4.
  • An award ticket still carries taxes and any surcharges, so the dollars you pay come off the top of the value before you divide.

Terms used in this article

Related tools

Latest on this topic